Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Motor vehicle accidents in CPAP-compliant obstructive sleep apnea patients—a long-term observational study

  • 141 Accesses

Abstract

Purpose

Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) has been associated with a 2- to 7-fold risk of motor vehicle accidents (MVAs). Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) treatment may reduce MVA risk. We further explored this issue in long-term CPAP users and untreated controls.

Methods

We used both before-after and case-control study designs. The observational cohort consisted of CPAP-treated and untreated patients matched for gender, age, and apnea-hypopnea index. All MVAs reported to the police were identified.

Results

A total of 2060 patients (75.8% male, mean age 56.0 ± 10.5 years) were included. The CPAP-treated patients (N = 1030) were screened for MVAs for a median of 9.0 years before and after treatment. The median CPAP usage was 6.4 h/day. The control patients (N = 1030) were screened for MVAs for a median of 6.5 years after discontinuation of CPAP. No significant differences were observed between the incidences of MVAs per 1000 person years before treatment (3.2), after treatment (3.9), or in controls (2.6). Compared with controls, patients who had MVA after treatment had a higher body mass index (BMI), but did not differ in terms of other baseline characteristics, sleep study data, or accident conditions. In the majority of these patients, daytime sleepiness was reduced, whereas BMI tended to increase during treatment.

Conclusions

The MVA incidence did not change after CPAP treatment. Among the patients who had MVA, BMI was the only baseline characteristic that differed between the groups and tended to further increase after CPAP treatment. Differences in sleep study data or accident conditions were not observed.

Introduction

Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) has been associated with a 2–7-fold risk of motor vehicle accidents (MVAs) [1]. Body mass index (BMI), excessive daytime sleepiness, apnea-hypopnea index (AHI), oxygen saturation, and changes in brain morphology and neural activation resulting in cognitive impairment may contribute to this risk [1, 2].

In a meta-analysis of nine observational studies (N = 1976 in total), MVA risk decreased by 65–78% after CPAP in observation periods of 6 months to 5 years before and after treatment [3]. In one included study, MVAs were reduced both after CPAP and in healthy controls. None of the studies provided objective data on both MVAs and CPAP adherence [3]. Objective data on MVAs has been shown to be more reliable, since OSA patients subjectively reported only one-third of their MVAs, implying their reluctance to disclose their MVA history [4]. In a recent observational study, CPAP use of ≥ 4 h/day was associated with a significantly reduced and lesser use with increased risk of objectively reported MVAs compared with before CPAP [5]. Conversely, a recent randomized controlled trial study found no differences in MVAs among patients treated with CPAP or best supportive care [6]. In both of these studies, less than half of the CPAP-treated patients had used CPAP for ≥ 4 h/day [5, 6].

To overcome limitations of previous studies including inadequate CPAP compliance and lack of long-term data on objectively reported MVAs, we evaluated the incidence of police-reported MVAs in a large cohort of highly adherent OSA patients using both (1) before-after and (2) matched case-control study designs.

Methods

Our age-, gender-, and AHI-matched case-control OSA patient populations have been previously described [7]. All the patients had been treated at the Department of Pulmonary Diseases, Turku University Hospital during 2002–2009 (Fig. 1). Patients without available cardiorespiratory polygraphy data prior to CPAP were excluded. Cases (N = 1030) had used CPAP at least for 5 years with at least 4 follow-up visits. All patients in the control group (N = 1030) had used CPAP, but despite the doctor’s advice discontinued the treatment within 5 years (median 4 months).

Fig. 1
figure1

Flowchart of the recruitment of the continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP)-treated obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) patients and their controls matched for age, gender, and apnea-hypopnea index (AHI). Modified and reprinted by permission from Reference [7]

Baseline variables were derived from the electronic medical records [7]. All MVAs reported to the police were identified from the national registry maintained by Statistics Finland. Only accidents involving the study subject as the actual driver were included. In CPAP-treated patients, the median duration of CPAP treatment was 9.0 (IQR 2.5) years with an average of 8.4 ± 2.2 follow-up visits per patient calculated from the commencement of treatment to withdrawal or to the last follow-up visit before the end of 2014. In order to compare MVAs before and after treatment, CPAP-treated patients were also screened for MVAs for 9 years prior to CPAP. The control patients were screened for MVAs for 6.5 years prior to CPAP and for a median of 6.5 (IQR 3.9) years after discontinuation of CPAP calculated from the last CPAP follow-up visit until death or the end of 2014. Data on all-cause death was derived from the national registry. CPAP usage hours (h/day) were recorded by inbuilt counter clock of the CPAP device. For each patient, the mean usage hours across the treatment period were determined.

Statistical analyses

Data analyses were performed using the IBM SPSS Statistics 25.0 and SAS 9.4 software packages. Normally distributed continuous variables were presented as mean values and standard deviations (SD), and not normally distributed as median values and interquartile ranges (IQR). Means and medians were compared by the independent-sample T test and the Mann-Whitney U test, respectively, and categorical variables by the χ2 test. Cases and controls were matched by using the K-means clustering algorithm with Manhattan distance (absolute value distance). The Poisson regression, in which the individual length of observation was taken into account for each patient, was used for the comparison of MVA incidences between the study groups. p values of < 0.05 were considered significant.

Results

At baseline, CPAP-treated and control patients did not differ in terms of age, gender, or AHI. However, differences in comorbidities, BMI, and smoking habits were observed (Table 1) [7]. In the CPAP-treated patients, the median CPAP use across the 9-year treatment period was 6.4 (IQR 2.3) h/day, and 913 (88.6%) of the patients were compliant to CPAP (≥ 4 h/day). Of the CPAP-treated and control patients, 1.2% and 0.9%, respectively, had engaged in bariatric surgery (p = 0.5), and 6.3% of the controls had used a mandibular advancement device (MAD) treatment after CPAP. Data on MAD compliance was not available.

Table 1 Baseline characteristics of the studied OSA patients, and comparison of variables between the CPAP-treated patients and controls. Modified and reprinted by permission from Reference 7

Of the 1030 CPAP-treated patients, MVAs were registered in total of 30 patients before and 39 patients after CPAP. Of the latter, 3 MVAs occurred after a several months’ break from CPAP and were thus excluded from the analyses. Of the 1030 controls, MVAs were registered in 17 patients. The incidence of MVAs per 1000 person years was 3.2 (95% CI 2.3–4.6) before, 3.9 (95% CI 2.8–5.3) after CPAP, and 2.6 (95% CI 1.6–4.1) in controls (Fig. 2). Risk for having a MVA did not differ significantly between after and before treatment groups (risk ratio (RR) 1.19, 95% CI 0.73–1.94, p = 0.5), or between CPAP-treated and control patients (RR 1.5, 95% CI 0.85–2.69, p = 0.2). One patient had two MVAs after CPAP, and one patient had a MVA before and after CPAP. None of the controls had multiple MVAs. Excluding those controls who had used MAD after CPAP did not change the results. Furthermore, the MVA incidence did not differ between the compliant and noncompliant CPAP-treated patients. Among the latter, the incidence tended to increase after CPAP, but the difference was not significant (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2
figure2

Incidence of motor vehicle accidents (MVAs) per 1000 person years (A) in continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP)-treated patients 9 years before and after the commencement of CPAP treatment in all patients (1), in subgroups of patients with CPAP use of ≥ 4 h/day (1a) or of < 4 h/day (1b), and (B) in control patients 6.5 years before CPAP and after discontinuation of CPAP (2)

Among the patients with MVA, the only baseline difference was higher BMI in CPAP-treated than in control patients (median 34.2 vs. 31.3 kg/m2, p = 0.03) (Table 2). The prevalence of cardiovascular disease and the number of professional drivers were low and did not differ between the groups. No differences were observed in sleep study data (Table 2) or accident conditions including the hour of the accident (Table 3). Time to the first MVA, however, was longer among CPAP-treated than that of among controls (median 42.5 vs. 15.0 months, p = 0.02). In the CPAP-treated patients with MVA, a mean increase of 1.2 ± 3.7 kg/m2 units and a mean decrease of 3.7 ± 3.6 scores were observed during treatment in BMI and Epworth sleepiness scale (ESS) score, respectively. The median use of CPAP did not differ between CPAP-treated patients with or without MVA (median 6.4, IQR 2.2 vs. 6.4, IQR 2.3 h/day, p = 0.8).

Table 2 Comparison of the characteristics between the CPAP-treated and control patients with motor vehicle accident, and between the patients with and without motor vehicle accident
Table 3 Comparison of the characteristics of motor vehicle accidents between the CPAP-treated and control patients

Discussion

In this large long-term observational study, MVA incidence did not change when compared before and after CPAP, compliant and non-compliant CPAP users, or CPAP-treated and untreated patients. Similarly, in a previous observational study by Català et al., MVAs did not differ between 1 year before and after treatment in patients with CPAP use of ≥ 4 h/day or less [8]. However, the result of the present study differed from most previous studies and was to some extent unexpected. Despite good CPAP compliance, the sleep duration of the CPAP-treated patients may have been insufficient, thus predisposing to MVAs. MVA data was based on a national registry in which small, near miss accidents or close shaves on the road are not reported. In addition, we do not know the actual annual driving exposure in the cohort. In general, 93% of the Finnish population aged 50–54 years has a valid driver’s license [9,10,11]. CPAP-treated and control patients were matched for age and gender, which likely decreases differences in driving habits. Potential differences should not have an effect on before and after comparisons.

As a further limitation, data on changes in BMI and ESS score was not available for controls since they were followed through the MVA registry. Even though the controls were selected as carefully as possible, there may be some underlying patient characteristics including different phenotypes of OSA and personal types causing bias in the results, since patients compliant to CPAP may differ from those who refuse to continue CPAP. All the patients had been diagnosed and treated at one clinic using the same protocol and treatment guidelines. Similar to previous studies, patients with MVA were more frequently male [12], younger [5, 12], and had a higher prevalence of smokers [13] than those without MVA (Table 2). Smoking has been associated with an increased risk of MVAs possibly due to smoking-related diseases, distractibility, and smokers’ susceptibility to risky behavior [13]. We also showed that accident conditions, a possible confounding factor for MVAs, did not differ between the CPAP-treated patients and controls, which to our knowledge have not been assessed before.

Interestingly, time to the first MVA was almost three times longer among CPAP-treated than those among controls. In further analysis, the MVA incidence did not, however, significantly differ between the groups when the length of observation was reduced in both groups to 2, 3.5, or 5 years. Furthermore, daytime sleepiness tended to decrease in the majority of the patients who had MVA after CPAP. It has been actually suggested that cognitive impairment and daytime sleepiness may not be fully normalized by CPAP despite good treatment compliance [14]. However, current data on the association between long-term CPAP treatment and cognitive changes is scarce, and the possible effect of the residual cognitive impairment on the results of the present study remains as a speculation. Baseline BMI was also higher among the OSA patients who adapted to CPAP than those who did not, and tended to further increase during treatment among the patients with MVA. Adipocytes have shown to secrete cytokines, which may increase daytime sleepiness and thus predispose to MVAs [15].

Conclusion

Despite good CPAP compliance, the MVA incidence did not differ between before and after CPAP or between CPAP-treated and untreated OSA patients. Apart from BMI, differences in baseline characteristics, sleep study data, or accident conditions were not observed between the CPAP-treated and control patients with MVA. The results remain to be confirmed in further studies with even longer follow-ups, objective data on MVAs, patients compliant to CPAP, and data on both actual annual driving exposure and changes in BMI and cognition.

References

  1. 1.

    Sanna A (2013) Obstructive sleep apnoea, motor vehicle accidents, and work performance. Chron Respir Dis 10:29–33

  2. 2.

    Tregear S, Reston J, Schoelles K, Phillips B (2009) Obstructive sleep apnea and risk of motor vehicle crash: systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Sleep Med 5:573–581 Review

  3. 3.

    Tregear S, Reston J, Schoelles K, Phillips B (2010) Continuous positive airway pressure reduces risk of motor vehicle crash among drivers with obstructive sleep apnea: systematic review and meta-analysis. Sleep. 33:1373–1380 Review

  4. 4.

    Findley L, Smith C, Hooper J, Dineen M, Suratt PM (2000) Treatment with nasal CPAP decreases automobile accidents in patients with sleep apnea. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 161:857–859

  5. 5.

    Karimi M, Hedner J, Häbel H, Nerman O, Grote L (2015) Sleep apnea-related risk of motor vehicle accidents is reduced by continuous positive airway pressure: Swedish Traffic Accident Registry data. Sleep. 38:341–349

  6. 6.

    McMillan A, Bratton DJ, Faria R, Laskawiec-Szkonter M, Griffin S, Davies RJ, Nunn AJ, Stradling JR, Riha RL, Morrell MJ, PREDICT Investigators (2014) Continuous positive airway pressure in older people with obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome (PREDICT): a 12-month, multicentre, randomised trial. Lancet Respir Med 2:804–812

  7. 7.

    Myllylä M, Hammais A, Stepanov M, Anttalainen U, Saaresranta T, Laitinen T (2019) Nonfatal and fatal cardiovascular disease events in CPAP compliant obstructive sleep apnea patients. Sleep Breath 23:1209–1217

  8. 8.

    Català R, Villoro R, Merino M, Sangenís S, Colomés L, Hernández Flix S, Pérez de Llano LA (2016) Cost-effectiveness of continuous positive airway pressure treatment in moderate-severe obstructive sleep apnea syndrome. Arch Bronconeumol 52:461–469

  9. 9.

    Suomen virallinen tilasto (SVT): Väestörakenne (verkkojulkaisu). ISSN=1797–5379. Vuosikatsaus 2016, Liitetaulukko 4. Naiset iän, lasten määrän ja synnyttäneiden osuuden mukaan 31.12.2016. Helsinki: Tilastokeskus. [Official Statistics of Finland (OSF): Population structure (e-publication). ISSN=1797–5379. Annual review 2016, Appendix table 4. Women by age, number of children and the proportion of birth 31st of December 2016. Helsinki: Statistics Finland]. Last accessed Oct 20, 2019. Access method: http://www.stat.fi/til/vaerak/2016/01/vaerak_2016_01_2017-09-22_tau_004_en.html

  10. 10.

    Suomen virallinen tilasto (SVT): Väestörakenne (verkkojulkaisu). ISSN=1797–5379. Vuosikatsaus 2016, Liitetaulukko 5. Miehet iän, lasten määrän ja isien osuuden mukaan 31.12.2016. Helsinki: Tilastokeskus. [Official Statistics of Finland (OSF): Population structure (e-publication). ISSN=1797–5379. Annual review 2016, Appendix table 5. Males by age and number of children 31st of December 2016. Helsinki: Statistics Finland]. Last accessed Oct 20, 2019. Access method: http://www.stat.fi/til/vaerak/2016/01/vaerak_2016_01_2017-09-22_tau_005_en.html

  11. 11.

    Traficom. Voimassa olevien ajokorttien tilasto. [Traficom. Statistics of valid driving licenses]. Last accessed Oct 20, 2019. Access method: https://www.traficom.fi/fi/tilastot/voimassa-olevien-ajokorttien-tilasto

  12. 12.

    Phillips RO, Sagberg F (2013) Road accidents caused by sleepy drivers: update of a Norwegian survey. Accid Anal Prev 50:138–146

  13. 13.

    Sacks JJ, Nelson DE (1994) Smoking and injuries: an overview. Prev Med 23:515–520

  14. 14.

    Antic NA, Catcheside P, Buchan C, Hensley M, Naughton MT, Rowland S, Williamson B, Windler S, McEvoy RD (2011) The effect of CPAP in normalizing daytime sleepiness, quality of life, and neurocognitive function in patients with moderate to severe OSA. Sleep. 34:111–119

  15. 15.

    Vgontzas AN, Bixler EO, Chrousos GP (2006) Obesity-related sleepiness and fatigue: the role of the stress system and cytokines. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1083:329–344

Download references

Acknowledgments

The authors thank and acknowledge the following individuals: RN Heli Rajalin and NP Sirkka Hakko for their excellent assistance in the identification of the patients who have commenced CPAP treatment at our clinic, and data scientist Samu Kurki for his valuable input in data collection. The authors gratefully acknowledge the statistical advice and assistance of the data management specialist Anna Hammais, and statisticians Mikhail Stepanov and Tero Vahlberg.

Funding

Open access funding provided by University of Turku (UTU) including Turku University Central Hospital. The study was funded by grants of the Clinical Research Fund of the Turku University Hospital, Finnish Anti-Tuberculosis Foundation, Research Foundation of the Pulmonary Diseases, Tampere Tuberculosis Foundation, Emil Aaltonen Foundation, Turku University Foundation, and Valto Takala Foundation managed by the University Society of Turku.

Author information

Correspondence to Minna Myllylä.

Ethics declarations

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Ethical approval

This article does not contain any studies with human participants performed by any of the authors due to the retrospective study design. This registry-based study design was approved by the Office of the Data Protection Ombudsman, Finland. The data gathering and analysis were performed with the permission of the Turku University Hospital.

Additional information

Publisher’s note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Myllylä, M., Anttalainen, U., Saaresranta, T. et al. Motor vehicle accidents in CPAP-compliant obstructive sleep apnea patients—a long-term observational study. Sleep Breath (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11325-020-02023-2

Download citation

Keywords

  • Obstructive sleep apnea
  • Continuous positive airway pressure
  • Motor vehicle accident
  • Real-world study