Unleaded hunting: Are copper bullets and lead-based bullets equally effective for killing big game?
- 51 Downloads
Semi-jacketed lead-cored or copper-based homogenous rifle bullets are commonly used for hunting big game. Ever since their introduction in the 1990’s, copper-based bullets have not been widely accepted by hunters due to limited supply, higher expense, and the perception that they exhibit inferior killing efficiency and correspondingly higher wounding rates. Here, we present data showing that animal flight distances for roe deer, red deer, brown bear, and moose dispatched with lead- or copper-based hunting bullets did not significantly differ from an animal welfare standardized animal flight distance based on body mass. Lead-cored bullets typical fragment on impact, whereas copper-based bullets retain more mass and expand more than their leaden counterparts. Our data demonstrate that the relative killing efficiency of lead and copper bullets is similar in terms of animal flight distance after fatal shots. Hunters that traditionally use lead bullets should consider switching to copper bullets to enhance human and environmental health.
KeywordsAnimal flight distance Animal welfare Hunting bullet expansion Killing efficiency Lead and copper ammunition Wound ballistics
This study was carried out in collaboration with the Swedish Association for Hunting and Wildlife Management and the Finnish Wildlife Agency and partly funded by Norwegian Environment Agency. We thank L. Botten, who carried out the laboratory work on retrieved bullets, and Arne Söderberg for his inestimable work to gather and systematize the brown bear data. We are grateful to A/S Norske Shell who enabled our sampling of culling data from their effort to remove roe- and red deer from their plant site at Nyhamna, Norway. And finally, we thank thousands of anonymous hunters in Norway, Sweden, and Finland, who submitted bullets and provided data on hunting practices.
- Almar-Næss, A. 1985. Metallic materials. Trondheim: Tapir Akademisk Forlag. (In Norwegian).Google Scholar
- Batha, C., and P. Lehman. 2010. How good are copper bullets, really? Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. Retrieved 8 February, 2019, from http://www.fwspubs.org/doi/suppl/10.3996/032013-JFWM-029/suppl_file/032013-jfwm-029r2-s02.pdf.
- Bundesinstitut für Risikobewertung. 2013. BfR-symposium on wild game research (In German). Retrieved 8 February, 2019, from http://www.bfr.bund.de/cm/350/alleswild-bfr-symposium-zu-forschungsvorhaben-zum-thema-wildbret-tagungsband.pdf.
- Carlucci, D.E., and S.S. Jacobson. 2014. Ballistics; theory and design of guns and ammunition. Boca raton: CRC Press.Google Scholar
- Caudell, J.N., S.R. Stopak, and P.C. Wolf. 2012. Lead-free, high-powered rifle bullets and their applicability in wildlife management. Human-Wildlife Interactions 6: 105–111.Google Scholar
- Cornicelli L., and M. Grund. 2008. Examining variability associated with bullet fragmentation and deposition in white-tailed deer and domestic sheep: preliminary results. Minnesota Department of Natural Resources. Retrieved 8 February, 2019, from https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/hunting/ammo/lead.html.
- Delahay, R.J., and C.J. Spray. 2015. Proceedings of the Oxford lead symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute.Google Scholar
- Di Maio, V.J.M. 1999. Gunshot wounds, practical aspects of firearms, ballistics and forensic techniques, 2nd ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press.Google Scholar
- Fackler, M.L. 1988. Wound ballistics: A review of common misconceptions. The Association of Firearm and Tool Mark Examiners (AFTE) Journal 21: 25–29.Google Scholar
- Fackler, M.L. 2001. Wound profiles. Wound Ballistic Review 5: 25–38.Google Scholar
- Gaieski, D., and M. Mikkelsen. 2017. Definition, classification, etiology, and pathophysiology of shock in adults. In UpToDate, ed. P. E. Parsons, UpToDate Inc. Retrieved 8 February, 2019, from https://www.uptodate.com/contents/definition-classification-etiology-and-pathophysiology-of-shock-in-adults.
- Gerofke, A.E., A. Ulbig, C. Martin, T. Müller-Graf, C. Selhorst, M. Gremse, H.Schafft Spolders, et al. 2018. Lead content in wild game shot with lead or non-lead ammunition: Does “state of the art consumer health protection” require non-lead ammunition? PLoS ONE 13: e0200792. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0200792.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Gremse, C. and S. Rieger. 2014. Ergänzende Untersuchungen zur Tötungswirkung bleifreier Geschosse. Erweiterter Bericht zum Abschlussbericht vom 30.11.2012. Fachgebiet Wildbiologie, Wildtiermanagement & Jagdbetriebskunde. Eberswalde: Eberswalde Hochschule für nachhaltige Entwicklung (In German).Google Scholar
- Grund, M.D., L. Cornicelli, L.T. Carlson, and E.A. Butler. 2010. Bullet fragmentation and lead deposition in white-tailed deer and domestic sheep. Human-Wildlife Interactions 4: 257–265.Google Scholar
- Guruswamy, S. 2000. Engineering properties and applications of lead alloys. New York: Marcel Dekker.Google Scholar
- Hjorteviltregisteret. 2016. Species facts (In Norwegian). Retrieved 8 February, 2019, from http://www.hjortevilt.no/fakta-om-artene/.
- Janzon, B., J.B. Hull, and J.M. Ryan. 1997. Projectile, material interactions: soft tissue and bone. In Scientific foundations of trauma, ed. G.J. Cooper, H.A.F. Dudley, D.S. Gann, R.A. Little, and R.L. Maynard, 37–52. Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.Google Scholar
- Kneubuehl, B.P., R.M. Coupland, M.A. Rothschild, and M.J. Thali. 2011. Wound Ballistics, basics and applications. Berlin: Springer.Google Scholar
- Knott, J., J. Gilbert, R.E. Green, and D.G. Hoccom. 2009. Comparison of the lethality of lead and copper bullets in deer control operations to reduce incidental lead poisoning; field trials in England and Scotland. Conservation Evidence 6: 71–78.Google Scholar
- Krone, O., and H. Hofer. 2005. Spent ammunition and lead poisoning of white-tailed sea eagles. Berlin: Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research. (In German).Google Scholar
- MacPherson, D. 1994. Bullet penetration—modeling the dynamics and incapacitation resulting from wound trauma, 2nd ed. El Segundo: Ballistic Publications.Google Scholar
- Manly, B.F.J. 2001. Randomization, bootstrap and Monte Carlo methods in biology. Boca Raton: Chapman & Hall/CRC Press.Google Scholar
- McCann, B.E., W. Whitworth, and R.A. Newman. 2016. Efficacy of non-lead ammunition for culling elk at Theodore Roosevelt National Park. Human-Wildlife Interactions 10: 268–282.Google Scholar
- Roberts, G.K. 1988. The wounding effect of 5.56 mm/.223 law enforcement general purpose shoulder fired carbines compared with 12 GA. shotguns and pistol caliber weapons using 10% ordnance gelatine as a tissue simulant. Wound Ballistics Review 3: 16–28.Google Scholar
- Southwick Associates Inc. 2014. Effects of the ban on traditional ammunition for hunting in California on hunting participation and associated economic measures. Prepared for the National Shooting Sports Foundation. Fernandina Beach, Florida. Retrieved 12 February from https://www.google.no/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwinhsCAx7bgAhXmw8QBHQFwDJ8QFjAAegQIARAC and https://oregon-alliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/FCA-Alternative-Ammo-Impacts_9-15-2014.pdf&usg=AOvVaw2fdvs7VhlwYQkWghC3K2yA.
- Solberg, E.J., V. Veiberg, C.M. Rolandsen, M. Ueno, E.B Nilsen, L.E. Gangsei, M. Stenbrenden, and L.E. Libjå. 2014. Sett elg- og sett hjort-overvåkingen: Styrker og forbedringspotensial. NINA Rapport 1043. 103 s. (In Norwegian with English abstract).Google Scholar
- Spicher, V. 2008. Experience with lead-free bullets–a field report. In Wildtierforschung Leibniz-Institut für Zoo- und Wildtierforschung, ed. O. Krone, 81–91. Bleivergiftungen bei Seeadlern: Ursachen und Lösungsansätze. Berlin.Google Scholar
- Stefanopoulos, P.K., K. Filippakis, O.T. Soupiou, and V.C. Pazarakiotis. 2014. Wound ballistics of firearm-related injuries-Part 1: Missile characteristics and mechanisms of soft tissue wounding. International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 43: 1445–1458. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijom.2014.07.013.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Stokke, S., J.M. Arnemo, A. Söderberg, and M. Kraabøl. 2012. Wounding of carnivores—understanding of concepts, status of knowledge and quantification. NINA Report 838, Trondheim (In Norwegian). https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.1.2227.2165.
- Stokke, S., J.M. Arnemo, S. Brainerd, A. Söderberg, M. Kraabøl, and B. Ytrehus. 2018. Defining animal welfare standards in hunting: body mass determines thresholds for incapacitation time and flight distance. Scientific Reports 8: 13786. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-32102-0.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Wolberg, E.J. 1991. Performance of the Winchester 9 mm 147 grain subsonic jacketed hollow point bullet in human tissue and tissue simulant. Wound Ballistic Review 91: 10–13.Google Scholar