Assessment of Uncertainty in Long-Term Mass Balances for Acidification Assessments: A MAGIC Model Exercise
- 172 Downloads
Long-term (1860–2010) catchment mass balance calculations rely on models and assumptions which are sources of uncertainty in acidification assessments. In this article, we report on an application of MAGIC to model acidification at the four Swedish IM forested catchments that have been subject to differing degrees of acidification stress. Uncertainties in the modeled mass balances were mainly associated with the deposition scenario and assumptions about sulfate adsorption and soil mass. Estimated base cation (BC) release rates (weathering) varied in a relatively narrow range of 47–62 or 42–47 meq m−2 year−1, depending on assumptions made about soil cation exchange capacity and base saturation. By varying aluminum solubility or introducing a dynamic weathering feedback that allowed BC release to increase at more acidic pHs, a systematic effect on predicted changes in acid neutralizing capacity (ΔANC ca. 10–41 μeq l−1) and pH (ca. ΔpH = 0.1–0.6) at all sites was observed. More robust projections of future changes in pH and ANC are dependent on reducing uncertainties in BC release rates, the timing, and extent of natural acidification through BC uptake by plants, temporal changes in soil element pools, and fluxes of Al between compartments.
KeywordsMAGIC Weathering Modeling Base cations Aluminum Acidification
The Swedish IM program has been funded by the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency since the program was initiated. None of the findings would have possible without access to high quality long-term data series. Therefore, the authors would like to dedicate this article to the large number of people involved in establishing, sampling, and analyzing data at the four Swedish IM sites. MNF was funded by the MISTRA Future Forests program.
- Anon. 2008. Historic deposition data for the EMAP 50*50 km Grid. Coordination Centre for Effects, Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, Bilthoven, The Netherlands.Google Scholar
- Fölster, J., C. Andrén, K. Bishop, I. Buffam, N. Cory, W. Goedkoop, K. Holmgren, R. Johnson, et al. 2007. A novel environmental quality criterion for acidification in Swedish lakes–an application of studies on the relationship between biota and water chemistry. Water, Air, and Soil pollution 7: 331–338.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Granat, L. 1988. Luft- och nederbördskemiska stationsnätet inom PMK. Rapport från verksamheten 1988. Rapport no 3649. Stockholm (in Swedish, English summary).Google Scholar
- Grimvall, A. 2004. FLOWNORM 2.0–A visual basic program for computing riverine loads of substances and extracting anthropogenic signals from time series of load data. Linköping: Department of Mathematics, Linköping University.Google Scholar
- Hellsten, S., and O. Westling. 2006. Försurande och övergödande nedfall i skog. Delprogram Krondropp inom programområdet luft. Sakrapport 2006-06-01 för naturvårdsverket, IVL, Göteborg (in Swedish, English summary).Google Scholar
- Jenkins, A., T. Larssen, F. Moldan, J. Hruska, P. Kram, and S. Kleemola. 2003. Dynamic modelling at integrating monitoring sites—model tested against observations and uncertainty. Helsinki: Finnish Environment Institute.Google Scholar
- Grandin, U. 2011a. Epiphytic algae and lichen cover in boreal forests—a long-term study along a N and S deposition gradient in Sweden. AMBIO. doi: 10.1007/s13280-011-0205-x.
- Grandin, U. 2011b. Understorey vegetation stability and dynamics in unmanaged boreal forests along a deposition gradient in Sweden. AMBIO. doi: 10.1007/s13280-011-0206-9.
- Klaminder, J., R.W. Lucas, M.N. Futter, K.H. Bishop, S.J. Köhler, G. Egnell, and H. Laudon. 2011. Silicate mineral weathering rate estimates: are they precise enough to be useful when predicting the recovery of nutrient pools after harvesting? Forest Ecology and Management 261: 1–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kram, P., K. Bishop, and F. Moldan. 2001. Modeling long-term streamwater chemistry in the Berg catchment, southwestern Sweden. Paper presented at the Nordic hydrological conference (Uppsala, Sweden, June 2000), vol. 32, 249–264.Google Scholar
- Lind, B.B., and L. Lundin. 1990. Saturated hydrological conductivity Scandinavian tills. Nordic Hydrology 21: 107–118.Google Scholar
- Löfgren, S., L. Bringmark, M. Aastrup, H. Hultberg, K. Kindbom, and H. Kvarnäs. 2001. Sulphur balances and dynamics in three forested catchments in Sweden. Water, Air, and Soil pollution 130: 632–636.Google Scholar
- Löfgren, S., M. Aastrup, L. Bringmark, H. Hultberg, L. Lewin-Pihlblad, L. Lundin, G.P. Karlsson, and B. Thunholm. 2011. Recovery of soil water, groundwater and streamwater from acidification at the Swedish Integrated Monitoring catchments. AMBIO. doi: 10.1007/s13280-011-0207-8.
- Lövblad, G., C. Persson, and E. Roos. 2000. Deposition of base cations in Sweden. Swedish Environmental Protection Agence report 5119, Stockholm.Google Scholar
- MAGIC library 2010. http://www.ivl.se/tjanster/datavardskap/magicbiblioteket/magicbiblioteket/ingaendesjoarochvattendrag.4.7df4c4e812d2da6a416800077587.htm. Retrieved 20 Oct 2010
- Mörth, C.M., P. Torssander, and H. Kusakabe. 1999. Sulfur isotope values in a forested catchment over four years: Evidence for oxidation and reduction processes. Biogeochemistry 44: 51–71.Google Scholar
- Parkhurst, D. 1998. PHREEQC (Version2)—A computer program for speciation, batch reaction, one-dimensional transport and inverse geochemical calculations. http://wwwbrr.cr.usgs.gov/projects/GWC_coupled/phreeqc/index.html.
- Persson, C., M. Ferm, and O. Westling. 2004. Förbättrad mätning och beräkning av belastningen av försurande och övergödande luftföroreningar. Specialprojekt på uppdrag av Naturvårdsverkets miljöövervakningsenhet, SMHI och IVL. Göteborg (in Swedish).Google Scholar
- Rhode, A. 2003. Flow paths of waters in Swedish forests. Kungliga Skogs—och Lantbruksakademiens Tidskrift 142: 23–29.Google Scholar
- Sverdrup, H. U. Johnson & Felming. 1942. The Oceans. In Handbook of chemistry and physics, ed. R.C. Weast. Cleveland: Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
- Ulrich, B. 1983. Interaction of forest canopies with atmospheric constituents: CO2, alkali and earth alkali cations and chloride. In Effects of accumulation of air pollutants in Forest Ecosystems, ed. B. Ulrich and J. Pankrath, 13. Boston: Reidel.Google Scholar
- Whitfield, C.J., J. Aherne, B.J. Cosby, and S.A. Watmough. 2011. Modelling boreal lake catchment response to anthropogenic acid deposition. Journal of Limnology 69(suppl. 1): 135–146.Google Scholar
- Wieland, E., B. Wehrli, and W. Stumm. 1988. The coordination chemistry of weathering: III. A potential generalization on dissolution rated of minerals. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 52: 1969–1981.Google Scholar
- Wright, R.F., B.J. Cosby, R.C. Ferrier, A. Jenkins, A.J. Bulger, and R. Harriman. 1994. Changes in acidification of lochs in Galloway, Southwestern Scotland, 1979–1988: the Magic model used to evaluate the role of afforestation, calculate critical loads, and predict fish status. Journal of Hydrology 161: 257–285.CrossRefGoogle Scholar