Preclinical Validation of the Therapeutic Potential of Glasgow Oxygen Level Dependent (GOLD) Technology: a Theranostic for Acute Stroke
In acute stroke patients, penumbral tissue is non-functioning but potentially salvageable within a time window of variable duration and represents target tissue for rescue. Reperfusion by thrombolysis and/or thrombectomy can rescue penumbra and improve stroke outcomes, but these treatments are currently available to a minority of patients. In addition to the utility of Glasgow Oxygen Level Dependent (GOLD) as an MRI contrast capable of detecting penumbra, its constituent perfluorocarbon (PFC) oxygen carrier, combined with normobaric hyperoxia, also represents a potential acute stroke treatment through improved oxygen delivery to penumbra. Preclinical studies were designed to test the efficacy of an intravenous oxygen carrier, the perfluorocarbon emulsion Oxycyte® (O-PFC), combined with normobaric hyperoxia (50% O2) in both in vitro (neuronal cell culture) and in vivo rat models of ischaemic stroke. Outcome was assessed through the quantification of lipid peroxidation and oxidative stress levels, mortality, infarct volume, neurological scoring and sensorimotor tests of functional outcome in two in vivo models of stroke. Additionally, we investigated evidence for any positive or negative interactions with the thrombolytic recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA) following embolus-induced stroke in rats. Treatment with intravenous O-PFC + normobaric hyperoxia (50% O2) provided evidence of reduced infarct size and improved functional recovery. It did not exacerbate oxidative stress and showed no adverse interactions with rt-PA. The positive results and lack of adverse effects support human trials of O-PFC + 50% O2 normobaric hyperoxia as a potential therapeutic approach. Combined with the diagnostic data presented in the preceding paper, O-PFC and normobaric hyperoxia is a potential theranostic for acute ischaemic stroke.
KeywordsPerfluorocarbon Stroke MRI Penumbra Oxygen carrier Oxycyte (O-PFC) Hyperoxia
The concept of “Time is Brain” emphasises that in general, human brain tissue becomes irreversibly damaged rapidly after arterial occlusion, with an estimated 1.9 million neurons dying every minute following occlusive stroke . Following positive individual trials of intravenous recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA) [2, 3], meta-analysis of all randomised trials of rt-PA  has confirmed that treatment within 4.5 h of symptom onset increased the odds of reducing disability leading to an improved ability to perform daily activities independently, with earlier treatment within this time window associated with a greater absolute benefit. An absolute increased risk of early death from intracranial haemorrhage of about 2% was outweighed by an absolute increase in disability-free survival of about 10% for patients treated within 3 h and about 5% for patients where treatment delay was between 3 and 4.5 h. More recent randomised trials of second-generation mechanical thrombectomy devices have shown improved clinical and functional outcomes, within a time window of approximately 6 h from stroke onset, in patients with anterior circulation large artery strokes, who are less successfully treated with rt-PA . Most recently, benefit has been shown for both treatment with intravenous thrombolysis among patients with stroke of uncertain onset time when magnetic resonance imaging is used to define probable onset within the preceding 4.5 h,  and for thrombectomy up to 24 h after symptom onset when patients are selected on the basis of brain imaging findings that indicate a small volume of irreversibly damaged tissue in addition to a large artery occlusion [7, 8]. Currently a minority of patients are able to receive thrombolysis and/or thrombectomy. Access to thrombectomy in most countries requires transfer to specialist endovascular treatment centres from primary stroke centres that can initiate thrombolysis, and secondary transfer is associated with significantly longer onset-to-treatment times compared to those able to access endovascular treatment centres directly . The proportion of patients with imaging patterns consistent with benefit from delayed thrombectomy is uncertain, but it is thought to represent a minority of “slow progressing” patients . There is therefore considerable potential benefit for a treatment that could extend penumbral survival. Since tissue death following ischaemic stroke occurs principally because of a lack of tissue oxygen, improved oxygen delivery to penumbra could have a beneficial influence on stroke outcome.
Perfluorocarbons (PFCs) are fluorinated hydrocarbons with respiratory gas-carrying capacity superior to that of haemoglobin . They are hydrophobic in nature and therefore are emulsified for intravenous use as in vivo oxygen carriers. PFCs increase tissue oxygenation through their ability to effectively decrease the plasma gap through which oxygen must travel to reach the red blood cells (RBCs) and/or vascular endothelium . Because of their small particle size, PFC emulsions penetrate capillaries within ischaemic and hypoperfused microcirculation, supplying oxygen, removing carbon dioxide, reinstituting aerobic metabolism, and possibly restoring flexibility of erythrocytes stiffened by acidosis .
Two major mechanisms underlie the efficacy of PFCs for oxygen transport . Firstly, they have a high capacity to dissolve respiratory gases including oxygen rather than binding them like a ligand. They load and unload oxygen twice as fast as haemoglobin, since gases are exchanged by simple diffusion down a partial pressure gradient. Pure PFCs can dissolve approximately 2.5 times the amount of oxygen than an equivalent volume of whole blood. Secondly, once emulsified, PFC particle size is very small (approximately 0.2 μm compared to ~ 7–8 μm for human erythrocytes), enabling better infiltration through the microcirculation and thus improving oxygen supply to tissue where perfusion of RBCs is restricted. Therefore, PFCs offer the possibility of oxygenating and thereby supporting penumbral tissue during the critical hours following stroke.
PFC’s ability to deliver oxygen to hypoxic tissue, along with the paramagnetic properties of oxygen and the different effects of oxy- and deoxyhaemoglobin on the blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) T2* signal has been utilised to identify penumbral tissue in series of studies by our group [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. These unique characteristics make PFCs potential agents with dual diagnostic  and therapeutic properties: providing an efficient carrier for paramagnetic oxygen and enhancing oxygen delivery to hypoxic brain tissue through any remaining plasma flow.
A number of published preclinical studies support the potential benefit of oxygenated PFCs in traumatic brain injury (TBI). Following fluid percussion injury, treatment with Oxygent (a second-generation PFC emulsion) combined with 100% inhaled oxygen for up to 4 h, improved both brain oxygen tension as well as mitochondrial oxidative activity . In separate studies, Oxygent administration resulted in a significant increase in brain oxygen tension and a substantial reduction (41%) in the volume of posttraumatic brain damage .
The pharmacodynamic properties of Oxycyte® (a third-generation PFC emulsion) during haemodilution and brain injury have been investigated in rodents. Using experimental models of haemodilution, administration of intravenous Oxycyte resulted in an enhancement of tissue oxygenation at the microcirculatory level and maintained blood oxygen levels following significant blood loss  and effective tissue oxygenation in ischaemic states in rats and hamsters [25, 26, 27]. Oxycyte has been evaluated in rodent models of lateral fluid percussion brain injury , contusive spinal cord injury [29, 30] and permanent middle cerebral artery occlusion  where it was shown to exert a neuroprotective effect in the early phase of brain ischaemia and improve brain oxygenation. After traumatic brain injury in rats, Oxycyte improved cognitive recovery and reduced hippocampal neuronal cell loss and traumatic axonal injury . Treatment with Oxycyte significantly enhanced spinal cord grey and white matter preservation following spinal cord injury as well as increasing spinal cord oxygenation .
Given the relatively large body of research in the literature dating back to the late 1960s, it is clear that PFCs have generated a great deal of interest for their potential use in a variety of potential indications, related to their oxygen carrying properties in vivo. Over recent years, our group has focussed on exploiting the superior oxygen carrying properties of PFCs towards the development of novel MRI-based imaging techniques to identify ischaemic penumbra following an oxygen challenge [14, 19]. Through this work, we have demonstrated the enhancement of our Glasgow Oxygen Level Dependent (GOLD) diagnostic imaging techniques to identify the metabolic penumbra in a rodent stroke model following intravenous Oxycyte (O-PFC) and hyperoxia. Regions identified as penumbra were shown to display maintained glucose metabolism. Successful translation of GOLD imaging could provide a significant advancement in the management of acute stroke patients by identifying those most likely to benefit from treatment irrespective of time from stroke onset.
With evidence of the ability to preserve penumbra from our diagnostic studies , we designed this program of studies to more rigorously investigate the therapeutic potential of O-PFC and hyperoxia in the acute stroke setting. These studies test the hypothesis that the administration of O-PFC in combination with an extended period of normobaric hyperoxia (50% O2) will exert beneficial effects on stroke outcome and oxidative stress levels in rodent stroke models.
Material and Methods
PFC emulsion O-PFC was supplied by Tenax Therapeutics Inc. The perfluorocarbon drug substance is perfluoro(t-butylcyclohexane) (or FtBu), a saturated alicyclic perfluorocarbon, with a molecular formula of C10F20 and a molecular mass of 500.08. The finished emulsified intravenous drug product contains 60% w/v FtBu.
Animals in the control groups were administered an equivalent volume of saline.
In Vitro Experiment
Rat neuronal cells (B50 neuroblastoma cells, European Collection of Cell Cultures, UK) were maintained in Dulbecco’s minimal essential medium supplemented with 10% (v/v) foetal bovine serum (FBS), 2 mmol/l L-glutamine, 100 U/ml penicillin and 100 μg/ml streptomycin. Twenty-four hours after plating, cells were exposed to 9 h hypoxia (1% O2, 5% CO2, balance N2) and serum deprivation followed by 24 h reoxygenation in complete media in either standard atmospheric air with 5% CO2 or hyperoxic (50% O2, 5% CO2, balance N2) conditions ± 10% (v/v) O-PFC. Cell lysis was then carried out.
Lipid Peroxidation Assay
A spectrophotometric assay (Tebu-Bio, UK) for malondialdehyde (MDA) was used to determine lipid peroxidation levels as per the manufacturer’s instructions. The MDA and hydroxyalkenal determination protocol was used and absorbance was measured at 586 nm in a spectrophotometer. All readings were normalised for protein using a BCA protein assay kit (Pierce).
Rodent In Vivo Studies
This manuscript has been written in accordance with the ARRIVE guidelines (http://www.nc3rs.org.uk/arrive). All experiments were performed on adult male Sprague Dawley (SD) (intraluminal filament model, studies 1–3; n = 197, 335.1 ± 22.6 g) or Wistar (embolic stroke model, study 4; n = 32, 332.8 ± 21.4 g) rats obtained from Harlan, UK. Animals were randomly allocated to the study group using an online random list generator (https://www.random.org/). Investigators performing analysis to determine infarct volume were blinded to treatment allocation.
In Vivo Rat Stroke Models
General anaesthesia was induced in all in vivo stroke studies with 5% isoflurane in nitrous oxide mixed with oxygen (70% N2O:30% O2). All surgeries were carried out under aseptic conditions. Following induction of anaesthesia, animals had oropharyngeal intubation and maintenance of anaesthesia through mechanical ventilation (approximately 3.0 ml stroke volume) with 2.5% isoflurane and N2O:O2. Prior to induction of stroke N2O:O2 was changed to medical air supplemented with ~ 5% O2 (26% O2: normoxia), delivered at a rate of approximately 60 breaths per min for all in vivo stroke surgery procedures. In animals administered hyperoxia, this was induced by increasing the balance of O2:medical air until a reading of 50% O2 was confirmed by an oxygen monitor connected to the anaesthetic outlet leading to the animal.
Body temperature was maintained at 37 °C ± 0.5 °C. A femoral vein was cannulated with polythene tubing (Portex, Smiths Medical, UK: external diameter 0.96 mm; internal diameter 0.58 mm) for administration of O-PFC or saline. Prior to recovery, the cannula was removed from the femoral vein with the small incision being repaired using diathermy.
Intraluminal Filament Model for Permanent and Transient MCAO
Middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO) was induced with an intraluminal filament. A 3.0 uncoated nylon filament with a heat-induced bulb at the tip (approximately 0.3 mm in diameter) was advanced along the left internal carotid artery for approximately 20–21 mm from the bifurcation of the external carotid artery until resistance was felt. For transient MCAO, the filament was removed following the predetermined occlusion time, the small incision in the vessel was sealed using diathermy, enabling restoration of blood flow. The animal was subsequently recovered from anaesthesia. For permanent MCAO, the filament was secured in position using ties around the internal carotid artery prior to recovery.
Embolic Stroke Model
Blood Clot Preparation
Twenty-four to 72 h prior to stroke induction, a blood clot was prepared from a donor rat. Blood was drawn from the femoral artery into a saline filled PE50 cannula, left to clot at room temperature for 2 h and stored at 4 °C for up to 72 h. When required, the clot was flushed from the cannula into sterile saline and a uniform section of ~ 30 mm was drawn into a new PE50 cannula and then pushed into a PE10 cannula, which was attached to the PE50. The clot was cut to required size within the PE10 cannula (26 ± 2 mm) for injection through the internal carotid artery.
Embolic Stroke Surgery
The model of embolic stroke employed was modified from a method previously described . MCAO was induced through the advancement of the PE10 cannula containing the clot into the left internal carotid artery. When the tip of the cannula was approximately 1–2 mm proximal to the origin of the middle cerebral artery, the clot was injected in 75 μl saline. Rats were transferred immediately to the MRI scanner, and successful MCAO was confirmed from the initial diffusion-weighted image (DWI) scan. Heart rate and rectal temperature were continuously recorded (AcqKnowledge, Biopac Systems, CA, USA) during scanning.
In all studies, functional outcome following stroke was assessed with an 18-point sensorimotor assessment  where a high score is indicative of improved outcome (studies 1–4). In addition, the adhesive label removal test was employed to assess sensorimotor function (study 2). The time taken for the rat to both contact and remove the adhesive label from both paws was measured .
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
MRI data were acquired using a Bruker Pharmascan 7 T/30 cm system with a gradient coil (internal diameter = 121 mm, 400 mT/m) and a 72 mm birdcage resonator. Following stroke surgery, anaesthetised rats were placed in the MRI rat cradle and the head was restrained using tooth and ear bars. A four-channel rat brain phased-array surface coil was placed above the rats head and secured. A pressure sensor was attached for respiratory monitoring and core body temperature was maintained at 37 ± 0.5 °C using a rectal thermocouple and a temperature controlled water jacket.
Diffusion-weighted imaging was employed to assess acute brain injury associated with embolic stroke (in vivo study 4). For quantitative determination of the apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC), a multishot spin-echo (echo planar imaging (EPI)) diffusion-weighted scan was used (TE, 22.9 ms; TR, 4000.0 ms, 2 averages, matrix, 96 × 96 mm; FOV, 25 × 25 mm2; 3 directions, x, y, z; B values, 0, 1000 s/mm2, 8 contiguous coronal slices of 1.5-mm thickness, 4-shot EPI). For image analysis, quantitative ADC maps (mm2/s) were generated for each of the eight contiguous coronal slices throughout the forebrain. Subsequent analysis of ADC maps was carried out using ImageJ software. Quantitative ADC maps in units of square millimetre per second were prepared and a reduction of 16.5% in the ADC of the mean contralateral value (excluding ventricles) was used as a threshold to determine ischaemic lesion volume .
T2-weighted imaging was employed to assess infarct volume 24 h (studies 3 and 4) or 7 days (study 2) after stroke using a RARE T2-weighted sequence (TE 100 ms, TR 5000 ms, rare factor 8, 2 averages, 256 × 256 matrix, 98 μm × 98 μm in-plane resolution, slice thickness 0.75 mm). The area of infarct was summed over all slices where infarcted tissue was evident. This was multiplied by slice thickness to calculate total infarct volume, which was corrected for brain swelling .
Levels of oxidative stress were measured by quantifying hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) activity present in brain tissue samples taken from the ischaemic cortex of animals selected from in vivo studies 3 and 4. An Amplex Red peroxide assay (Invitrogen, UK) was used as per manufacturer’s instructions.
Four in vivo stroke studies were carried out as follows: a transient intraluminal filament model of MCAO (t-MCAO) was employed for dose optimisation (study 1); efficacy assessment of O-PFC + hyperoxia was carried out in tMCAO (study 2) and in permanent MCAO (p-MCAO) (study 3); investigation of potential interactions with rt-PA was carried out in a model of embolus-induced stroke (study 4).
Study 1—O-PFC Dose Optimisation
Under general anaesthesia, t-MCAO was induced in SD rats using the intraluminal filament model. Reperfusion was induced by subsequent removal of the filament after 90 min. 10 min prior to reperfusion, animals were randomly assigned to the following (n = 4–5 per group): (1) normoxia (1 ml saline i.v. plus air); (2) hyperoxia (1 ml saline i.v. plus 50% O2); (3) 1.5 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2; (4) 3.0 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2; (5) 4.5 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2; and (6) 6.0 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2. On recovery from anaesthesia, hyperoxia (50% O2) was maintained (groups 2–6) for 48 h in an oxygen tent, and thereafter, animals were returned to room air until termination (72 h). Group 1 was recovered in air. Neurological scoring was carried out at 72 h using an 18 point neurological score. The animals were then terminated with an anaesthetic overdose and infarct volume assessed on fresh coronal brain slices (6 × 1.5 mm slices) stained with TTC and corrected for brain swelling .
Study 2—Efficacy of O-PFC + Hyperoxia in a t-MCAO Model
SD rats received 60 min intraluminal filament-induced MCAO. Ten minutes prior to reperfusion, animals were randomly assigned to the following (n = 16 per group): (1) normoxia (1 ml saline plus air); (2) hyperoxia (1 ml saline plus 50% O2); (3) 3.0 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2; and (4) 6.0 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2. On recovery from anaesthesia, hyperoxia (50% O2) was maintained (groups 2–4) for 48 h in an oxygen tent, and thereafter, animals were returned to room air until termination at day 7. Group 1 was recovered in air. Assessments of functional recovery were made at days 3 and 7 poststroke using an 18-point neurological score. Sensory and motor function was assessed at days 0, 3 and 7 using the adhesive label test . When performing this test, each rat was monitored for up to a maximum of 3 min with times noted for both contact and removal of the adhesive. Final infarct size was measured at day 7 from T2-weighted MRI scans.
Study 3—Efficacy of O-PFC Plus Hyperoxia in a p-MCAO Model
SD rats received intraluminal filament-induced p-MCAO with a 24 h endpoint. To inform on the minimum effective dose for clinical translation, a dose of 1.5 ml/kg O-PFC was included in this study. The therapeutic time window was also investigated by adding groups where initiation of treatment was delayed. At the relevant time point post-MCAO (indicated below), animals were randomly assigned to one of the following groups (n = 14 per group): (1) normoxia (saline i.v. + air starting 60 min post-MCAO); (2) hyperoxia (saline i.v. + 50% O2) starting 60 min post-MCAO; (3) 1.5 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2 starting 60 min post-MCAO; (4) 3 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2 starting 60 min post-MCAO; (5) hyperoxia (saline i.v. + 50% O2) starting 3 h post-MCAO; (6) 1.5 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2 starting 3 h post-MCAO; and (7) 3 ml/kg O-PFC i.v. + 50% O2 starting 3 h post-MCAO. On recovery from anaesthesia, hyperoxia (50% O2) was maintained (groups 2–7) for 24 h in an oxygen tent. Group 1 was recovered in air. An 18-point neurological score  was carried out at 24 h poststroke followed by infarct volume measurement from T2-weighted MRI scans. The animal was subsequently terminated and the brain was removed. The ipsilateral hemisphere was dissected free, and the cortical tissue was separated. This tissue was snap frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at − 80 °C for analysis of oxidative stress. This was done using an Amplex® Red Hydrogen Peroxide/Peroxidase Assay to measure levels of hydrogen peroxide in the ischaemic cortex of brain tissue from animals (n = 5) selected at random from each group.
Study 4—Investigation of Safety of O-PFC and Hyperoxia in Combination with rt-PA in an Embolic Stroke Model
Embolic Stroke Model—Blood Clot Preparation
Adult male Wistar rats were used for this study. The preparation of the blood clot and the embolic stroke surgery was performed as described above with the femoral vein also being cannulated for administration of O-PFC and rt-PA.
Treatment was initiated at approximately 75 min following introduction of blood clot and baseline DWI scanning to confirm evidence of early ischaemic damage (6 animals with no hyperintensity on DWI scans were excluded from the study). Animals were randomly assigned to one of the following groups (n = 8 per group): (1) 3 ml/kg saline + normoxia; (2) 3 ml/kg O-PFC + hyperoxia (50% O2); (3) 0.9 ml/kg rt-PA + normoxia; (4) 0.9 ml/kg rt-PA + 3 ml/kg O-PFC + hyperoxia (50% O2). In groups receiving rt-PA, the first 10% of the dose was given as a bolus with the remaining dose infused over 45 min. In group 4, treatment with O-PFC and hyperoxia was commenced immediately prior to rt-PA. At the end of the scanning protocol, animals were returned to the operating theatre for removal of the femoral cannula and recovery from anaesthesia. In groups 2 and 4 where treatment included hyperoxia, this was maintained for 24 h in an oxygen tent. Groups 1 and 3 were recovered in air. An 18-point neurological score  was carried out at 24 h poststroke followed by infarct volume measurement from T2 MRI scans. The animal was subsequently terminated and the brain was removed. The ipsilateral hemisphere was dissected free, and the cortex was separated and snap frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at − 80 °C for analysis of oxidative stress using the Amplex® Red Hydrogen Peroxide/Peroxidase Assay to measure levels of hydrogen peroxide in the ischaemic cortex of brain tissue from animals (n = 5) selected at random from each group.
In vitro experiments were performed in triplicate on ⩾ 3 independent occasions and analysed by unpaired Student’s t test. Comparison of final infarct size and label contact and removal time between in vivo groups was analysed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Bonferroni’s posttests for multiple comparisons. Comparison of 18-point neurological score data between in vivo groups was analysed using a Kruskall–Wallis non-parametric test with Dunn’s posttests for multiple comparisons. Comparison of changes in lesion size (study 4) over time and between treatment groups was analysed using a repeated measures (mixed model) ANOVA with Bonferroni’s posttests. Data in figures and tables are presented as mean ± SD.
In Vitro Model of Hypoxia and Reoxygenation
In Vivo Study 1—Dose Optimisation
In Vivo Study 2—Efficacy of O-PFC in a Transient MCAO Model
In Vivo Study 3—Efficacy of O-PFC in a Model of Permanent MCAO
A 1–2 point improvement in the 18-point neurological score in both the 1.5 ml/kg and 3 ml/kg O-PFC + 50% O2 groups compared to normoxic controls did not achieve statistical significance (Fig. 6b).
In Vivo Study 4—Investigation of Potential Interactions Between O-PFC + Hyperoxia and rt-PA in an Embolic Stroke Model
There was a suggestion towards an improvement in the 18-point (non-significant 2–3 point increase) neurological score in all treatment groups compared to the normoxic control group (Fig. 8c).
Ischaemic cortex samples, taken 24 h after embolic stroke, revealed no significant differences in oxidative stress levels between the treatment groups (Fig. 8d). The highest levels of H2O2 were recorded in the rt-PA group.
Early recanalisation of occluded cerebral arteries by thrombolysis and/or thrombectomy, significantly increases the likelihood of independence after stroke . Reperfusion, and thereby rescue, of the penumbra is the assumed mechanism. Potentially salvageable penumbral tissue is hypoperfused and cells switch to anaerobic metabolism in the absence of oxygen, which thereby significantly reduces their capacity to generate sufficient ATP for normal function, and consequently limits survival within the penumbra . Recanalisation of medium and large intracranial arteries visualised by conventional angiographic imaging methods does not address microvascular tissue perfusion. Rat brain capillaries have an average diameters of about 2.9 μm , and rat RBCs have a diameter of about 6.5 μm. To pass through these tiny blood vessels, RBCs require to rearrange their cytoskeleton, which is made difficult by stiffening consequent to acidosis in ischaemic tissues. O-PFC micelles however are 1/30th the size of rat RBCs (diameter of about 200 nm) and are able to penetrate the smallest blood vessels much more readily than RBCs, enabling oxygen delivery to ischaemic tissues.
During the development of GOLD imaging for diagnostic penumbral detection, we uncovered a serendipitous benefit, which was support of penumbral tissue, presumably through the restoration of oxygen levels (Figs. 5 and 6 in ). Thus, O-PFC combined with 50% normobaric hyperoxia (GOLD therapy) could support the penumbra when administered prior to reperfusion. This adjunctive therapy could potentially extend the time windows for rt-PA and thrombectomy, allowing more patients to be treated. Further, this therapy could potentially be of benefit when early recanalisation is not achieved, by improving oxygen delivery to penumbra via collateral flow. We have therefore explored the potential benefits of maintained normobaric hyperoxia using PFC emulsion O-PFC and 50% O2 in both permanent and transient MCAO rodent stroke models and investigated the possibility of any adverse interactions with rt-PA in an embolic stroke model.
Overall, the in vivo studies show evidence of efficacy in infarct size and neurological scores for poststroke treatment with O-PFC + 50% O2 in clinically relevant models. O-PFC + 50% O2 appears more effective than hyperoxia alone (studies 1, 2 and 3) with a proposed optimum dosing regime of 3 ml/kg + 50% O2 delivered within 1 h of stroke. This regime induced a significant 45% reduction in infarct size and a 2-point improvement in neurological score in the tMCAO model, which induces a surge reperfusion similar to thrombectomy. To our knowledge, O-PFC + 50% O2 has not previously been tested in a t-MCAO model. Delayed (3 h) administration in p-MCAO (study 3) and a higher dose of 6 ml/kg in t-MCAO (studies 1 and 2) were not effective. Infarct size and behavioural outcome are inherently variable in rodent stroke models, despite standardisation of techniques (e.g. maintaining consistency in the induction of stroke and control of physiological variables under anaesthesia). Perhaps this is the reason that O-PFC + 50% O2 did not consistently achieve statistical significance compared to the control group (normoxia + vehicle). In study 3 (pMCAO), the 1.5 and 3 ml/kg (administered 1 h poststroke) O-PFC + 50% O2 group infarcts were not significantly smaller than the control normoxia group, although there was a trend towards smaller infarcts in both O-PFC treated groups (1.5 ml/kg O-PFC decreased by 27%, p = 0.10, and 3.0 ml/kg O-PFC decreased by 33%, p = 0.06, when compared to normoxia + vehicle). However, infarct size was significantly smaller in both O-PFC-treated groups when compared to the hyperoxia + saline group, which had larger infarcts and a smaller SD than the control normoxia group. It was notable that there was a loss of the efficacy observed when administering O-PFC at 1 h, when delaying treatment until 3 h poststroke in the permanent MCAO model (study 3). The loss of efficacy is not surprising as penumbra would be expected to decrease during the hours following MCAO a model with no reperfusion. However, there was still a trend towards smaller infarcts in the group receiving the lower dose of O-PFC administered 3 h post-MCAO. We have previously shown evidence for existence of penumbra up to 3 h post-MCAO in this model using advanced imaging techniques . These data are encouraging, but the true therapeutic potential can only be realised through clinical testing. At present, there is a very limited literature for PFC studies in stroke models for comparison. One published study in rat p-MCAO reported a significant 12% reduction in brain damage using a very early endpoint after stroke (8 h) with O-PFC (1 ml/100 g, i.v.) + 100% normobaric O2 administered immediately after induction of stroke  while the same study design replacing normobaric with hyperbaric oxygenation was ineffective . Alternative PFC emulsions (e.g. dodecafluoropentane (DDFP), 0.6 ml/kg i.v.) have been tested in rodent and rabbit stroke models under normoxic conditions. In rat p-MCAO, infarct size and neurological status were improved within 6 h of stroke after single (1 h poststroke) and repeated DDFP administration  and this regime was similarly effective in a rabbit embolic stroke model [42, 43, 44]. Encouraging for the field of PFC research in stroke, DDFP is currently being investigated in an ongoing phase 1b clinical trial in acute ischaemic stroke patients (NCT02963376; https://clinicaltrials.gov).
An adverse interaction with rt-PA would significantly limit the development of any new acute stroke therapy. Study 4, conducted to investigate this point, did not uncover any significant increase in damage, neurological deficit or incidence of haemorrhage when rt-PA was combined with O-PFC + 50% hyperoxia in an embolic stroke model. This study was not powered to detect efficacy, but a rabbit embolic stroke model combining rt-PA and the PFC DDFP reported reduced infarct size and improved neurological scores for the combination compared to rt-PA alone .
Delivering oxygen to injured hypoperfused tissues might raise concerns about the potential to exacerbate oxidative stress and reperfusion-related injuries . However, a recent review on normobaric hyperoxia treatment in acute ischaemic stroke reported no evidence for increase reactive oxygen species or oxidative stress when normobaric hyperoxia is applied for a short duration (up to 8 h following MCAO): the benefits appear to significantly outweigh the risks of potential increases in reactive oxygen species . We found no evidence for increased levels of oxidative stress in rat models of t-MCAO treated with O-PFC + 50% O2. No negative interactions on lesion growth, infarct size or neurological deficit were identified when O-PFC + 50% O2 was combined with rt-PA in an embolic stroke model. Furthermore, in vitro experiments and data from blood and brain tissue samples showed no evidence of increased oxidative stress following administration of O-PFC + hyperoxia. These data suggest that O-PFC + 50% O2 does not put injured ischaemic tissue at increased risk of reperfusion or oxidative stress-related injuries.
Clinical stroke imaging studies using various methods indicate survival of penumbral tissue beyond the current 4.5-h treatment window for rt-PA , and recent results from endovascular (DAWN and DEFUSE-3) and intravenous thrombolytic (EXTEND) trials support the efficacy of reperfusion therapy in late time windows based on imaging signatures. The rate of progression of tissue damage varies markedly among individuals , leading to the concept of “fast” and “slow” progressors. In addition to acting as a contrast agent to image the penumbra, the O-PFC + 50% O2 approach has the added and unique advantage of potentially improving penumbral survival. The observations of possibly smaller infarct volumes among O-PFC-treated rats compared to control after permanent MCAO in particular might have relevance to the “slow progressor” group in a clinical setting.
Despite the best efforts to power the main efficacy studies (studies 2 and 3) to detect statistical differences in the key endpoints, it is likely they remained underpowered due to the known variability associated with preclinical stroke models. A further potential limitation relates to a reliance on neurological scores and one sensorimotor behavioural test to assess functional outcome. Given the subjective nature of neurological scoring, it is possible that studies could have been improved by assessing a greater range of sensorimotor tests with longer end-points, although there remains a lack of consensus on the appropriate tests to be used with a large variation in behavioural tests being used across different preclinical stroke models. All in vivo studies were performed under general anaesthesia which can influence physiological variables including blood pressure, respiration, blood gases and body temperature. Anaesthesia is required for stroke surgery and in vivo imaging in rodent models. However, the confounding effect of general anaesthesia on the results obtained was minimised by monitoring physiological variables throughout the experiments and maintaining these within physiological limits.
In summary, O-PFC with 50% O2 hyperoxia delivered as constituents of GOLD penumbral imaging has the potential to improve stroke outcome and be used as an adjunct for reperfusion therapy. The translational potential of the unique, dual diagnostic and therapeutic (theranostic) properties of this technology will be investigated in clinical trials in acute stroke patients scheduled to begin during the second half of 2018.
O-PFC (Oxycyte®) intravenous emulsion used in study 2 was supplied through a collaborative agreement with Tenax Therapeutics, Morrisville, NC, USA. We acknowledge the excellent technical assistance provided by James Mullin, Lindsay Gallagher and Linda Carberry.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
This work was supported by an award from the Chief Scientist Office, NHS Scotland (ETM/146). All experiments were approved by the University of Glasgow Ethical Review Panel and performed under a licence from the UK Home Office and subject to the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act, 1986 incorporating European Directive 2010/63/EU.
Conflict of Interest
Authors CS and GAD are inventors on patents relating to the use of PFCs and MRI technology with hyperoxia, to determine the metabolic state of different tissue compartments in the ischaemic brain using GOLD imaging technology. CS, CM and GAD declare ownership of stock in Aurum Biosciences Ltd., the company developing and commercialising GOLD imaging technology.
- 4.Emberson J, Lees KR, Lyden P, Blackwell L, Albers G, Bluhmki E, et al. Effect of treatment delay, age, and stroke severity on the effects of intravenous thrombolysis with alteplase for acute ischaemic stroke: a meta-analysis of individual patient data from randomised trials. Lancet. 2014;384:1929–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 15.Santosh C, Brennan D, McCabe C, et al. Potential use of Oxygen as a metabolic bio-tracer in combination with T2* weighted MRI, to define the ischemic penumbra. J CBF & Metabol. 2008;28:1742–53.Google Scholar
- 17.Robertson C, McCabe C, Gallagher L, et al. Stroke penumbra defined by an MRI-based oxygen challenge technique: 1. Validation using [14C]2-deoxyglucose autoradiography. J CBF & Metabol. 2011;31:1778–87.Google Scholar
- 18.Robertson C, McCabe C, Gallagher L, et al. Stroke penumbra defined by an MRI-based oxygen challenge technique: 2. Validation based on the consequences of reperfusion. J CBF & Metabol. 2011;31:1788–98.Google Scholar
- 19.Deuchar GA, Brennan D, Griffiths H, et al. Perflourocarbons enhance a T2* based MRI technique for identifying the penumbra in a rat model of acute ischemic stroke. J CBF & Metabol. 2013;33:1422–8.Google Scholar
- 21.Dani KA, Moreton FC, Santosh C, et al. Oxygen challenge MR imaging in healthy human volunteers. J CBF & Metabol. 2017;37:366–76.Google Scholar
- 39.Ford DH, Systems LABB. Elsevier, Amsterdam. 1968:p275.Google Scholar
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.