Resumen
El presente trabajo es el resultado de una aplicación de la programación multicriterio interactiva a la planificación agraria y pretende de seleccionar a priori qué método puede ser más adecuado a un problema de programación multicriterio. Para realizar esta selección se han definido un conjunto de características obtenidas bajo consideraciones tanto subjetivas como objetivas. Los métodos de programación multicriterio interactivos que se han contrastado se han analizado tanto a nivel teórico como práctico, lo que ha permitido evaluar relativamente cada método así como obtener sus ventajas e inconvenientes.
Summary
The purpose of this article is to select, in advance, wich method can be the most adequate in order to solve a multicriterion problem. A set of objective and subjective characteristics is defined as a useful tool for methods selection. Interactive multicriteria methods are contrasted and analyzed from theoretical and practical point of view. This enables to evaluate each method and obtain its advantages and weaknesses.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Referencias
ALONSO, R., y IRURETAGOYENA, M. T. (1989): «Los métodos multicriterio en la programación de actividades agrarias»,Comunicaciones I.N.I.A., 29.
ARIAS, P. (1989a): «El método de Ponderaciones Recursivas de Programación multicriterio y su aplicación a la planificación agraria»,I.N.I.A., Econ., 4(2): 175–190.
ARIAS, P. (1990b): «Las técnicas interactivas de programación multicriterio en planificación agraria»,Comunicaciones I.N.I.A., 34.
BELENSON, S. M., y KAPUR, K. C. (1973): «An algorithm for solving multicriterion linea programming problems with examples»,Op. Res. Q., 24(1): 65–77.
BENAYOUN, R.; DE MONTGOLFIER, J.; TERGNY, J., y LARICHEV, O. (1971): «Linear programming with multiple objective functions: Step method (STEM)»,Matematical Programming, 1: 366–375.
CHANKONG, V., y HAIMES, Y. (1983): «Multiobjective decisionmaking. Theory and methodology»,Elsevier Science (USA).
COHON, J. R. (1978):Multiobjetive programming and Planning», Academic Press, New York (USA).
GEOFFRION, A.; DYER, J., y FEINBERG, A. (1972): «An interactive approach for multicriterion optimization, with an application to the operation of an Academic Department»,Management Science, 19: 357–368.
GOICOECHEA, A.; DUCKSTEIN, L., y BULFIN, R. L. (1976): «Multiobjective stochastic programming: the PROTRADE method»,Paper presented to Operations Society of America, Miami Beach, nov. 3–5.
GOICOECHEA, A.; DUCKSTEIN, L., y FOGEL, M. H. (1979): «Multiple objective under uncertainty: an illustrative application of PROTRADE»,Water Resources Research, 15: 203–210.
GOICOECHEA, A.; HANSEN, D. R., y DUCKSTEIN, L. (1982):Multiobjective decision analysis with engineering and business applications, John Wiley and Sons (USA).
GRAUER, M., y WIERZBICKI, A. (1984):Interactive decision analysis, Ed. Springer-Verlag, Berlín.
HAZELL, P. (1971): «A linear alternative to quadratic and semi-variance programming»,Amer. J. Agric. Econ., 53; 53–62.
HWANG, C., y MASUD, A. (1979):Multiple objective decisionmaking, methods and applications, Ed. Springer-Verlag, Berlín (Germany).
MASUD, A. S., y HWANG, C. L. (1981): «Interactive Sequential Goal Programming»,J. Op. Soc., 32: 391–400.
ROMERO, C., y REHMAN, T. (1989): «Multiple criteria analysis for agricultural decisions»,Elsevier Science Publishers, Netherlands.
ROY, G. G. (1980): «A man-machine approach to multicriteria decision making»,Int. J. Man-Machine Studies, 12: 203–215.
SAKAWA, M., y FUMIKO, S. (1982): «Interactive multiobjective decisionmaking in environmental systems using sequential proxy optimization techniques (SPOT)»,Automatica, 18 (2): 155–165.
SAKAWA, M., y FUMIKO, S. (1983): «Interactive multiobjetive decision-making in environmental systems using the fuzzy sequential proxy optimization technique»,Large Scale Systems, 4: 223–243.
SPRONK, J. (1981): «Interactive Multiple Goal Programming as an aid for capital budgeting and financial planning with multiple goals», en R. L. Crum and F. G. J. Derkinderen (eds.),capital Budgeting under Conditions of Uncertainty, chapter 10, Martinus Nijhoff.
STEUER, R. E. (1977): «An interactive multiple objetive linear programming procedure», inTIMS Studies in the Management Sciences (Edited by M. K. Starr and M. Zeleny), 6: 225–239.
STEUER, R. E. (1986): «Multiple criteria optimization:Theory computation and application, John Wiley and Sons, New York (USA).
TEGHEM, J., y KUNSCH, P. L. (1985): «Application of multi-objective stochastic linear programming to power systems planning»,Enginering Costs and Production Economics, 9: 83–89.
WALLENIUS, H.; WALLENIUS, J., y VARTIA, P. (1978): «An approach to solving multiple criteria macroeconomic policy problems and an application»,Management Science, 24 (10): 1021–1030.
ZELENY, M. (1982):Multiple criteria decision making, McGraw-Hill, Inc. (USA).
ZIONTS, S. (1985): «Multiple Criteria Mathematical programming: an overview and several approaches»,Multiple Criteria Decision Methods and Applications (Ed.) Springer-Verlag, Berlín (Germany) 85–128.
ZIONTS, S. y WALLENIUS, J. (1976): «An interative programming method for solving the multiple criteria problem»,Management Science, 22 (6): 652–663.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Martín, P.A. Una evaluacion critica de los metodos interactivos de programacion multicriterio. Trabajos de Investigacion Operativa 7, 173–193 (1992). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02888265
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02888265