Advertisement

The Impact of MGNREGA on Agricultural Outcomes and the Rural Labour Market: A Matched DID Approach

  • Deepak Varshney
  • Deepti Goel
  • J. V. MeenakshiEmail author
Article
  • 6 Downloads

Abstract

This paper attempts to address the impact of the MGNREGA on the rural agricultural sector, focusing on cropping patterns, irrigated area, crop yields, wages and rural employment. The analysis is based on two data sources: the first is a unique district-season level panel dataset that we construct using multiple sources, and the second is unit record data from the NSS Employment Unemployment Surveys. To identify causal effects, we employ a difference-in-difference matching procedure, where districts are matched based on propensity scores; the use of propensity scores represents a novel aspect of this paper. We also examine pre-programme trends for each outcome variable to provide a check on the validity of our estimates. Our results indicate modest changes in cropping patterns that are state and period specific; however, they do not indicate any improvements in crop yields that were expected given the MGNREGA’s focus on investments in irrigation, although there is some evidence that irrigated area may have expanded after a lag. We also find that there is no systematic evidence of impact on wages and therefore no evidence that public works employment in MGNREGA crowded out casual labour in agriculture.

Keywords

MGNREGA Public works Agriculture Employment 

JEL Classification

J31 J46 J48 Q15 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank the Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India, for providing us with the seasonal area, production and yield data. We would also like to thank K.L.Krishna, S.C.Panda, Ashwini Deshpande, Uday Bhanu Sinha, Anirban Kar, Abhiroop Mukhopadhyaya and an anonymous referee for their input and suggestions to improve the paper. We are also grateful to participants at the IZA young scholar programme, the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research (IGIDR) conference on MGNREGA and the Indian Statistical Institute annual conference on economic growth and development, for their feedback. Any errors are our own.

Supplementary material

41027_2019_151_MOESM1_ESM.docx (72 kb)
Supplementary material 1 (DOCX 72 kb)

References

  1. Aggarwal, A., A. Gupta, and G. Kumar. 2012. Evaluation of NREGA wells in Jharkhand. Economic and Political Weekly 47(35): 24–27.Google Scholar
  2. Azam, M. 2012. The impact of Indian job guarantee scheme on labor market outcomes: Evidence from a natural experiment. IZA Discussion Paper 6548. Bonn, Germany: Institute for the Study of Labor.Google Scholar
  3. Berg, E., S. Bhattacharyya, R. Durgam, and M. Ramachandra. 2015. Can public works increase equilibrium wages? Evidence from India’s National Rural Employment Guarantee. Working Paper 2015. Bristol, UK: University of Bristol.Google Scholar
  4. Bhargava, A. 2014. The impact of India’s rural employment guarantee on demand for agricultural technology. Working Paper. Davis, USA: University of California.Google Scholar
  5. Bhatia, Raag, Shonar L. Chinoy, Bharat Kaushish, Jyotsna Puri, Vijit S. Chahar and Hugh Waddington. 2016. Examining the evidence on the effectiveness of India’s rural employment guarantee act. Working Paper 27. International Initiative for Impact Evaluation.Google Scholar
  6. CSE (Centre for Science and Environment). 2008. An assessment of the performance the National Rural Employment guarantee in terms of its potential for creation of Natural wealth in villages. New Delhi.Google Scholar
  7. Dutta, P., R. Murgai, M. Ravallion, and D.V.D. Walle. 2012. Does India’s employment guarantee scheme guarantee employment. Economic and Political Weekly 47(16): 55–64.Google Scholar
  8. Esteaves, T., Rao, K. V., Sinha, B., & Roy, S. S. (2013). Environmental Benefits and Vulnerability Reduction Through Mahatma Gandhi NREGS: A Synthesis Report. Ministry of Rural Development, Government of India and Deutsche GIZ.Google Scholar
  9. Gehrke, E. 2014. An employment guarantee at risk insurance? Assessing the effects of the NREGS on agricultural production decisions. BGPE Discussion Paper No. 152. Germany, Nuremberg: Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics.Google Scholar
  10. GOI (Government of India). 2005. The National Rural Employment Guarantee Act: The Gazette of India, Extraordinary. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
  11. Heckman, J., H. Ichimura, and P.E. Todd. 1997. Matching as an econometric evaluation estimator: Evidence from evaluating a job training programme. The Review of Economic Studies 64(4): 604–654.Google Scholar
  12. Imbert, C., and J. Papp. 2015. Labor market effects of social programs: Evidence from India’s Employment Guarantee. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 7(2): 233–263.Google Scholar
  13. Kareemulla, K., K.S. Reddy, C.A.R. Rao, S. Kumar, and B. Venkateswarlu. 2009. Soil and water conservation works through National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme in Andhra Pradesh-analysis of livelihood impact. Agricultural Economics Research Review 22: 443–450.Google Scholar
  14. Liu, U., and C.B. Barrett. 2013. Heterogenous pro-poor targeting in the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme. Economic and Political Weekly 48(10): 46–53.Google Scholar
  15. Mahajan, K. 2014. Farm wages and public works: How robust are the impacts of national rural employment guarantee scheme? Indian Growth and Development Review 8(1): 19–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. MORD (Ministry of Rural Development). 2012. MGNREGA Sameeksha: An anthology of research studies on the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005, 2006–2012. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
  17. Nagaraj, N., C. Bantilan, L. Pandey, and N.S. Roy. 2016. Impact of MGNREGA on rural agricultural wages, farm productivity and net returns: An economic analysis across SAT Villages. Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics 71(02): 176–190.Google Scholar
  18. NSSO (National Sample of Survey Organization) 2006. Employment and unemployment situation in India, 2004-05 (Part-I). Technical Report. Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, Government of India. New Delhi.Google Scholar
  19. Rangarajan, C., P.I. Kaul, and Seema. 2011. Where is the missing labour force? Economic and Political Weekly 46(39): 68–72.Google Scholar
  20. Saxena, R., S. Pal, and P.K. Joshi. 2001. Delineation and characterisation of agro-eco region. Task Force on Prioritization, Monitoring and Evaluation 6. New Delhi: Indian Council of Agricultural Research.Google Scholar
  21. Sheahan, M., Liu, Y., Narayanan, S., and Barrett, C. B. 2016. Disaggregated labor supply implications of guaranteed employment in India. Boston, MA (No. 237345): Agricultural and Applied Economics Association.Google Scholar
  22. Sinha, B., Basu, A., Katiyar, A.K. 2011. Impact Assessment of MGNREGA’s Activities for Ecological and Economic Security,  IIFM: Indian Institute of Forest Managagement.Google Scholar
  23. Sukhtantar, S. 2016. India’s National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme: What do we really know about the world’s largest workfare program? Working Paper.Google Scholar
  24. Tiwari, R., H.I. Somashekhar, V.R. Ramakrishna Parama, I.K. Murthy, M.S. Mohan Kumar, B.K. Mohan Kumar, H. Parate, M. Varma, S. Malaviya, A.S. Rao, A. Sengupta, R. Kattumuri, and N.H. Ravindranath. 2011. MGNREGA for environmental service enhancement and vulnerability reduction: Rapid appraisal in Chitradurga district. Economic and Political Weekly 46(20): 39–47.Google Scholar
  25. Verma, S., and T. Shah. 2012. Beyond digging and filling holes: Lessons from case studies of best-performing MGNREGA water assets. Water Policy Research Highlight: International Water Management Institute (IWMI)—TATA Water Policy Program.Google Scholar
  26. Zimmermann, L. 2015. Why guarantee employment? Evidence from a large Indian public-works program. Working Paper. Georgia, USA: University of Georgia.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Indian Society of Labour Economics 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Research CollaboratorInternational Food Policy Research Institute, South Asia OfficeNew DelhiIndia
  2. 2.Department of Economics, Delhi School of EconomicsUniversity of DelhiNew DelhiIndia

Personalised recommendations