Advertisement

Differential access to metal wealth from colony to capital to collapse at Phoenician and Punic Carthage: non-ferrous alloys and mineral resources from the Bir Massouda site

  • Brett KaufmanEmail author
  • Roald Docter
  • David A. Scott
  • Fethi Chelbi
  • Boutheina Maraoui Telmini
Original Paper
  • 6 Downloads

Abstract

This article presents the first stratified archaeometric data of the earliest metallurgical assemblage of Maghrebi North Africa from the perspective of the non-ferrous alloys and minerals. From its foundations as a colony to its formation as an imperial power and subsequent decline and collapse, the Carthaginian state maintained a tradition of metallurgical production. Previous research has highlighted workshops of iron and steel manufacture at Bir Massouda and how this facilitated empire formation. The non-ferrous metals and alloys from Bir Massouda also provide information on the shifting fortunes of the Phoenician-Punic commercial endeavor in its geopolitical Mediterranean context. Following its foundation, Carthaginian non-ferrous alloys included the pure copper, tin bronze, and recycled arsenic-tin bronze alloys typical to Iron Age Mediterranean archeological deposits. At its imperial peak, Carthage maintained a relatively high diversity of alloy and mineral types, including pure copper, tin bronze, arsenical copper, leaded tin bronze, leaded arsenical copper, and lead. Two pieces of non-ferrous slag are evidence for bronze recycling. A special cobalt-iron-copper mineral was being processed likely as a colorant for glass or other decorative pigment, and glassy copper-based debris was found adhered to a ceramic or kiln component. During its early clashes with Rome and eventual decline and collapse, the Late Punic metal procurement system was stilted, likely due to restricted access to territorial mines previously held by Carthage in the Iberian Peninsula and Sardinia, with a reversion back to an assemblage of pure copper, arsenical copper, arsenic-tin bronze, and lead.

Keywords

Non-ferrous metallurgy Archaeometallurgy Cobalt Glass colorants Political economy Wealth finance 

Notes

Acknowledgments

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under Grant No. DGE-0707424.The excavations in Carthage in 2000 and 2001 have been supported by a generous grant of the UTOPA Foundation (the Netherlands); the joint excavations of the Institut National de Patrimoine (INP) and Ghent University between 2002 and 2005 have been supported by several grants of the Flemish Fund for Scientific Research (FWO). Thanks go to the respective directors and staff of the INP and the Museum and Site of Carthage for their trust and support over the years. Thanks are due to Christian Fischer, Ioanna Kakoulli, and Sergey Prikhodko for access to analytical instruments, including those of the Molecular and Nano Archaeology Laboratory (MNA) of the Cotsen Institute of Archaeology at UCLA. Arlen Heginbotham (Getty Museum) kindly provided the bronze standards. Thanks are due to Eve MacDonald for pointing us toward the Livy silver debasement quote.

References

  1. Attanasio D, Bultrini G, Ingo GM (2001) The possibility of provenancing a series of bronze Punic coins found at Tharros (Western Sardinia) using the literature lead isotope database. Archaeometry 43(4):529–547CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bechtold B (2008) Observations on the Amphora Repertoire of Middle Punic Carthage. Carthage Stud 2:1–145Google Scholar
  3. Bechtold B (2010) The pottery repertoire from late 6th-mid 2nd century BC Carthage: observations based on the Bir Messaouda excavations. Carthage Stud 4:1–81Google Scholar
  4. Bechtold B (forthcoming-a 1) Selected contexts of the second and last third of the 5th century BCE (MP I-MP II.1 periods). In: Docter RF, Bechtold B et al. (eds) Carthage Bir Messaouda: the finds assemblagesGoogle Scholar
  5. Bechtold B (forthcoming-b 2), Selected contexts of the late Early Punic period (EP II), the transitional Early Punic/Middle Punic period (EP/MP), and the Middle Punic period (MPI). In: Docter RF, Bechtold B et al. (eds) Carthage Bir Messaouda: the finds assemblagesGoogle Scholar
  6. Bechtold B (forthcoming-c 3) Selected contexts containing material of the 4th century BCE (MP II.2 period). In Docter RF, Bechtold B et al. (eds) Carthage Bir Messaouda: the finds assemblagesGoogle Scholar
  7. Bechtold B (forthcoming-d 4) Selected closed contexts from Trench 2 (BM 02-05) (unpublished manuscript)Google Scholar
  8. Bechtold B (forthcoming-e 5) Two Middle Punic primary contexts from Trench 4 (BM04) (unpublished manuscript)Google Scholar
  9. Bechtold B, Docter RF (2011) Transport amphorae from Carthage: an overview. In: Nigro L (ed) The Phoenician Ceramic Repertoire between the Levant and the West 9th - 6th century BC. Proceedings of the International Conference held in Rome, 26th February 2010. Quaderni di Archeologia Fenici-Punica, Roma, pp 85–116Google Scholar
  10. Bernardini P (2008) Sardinia: the chronology of the Phoenician and Punic presence from the ninth to fifth centuries BC. In: Sagona C (ed) Beyond the homeland: markers in Phoenician chronology. Ancient Near Eastern studies, supplement 28. Peeters, Leuven-Paris-DudleyGoogle Scholar
  11. Blyth PH (1993) Metallurgy of two fragmentary archaic Greek helmets. J Hist Metal Soc 27(1):25–36Google Scholar
  12. Brett M, Fentress E (1996) The Berbers. Blackwell, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  13. Budd P, Ottaway BS (1991) The properties of arsenical copper alloys: implications for the development of Eneolithic metallurgy. In: Budd P, Chapman B, Jackson C, Janaway R, Ottaway B (eds) Archaeological Sciences 1989: proceedings of a conference on the application of scientific techniques to archaeology. Oxbow Monograph, Bradford, pp 132–142Google Scholar
  14. Cintas P (1970) Manuel d’Archéologie Punique. A. et J. Picard, ParisGoogle Scholar
  15. Delattre A-L (1898) Nouvelle des Fouilles à Carthage. CRAI Comptes-rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres 42(1):96–100Google Scholar
  16. Delattre A-L (1899) Fouilles Exécutées à Carthage, Pendant le Premier Semestre de 1899, dans la Nécropole Punique Située entre Bordj-Djedid et la Colline de Sainte-Monique. CRAI Comptes-rendus des séances de l’Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres 43(3):308–322Google Scholar
  17. Docter RF (2002-2003) The topography of archaic Carthage: preliminary results of recent excavations and some prospects. TALANTA XXXIV-XXXV:113–133Google Scholar
  18. Docter RF (2005) Een spectaculair einde: Carthago en Rome 246-146 voor Chr., Lampas 38.3:313–329Google Scholar
  19. Docter RF (ed) (2007) Carthage studies 1. Department of Archaeology, Ghent University, GentGoogle Scholar
  20. Docter RF (ed) (2008) Carthage studies 2. Department of Archaeology, Ghent University, GentGoogle Scholar
  21. Docter RF (ed) (2009) Carthage studies 3. Department of Archaeology, Ghent University, GentGoogle Scholar
  22. Docter RF (ed) (2010) Carthage studies 4. Department of Archaeology, Ghent University, GentGoogle Scholar
  23. Docter RF (forthcoming) Selected contexts containing material of the 8th till 5th centuries BCE, in R.F. Docter, B. Bechtold et al., Carthage Bir Messaouda: the finds assemblagesGoogle Scholar
  24. Docter RF, Bechtold B (2011) Two forgotten amphorae from the Hamburg excavations at Carthage (Cyprus and the Iberian Peninsula) and their contexts. Carthage Stud 5:91–128Google Scholar
  25. Docter RF, Sonneveld J (2009) Punic glass from Carthaginian settlement excavations. Carthage Stud 3:125–145Google Scholar
  26. Docter RF, Chelbi F, Maraoui Telmini B (2002) Carthage Bir Massouda: excavations by the Universiteit van Amsterdam (UVA) in 2000 and 2001 (1). CEDAC Carthage Bulletin 21:29–34Google Scholar
  27. Docter RF, Chelbi F, Maraoui Telmini B, Bechtold B, Koens H, Schmidt K, Neer WV (2003) Carthage Bir Massouda—preliminary report on the first bilateral excavations of Ghent University and the Institut National du Patrimoine (2002-2003). BABesch 78:43–70Google Scholar
  28. Docter RF, Niemeyer HG, Nijboer AJ, van der Plicht H (2005) Radiocarbon dates of animal bones in the earliest levels of Carthage. In: Bartoloni G, Delpino F (eds) Oriente e Occidente: metodi e discipline a confronto. Riflessioni sulla cronologia dell’età del ferro in Italia, Atti dell’Incontro di studi, Roma, 30–31 ottobre 2003. Mediterranea, 1 (2004). Istituti Editoriali e Poligrafici Internazionali, Pisa, pp 557–577Google Scholar
  29. Docter RF, Chelbi F, Maraoui Telmini B, Bechtold B, Romdhane HB, Declercq V, Schacht TD, Deweirdt E, Wulf AD, Fersi L, Frey-Kupper S, Garsallah S, Joosten I, Koens H, Mabrouk J, Redissi T, Chebbi SR, Ryckbosch K, Schmidt K, Taverniers B, Kerckhove JV, Verdonck L (2006) Carthage Bir Massouda: second preliminary report on the bilateral excavations of Ghent University and the Institut National du Patrimoine (2003-2004). BABesch 81:37–89Google Scholar
  30. Docter RF, Chelbi F, Maraoui Telmini B, Nijboer AJ, Van der Plicht J, Van Neer W, Mansel K, Garsallah S (2008) New radiocarbon dates from Carthage: bridging the gap between history and archaeology? In: Sagona C (ed) Beyond the homeland: markers in Phoenician chronology, vol Ancient Near Eastern studies 28. Peeters, LeuvenGoogle Scholar
  31. Earle T (1997) How chiefs come to power: the political economy in prehistory. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  32. Earle T, Ling J, Uhnér C, Stos-Gale Z, Melheim L (2015) The political economy and metal trade in Bronze age Europe: understanding regional variability in terms of comparative advantages and articulations. Eur J Archaeol 18(4):633–657CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Eliyahu-Behar A, Yahalom-Mack N (2018) Reevaluating early iron-working skills in the southern Levant through microstructure analysis. J Archaeol Sci Rep 18:447–462Google Scholar
  34. Eliyahu-Behar A, Yahalom-Mack N, Gadot Y, Finkelstein I (2013) Iron smelting and Smithing in major urban centers in Israel during the Iron Age. J Archaeol Sci 40:4319–4330CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Eremin K, Degryse P, Erb-Satullo N, Ganio M, Greene J, Shortland A, Walton M, Stager L (2012) Iron age glass beads from Carthage. In: Meeks N, Cartwright C, Meek A, Mongiatti A (eds) Historical technology, materials and conservation: SEM and microanalysis. Archetype Publications in association with the British Museum,Google Scholar
  36. Freestone I (2008) Pliny on Roman Glassmaking. In: Martinón-Torres M, Rehren T (eds) Archaeology, history and science: integrating approaches to ancient materials. University College LondonGoogle Scholar
  37. Frey-Kupper S (2009) A stone mould from Bir Messaouda (Carthage) for bronze coins of the Second Punic War. Preliminary notes. Schweizerische Numismatische Rundschau (Revue Suisse de Numismatique) 88:185–191Google Scholar
  38. Frey-Kupper S (forthcoming) The coins from the Bir Messaouda site (2003–2005) (unpublished manuscript)Google Scholar
  39. Gauckler P (1915) Nécropoles Puniques de Carthage. Part 2. ParisGoogle Scholar
  40. Gerner-Hansen C (ed) (2001) Carthage Vol. I, a Roman bath in Carthage: an architectural description and evaluation of a building excavated by the Swedish Mission to Carthage. Svenska Institutet i Rom : distrib. P. Aströms, StockholmGoogle Scholar
  41. Giardino C (1995) The West Mediterranean between the 14th and 8th centuries B.C.: mining and metallurgical spheres. BAR International Series 612, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  42. González-Ruibal A (2006) Past the last outpost: Punic merchants in the Atlantic Ocean (5th-1st centuries BC). JMA 19(1):121–150CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Heginbotham A, Bezur A, Bouchard M, Davis JM, Eremin K, Frantz JH, Glinsman L, Hayek L-A, Hook D, Kantarelou V, Karydas AG, Lee L, Mass J, Matsen C, McCarthy B, McGath M, Shugar A, Sirois J, Smith D, Speakman RJ (2010) An evaluation of inter-laboratory reproducibility for quantitative XRF of historic copper alloys. In: Mardikian P, Chemello C, Watters C, Hull P (eds) International Conference on Metal Conservation. Interim Meeting of the International Council of Museums Committee for Conservation, Metal Working Group, Charleston, SC. Clemson UniversityGoogle Scholar
  44. Henderson J (1985) The raw materials of early glass production. Oxf J Archaeol 4(3):267–291CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Hoyos D (2015) Carthage after 201 B.C.: African prosperity and Roman protection. Classicum 41:25–32Google Scholar
  46. Hurst HR, Roskams S (eds) (1984) Excavations at Carthage: the British Mission, vol I, 1. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  47. Hurst H, Stager LE (1978) A metropolitan landscape: the late Punic port of Carthage. WoAr 9(3):334–346Google Scholar
  48. Hussein MM, Benzel K (2014) The gold of Nimrud. In: Aruz J, Graff SB, Rakic Y (eds) Assyria to Iberia at the Dawn of the Classical Age. Metropolitan Museum of Art and Yale University Press, New York, pp 125–131Google Scholar
  49. Icard F (1923) Découverte de l'Area du Sanctuaire de Tanit. Revue TunisienneGoogle Scholar
  50. Johnston PA, Kaufman B (forthcoming) Metallurgy and other technologies. In: Doak B, López-Ruiz C (eds) Oxford handbook of the Phoenician and Punic Mediterranean. Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
  51. Karmous T, Cherjf Z, Ayed N, Coupry C (2005) Les Peintures de Terres Cuites à Carthage. Identification des Pigments de Figurines et de Fruits ArcheoSciences 29:43–50Google Scholar
  52. Katzenstein HJ (1997) History of Tyre: from the beginning of the second millennium B.C.E. until the fall of the Neo-Babylonian Empire in 538 B.C.E. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Press, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  53. Kaufman B (2014) Empire without a voice: Phoenician iron metallurgy and imperial strategy at Carthage. Dissertation, University of California, Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
  54. Kaufman B (2017) Political economy of Carthage: the Carthaginian constitution as reconstructed through archaeology, historical texts and epigraphy. In: Avetisyan PS, Grekyan YH (eds) Bridging times and spaces: papers in ancient Near Eastern, Mediterranean and Armenian studies, Honouring Gregory E. Areshian on the Occasion of his Sixty-fifth Birthday. Archaeopress, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  55. Kaufman B (2018) Anthropology of metallurgical design: a survey of metallurgical traditions from hominin evolution to the Industrial Revolution. In: Kaufman B, Briant CL (eds) Metallurgical design and industry: prehistory to the Space Age. SpringerGoogle Scholar
  56. Kaufman B, Fischer C, Docter RF, Maraoui Telmini B, Chelbi F (2016) Ferrous metallurgy from the Bir Massouda metallurgical precinct at Phoenician and Punic Carthage and the beginning of the North African Iron Age. J Archaeol Sci 71:33–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Keesmann I (2001) Untersuchungen Zur Metallurgie im archaischen und punischen Karthago. Mediterranean archaeology 14 (The origins of iron metallurgy):95-108Google Scholar
  58. Keesmann I, Sveikauskaite A (2007) Neue Untersuchungen zur vorrömischen Metallurgie. In: Niemeyer HG, Docter RF, Schmidt K (eds) Karthago: die Ergebnisse der Hamburger Grabung unter dem Decumanus Maximus. Verlag Philipp Von Zabern, Mainz, pp 853–866Google Scholar
  59. Kelsey FW (1926) Excavations at Carthage, 1925; a preliminary report. The Macmillan Company, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  60. Lancel S (ed) (1979) Byrsa I: Rapports Préliminaires des Fouilles (1974–1976). École française de Rome, RomeGoogle Scholar
  61. Lancel S (ed) (1982) Byrsa II: Rapports Préliminaires sur les Fouilles 1977–1978, Niveaux et Vestiges Puniques. École française de Rome, RomeGoogle Scholar
  62. Lancel S (1995) Carthage: a history (trans: Nevill A). Blackwell, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  63. Lancel S (1998) Hannibal. Blackwell, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  64. Lapeyre G-G (1939) Les Fouilles du Musée Lavigerie à Carthage de 1935 à 1939. CRAI Comptes-Rendus des Séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres:294–304Google Scholar
  65. Lechtman H (2007) The Inka, and Andean metallurgical tradition. In: Burger RL, Morris C, Matos Mendieta R (eds) Variations in the expression of Inka power. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D. CGoogle Scholar
  66. Maraoui Telmini B (2011) Découverte de latrines puniques du 5ème siècle av. J.-C. à Carthage (Bir Massouda). BABESCH 86:53–70Google Scholar
  67. Maraoui Telmini B (2012) Vestiges d’un Habitat de L’Époque Punique Moyenne À Bir Massouda (Carthage): Bilan des Fouilles le Sondage 7 et Analyse de la Céramique. Carthage Stud 6:1–202Google Scholar
  68. Maraoui Telmini B, Docter RF, Bechtold B, Chelbi F, van de Put W (2014) Defining Punic Carthage. In: Quinn JC, Vella NC (eds) The Punic Mediterranean: identities and identification from Phoenician settlement to Roman rule. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp 111–145Google Scholar
  69. Markoe GE (1985) Phoenician bronze and silver bowls from Cyprus and the Mediterranean. University of California Publications. Classical studies 26. University of California, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  70. Murillo-Barroso M, Montero-Ruiz I, Rafel N, Hunt Ortiz MA, Armada X-L (2016) The macro-regional scale of silver production in Iberia during the first millennium BC in the context of Mediterranean contexts. Oxf J Archaeol 35(1):75–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Neville A (2007) Mountains of silver and rivers of gold: the Phoenicians in Iberia. University of British Columbia studies in the ancient world 1. OxbowGoogle Scholar
  72. Niemeyer HG, Docter RF, Schmidt K (eds) (2007) Karthago: die Ergebnisse der Hamburger Grabung unter dem Decumanus Maximus. Verlag Philipp Von Zabern, MainzGoogle Scholar
  73. Núñez FJ (2014) The lowest levels at Bir Massouda and the Foundation of Carthage. A Levantine perspective. Carthage Stud 8:7–46Google Scholar
  74. Papadopoulos JK, Urton G (eds) (2012) The construction of value in the ancient world, Cotsen advanced seminar, vol 5. Cotsen Press, Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
  75. Pernicka E, Gentner W, Wagner GA, Vavelidis M, Gale NH (1980) Ancient lead and silver production on Thasos, Greece. In: Pernicka E, Gentner W, Wagner GA, Gale NH, Vavelidis M (eds) Beiträgë zur Archäometallurgie von Thasos, vorgetragen auf dem 22. Internationalen Symposium für Archäometrie, Paris. Max Planck Institut für Kernphysik, HeidelbergGoogle Scholar
  76. Pernicka E, Wagner GA, Assimenos K, Doumas C, Begemann F, Todt W (1982) An analytical study of prehistoric lead and silver objects from the Aegean. In: Aspinall A, Warren SE (eds) 22nd Symposium on Archaeometry. The University of Bradford, Bradford, U.K., March 30-April 3, 1982Google Scholar
  77. Quinn JC, Vella NC (eds) (2014) The Punic Mediterranean: identities and identification from Phoenician settlement to Roman rule. Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
  78. Rademakers FW, Rehren T, Pusch EB (2018) Bronze production in Pi-Ramesse: alloying technology and material use. In: Ben-Yosef E (ed) Mining for ancient copper: essays in memory of Professor Beno Rothenberg, vol Monograh series number 37. Tel Aviv University, Sonia and Marco Nadler Institute of Archaeology, Tel AvivGoogle Scholar
  79. Rakob F (1985) Carthage punique. Fouilles et prospections archéologiques de la Mission allemande, REPPAL 1:133–156Google Scholar
  80. Redissi T (2011) Les petits objets de Bir Massouda à Carthage Dermech. Carthage Stud 5:29–70Google Scholar
  81. Rehren T (1991) Selenium and tellurium in Mediterranean copper ingots. In: Gale NH (ed) Studies in Mediterranean archaeology Vol. XC: Bronze Age trade in the Mediterranean. Jonsered, Paul Åströms Förlag, Rewley House, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  82. Rehren T (2001) Aspects of the production of cobalt-blue glass in Egypt. Archaeometry 43(4):483–489CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Rehren T, Osório A, Anarbaev A (2010) Some notes on early Islamic glass in eastern Uzbekistan. In: Zorn B, Hilgner A (eds) Glass along the Silk Road: from 200 BC to AD 1000. Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums, MainzGoogle Scholar
  84. Renzi M, Rovira Llorens S (2015) Las Metalurgias Fenicias en el Mediterráneo. In: Rovira Llorens S, Renzi M (eds) PHICARIA III Encuentros Internacionales del Mediterráneo: Minería y metalurgia en el Mediterráneo y su periferia oceánica. Universidad Popular de MazarrónGoogle Scholar
  85. Sainte-Marie É (1884) Mission à Carthage. Ernst Leroux, ParisGoogle Scholar
  86. Sanmartí J (2009) Colonial relations and social change in Iberia (seventh to third centuries BC). In: Dietler M, López-Ruiz C (eds) Colonial encounters in ancient Iberia: Phoenician, Greek, and indigenous relations. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  87. Sanmartí J, Kallala N, Carme Belarte M, Ramon Torres J, Maraoui Telmini B, Jornet R, Miniaoui S, Fadrique T, López Reyes D, Morell N, Portillo M, Valenzuela S, Campillo J, Montanero D, Cantero F, Jenène M (2012) Filling gaps in the protohistory of the eastern Maghreb: the Althiburos Archaeological Project (El Kef, Tunisia). J Afr Archaeol 10(1):21–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Scott DA (1985) Periodic corrosion phenomena in bronze antiquities. Stud Conserv 30(2):49–57Google Scholar
  89. Scott D (2010) Ancient metals: microstructure and metallurgy, vol 1. Conservation Science Press, Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
  90. Stager LE (1978) Excavations at Carthage 1975—the Punic project: first interim report. AASOR 43:151–190Google Scholar
  91. Tylecote RF (1962) Metallurgy in archaeology: a prehistory of metallurgy in the British Isles. Edward Arnold (Publishers) Ltd, LondonGoogle Scholar
  92. Tylecote RF (1982) Metallurgy in Punic and Roman Carthage. In: Mines et Fonderies Antiques de la Gaule. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, ParisGoogle Scholar
  93. Valério P, Ávila de Melo A, de Barros L (2003) Fátima Araújo M Archaeometallurgical Studies of Pre-Historical Artefacts from Quinta Do Almaraz (Cacilhas, Portugal). In: Archaeometallurgy in Europe, 24–26 September 2003, Milan, Italy, pp 327–336Google Scholar
  94. Valério P, Soares AMM, Silva RJC, Araújo MF, Rebelo P, Neto N, Santos R, Fontes T (2013) Bronze production in southwestern Iberian Peninsula: the Late Bronze Age metallurgical workshop from Entre Águas 5 (Portugal). J Archaeol Sci 40:439–451CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  95. Van Dommelen P, Gómez Bellard C (2008) Rural landscapes of the Punic world. Equinox, London, OakvilleGoogle Scholar
  96. Veldhuijzen HA, Rehren T (2007) Slag and the city: early iron production at Tell Hammeh, Jordan, and Tel Beth-Shemesh, Israel. In: Niece SL, Hook D, Craddock P (eds) Metals and mines: studies in archaeometallurgy. Archetype/British Museum, LondonGoogle Scholar
  97. Vonhoff C (2015) Phoenician bronzes in Cyprus. In: Jiménez Ávila J (ed) Biblioteca Archaeologica Hispana 45. Real Academia de la Historia, MadridGoogle Scholar
  98. Waldbaum JC (1980) The first archaeological appearance of iron and the transition to the Iron Age. In: Wertime TA, Muhly JD (eds) The coming of the age of iron. Yale University Press, New Haven and LondonGoogle Scholar
  99. Warmington BH (1969) Carthage: a history. Barnes & Noble Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  100. Westner KJ, Birch T, Höfer H, Seitz H-M, Kemmers F, Klein S (2017) Rome’s rise to power as deduced by analysis of silver coinage. Paper presented at the Goldschmidt, August 13-18, Paris 2017Google Scholar
  101. White JC, Hamilton EG (2014) The transmission of early bronze technology to Thailand: new perspectives. In: Roberts BW, Thornton CP (eds) Archaeometallurgy in global perspective: methods and syntheses. SpringerGoogle Scholar
  102. Wolff SR (1986) Maritime trade at Punic Carthage. Ph.D. dissertation, Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations, University of Chicago, ChicagoGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of the ClassicsUniversity of Illinois at Urbana-ChampaignUrbanaUSA
  2. 2.Department of ArchaeologyGhent UniversityGhentBelgium
  3. 3.Cotsen Institute of ArchaeologyUniversity of CaliforniaLos AngelesUSA
  4. 4.Department of Art HistoryUniversity of CaliforniaLos AngelesUSA
  5. 5.Institut National du PatrimoineTunisTunisia
  6. 6.Faculté des Sciences Humaines et Sociales de TunisUniversity of TunisTunisTunisia

Personalised recommendations