The transition to non-lead sporting ammunition and fishing weights: Review of progress and barriers to implementation
This review presents evidence of lead exposure and toxicity to wildlife and humans from spent shotgun and rifle ammunition and fishing weights, and the barriers and bridges to completing the transition to non-lead products. Despite the international availability of effective non-lead substitutes, and that more jurisdictions are adopting suitable policies and regulations, a broader transition to non-lead alternatives is prevented because resolution remains divided among disparate human user constituencies. Progress has occurred only where evidence is most compelling or where a responsible public authority with statutory powers has managed to change mindsets in the wider public interest. Arguments opposing lead bans are shown to lack validity. Differing national regulations impede progress, requiring analysis to achieve better regulation. Evidence that lead bans have reduced wildlife exposure should be used more to promote sustainable hunting and fishing. Evidence of the lead contribution from hunted game to human exposure should shape policy and regulation to end lead ammunition use. The Special Issue presents evidence that a transition to non-lead products is both warranted and feasible.
KeywordsBullets Effectiveness Exposure Regulations Shot Socio-politics
The authors are grateful to the reviewers for their constructive comments on this paper. Funding was provided from the personal private resources of the authors.
- AFEMS/WFSA. 2015. Symposium “The sustainable use of lead ammunition in hunting and sports shooting: Facts and emotions” press release. http://leadsymposium.eu/en/the_symposium_release.aspx.
- Brown, M., E. Linton, and E.C. Rees. 1992. Causes of mortality among wild swans in Britain. Wildfowl 43: 70–79.Google Scholar
- Commission of the European Communities (CEC). 1979. Council Directive 79/409/EEC of 2 April on the conservation of wild birds. Official Journal of the European Union L103: 1–18.Google Scholar
- Commission Regulation (EC). 2001. Setting maximum levels for certain contaminants in foodstuffs. Official Journal of the European Communities No. 466/2001.Google Scholar
- Cromie, R., J. Newth, J. Reeves, M. O’Brien, K. Beckmann, and M. Brown. 2015. The sociological and political aspects of reducing lead poisoning from ammunition in the UK: Why the transition to non-toxic ammunition is so difficult. In Proceedings of the Oxford Lead Symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health, ed. R.J. Delahay and C.J. Spray, 104–124. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute, The University of Oxford.Google Scholar
- Delahay, R.J. and C.J. Spray (eds.). 2015. Proceedings of the Oxford Lead Symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute, The University of Oxford.Google Scholar
- Ecke, F., N.J. Singh, J.M. Arnemo, A. Bignert, B. Helander, A.M.M. Berglund, H. Borg, C. Bröjer, et al. 2017. Sublethal lead exposure alters movement behavior in free-ranging golden eagles. Environmental Science and Technology 51: 5729–5736. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.6b06024.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Fachehoun, R.C., B. Lévesque, P. Dumas, A. St-Louis, M. Dubé, and P. Ayotte. 2015. Lead exposure through consumption of big game meat in Quebec, Canada: Risk assessment and perception. Food Additives and Contaminants: Part: A 32: 1501–1511. https://doi.org/10.1080/19440049.2015.1071921.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Franklin, B. 1786. The famous Benjamin Franklin letter on lead poisoning. http://environmentaleducation.com/wp-content/uploads/userfiles/Ben%20Franklin%20Letter%20on%20EEA%281%29.pdf.
- Franson, J.C., S.P. Hansen, T.E. Creekmore, C.J. Brand, D.C. Evers, A.E. Duerr, and S. DeStefano. 2003. Lead fishing weights and other fishing tackle in selected waterbirds. Waterbirds 26: 345–352. https://doi.org/10.1675/1524-4695(2003)026%5b0345:LFWAOF%5d2.0.CO;2.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Garbett, R., G. Maude, P. Hancock, D. Kenny, R. Reading, and A. Amar. 2018. Association between hunting and elevated blood lead levels in the critically endangered African White-backed Vulture Gyps africanus. Science of the Total Environment 631–632: 1654–1665. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.02.220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Gerofke, A., E. Ubig, A. Martin, C. Müller-Graf, T. Selhorst, C. Gremse, M. Spolders, H. Schafft, et al. 2018. Lead content in wild game shot with lead or non-lead ammunition—does “state of the art consumer health protection” require non-lead ammunition?. PLoS ONE 13 (7): e0200792. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0200792.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Gil-Sánchez, J.M., S. Molleda, J.A. Sánchez-Zapata, J. Bautista, I. Navas, R. Godinho, A.J. García-Fernández, and M. Moleón. 2018. From sport hunting to breeding success: Patterns of lead ammunition ingestion and its effects on an endangered raptor. Science of the Total Environment 613–614: 483–491. https://doi.org/10.1016/jscitotenv.2017.09.069.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Golden, N.H., S.E. Warner, and M.J. Coffey. 2016. Review and assessment of spent lead ammunition and its exposure and effects to scavenging birds in the United States. In Review of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, Vol. 37, ed. P. de Voogt, 123–191. Switzerland: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-23573-8_6.
- Green, R.E., and D.J. Pain. 2015. Risks of health effects to humans in the UK from ammunition-derived lead. In Proceedings of the Oxford Lead Symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health, eds. R.J. Delahay and C.J. Spray, 27–43. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute, The University of Oxford.Google Scholar
- GWCT (Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust). 2016. Position statement: Lead ammunition. http://www.gwct.org.uk/policy/position-statements/lead-ammunition/?utm_source=Game.
- Helander, B., J. Axelsson, H. Borg, K. Holm, and A. Bignert. 2009. Ingestion of lead from ammunition and lead concentrations in white-tailed sea eagles (Heliaeetus albicilla) in Sweden. Science of the Total Environment 407: 5555–5563. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2009.07.027.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ishii, C., S.M.M. Nakayama, Y. Ikenaka, H. Nakata, K. Saito, Y. Watanabe, H. Mizukawa, S. Tanabe, et al. 2017. Lead exposure in raptors from Japan and source identification using Pb stable isotope ratios. Chemosphere 186: 367–373. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2017.07.143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Juric, A.K., M. Batal, W. David, D. Sharp, H. Schwartz, A. Ing, K. Fediuk, A. Black, et al. 2018. Risk assessment of dietary lead exposure among First Nations people living on-reserve in Ontario, Canada using a total diet study and a probabilistic approach. Journal of Hazardous Materials 344: 55–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2017.09.035.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kanstrup, N. 2015. Practical and social barriers to switching from lead to non-toxic gunshot—a perspective from the EU. In Proceedings of the Oxford Lead Symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health, eds. R.J. Delahay and C.J. Spray, 98–103. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute, The University of Oxford.Google Scholar
- Kanstrup, N. 2019. Lessons learned from 33 years of lead shot regulation in Denmark. In Lead in hunting ammunition: Persistent problems and solutions, eds. N. Kanstrup, V.G. Thomas, and A.D. Fox, Ambio vol. 48, Special Issue. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-018-1125-9.
- Kelly, T.R., P.H. Bloom, S.G. Torres, Y.Z. Hernandez, R.H. Poppenga, W.M. Boyce, and C.K. Johnson. 2011. Impact of the California lead ammunition ban on reducing lead exposure in golden eagles and turkey vultures. PLoS ONE 6: e17656. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0017656.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Krebs, C.J. 1994. Ecology: The experimental analysis of distribution and abundance, 4th ed. New York, NY: Harper Collins.Google Scholar
- Krone, O., N. Kenntner, A. Trinogga, M. Nadjafzadeh, F. Scholz, J. Sulawa, K. Totschek, P. Schuck-Wersig, et al. 2009. Lead poisoning in White-tailed Sea Eagles: Causes and approaches to solutions in Germany. In Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: Implications for wildlife and humans, eds. R.T. Watson, M. Fuller, M. Pokras, and W.G. Hunt, 289–301. Boise, ID: The Peregrine Fund. https://doi.org/10.4080/ilsa.2009.0207.
- Leopold, A. 1930. Game management. Madison, Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
- Maret, W. 2017. The bioinorganic chemistry of lead in the context of its toxicity. In Lead: Its effects on environment and health, ed. A. Siegel, H. Siegel, and R. Siegel, 1–20. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter and Co. KG.Google Scholar
- Mateo, R., N. Vallverdú-Coll, A. López-Antia, M.A. Taggart, M. Matínez-Haro, R. Guitart, and M.E. Ortiz-Santaliestra. 2014. Reducing Pb poisoning in birds and Pb exposure in game meat consumers: The dual benefit of effective Pb shot regulation. Environment International 63: 163–168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2013.11.006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McCann, B.E., W. Whitworth, and R.A. Newman. 2016. Efficacy of non-lead ammunition for culling elk at Theodore Roosevelt National Park. Human-Wildlife Interactions 10: 268–282.Google Scholar
- Nagy, S., N. Petkov, E. Rees, A. Solokha, G. Hilton, J. Beekman, and B. Nolet. 2012. International Single Species Action Plan for the conservation of the Northwest European population of Bewick’s Swan Cygnus columbianus bewickii. AEWA Technical Series No. 44, 63 pp. Bonn, Germany: AEWA. http://www.unep-aewa.org/meetings/en/mop/mop5_docs/pdf/mop5_26_draft_ssap_bewicks-swan_jkrev.pdf.
- Newth, J.L., R.L. Cromie, M.J. Brown, R.J. Delahay, A.A. Meharg, C. Deacon, G.J. Norton, M.F. O’Brien, et al. 2013. Poisoning from lead gunshot: Still a threat to wild waterbirds in Britain. European Journal of Wildlife Research 59: 195–204. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10344-012-0666-7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Newth, J.L., E.C. Rees, R.L. Cromie, R.A. McDonald, S. Bearhop, D.J. Pain, G.L. Norton, C. Deacon, et al. 2016. Widespread exposure to lead affects body condition of free-living whooper swans Cygnus cygnus wintering in Britain. Environmental Pollution 209: 60–67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2015.11.007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Pain, D.J. (ed.). 1992. Lead poisoning in waterfowl. Proceedings of an IWRB workshop. Slimbridge: IWRB Special Publication No. 16. The International Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau.Google Scholar
- Pain, D.J., I.J. Fisher, and V.G. Thomas. 2009. A global update of lead poisoning in terrestrial birds from ammunition sources. In Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: Implications for wildlife and humans, eds. R.T. Watson, M. Fuller, M. Pokras, and W.G. Hunt, 99–118. Boise, ID: The Peregrine Fund. https://doi.org/10.4080/ilsa.2009.010.8.
- Rees, E.C. 2006. Bewick’s Swan. London: T. and A.D. Poyser.Google Scholar
- Rodriguez-Ramos Fernandez, J., U. Höfle, R. Mateo, O. Nicolas de Francisco, R. Abbott, P. Acevedo, and J.M. Blanco. 2011. Assessment of lead exposure in Spanish imperial eagle (Aquila adalberti) from spent ammunition in central Spain. Ecotoxicology 20: 670–681. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10646-011-0607-3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sears, J., and A. Hunt. 1991. Lead poisoning in Mute Swans, Cygnus olor, in England. Wildfowl Supplement No. 1: 383–388.Google Scholar
- Stroud, D.A. 2015. Regulation of some sources of lead poisoning: A brief review. In Proceedings of the Oxford Lead Symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health, eds. R.J. Delahay and C.J. Spray, 8–26. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute, The University of Oxford.Google Scholar
- Thomas, V.G. 2009. The policy and legislative dimensions of nontoxic shot and bullet use in North America. In Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: Implications for wildlife and humans, eds. R.T. Watson, M. Fuller, M. Pokras, and W.G. Hunt, 351–362. Boise, ID: The Peregrine Fund. https://doi.org/10.4080/ilsa.2009.0311.
- Thomas, V.G. 2015. Availability and use of lead-free shotgun and rifle cartridges in the UK, with reference to regulations in other jurisdictions. In Proceedings of the Oxford Lead Symposium. Lead ammunition: Understanding and minimising the risks to human and environmental health, eds. R.J. Delahay and C.J. Spray, 85–97. Oxford: Edward Grey Institute, The University of Oxford.Google Scholar
- Trinogga, A., G. Fritsch, H. Hofer, and O. Krone. 2013. Are lead-free hunting rifle bullets as effective at killing wildlife as conventional lead bullets? A comparison based on wound size and morphology. Science of the Total Environment 443: 226–232. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.10.084.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme). 2010. Final review of scientific information on lead. Paris: DTIE, United Nations Environment Programme.Google Scholar
- UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme). 2016. Global report on the status of legal limits on lead in paint. Nairobi: United Nations Environment Programme.Google Scholar
- U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1986. Use of lead shot for hunting migratory birds in the United States. Washington, DC: Office of Migratory Bird Management.Google Scholar
- Vallverdú-Coll, N., A. López-Anita, M. Martinez-Haro, M.E. Ortiz-Santaliestra, and R. Mateo. 2015. Altered immune response in mallard ducklings exposed to lead through maternal transfer in the wild. Environmental Pollution 205: 350–356. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2015.06.014.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Vogt, G., and E.A. Tysnes. 2015. Lead in minced beef from Norwegian hunted game, Elg (Alces alces). Moss: Eurofins Food and Feed Testing Norway AS.Google Scholar
- Watson, R.T., M. Fuller, M. Pokras, and W.G. Hunt (eds.). 2009. Ingestion of lead from spent ammunition: Implications for wildlife and humans. Boise, ID: The Peregrine Fund.Google Scholar
- WHO (World Health Organization). 2015. Lead poisoning and health. http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs379/en/.
- Wiemeyer, G.M., M.A. Pérez, L.T. Bianchini, L. Sampietro, G.F. Bravo, N.L. Jácome, V. Astore, and S.A. Lambertucci. 2017. Repeated conservation threats across the Americas: High levels of blood and bone lead in the Andean Condor widen the problem to a continental scale. Environmental Pollution 220: 672–679. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2016.10.025.CrossRefGoogle Scholar