Stress-induced degradation of 5 mol% yttria–zirconia in water at 300 °C
- 52 Downloads
5 mol% yttria–zirconia ceramic was studied for its use as solid electrolyte in high-temperature pH sensors since this material has interesting mechanical and ion-conducting properties and is available on an industrial scale. However, although its fracture mode in air is transgranular, some batches showed severe intergranular cracking in the working medium, water at 300 °C. In a previous study, it was found that the degradation could be related to the stress caused by the martensitic transformation of intergranular tetragonal precipitates. The aim of present study was to prove this assumption by experiment. To simulate the effect of transforming grain boundary precipitates, a nearly precipitate free material was subjected to an externally applied stress while exposed to 300 °C water. It was found that this also led to degradation by intergranular fracture. This proved the effect of tensile stress, but it also showed that the occurrence of intergranular fracture cannot be attributed solely to the location of the transforming precipitates at the grain boundaries. In an attempt to find the cause of the stress-induced intergranular fracture, 8 mol% yttria–zirconia was tested as well but this material showed only transgranular fracture. As a possible explanation, it is suggested that the occurrence of intergranular fracture in the 5 mol% yttria ceramic is not a property of the pure yttria–zirconia system but that sintering additives or impurities, segregated at the grain boundaries, could be the cause. However, examination of such segregation was not foreseen in the present study. Nevertheless, based on the present results it is thought that it should be possible to reduce degradation by a strict decrease of the amount and size of the intergranular tetragonal precipitates.
KeywordsYttria Zirconia 5 mol% 8 mol% Degradation Water
Zirconia ceramics are not only known for applications where mechanical strength, wear resistance and low thermal conductivity are required but also for applications based on ion-conducting properties, the so-called solid electrolytes [1, 2].
5 mol% Y2O3–ZrO2 (5YSZ), used as the main material in the present study, is industrially produced and used as sensor electrolyte to measure the oxygen content in liquid steel . For reasons of availability, strength and conductivity, it is also being evaluated for more advanced applications. As such it is studied for use in solid state oxygen pumps to control the oxygen level in molten eutectic lead–bismuth alloys, used as the coolant in advanced nuclear reactors [4, 5]. Another advanced application under consideration is as cladding protection material in supercritical water reactors .
On a somewhat shorter timescale, it was used as electrolyte for pH sensors in corrosion test installations, simulating nuclear power reactor conditions, i.e. water at 300 °C [7, 8]. However, during tests in hot water it was found that some batches showed intergranular cracking within 100 h while others remained intact for more than 1500 h. Therefore, a study was initiated to characterize the structural differences between “degradation sensitive” and “degradation resistant” batches. In this study, samples from different batches were exposed for different times in water at 300 °C in an autoclave. After exposure, they were examined for the presence of cracks. An extensive description of the obtained results was published previously but an overview of the most important observations will be given below . However, because of the rather complex structure of the material a short description of the yttria–zirconia phase diagram will be given first .
Pure zirconia (ZrO2) may have three different crystallographic structures: cubic above 2400 °C, monoclinic below 1200 °C and tetragonal in the intermediate temperature range. The transformation from tetragonal to monoclinic occurs by a martensitic mechanism. Due to the accompanying shape and volume change, cracks form and render the pure zirconia useless as a structural material. However, by adding 2–3 mol% yttria the tetragonal structure can be retained down to room temperature. The resulting material is strong, tough and wear resistant. Unfortunately, in the temperature range of 60–400 °C the presence of water or water vapour causes the martensitic transformation to occur [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. Fragmentation of the material may happen rapidly unless the transformation is prevented by protecting layers or by using a grain size below about 0.5 µm [15, 17]. As will be seen later, this effect also contributes to the degradation of the 5YSZ sensor material.
Adding 8 mol% yttria (8YSZ) results in the stabilization of the cubic structure down to room temperature and avoids formation of the tetragonal phase. 8YSZ is a good oxygen ion conductor and is therefore used in solid oxide fuel cells and in electrochemical sensors . It shows no degradation in hot water but its bending strength (300 MPa) was judged too low for its use in the pH sensor mentioned above [1, 16, 18, 19].
The material, subject of the present study, contains nominally 5 mol% yttria and 3–4 vol% alumina. Silica was definitely present, to a lesser extent, but was not determined quantitatively. Because knowledge of the structure is important for understanding the degradation behaviour, some data obtained in the previous study are reminded below . Since the material is a commercial one, no information on the starting powders and sintering conditions is available.
The grains consist of a cubic matrix and have a size of the order of 40 µm. Two types of tetragonal precipitates are present. The so-called “large ones” are situated at the grain boundaries. In the batch with good degradation resistance, these particles have a diameter of around 3 µm and occupy about 3 vol%. In the degradation sensitive batches, these figures are, respectively, 11 µm and 8 vol%. Within the grains, a dispersion of small (50–200 nm) tetragonal precipitates is found. They are estimated to occupy roughly 50% of the volume. Such populations of sub-micron precipitates are well known to occur in zirconia ceramics [20, 21, 22, 23]. A glassy phase, containing silicon and aluminium oxide, besides yttria and zirconia, was found but only at some grain boundaries and triple points. This may locally have caused intergranular fracture but globally its effect is thought to be negligible. Finally, alumina particles are present in the grains and at the grain boundaries. They behave rather inert since energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) showed no presence of alumina in the zirconia phases and vice versa.
In a previous study, C-ring bending tests were performed at constant displacement rate of 0.5 mm/min in air at room temperature. The rupture stress was found to be between 400 and 600 MPa .
Constant load bending tests in air at room temperature always showed a transgranular fracture mode. Autoclave exposure caused spontaneous intergranular cracking. The amount of intergranular cracking was found to increase with the size and amount of the tetragonal grain boundary precipitates. From this observation, it was concluded that internal stresses, resulting from the water-induced martensitic transformation of the tetragonal grain boundary precipitates, were a prerequisite for degradation to occur.
The main aim of the present study was to demonstrate this conclusion. Therefore, the material with the lowest amount of intergranular precipitates, used in the previous study, was subjected to an external load in 300 °C water and examined for its degradation behaviour. The observations made are described in the following.
Finally, a limited attempt was made to compare the degradation behaviour of the 5YSZ with the behaviour of 8YSZ material under stress in water at 300 °C. This comparison was justified as follows. It was expected that, according to the phase diagram, the yttria content of the cubic 5YSZ grain matrix would be close to 8 mol%, and it might be expected that the degradation behaviour of the latter would be similar. This expectation turned out to be wrong as shown below.
2 Experimental and materials
The 5YSZ material is industrially produced as tubes with nominally 3 mm inner diameter and 6 mm outer diameter. Details on the composition and structure, obtained in a previous study, are given in the introduction. 8YSZ tubes were made on laboratory scale by isostatic pressing and sintering at 1500 °C of Tosoh TZ-8YS powder. The manufacturer data for this material mention (wt%), Al2O3 < 0.1, SiO2 < 0.02, Fe2O3 < 0.01, Na2O < 0.12. No glassy phase was observed at the grain boundaries.
The cylindrical surface of the specimens was left in the as-sintered condition. For the first tests, the flanks and edges were also left in the as-cut condition. For later tests, the specimen flanks were polished and the edges were chamfered to remove possible cutting defects which might affect crack initiation.
In the first tests, three specimens were mounted at 120° positions and carried each one third of the deadweight. The specimen supports, not shown in Fig. 1b, were designed to limit the drop of the loading weight upon rupture of a specimen. Yet, it could not be excluded that a minor shock, caused by rupture of one specimen, might cause fracture of another as well. Therefore, in subsequent tests only one sample was mounted and at the two other positions metal dummies were placed. Specimens which did not break during autoclave exposure were afterwards broken with pincers and examined for the presence of intergranular cracks which might have formed.
In order to examine the autoclave behaviour of the present material in the absence of external stress, samples with partially as-sintered and partially polished surfaces were exposed in the autoclave without load for times up to 1730 h. Both surface types were examined by optical (OM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). In addition, they were then broken in a bending test to provide a fracture surface for examination.
The water exposure was done at 300 °C in demineralized water containing 1000 ppm B and 2 ppm Li to stabilize the pH at 7.
SEM work was done with a JEOL JSM-6610 microscope, operated at 7 kV, using secondary electrons and spot size 40. Al sample surfaces were coated with platinum to avoid charging effects.
In one case, an intergranular fracture surface was etched in a 45/10/45 vol% mixture of HNO3/H2O/HF to reveal the intragranular precipitates. Images of etched polished surfaces can be found in [8, 9].
3 Results on 5YSZ
3.1 Proof tests in air at room temperature
Specimens to be used in the autoclave were proof-tested under constant load in air at room temperature. About two thirds of the air-tested specimens survived proof tests at 200–250 MPa for around 50 h. Survivors were then tested in the autoclave.
All specimens which ruptured in air showed a similar fracture origin as shown in Fig. 2. It is therefore likely that most fractures in air are linked to machining defects as they start from the cut surface. For this reason, most autoclave specimens were chamfered or rounded at the edges.
3.2 Autoclave exposure without external stress
3.2.1 Examination of the as-sintered surface
Nevertheless, it is clear that possible intergranular cracks cannot be detected by bright field observation in the OM. A more appropriate method, not further discussed here, has been published elsewhere .
3.2.2 Cracking observations on polished surfaces
3.2.3 Observations on fracture surfaces
3.3 Autoclave exposure on externally loaded samples
3.3.1 Stress versus rupture time results
3.3.2 SEM examination of the fracture surfaces
The small ones with depths up to 100 µm. These are in size similar to the cracks found in the specimens exposed without load. Therefore, they are expected to show only a limited contribution of the applied stress.
Crack depths between 100 and 350 µm. These are expected to be caused by the stress applied during exposure.
Very large cracks, with a depth of more than 400 µm. These suggest an unlikely high fracture toughness as will be discussed below.
3.3.3 Fracture toughness
From the river pattern in the transgranular fracture region, it can be seen that the mixed fracture region acts to start the purely transgranular crack which causes final rupture (Fig. 9). It is therefore likely that at the border between the two zones the critical stress state is reached which allows fast fracture, unaffected by the environment. KIc values were calculated for a geometry corresponding to an edge crack in a plate of given width, subjected to a crack opening bending moment in the plane of the plate . The measured adepth was used as crack size, and the bending moment was calculated from the specimen dimensions and applied load (Fig. 1).
Six specimens broke at KI values between 3 and 5 MPa m0.5. These can be considered as “normal” for the 5YSZ material. Four results are between 5 and 10 MPa m0.5 which is unusually high. They were tested at about the same applied stress as the others, yet they show the four largest crack depths. A possible explanation for these results follows below.
3.3.4 Examination of the fracture mode
In the previous study, it was found that the mixed fracture mode resulted from a fully three-dimensional network of intergranular cracks . Transgranular cracks were supposed to be caused in interlocking grains, bridging the crack upon failure. However, since it was found that slow transgranular cracking occurs in air at room temperature, as shown in Sect. 3.2, the possibility was envisaged that cracking in the mixed fracture zone occurs by both inter- and transgranular slow crack growth. Therefore, additional observations were made to examine the three-dimensional extent of the cracks under external stress conditions and to look for indications of slow transgranular crack growth.
The possible magnitude of the interlocking and bridging effect was estimated from room temperature constant rate bending tests on specimens in which an intergranular network was known to be fully developed three dimensionally by unloaded exposure. These specimens were obtained from tubes with high tetragonal phase content which were actually used as sensor. Although nearly all the grain boundaries were cracked, these specimens remained intact notwithstanding handling and cutting. C-ring bend tests showed rupture stresses between 100 and 230 MPa which is close to the stress applied in the present tests.
As for all the fracture surfaces observed till now, no indication of slow transgranular growth could be found in the mixed mode region, and neither could a difference be found between the transgranular crack appearance in the mixed mode zone and in the fully transgranular zone. It is therefore thought that the contribution to the fracture process of transgranular slow crack growth, if occurring, is of secondary importance.
4 Results on 8YSZ
The 8YSZ material is single phase cubic with a grain size of around 3 µm. To examine the fracture mode, C-ring specimens of 8YSZ were tested in the same way as the 5YSZ.
These tests show only transgranular crack growth to occur in air at room temperature and in 300 °C water. Moreover, as far as could be seen from the limited number of tests and the uncertainty of the rupture time in the autoclave, no effect of the water environment on the rupture time of 8YSZ was found. The expectation that 8YSZ would behave similarly to 5YSZ clearly was not confirmed. This is further discussed below.
Since most of the more detailed observations have been considered in the results section, this discussion will be limited to the major points raised during this study. Unless specified otherwise, observations and conclusions are supposed to be bear on the material selected for this study, i.e. 5YSZ with low content of tetragonal precipitates.
The autoclave tests on the unloaded specimens confirm that in this material, as expected from previous work, degradation does not occur or at least is strongly reduced. This is explained by the fact that only low internal transformation stresses are generated .
Tests under load show that application of externally applied stress, of the order of 200 MPa, causes intergranular crack growth in a plane approximately perpendicular to the stress. This clearly shows that the assumption that the presence of a stress is a prerequisite for degradation in 300 °C water is confirmed. This confirmation was the main incentive for this study. It also shows that the origin of the stress, external source or transformed precipitates does not matter.
Some additional points are worth mentioning. All autoclave specimens show that the intergranular fracture does not extend over the complete surface. It always consists of two regions: an initiation region, containing an intergranular (or mixed) fracture mode, followed by a final fracture region with purely transgranular fracture. This transition can be understood from the fact that the test is executed under constant load. At the start of the test, the critical stress intensity factor for transgranular cracking is obviously not reached at any point. Therefore, fast transgranular cracking cannot occur and slow transgranular growth is negligible, as suggested by the tests at room temperature. Therefore, an intergranular crack can grow until the critical stress intensity for transgranular fracture is reached at its front and fast rupture takes place. Support for this model is found in the fact that acceptable KIc values could be calculated from the size of the intergranular region.
Another problem remains: why is intergranular cracking only found in water and not in air? The present results show that the fact that cracking is intergranular cannot be explained by the transformation stress of the tetragonal grain boundary precipitates. This assumption can be excluded because in the present material there are not sufficient precipitates as shown by the unloaded autoclave tests, yet intergranular cracking occurs when a load is applied. The small amount of precipitates may have contributed but is clearly not the primary cause. Moreover, it should be recognized that, except in special cases where the precipitates would cause systematically a tensile stress perpendicular to the grain boundaries, a randomly oriented stress source at a grain boundary might as well cause transgranular cracking as intergranular cracking.
An obvious conclusion would be to attribute the occurrence of intergranular fracture to the presence of water. Water is known to induce the martensitic transformation of the tetragonal phase. However, in the present case the intergranular cracking occurs along cubic grain boundaries, a phase which is known to be stable in hot water. Therefore, since according to the phase diagram, the 5YSZ cubic phase must have an yttria content close to 8 mol%, it might be expected that intergranular fracture would also be found in the latter material when loaded in hot water. The present tests with 8YSZ specimens show that this does not happen. No intergranular fracture could be detected, and within the limited test matrix no effect of water on the fracture time was found in 8YSZ. This shows that still another factor besides the presence of water and stress is required for intergranular fracture to occur.
Therefore, the present results on 8YSZ were compared with the literature. Specimens made of Tosoh powder were exposed for 2 years at 250 °C to argon containing water vapour by Guo and He . These samples showed only transgranular cracking but this does not exclude that testing in liquid water might have caused intergranular cracking since water may leach some elements or cause electrochemical processes, phenomena which do not occur in vapour.
A similar set of tests was performed by Siebert-Timmer and Bichler , using another, not specified 8YSZ powder type which was spark sintered and hot pressed for 7 min at 1400 °C. The samples were exposed to supercritical water at 400 °C for about 10 h. This material, with a grain size of 20 µm, showed fully intergranular fracture, even in the as-sintered condition. After supercritical water exposure, considerably more intergranular cracks could be seen. The intergranular fracture found by Bichler et al. might result from the powder type or from the sintering method which, due to the very short sintering time, may have produced a material with high residual stress. However, the increased intergranular cracking during critical water exposure could be an effect of crack growth in hot water similar to 5YSZ.
From the above, no clear picture appears which would explain intergranular cracking at cubic grain boundaries in hot water. The presence of a thin glassy layer was considered as well. However, in the present study, OM and SEM showed a glassy phase only at a limited number of grain boundaries. Within the detection limits of SEM, most grain boundaries were seen to be free of a continuous second phase. This agrees with high-resolution TEM examinations, described in the literature, which show the absence of amorphous phases at grain boundaries in several ceramics [18, 19, 26, 27]. Therefore, a glassy phase can probably be excluded as the cause of intergranular fracture in the 5YSZ. However, this does not exclude its presence at a nanometre scale. Alternatively, aluminium, silicon or other impurities might be segregated (or depleted) as solute at the grain boundaries. However, in the present study it was not foreseen to make a detailed investigation of these possibilities.
A study was made of the effect of an externally applied bending stress on the cracking mode of industrially produced 5 mol% yttria-zirconia (5YSZ) in water at 300 °C.
In the absence of stress, the selected batch shows no degradation which might inhibit its use for a pH sensor.
Application of an external stress causes initially slow growth of an intergranular crack, followed by catastrophic transgranular rupture. This proves that the presence of stress is a prerequisite for degradation as set forward at the beginning of this study. This also explains previous results which related the sensitivity to degradation to the amount of intergranular tetragonal precipitates.
The cubic 8YSZ, used in this study for comparison, shows no intergranular degradation. However, literature data show that intergranular fracture in some types of 8YSZ may occur. As discussed in Sect. 5, a possible cause for intergranular fracture in the presence of stress and water might be the presence of minor elements (Al, Si or other) at the grain boundaries.
The practical problem of degradation is likely to be solved by a reduction in the amount of intergranular tetragonal precipitates to avoid harmful transformation stresses.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.
- 7.Bosch R-W, Wéber M, Vandermeulen W (2009) Development and testing of an in-core YSZ high-temperature reference electrode. Power Plant Chem 11(4):198–205Google Scholar
- 8.Vandermeulen W, Bosch R-W (2008) Degradation of 5 mol% Y2O3–ZrO2 used for the YSZ membrane electrode in high temperature water (300°C). In: Proceedings of international conference on water chemistry of nuclear reactor systems, Berlin, GermanyGoogle Scholar
- 11.Nakajima K, Kobayashi K, Murata Y (1984) Phase stability of Y-PSZ in aqueous solutions. In: Claussen N, Rühle M, Heuer AH (eds) Science and technology of zirconia II. Advances in ceramics, vol 12. American Ceramic Society, ColumbusGoogle Scholar
- 15.Hirano M (1992) Inhibition of low temperature degradation of tetragonal zirconia ceramics—a review. Br Ceram Trans J 91:139–147Google Scholar
- 17.Schubert H, Claussen N, Rühle M (1984) Surface stabilization of Y-TZP. Proc Br Ceram Soc 34:157–160Google Scholar
- 24.Quinn GD (2007) Fractography of ceramics and glasses. Special publication 960-16. National Institute of Standards and Technology, GaithersburgGoogle Scholar
- 25.Rooke DP, Cartwright DJ (1976) Compendium of stress intensity factors. The Hillingdon Press, Middlesex, p 86Google Scholar