Exploring the relationship between humility and the virtues: toward improving the effectiveness of ethics education
- 71 Downloads
We define humility as the ability to realistically assess one’s limitations and strengths. Unlike other moral virtues, humility has been found distinctively difficult to acquire. Our paper makes two significant contributions. Although the role and importance of humility have been clearly established in the literature, our paper is the first to empirically test a theoretically-posited inter-relationship between humility and the moral virtues. Our paper empirically tests this relationship, specifically between humility and the social virtues with the personal virtues acting as a mediator. The second contribution of our paper is to present the design and delivery of a humility-embedded pedagogical teaching and learning approach using a professional ethics course. Essentially, we are suggesting a methodology that make ethics education more effective. We follow Sims and Felton (Journal of Business Ethics 63 (3): 297–312, 2006) analytical framework that incorporates targeted learning outcomes, environment, processes, and experience facilitated through a student-led pedagogical approach. We utilize the concept of “critical consciousness”, developed by Jagger and Volkman (The International Journal of Management Education 12 (2): 177–185, 2013), which is captured through the mechanisms of a Student Learning Portfolio and a Process-Oriented-Guided-Enquiry approach. Both these mechanisms incorporate critical self-reflection and the application of knowledge derived from experience. Our findings have significant implications for the effective teaching of ethics, and more generally for business and management education.
KeywordsTeaching ethics Personal virtues Social virtues Humility Critical consciousness Student learning portfolio
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest statement
On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.
- Andrew, M.J., C. Brotheridge, and J. Urbanski. 2005. Bringing humility to leadership: Antecedents and consequences of leader humility. Human Relations 58 (10): 1323–1350.Google Scholar
- Argandoña, A. 2015. Humility in management. Journal of Business Ethics 132 (1): 63–71.Google Scholar
- Baden, D. 2014. Look on the bright side: A comparison of positive and negative role models in business ethics education. Academy of Management Learning and Education 13 (2): 154–170.Google Scholar
- Baldoni, J. 2009. Humility as a leadership trait. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2009/09/humility-as-a-leadership-trait/. Accessed 15 April 2018.
- Baron, R.M., and D.A. Kenny. 1986. The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 51 (6): 1173–1182.Google Scholar
- Berk, R. 2009. Multimedia teaching with video clips: TV, movies, YouTube, and MtvU in the college classroom. International Journal of Technology in Teaching and Learning 5 (1): 1–21.Google Scholar
- Bradley, O., and D. Hekman. 2016. How does leader humility influence team performance? Exploring the mechanisms of contagion and collective promotion focus. Academy of Management Journal 59 (3): 1088–1111.Google Scholar
- Cajiao, J., and M. Burk. 2016. How instructional methods influence skill development in management education. Academy of Management Learning & Education 15 (3): 508–524.Google Scholar
- Caldwell, C., R. Ichiho, and V. Anderson. 2017. Understanding level 5 leaders: The ethical perspectives of leadership humility. Journal of Management Development 36 (5): 724–732.Google Scholar
- Chory, R., and E. Offstein. 2017. Your professor will know you as a person: Evaluating and rethinking the relational boundaries between faculty and students. Journal of Management Education 41 (1): 9–38.Google Scholar
- Collins, J. 2005. Level 5 leadership: The triumph of humility and fierce resolve. Harvard Business Review 83 (7): 136–146.Google Scholar
- Dame, J., and J. Gedmin. 2013. Six principles for developing humility as a leader. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2013/09/six-principles-for-developing/. Accessed 16 April 2018.
- Davis, E. 2017. Ethics Within and Throughout. AACSB Blog. http://www.aacsb.edu/blog/2017/august/ethics-within-and-throughout/. Accessed 16 May 2018.
- Dudani, S. 2014. Stanford Panel Debates: Does Teaching Ethics Do Any Good. Stanford Report. http://news.stanford.edu/news/2014/may/ethics-in-society-051314.html. Accessed 03 September 2018.
- Edward Watkins, C., J. Hook, J. Ramaeker, and M. Ramos. 2016. Repairing the ruptured supervisory Alliance: Humility as a foundational virtue in clinical supervision. The Clinical Supervisor 35 (1): 22–41.Google Scholar
- Feng, B., and J. Berdahl. 2016. Gaining influence by being humble: An empirical test of the virtue theory of status attainment. Academy of Management Annual Proceedings. https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/ambpp.2016.16948abstract/. Accessed 16 January 2018.
- Fontrodona, J., A. Sison, and B. de Bruin. 2013. Putting virtues into practice. A challenge for business and organizations. Journal of Business Ethics 113 (4): 563–565.Google Scholar
- Frostenson, M. 2016. Humility in business: A contextual approach. Journal of Business Ethics 138 (1): 91–102.Google Scholar
- Giacalone, R., and M. Promislo. 2013. Broken when entering: The stigmatization of goodness and business ethics education. Academy of Management Learning and Education 12 (1): 86–101.Google Scholar
- Hair, J., W. Black, B. Babin, and R. Anderson. 2010. Multivariate Data Analysis. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
- Himsel, D. 2014. Business schools Aren’t producing ethical graduates. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-08-06/business-schools-don’t-teach-ethiceffectively/. Accessed 10 February 2018.
- Jagger, S., and R. Volkman. 2013. Helping students to see for themselves that ethics matters. The International Journal of Management Education 12 (2): 177–185.Google Scholar
- Jeung, C., and H. Yoon. 2016. Leader humility and psychological empowerment: Investigating contingencies. Journal of Managerial Psychology 31 (7): 1122–1136.Google Scholar
- Kamerick, M. 2017. Can business schools make companies ethical? https://www.fastcompany/40508606/can-business-schools-make-companies-ethical/. Accessed 20 March 2018.
- Kiel, F. 2015. Measuring the return on character. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2013/09/six-principles-for-developing/. Accessed 16 April 2018.
- Knights, J., D. Grant, and G. Young. 2018. Leading beyond the Ego: How to become a transpersonal leader. Oxon: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Korn, M. 2013. Does an ‘A’ in Ethics Have Any Value? The Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887324761004578286102004694378?mod=e2fb/. Accessed 19 April 2018.
- Lennick, D., F. Kiel, and K. Jordan. 2011. Moral intelligence 2.0: Enhancing business performance and leadership success in turbulent times. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
- Loughran, J. 2002. Effective reflective practice: In search of meaning in learning about teaching. Journal of Teacher Education 53 (1): 37–43.Google Scholar
- Marquis, M. 2003. Using literature to teach ethics. Journal of Applied Economics and Policy 22: 53–60.Google Scholar
- McDonald, D. 2017. The Golden passport: The limits of capitalism, and the moral failure of the MBA elite. New York: Harper Business.Google Scholar
- Moog, R., and J. Spencer, eds. 2008. Process oriented guided inquiry learning (POGIL). Washington DC: American Chemical Society.Google Scholar
- Morales-Sánchez, R., and C. Cabello-Medina. 2015. Integrating character in management: Virtues, character strengths, and competencies. Business Ethics: A European Review 24 (3): 156–174.Google Scholar
- Nielson, R., and J. Marrone. 2018. Humility: Our current understanding of the construct and its role in organizations. International Journal of Management Reviews 20 (4): 805–824.Google Scholar
- O’Boyle, E., and L. Sandonà. 2014. Teaching business ethics through popular feature films: An experiential approach. Journal of Business Ethics 121 (3): 329–340.Google Scholar
- Owens, B., and D. Hekman. 2012. Modeling how to grow: An inductive examination of humble leader behaviors, contingencies, and outcomes. Academy of Management Journal 55 (4): 787–818.Google Scholar
- Owens, B., M. Johnson, and T. Mitchell. 2013. Expressed humility in organizations: Implications for performance, teams, and leadership. Organizational Science 24 (5): 1517–1538.Google Scholar
- Paine, D., S. Sandage, D. Rupert, N. Devor, and M. Bronstein. 2015. Humility as a psychotherapeutic virtue: Spiritual, philosophical, and psychological foundations. Journal of Spirituality in Mental Illness 17 (1): 3–25.Google Scholar
- Prime, J., and E. Salib. 2014. The best leaders are humble leaders. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2014/05/the-best-leaders-are-humble-leaders/. Accessed 19 January 2018.
- Rego, A., M. Pina e Cunha, and A. Simpson. 2018. The perceived impact of leaders’ humility on team effectiveness: An empirical study. Journal of Business Ethics 148 (1): 205–218.Google Scholar
- Rimanoczy, I. 2016. Stop teaching: Principles and practices for responsible management. New York: Business Expert Press.Google Scholar
- Sims, R., and E. Felton. 2006. Designing and delivering business ethics teaching and learning. Journal of Business Ethics 63 (3): 297–312.Google Scholar
- Tangney, J. 2000. Humility: Theoretical perspectives, empirical findings and directions for future research. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 19 (1): 70–82.Google Scholar
- Tong, E., K. Tan, A. Chor, E. Koh, J. Lee, and R. Tan. 2016. Humility facilitates higher self-control. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 62: 30–39.Google Scholar
- Vera, D., and A. Rodriguez-Lopez. 2004. Strategic virtues: Humility as a source of competitive advantage. Organizational Dynamics 33 (4): 393–340.Google Scholar
- Vogt, C. 2016. Virtue: Personal formation and social transformation. Theological Studies 77 (1): 181–196.Google Scholar
- Wallace, A., A. Ou, and B. Owens. 2017. Humility in management. Oxford Bibliographies. http://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199846740/obo-9780199846740-0132.xml/. Accessed 19 January 2018.
- Wang, L., L. Junchao, and S. Lihua. 2016. Who Displays Humility, When Does It Matter, and How Does It Feel? In Academy of Management Proceedings. https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/ambpp.2016.12275abstract/. Accessed 20 April 2018.Google Scholar
- Whatley, L.R. 2014. The role of humility within personality architecture. Organization Development Journal 32 (1): 21–32.Google Scholar
- Ẑiaran, P. 2015. Humility and self-esteem as key predictors of ethical attitude in leadership. Procedia Economics and Finance 34: 689–696.Google Scholar
- Zubizarreta, J. 2004. The Learning Portfolio: Reflective Practice for Improving Student Learning. Bolton: Anker.Google Scholar