Advertisement

“Keep calm”? A critique of Wolfgang Behringer’s “A Cultural History of Climate”

  • Rüdiger HaudeEmail author
Original Article
  • 8 Downloads

Abstract

The field of climate historiography is still young, and more internal criticism is needed. In the German-speaking world, the bestseller in this field is Wolfgang Behringer’s A Cultural History of Climate, which has also been translated into various other languages, including English. This book runs the climate change denier business. In doing so, it violates the standards of historical science. The paper demonstrates this problem by means of Behringer’s highly problematic handling of sources and literature, both in the field of history and in the natural sciences. Further, fundamental premises of the author—such as the parallelization of climate science with the witch-hunters of the early modern period or the assumption that global warming has historically always been favorable—are analyzed in the sense of a critique of ideology. Behringer’s political concern of delegitimizing climate science is wrapped up in a par force ride through earth and human history, for which the book has been widely acclaimed. But ideology comes to the surface on many pages. Thus, he criticizes the use of metaphors within climate science without understanding the inevitability of metaphorical language use within the sciences. Dealing with the natural sciences, he uses obsolete insights, confuses logical categories, contradicts himself, and violates the literature used—all these only if it is in favor of his objective. And this does not change when it comes to his own field of expertise, historical science. The essay contextualizes the criticized work within the oeuvre of the renowned author, and it presents the remarkable reception history of the book. Behringer’s call to inaction appears to be very influential indeed, at least in German language discourses of education and of journalism. In a time in which fast, decisive action is the highest duty of the international community, and of every national government, this makes his book a dangerous phenomenon.

Keywords

Climate history Climate deniers Little Ice Age Political education Witch-hunt 

References

  1. Allemeyer M (2009) Review to: Wolfgang Behringer, Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. Zeitschrift für Historische Forschung 36(1):95–97Google Scholar
  2. Archibald JD (1996) Dinosaur extinction and the end of an era. What the fossils say. Columbia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  3. Behringer W (1995) Weather, hunger and fear: origins of the European witch-hunts in climate, society and mentality. In: German history 13 (1995), No. 1:1–27Google Scholar
  4. Behringer W (2005) “Kleine Eiszeit” und Frühe Neuzeit. In: Behringer W, Lehmann H, Pfister C (eds) Kulturelle Konsequenzen der "Kleinen Eiszeit". Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen, pp 415–508Google Scholar
  5. Behringer W (2010a) Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. Von der Eiszeit bis zur globalen Erwärmung, Beck, Munich [first published 2007Google Scholar
  6. Behringer W (2010b) A cultural history of climate. Translated by Patrick Camiller. Polity Press, Cambridge/Malden (MA)Google Scholar
  7. Behringer W (2013) Klimageschichte, Hexenverfolgung und Industrielle Revolution. Eine neue Sicht Europas in der Neuzeit. In: Kuhn B, Windus A (eds) Umwelt und Klima im Geschichtsunterricht. Röhrig, St. Ingbert, pp 29–36Google Scholar
  8. Behringer W (2015) Climatic change and witch-Hunting: the impact of the Little Ice Age on mentalities. In: Hulme M (ed) Climates and cultures. Sage, Los Angeles, pp 17–33 [first published in: Climatic Change 43 (1999), 1, pp 335–351]Google Scholar
  9. Behringer W (2016a) Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. Von der Eiszeit bis zur globalen Erwärmung. dtv, Munich. [first published 2007]Google Scholar
  10. Behringer W (2016b) Tambora und das Jahr ohne Sommer. Wie ein Vulkan die Welt in die Krise stürzte. Beck, MunichGoogle Scholar
  11. Behringer W (2017) Das wechselhafte Klima der letzten 1000 Jahre. In: Meller H, Puttkammer T (ed) Klimagewalten. Treibende Kraft der Evolution. Begleitband zur Sonderausstellung im Landesmuseum für Vorgeschichte Halle (Saale), 30. November 2017 bis 21. Mai 2018. Theiss, Darmstadt, pp 392–403Google Scholar
  12. Behringer W (2018) Review to: Haus der Geschichte Baden-Württemberg (ed): Tambora. Ein Vulkan verändert Südwestdeutschland. Ubstadt-Weiher 2017, in: H/Soz/Kult, 05/07/2018, www.hsozkult.de/publicationreview/id/rezbuecher-27970 (last checked: 01/19/2019)
  13. Boehm P (2006) Global warning: devastation of an atoll. In: Independent, 08/30/2006. https://www.independent.co.uk/environment/global-warning-devastation-of-an-atoll-413922.html (last checked: 01/19/2019)
  14. Buber M (1956) Königtum Gottes. Lambert Schneider, Heidelberg [first published in 1932]Google Scholar
  15. Erwin DH (1993) The great Paleozoic crisis. Life and death in the Permian. Columbia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  16. Haude R, Wagner T (2004) „Herrschaftsfreie Gesellschaft”. In: Historisch-Kritisches Wörterbuch des Marxismus. Vol. 6/1. Argument, Berlin, columns 135–161Google Scholar
  17. Howe JP (2017) Making climate change history. Primary sources from global warming’s past. University of Washington Press, Seattle/LondonGoogle Scholar
  18. ICAS (1974) Report of the Ad Hoc Panel on the Present Interglacial. ICAS 18b-FY75, August 1974. https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/008363827 (last checked: 01/19/2019)
  19. IPCC (2018) Global warming of 1.5°C. An IPCC Special Report on the impacts of global warming of 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change, sustainable development, and efforts to eradicate poverty. Summary for Policymakers. https://report.ipcc.ch/sr15/pdf/sr15_spm_final.pdf Accessed 01/20/2019
  20. Kukla GJ, Matthews RK (1972) When will the present interglacial end? Science 178(1972):190–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Lübken U (2008) Review to: Wolfgang Behringer: Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. In: sehepunkte 8, no. 11 (11/15/2008). http://www.sehepunkte.de/2008/11/13282.html (last checked: 01/29/2018)
  22. Ludwig KH (2006) Eine kurze Geschichte des Klimas. Von der Entstehung der Erde bis heute. Beck, MunichGoogle Scholar
  23. Mauelshagen F (2007) Ist das Wetter an allem Schuld? Review to: Wolfgang Behringer, Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. Neue Zürcher Zeitung:12/06/2007Google Scholar
  24. Meadows DH, Meadows DL, Randers J, Behrens WW III (2017) The limits to growth. A report for the Club of Rome’s project on the predicament of mankind. In: Howe 2017, pp. 103–107 [first published in 1972]Google Scholar
  25. Oreskes N, Conway EM (2010) Merchants of doubt. How a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming. Bloomsbury, LondonGoogle Scholar
  26. Pfister C (2008) Review to: Wolfgang Behringer: Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. Vierteljahrschrift für Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte 95(2008):338–339Google Scholar
  27. Pfister C (2009) Review to: Wolfgang Behringer: Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. Hist Z 288(2009):152–154Google Scholar
  28. Poliwoda G (2008) Review to: Wolfgang Behringer: Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. In: H/Soz/Kult, 03/18/2008. www.hsozkult.de/publicationreview/id/rezbuecher-10576 (last checked: 01/20/2019)
  29. Robisheaux T (1989) Rural society and the search for order in early modern Germany. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Saltzwedel J (2007) Review to: Wolfgang Behringer, Kulturgeschichte des Klimas. In: Der Spiegel, 24.9.2007. http://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/kulturspiegel/d-53078791.html (last checked: 01/19/2019)
  31. Schellnhuber HJ (2015) Selbstverbrennung. Die fatale Dreiecksbeziehung zwischen Klima, Mensch und Kohlenstoff. Bertelsmann, MunichGoogle Scholar
  32. Schlecking K (2013) Hexenverfolgung in der "Kleinen Eiszeit". In: Kuhn B, Windus A (eds) Umwelt und Klima im Geschichtsunterricht. Tubular, St. Ingbert, pp 113–116Google Scholar
  33. Sheehan PM (2001) The late Ordovician mass extinction. Annu Rev Earth Planet Sci 29(2001):331–364.  https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.earth.29.1.331 (last checked: 01/11/2019)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Somerville RCJ (2006) Medical metaphors for climate issues. An editorial essay. Clim Chang 76(2006):1–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Tashman B (2017) Pat Robertson: climate scientists are religious fundamentalists (02/01/2017). http://www.rightwingwatch.org/post/pat-robertson-climate-scientists-are-religious-fundamentalists/ (last checked: 01/19/2019)
  36. Warrick O (2011) The adaptive capacity of the Tegua island community, Torres Islands, Vanuatu.http://www.environment.gov.au/system/files/resources/26e3a6ec-d45e-4c95-8cda-fecfe9ae981c/files/usp-adaptive-capacity-vanuatu.pdf (last checked: 01/19/2019)
  37. Wehen-Behrens B (2015) Klimageschichte. In: Reeken Dv, Döpcke I, Wehen-Behrens B (ed) Umweltgeschichte lehren und lernen. Keine Katastrophe! Wochenschau, Schwalbach/Taunus, pp. 163–183Google Scholar

Copyright information

© AESS 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Historisches InstitutRWTH Aachen UniversityAachenGermany

Personalised recommendations