AMBIO

, Volume 39, Issue 8, pp 585–599 | Cite as

Organic Farming and Soil Carbon Sequestration: What Do We Really Know About the Benefits?

Report

Abstract

Organic farming is believed to improve soil fertility by enhancing soil organic matter (SOM) contents. An important co-benefit would be the sequestration of carbon from atmospheric CO2. Such a positive effect has been suggested based on data from field experiments though many studies were not designed to address the issue of carbon sequestration. The aim of our study was to examine published data in order to identify possible flaws such as missing a proper baseline, carbon mass measurements, or lack of a clear distinction between conventional and organic farming practices, thereby attributing effects of specific practices to organic farming, which are not uniquely organic. A total of 68 data sets were analyzed from 32 peer-reviewed publications aiming to compare conventional with organic farming. The analysis revealed that after conversion, soil C content (SOC) in organic systems increased annually by 2.2% on average, whereas in conventional systems SOC did not change significantly. The majority of publications reported SOC concentrations rather than amounts thus neglecting possible changes in soil bulk density. 34 out of 68 data sets missed a true control with well-defined starting conditions. In 37 out of 50 cases, the amount of organic fertilizer in the organic system exceeded that applied in the compared conventional system, and in half of the cases crop rotations differed between systems. In the few studies where crop rotation and organic fertilization were comparable in both systems no consistent difference in SOC was found. From this data analysis, we conclude that the claim for beneficial effects of organic farming on SOC is premature and that reported advantages of organic farming for SOC are largely determined by higher and often disproportionate application of organic fertilizer compared to conventional farming.

Keywords

Agriculture Organic farming Carbon sequestration Organic fertilizer 

References

  1. Andrén, O., T. Kätterer, and H. Kirchmann. 2008. How will conversion to organic cereal production affect carbon stocks in Swedish agricultural soils? In Organic crop production–ambitions and limitations, ed. H. Kirchmann, and L. Bergström, 161–172. Berlin: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Baisden, W.T., and R.L. Parfitt. 2007. Bomb C-14 enrichment indicates decadal C pool in deep soil? Biogeochemistry 85: 59–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Baker, J.M., T.E. Ochsner, R.T. Venterea, and T.J. Griffis. 2007. Tillage and soil carbon sequestration—what do we really know? Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 118: 1–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bergström, L., H. Kirchmann, H. Aronsson, G. Torstensson, and K. Mattsson. 2008. Use efficiency and leaching of nutrients in organic and conventional cropping systems in Sweden. In Organic crop production—ambitions and limitations, ed. H. Kirchmann, and L. Bergström, 143–160. Berlin: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Blair, N., R.D. Faulkner, A.R. Till, M. Korschens, and E. Schulz. 2006. Long-term management impacts on soil C, N and physical fertility—Part II: Bad Lauchstädt static and extreme FYM experiments. Soil Tillage Research 91: 39–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Blakemore, R.J. 2000. Ecology of earthworms under the ‘Haughley Experiment’ of organic and conventional management regimes. Biology, Agriculture and Horticulture 18: 141–159.Google Scholar
  7. Breland, T.A., and R. Eltun. 1999. Soil microbial biomass and mineralization of carbon and nitrogen in ecological, integrated and conventional forage and arable cropping systems. Biology and Fertility of Soils 30: 193–201.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Buyanovsky, G.A., and G.H. Wagner. 1998. Carbon cycling in cultivated land and its global significance. Global Change Biology 4: 131–141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Clark, M.S., W.R. Horwath, C. Shennan, and K.M. Scow. 1998. Changes in soil chemical properties resulting from organic and low-input farming practices. Agronomy Journal 90: 662–671.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Collins, H.P., E.T. Elliott, K. Paustian, L.C. Bundy, W.A. Dick, D.R. Huggins, A.J.M. Smucker, and E.A. Paul. 2000. Soil carbon pools and fluxes in long-term corn belt agroecosystems. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 32: 157–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Denison, R.F., D.C. Bryant, and T.E. Kearney. 2004. Crop yields over the first nine years of LTRAS, a long-term comparison of field crop systems in a Mediterranean climate. Field Crops Research 86: 267–277.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Dijkstra, P., O.V. Menyailo, R.R. Doucett, S.C. Hart, E. Schwartz, and B. Hungate. 2006. C and N availability affects the N-15 natural abundance of the soil microbial biomass across a cattle manure gradient. European Journal of Soil Science 57: 468–475.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Don, A., T. Scholten, and E.D. Schulze. 2009. Conversion of cropland into grassland: Implications for soil organic-carbon stocks in two soils with different texture. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science 172: 53–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Drinkwater, L., P. Wagoner, and M. Sarrantonio. 1998. Legume-based cropping systems have reduced carbon and nitrogen losses. Nature 396: 262–265.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Droogers, P., and J. Bouma. 1996. Biodynamic vs. conventional farming effects on soil structure expressed by simulated potential productivity. Soil Science Society of America Journal 60: 1552–1558.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. EEC. 1991. Council Regulation (EEC) No 2092/91 of 24 June 1991 on organic production of agricultural products and indications referring thereto on agricultural products and foodstuffs. Brussels: EEC.Google Scholar
  17. Ellert, B.H., and J.R. Bettany. 1995. Calculation of organic matter and nutrients stored in soils under contrasting management regimes. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 75: 529–538.Google Scholar
  18. Eltun, R., A. Korsaeth, and O. Nordheim. 2002. A comparison of environmental, soil fertility, yield, and economical effects in six cropping systems based on an 8-year experiment in Norway. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 90: 155–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Ewers, R.M., J.P.W. Scharlemann, A. Balmford, and R.E. Green. 2009. Do increases in agricultural yield spare land for nature? Global Change Biology 15: 1716–1726.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Flessa, H., R. Ruser, P. Dorsch, T. Kamp, M.A. Jiminez, J.C. Munch, and F. Beese. 2002. Integrated evaluation of greenhouse gas emissions (CO2, CH4, N2O) from two farming systems in southern Germany. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 91: 175–189.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Fließbach, A., H.-R. Oberholzer, L. Gunst, and P. Mäder. 2007. Soil organic matter and biological soil quality indicators after 21 years of organic and conventional farming. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 118: 273–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Friedel, J.K. 2000. The effect of farming system on labile fractions of organic matter in Calcari-epileptic regosols. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science 163: 41–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gerhardt, F.A. 1997. A comparative analysis of the effects of conventional and organic farming systems on soil structure. Biology, Agriculture and Horticulture 14: 139–157.Google Scholar
  24. Glover, J.D., J.P. Reganold, and P.K. Andrews. 2000. Systematic method for rating soil quality of conventional, organic, and integrated apple orchards in Washington State. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 80: 29–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Haas, G., F. Wetterich, and U. Köpke. 2001. Comparing intensive, extensified and organic grassland farming in southern Germany by process life cycle assessment. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 83: 43–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. IFOAM. 2006. The IFOAM basic standards for organic production and processing version 2005. Bonn: International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements.Google Scholar
  27. Jarecki, M.K., and R. Lal. 2003. Crop management for soil carbon sequestration. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 22: 471–502.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Jenkinson, D.S. 1991. The Rothamsted long-term experiments—are they still of use? Agronomy Journal 83: 2–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Johnston, A., P.R. Poulton, and K. Coleman. 2009. Soil organic matter: Its importance in sustainable agriculture and carbon dioxide fluxes. Advances in Agronomy 101: 1–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Jones, S.K., R.M. Rees, D. Kosmas, B.C. Ball, and U.M. Skiba. 2006. Carbon sequestration in a temperate grassland: Management and climatic controls. Soil Use and Management 22: 132–142.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Kirchmann, H., L. Bergstrom, T. Kätterer, L. Mattsson, and S. Gesslein. 2007. Comparison of long-term organic and conventional crop-livestock systems on a previously nutrient-depleted soil in Sweden. Agronomy Journal 99: 960–972.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kong, A.Y.Y., J. Six, D.C. Bryant, R.F. Denison, and C. Van Kessel. 2005. The relationship between carbon input, aggregation, and soil organic carbon stabilization in sustainable cropping systems. Soil Science Society of America Journal 69: 1078–1085.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Kong, A.Y.Y., S.J. Fonte, C. Van Kessel, and J. Six. 2007. Soil aggregates control N cycling efficiency in long-term conventional and alternative cropping systems. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 79: 45–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Kramer, S.B., J.P. Reganold, J.D. Glover, B.J.M. Bohannan, and H.A. Mooney. 2006. Reduced nitrate leaching and enhanced denitrifier activity and efficiency in organically fertilized soils. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103: 4522–4527.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Lal, R. 2004. Soil carbon sequestration impacts on global climate change and food security. Science 304: 1623–1627.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Leifeld, J., H.-R. Oberholzer, and R. Reiser. 2009. Consequences of conventional vs. organic farming on soil carbon: Results from a 27-year field experiment. Agronomy Journal 101: 1204–1218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Liebhardt, W.C., R.W. Andrews, M.N. Culik, R.R. Harwood, R.R. Janke, J.K. Radke, and S.L. Riegerschwartz. 1989. Crop production during conversion from conventional to low-input methods. Agronomy Journal 81: 150–159.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Liebig, M.A., and J.W. Doran. 1999. Impact of organic production practices on soil quality indicators. Journal of Environmental Quality 28: 1601–1609.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Marinari, S., R. Mancinelli, E. Carnpiglia, and S. Grego. 2006. Chemical and biological indicators of soil quality in organic and conventional farming systems in central Italy. Ecology Indicators 6: 701–711.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Melero, S., J.C.R. Porras, J.F. Herencia, and E. Madejon. 2006. Chemical and biochemical properties in a silty loam soil under conventional and organic management. Soil Tillage Research 90: 162–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Nguyen, M.L., R.J. Haynes, and K.M. Goh. 1995. Nutrient budgets and status in 3 pairs of conventional and alternative mixed cropping farms in Canterbury. New Zealand Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 52: 149–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Niggli, U., A. Fließbach, P. Hepperly, and N. Scialabba. 2009. Low greenhouse gas agriculture: Mitigation and adaptation potential of sustainable farming systems. Rome, Italy: FAO. May 2009, Rev. 1-2009.Google Scholar
  43. Olson, B.M., and L.W. Papworth. 2006. Soil chemical changes following manure application on irrigated alfalfa and rainfed Timothy in southern Alberta. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 86: 119–132.Google Scholar
  44. Pimentel, D., P. Hepperly, J. Hanson, D. Douds, and R. Seidel. 2005. Environmental, energetic, and economic comparisons of organic and conventional farming systems. BioScience 55: 573–582.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Pulleman, M., A. Jongmans, J. Marinissen, and J. Bouma. 2003. Effects of organic versus conventional arable farming on soil structure and organic matter dynamics in a Marine Loam in the Netherlands. Soil Use Management 19: 157–165.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Raupp, J. 2001. Manure fertilization for soil organic matter maintenance and its effect upon crops and the environment, evaluated in a long-term trial. In Sustainable management of soil organic matter, ed. R.M. Rees, C.D. Campbell, and C.A. Watson, 301–308. Wallingford: CAB International.Google Scholar
  47. Reeve, J.R., L. Carpenter-Boggs, J.P. Reganold, A.L. York, G. McGourty, and L.P. McCloskey. 2005. Soil and vinegrape quality in biodynamically and organically managed vineyards. American Journal of Enology and Viticulture 56: 367–376.Google Scholar
  48. Reganold, J.P., A.S. Palmer, J.C. Lockhart, and A.N. Macgregor. 1993. Soil quality and financial performance of biodynamic and conventional farms in New Zealand. Science 260: 344–349.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Reganold, J.P., J.D. Glover, P.K. Andrews, and H.R. Hinman. 2001. Sustainability of three apple production systems. Nature 410: 926–930.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Robertson, G.P., E.A. Paul, and R.R. Harwood. 2000. Greenhouse gases in intensive agriculture: Contributions of individual gases to the radiative forcing of the atmosphere. Science 289: 1922–1925.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Scheller, E., and J. Raupp. 2005. Amino acid and soil organic matter content of topsoil in a long term trial with farmyard manure and mineral fertilizers. Biology, Agriculture and Horticulture 22: 379–397.Google Scholar
  52. Schlesinger, W.H. 2000. Carbon sequestration in soils: Some cautions amidst optimism. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 82: 121–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Shannon, D., A.M. Sen, and D.B. Johnson. 2002. A comparative study of the microbiology of soils managed under organic and conventional regimes. Soil Use Management 18: 274–283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Smith, P., K.W. Goulding, K.A. Smith, D.S. Powlson, J.U. Smith, P. Falloon, and K. Coleman. 2001. Enhancing the carbon sink in European agricultural soils: Including trace gas fluxes in estimates of carbon mitigation potential. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 60: 237–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Smith, P., S.J. Chapman, W.A. Scott, H.I.J. Black, M. Wattenbach, R. Milne, C. Campbell, A. Lilly, N. Ostle, P.E. Levy, D.G. Lumsdon, P. Millard, W. Towers, S. Zaehle, and J.J. Smith. 2007. Climate change cannot be entirely responsible for soil carbon loss observed in England and Wales, 1978–2003. Global Change Biology 13: 2605–2609.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Stamatiadis, S., A. Liopa-Tsakalidi, L.M. Maniati, P. Karageorgou, and E. Natioti. 1996. A comparative study of soil quality in two vineyards differing in soil management practices. In Methods for assessing soil quality, eds. J.W. Doran and A.J. Jones, 381–392. SSSA Spec. Pub. 49. Madison, WI: Soil Science Society of America.Google Scholar
  57. Stewart, C.E., K. Paustian, R.T. Conant, A.F. Plante, and J. Six. 2007. Soil carbon saturation: concept, evidence and evaluation. Biogeochemistry 86: 19–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. UNFCCC. 2008. Challenges and opportunities for mitigation in the agricultural sector. Technical paper FCCC/TP/2008/8, Bonn, 21 Nov 2008.Google Scholar
  59. USDA. 1990. Federal Organic Foods Production Act, 1990. Washington, DC: United States Department of Agriculture.Google Scholar
  60. Wander, M.M., S.J. Traina, B.R. Stinner, and S.E. Peters. 1994. Organic and conventional management effects on biologically-active soil organic matter pools. Soil Science Society of America Journal 58: 1130–1139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Wells, A.T., K.Y. Chan, and P.S. Cornish. 2000. Comparison of conventional and alternative vegetable farming systems on the properties of a Yellow Earth in New South Wales. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 80: 47–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Wilts, A.R., D.C. Reicosky, R.R. Allmaras, and C.E. Clapp. 2004. Long-term corn residue effects: Harvest alternatives, soil carbon turnover, and root-derived carbon. Soil Science Society of America Journal 68: 1342–1351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Agroscope Reckenholz-Tänikon Research Station ARTAir Pollution/Climate GroupZurichSwitzerland

Personalised recommendations