Advertisement

Review of Managerial Science

, Volume 13, Issue 2, pp 207–226 | Cite as

Coopetition as the new trend in inter-firm alliances: literature review and research patterns

  • Carlos DeveceEmail author
  • D. Enrique Ribeiro-Soriano
  • Daniel Palacios-Marqués
Review Paper

Abstract

Since the end of the 1990s, the number of articles on coopetition—a relationship built on simultaneous competition and cooperation—has steadily increased in response to the growing prevalence of relationships of coopetition in many industries. The tension inherent in a relationship of coopetition with a direct competitor presents both a challenge for managers and, at the same time, an exciting and complex research area. Different researchers of coopetition have addressed the topic from vastly different perspectives, basing their research on different theoretical frameworks, types of analysis, methods, and aims. By classifying articles on coopetition published in the last 20 years, this paper presents an application of cluster analysis to examine trends and tendencies in coopetition research. The paper also assesses whether this research field has followed a coherent progression during this period. The research reveals two independent research trends within the coopetition literature. The first research trend consists of studies that have mathematically modeled and simulated coopetition scenarios using game theory, whereas the second research stream consists of theoretical research describing the dynamics and tensions of coopetition based on evidence from case studies. Based on the cluster analysis, inter-firm alliances and their governance mechanisms emerge as the most promising theoretical and practical approach to improve cooperation between competitors.

Keywords

Coopetition Literature review Inter-firm alliances State-of-the-art Cluster analysis Research patterns 

Mathematics Subject Classification

62H30 

References

  1. Afuah A (2000) Do your co-opetitors’ capabilities matter in the face of a technological change? Strateg Manag J 21(3):387–404Google Scholar
  2. Afuah A (2004) Does a focal firm’s technology entry timing depend on the impact of the technology on co-opetitors? Res Policy 33(8):1231–1246Google Scholar
  3. Allal-Chérif O, Bidan M (2017) Collaborative open training with serious games: relations, culture, knowledge, innovation, and desire. J Innov Knowl 2(1):31–38Google Scholar
  4. Alves H, Ferreira JJ, Fernandes CI (2016) Customer’s operant resources effects on co-creation activities. J Innov Knowl 1(2):69–80Google Scholar
  5. Aragon-Sanchez A, Sanchez-Marin G (2005) Strategic orientation, management characteristics, and performance: a study of Spanish SMEs. J Small Bus Manag 43(3):287–308Google Scholar
  6. Baruch Y, Lin C (2012) All for one, one for all: coopetition and virtual team performance. Technol Forecast Soc Change 79(6):1155–1168Google Scholar
  7. Bengtsson M, Johansson M (2014) Managing coopetition to create opportunities for small firms. Int Small Bus J 32(4):401–427Google Scholar
  8. Bengtsson M, Kock S (2000) “Coopetition” in business networks—to cooperate and compete simultaneously. Ind Mark Manag 29(5):411–426Google Scholar
  9. Bengtsson M, Kock S (2014) Coopetition-Quo vadis? past accomplishments and future challenges. Ind Mark Manag 43(2):180–188Google Scholar
  10. Bengtsson M, Raza-Ullah T (2016) A systematic review of research on coopetition: toward a multilevel understanding. Ind Mark Manag 57:23–39Google Scholar
  11. Bengtsson M, Eriksson J, Wincent J (2010) Co-opetition dynamics—an outline for further inquiry. Compet Rev 20(2):194–214Google Scholar
  12. Bonel E, Rocco E (2007) Coopeting to survive, surviving coopetition. Int Stud Manag Organ 37(2):70–96Google Scholar
  13. Bouncken RB, Fredrich V (2015) Learning in coopetition: alliance orientation, network size, and firm types. J Bus Res 69(5):1753–1758Google Scholar
  14. Bouncken RB, Fredrich V (2016) Good fences make good neighbors? directions and safeguards in alliances on business model innovation. J Bus Res 69(11):5196–5202Google Scholar
  15. Bouncken R, Ricarda B, Kraus S (2013) Innovation in knowledge-intensive industries: the double-edged sword of coopetition. J Bus Res 66(10):2060–2070Google Scholar
  16. Bouncken RB, Plüschke BD, Pesch R, Kraus S (2014) Entrepreneurial orientation in vertical alliances: joint product innovation and learning from allies. Rev Manag Sci. doi: 10.1007/s11846-014-0150-8 Google Scholar
  17. Bouncken RB, Gast J, Kraus S, Bogers M (2015a) Coopetition: a systematic review, synthesis, and future research directions. Rev Manag Sci 9:577–601Google Scholar
  18. Bouncken R, Pesch R, Kraus S (2015b) SME innovativeness in buyer–seller alliances: effects of entry timing strategies and inter-organizational learning. Rev Manag Sci 9(2):361–384Google Scholar
  19. Bouncken RB, Pesch R, Reuschl A (2016a) Copoiesis: mutual knowledge creation in alliances. J Innov Knowl 1(1):44–50Google Scholar
  20. Bouncken R, Clauß T, Fredrich V (2016b) Product innovation through coopetition in alliances: singular or plural governance? Ind Mark Manag 53:77–90Google Scholar
  21. Bouncken RB, Fredrich V, Ritala P, Kraus S (2017) Coopetition in new product development alliances: advantages and tensions for incremental and radical innovation. Br J Manag. doi: 10.1111/14678551.12213 Google Scholar
  22. Brandenburger A, Nalebuff B (1996) Co-opetition. Doubleday Publishing, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  23. Chen MJ (2008) Reconceptualizing the competition–cooperation relationship a transparadox perspective. J Manag Inq 17(4):288–304Google Scholar
  24. Chetty SK, Wilson HIM (2003) Collaborating with competitors to acquire resources. Int Bus Rev 12(1):61–81Google Scholar
  25. Chiambaretto P, Fernandez AS (2016) The evolution of coopetitive and collaborative alliances in an alliance portfolio: the Air France case. Ind Mark Manag 57:75–85Google Scholar
  26. Chien TH (2005) Competition and cooperation intensity in a network—a case study in Taiwan simulator industry. J Am Acad Bus 7(2):150–156Google Scholar
  27. Chin K-S, Chan BL, Lam P-K (2008) Identifying and prioritizing critical success factors for coopetition strategy. Ind Manag Data Syst 4(108):437–454Google Scholar
  28. Dahl J (2014) Conceptualizing coopetition as a process: an outline of change in cooperative and competitive interactions. Ind Mark Manag 43(2):272–279Google Scholar
  29. Das TK (2004) Time-span and risk of partner opportunism in strategic alliances. J Manag Psychol 19(8):744–759Google Scholar
  30. Enberg C (2012) Enabling knowledge integration in coopetitive R&D projects—the management of conflicting logics. Int J Proj Manag 30(7):771–780Google Scholar
  31. Fernandez AS, Le Roy F, Gnyawali DR (2014) Sources and management of tension in co-opetition case evidence from telecommunications satellites manufacturing in Europe. Ind Mark Manag 43(2):222–235Google Scholar
  32. Gast J, Filser M, Gundolf K, Kraus S (2015) Coopetition research: towards a better understanding of past trends and future directions. Int J Entrep Small Bus 24(4):492–521Google Scholar
  33. Ghobadi S, D’Ambra J (2012) Knowledge sharing in cross-functional teams: a coopetitive model. J Knowl Manag 16(2):285–301Google Scholar
  34. Gnyawali DR, Madhavan BJR (2001) Cooperative networks and competitive dynamics: a structural embeddedness perspective. Acad Manag Rev 26(3):431–445Google Scholar
  35. Gnyawali DR, Park R (2009) Co-opetition and technological innovation in small and medium sized enterprises: a multilevel conceptual model. J Small Bus Manag 47(3):308–330Google Scholar
  36. Gnyawali DR, Park BJR (2011) Co-opetition between giants: collaboration with competitors for technological innovation. Res Policy 40(5):650–663Google Scholar
  37. Gnyawali DR, He J, Madhavan R (2008) Coopetition. Promises and challenges. In: Wankel C (ed) 21st century management: a reference handbook. Sage, Thousand Oaks, pp 386–398Google Scholar
  38. Gnyawali DR, Madhavan R, He J, Bengtsson M (2016) The competition–cooperation paradox in inter- firm relationships: a conceptual framework. Ind Mark Manag 53:7–18Google Scholar
  39. Grant RM (1991) The resource-based theory of competitive advantages. Implications for strategy formulation. Calif Manag Rev 33(3):114–135Google Scholar
  40. Gueguen G (2009) Coopetition and business ecosystems in the information technology sector: the example of intelligent mobile terminals. Int J Entrep Small Bus 8(1):135–153Google Scholar
  41. Gurnani H, Erkoc M, Luo Y (2007) Impact of product pricing and timing of investment decisions on supply chain co-opetition. Eur J Oper Res 180(1):228–248Google Scholar
  42. Harbison JR, Pekar PP, Stasior WF (1998) Smart alliances: a practical guide to repeatable success. Jossey-Bass, San FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  43. Harms R, Reschke CH, Kraus S, Fink M (2010) Antecedents to innovation and growth: analyzing the impact of entrepreneurial orientation and goal-oriented management. Int J Technol Manag 52(1/2):135–152Google Scholar
  44. Ho H, Ganesan S (2013) Does knowledge base compatibility help or hurt knowledge sharing between suppliers in coopetition? The role of customer participation. J Mark 77(6):91–107Google Scholar
  45. Hong JFL, Snell RS (2015) Knowledge development through co-opetition: a case study of a Japanese foreign subsidiary and its local suppliers. J World Bus 50(4):769–780Google Scholar
  46. Huang KF, Yu CMJ (2011) The effect of competitive and non-competitive R&D collaboration on firm innovation. J Technol Transf 36(4):383–403Google Scholar
  47. Hung S-W, Chang C-C (2012) A co-opetition perspective of technology alliance governance modes. Technol Anal Strateg 24(7):679–696Google Scholar
  48. Hutter K, Hautz J, Füller J, Mueller J, Matzler K (2011) Communitition: the tension between competition and collaboration in community-based design contests. Creat Innov Manag 20(1):3–21Google Scholar
  49. Khanna T, Gulati R, Nohria N (1998) The dynamics of learning alliances: competition, cooperation, and relative scope. Strateg Manag J 19(3):193–210Google Scholar
  50. Kraus S, Pohjola M, Koponen A (2012) Innovation in family firms: an empirical analysis linking organizational and managerial innovation to corporate success. Rev Manag Sci 6(3):265–286Google Scholar
  51. Kraus S, Mensching H, Calabro A, Cheng CF, Filser M (2016) Family firm internationalization: a configurational approach. J Bus Res 69(11):5473–5478Google Scholar
  52. Kraus S, Meier F, Niemand T, Bouncken RB, Ritala P (2017) In search for the ideal coopetition partner: an experimental study. Rev Manag Sci. doi: 10.1007/s11846-017-0237-0 Google Scholar
  53. Kwok JJM, Lee D-Y (2015) Coopetitive supply chain relationship model: application to the smartphone manufacturing network. PLoS ONE 10(7):e0132844. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0132844 Google Scholar
  54. Lado AA, Boyd NG, Hanlon SC (1997) Competition, cooperation, and the search for economic rents: a syncretic model. Acad Manag Rev 22(1):110–141Google Scholar
  55. Lai K, Su F, Weng C, Chen C (2007) Co-opetition strategy from the patent analysis perspective: the case of the stent market. Int J Innov Technol Manag 4(02):137–153Google Scholar
  56. Le Roy F, Czakon W (2016) Managing coopetition: the missing link between strategy and performance. Ind Mark Manag 53:3–6Google Scholar
  57. Li Y, Liu Y, Liu H (2011) Co-opetition, distributor’s entrepreneurial orientation and manufacturer’s knowledge acquisition: evidence from China. J Oper Manag 29(1–2):128–142Google Scholar
  58. Lin C-P, Wang Y-J, Tsai Y-H, Hsu Y-F (2010) Perceived job effectiveness in coopetition: a survey of virtual teams within business organizations. Comput Hum Behav 26(6):1598–1606Google Scholar
  59. Liu Y, Luo Y, Yang P, Maksimov V (2014) Typology and effects of co-opetition in Buyer–Supplier relationships: evidence from the Chinese Home Appliance Industry. Manag Organ Rev 10(3):439–465Google Scholar
  60. Lowensberg DA (2010) A “new” view on “traditional” strategic alliances’ formation paradigms. Manag Decis 48(7):1090–1110Google Scholar
  61. Luo Y (2005) Toward coopetition within a multinational enterprise: a perspective from foreign subsidiaries. J World Bus 40(1):71–90Google Scholar
  62. Luo Y (2007) A coopetition perspective of global competition. J World Bus 42(2):129–144Google Scholar
  63. Luo YD, Rui HC (2009) An ambidexterity perspective toward multinational enterprises from emerging economies. Acad Manag Perspect 23(4):49–70Google Scholar
  64. Luo X, Slotegraaf R, Pan X (2006) Cross-functional ‘‘coopetition’’: the simultaneous role of cooperation and competition within firms. J Mark 70(2):67–80Google Scholar
  65. M’Chirgui Z (2005) The economics of the smart card industry: towards coopetitive strategies. Econ Innov New Technol 14(6):455–477Google Scholar
  66. Madhaven R, Gnyawali DR, He J (2004) Two’s company, three’s a crowd? Triads in cooperative competitive networks. Acad Manag J 6(47):918–927Google Scholar
  67. Niu B, Wang Y, Guo P (2015) Equilibrium pricing sequence in a co-opetitive supply chain with the ODM as a downstream rival of Its OEM. Omega Int J Manag S 57:249–270Google Scholar
  68. Okura M (2007) Coopetitive strategies of Japanese insurance firms a game-theory approach. Int Stud Manag Organ 37(2):53–69Google Scholar
  69. Oum TH, Park JH, Kim K, Yu C (2004) The effect of horizontal alliances on firm productivity and profitability: evidence from the global airline industry. J Bus Res 57:844–853Google Scholar
  70. Park BJR, Srivastava MK, Gnyawali DR (2014a) Walking the tight rope of coopetition: impact of competition and cooperation intensities and balance on firm innovation performance. Ind Mark Manag 43(2):210–221Google Scholar
  71. Park BJR, Srivastava MK, Gnyawali DR (2014b) Impact of coopetition in the alliance portfolio and coopetition experience on firm innovation. Technol Anal Strateg Manag 26(8):943–957Google Scholar
  72. Peng T, Bourne M (2009) The coexistence of competition and cooperation between networks: implications from two Taiwanese healthcare networks. Br J Manag 20(3):377–400Google Scholar
  73. Peng T, Pike S, Yang J, Roos G (2012) Is cooperation with competitors a good idea? An example in practice. Br J Manag 23(4):532–560Google Scholar
  74. Perry ML, Sengupta S, Krapfel R (2004) Effectiveness of horizontal strategic alliances in technologically uncertain environments: are trust and commitment enough? J Bus Res 57(9):951–956Google Scholar
  75. Peteraf MA (1993) The cornerstone of competitive advantage. A resource-based view. Strateg Manag J 14:179–191Google Scholar
  76. Pil FK, Holweg M (2003) Exploring scale: the advantages of thinking small. Sloan Manag Rev 44(2):33–39Google Scholar
  77. Poulsen MBJ (2001) Competition and cooperation: what roles in scientific dynamics? Int J Technol Manag 22(7/8):782–793Google Scholar
  78. Powell WW, Koput KW, Smith-Doerr L (1996) Interorganizational collaboration and the locus of innovation: networks of learning in biotechnology. Admin Sci Quart 41(1):116–141Google Scholar
  79. Pun H (2013) Channel structure design for complementary products under a co-opetitive environment. Decis Sci 44(4):785–796Google Scholar
  80. Quintana-García C, Benavides-Velasco CA (2004) Cooperation, competition, and innovative capability: a panel data of European dedicated biotechnology firms. Technovation 24(12):927–938Google Scholar
  81. Raza-Ullah T, Bengtsson M, Kock S (2014) The coopetition paradox and tension in coopetition at multiple levels. Ind Mark Manag 43(2):189–198Google Scholar
  82. Ricciardi F, Zardini A, Rossignoli C (2016) Organizational dynamism and adaptive business model innovation: the triple paradox configuration. J Bus Res 69(11):5487–5493Google Scholar
  83. Ritala P (2012) Coopetition strategy: when is it successful? Empirical evidence on innovation and market performance. Br J Manag 23(3):307–324Google Scholar
  84. Ritala P, Hurmelinna-Laukkanen P (2009) What’s in it for me? creating and appropriating value in innovation-related coopetition. Technovation 29:819–828Google Scholar
  85. Ritala P, Sainio L-M (2014) Coopetition for radical innovation: technology, market and business-model perspectives. Technol Anal Strateg Manag 26(2):155–169Google Scholar
  86. Ritala P, Tidström A (2014) Untangling the value-creation and value-appropriation elements of coopetition strategy: a longitudinal analysis on the firm and relational levels. Scand J Manag 30(4):498–515Google Scholar
  87. Ritala P, Hallikas J, Sissonen H (2008) The effect of strategic alliances between key competitors on firm performance. Manag Res J Iberoam Acad Manag 6(3):179–187Google Scholar
  88. Ritala P, Golnam A, Wegmann A (2014) Coopetition-based business models: the case of Amazon.com. Ind Mark Manag 43(2):236–249Google Scholar
  89. Rodrigues F, Souza V, Leitao J (2009) Strategic coopetition of global brands: a game theory approach to ‘Nike? iPod Sport Kit’ co-branding. Int J Entrep Ventur 3(4):435–455Google Scholar
  90. Shao YB (2012) Analysis on the Game of Co-opetition of ports in the China Yangtze Delta-Taking Shanghai port and Ningbo-Zhoushan port as an example. J Korean Navig Port Res 36(2):123–129Google Scholar
  91. Shih M, Tsai H, Wu C, Lu C (2006) A holistic knowledge sharing framework in high-tech firms: game and co-opetition perspectives. Int J Technol Manag 36(4):354–367Google Scholar
  92. Smith WK, Lewis MW (2011) Toward a theory of paradox: a dynamic equilibrium model of organizing. Acad Manag Rev 36(2):381–403Google Scholar
  93. Song DW, Lee ES (2012) Coopetitive networks, knowledge acquisition and maritime logistics value. Int J Logist Res Appl 15(1):15–35Google Scholar
  94. Soriano DR, Palacios-Marqués D, Devece-Carañana C, Peris-Ortíz M (2014) How to create international business competences and their impact on firm performance. Eur J Int Manag 8(3):279–292Google Scholar
  95. Soubeyran A, Weber S (2002) District formation and local social capital: a (tacit) co-opetition approach. J Urban Econ 52:65–92Google Scholar
  96. Tidström A, Rajala A (2016) Coopetition strategy as interrelated praxis and practices on multiple levels. Ind Mark Manag 58:35–44Google Scholar
  97. Todeva E, Knoke D (2005) Strategic alliances and models of collaboration. Manag Decis 43(1):123–148Google Scholar
  98. Tsai W (2002) Social structure of “coopetition” within a multiunit organization: coordination, competition, and intraorganizational knowledge sharing. Organ Sci 13(2):179–190Google Scholar
  99. Walley K (2007) Coopetition: an introduction to the subject and an agenda for research. Int Stud Manag Organ 37(2):11–31Google Scholar
  100. Wang Y, Krakover S (2008) Destination marketing: competition, cooperation or coopetition? Int J Contemp Hosp Manag 20(2):126–141Google Scholar
  101. Wiener MS, Saunders C (2014) Forced coopetition in IT multi-sourcing. J Strateg Inf Syst 23(3):210–225Google Scholar
  102. Wilhelm M (2011) Managing coopetition through horizontal supply chain relations: linking dyadic and network levels of analysis. J Oper Manag 29(8):663–676Google Scholar
  103. Wilhelm MM, Kohlbacher F (2011) Co-opetition and knowledge co-creation in Japanese supplier-networks: the case of Toyota. Asian Bus Manag 10(1):66–86Google Scholar
  104. Wong A, Tjosvold D, Su F (2007) Social face for innovation in strategic alliances in China: the mediating roles of resource exchange and reflexivity. J Organ Behav 28:961–978Google Scholar
  105. Woodside AG (2013) Moving beyond multiple regression analysis to algorithms: calling for adoption of a paradigm shift from symmetric to asymmetric thinking in data analysis and crafting theory. J Bus Res 66(4):463–472Google Scholar
  106. Zeng M, Chen X (2003) Achieving cooperation in multiparty alliances; a social dilemma approach to partnership management. Acad Manag J 28(4):587–605Google Scholar
  107. Zhang HS, Shu CL, Jiang X, Malter AJ (2010) Managing knowledge for innovation: the role of cooperation, competition, and alliance nationality. J Int Mark 18(4):74–94Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Carlos Devece
    • 1
    Email author
  • D. Enrique Ribeiro-Soriano
    • 2
  • Daniel Palacios-Marqués
    • 1
  1. 1.Business Organization DepartmentUniversitat Politècnica de ValènciaValenciaSpain
  2. 2.IUDESCOOP and Business Administration Department “JJ Renau Piqueras”Universitat de València, Estudi GeneralValenciaSpain

Personalised recommendations