Atlantic Economic Journal

, Volume 46, Issue 1, pp 101–119 | Cite as

Electricity in Quebec before Nationalization, 1919 to 1939

Article

Abstract

History books tend to depict the early days of the electrical industry as one of monopoly where consumers were being gouged. The province of Quebec in Canada was no exception. With the use of wide-ranging data over time, we observe a different portrait: electrical firms in Quebec increased production faster than elsewhere while prices fell consistently. The main reason for this divergence between facts and history books is most likely the choice of comparing Quebec’s private industry with Ontario’s nationalized industry, which priced electricity at the average cost.

Keywords

Electricity Canadian economic history Monopoly 

JEL

D40 L10 N72 

Notes

Acknowledgements

Acknowledgements go to Alexandra Foucher, Mike Guetta, Robert Rogers and Art Carden, Jean-Thomas Bernard, Herbert Emery, Edward Stringham, Pierre Desrochers, Michael Giberson, Gérard Bélanger and the participants of the research seminar at Texas Tech University.

References

  1. Armentano, D. (1996). Antitrust and monopoly: Anatomy of a policy failure. Oakland: Independent Institute.Google Scholar
  2. Bellavance, C. (1998). L’État, la ‘houille blanche’ et le grand capital: L’aliénation des ressources hydrauliques du domaine public québécois au début du XXe siècle. Revue d’histoire de l’Amérique française, 51(4), 487–520.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bellavance, C., Levasseur, R., & Rousseau, Y. (1999). De la lutte antimonopoliste à la promotion de la grande entreprise. L’essor de deux institutions: Hydro-Québec et Desjardins, 1920–1965. Recherches sociographiques, 40(3), 551–578.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Biss, I. (1936). The contracts of the hydro-electric power commission of Ontario. Economic Journal, 46(183), 549–554.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bliss, M. (1987). Northern Enterprise: Five centuries of Canadian business. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.Google Scholar
  6. Boutet, D. (1999). Le mouvement d’opposition au monopole de l’électricité à Québec dans l’entre-deux-guerres. MA thesis: Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières. Available online at http://depot-e.uqtr.ca/3358/1/000658919.pdf.
  7. Bradley Jr., R. (1996). The origins of political electricity: Market failure or political opportunism? Energy Law Journal, 17(1), 59–102.Google Scholar
  8. Brown, M., and Macdonald, R. (2015). Provincial convergence and divergence in Canada, 1926 to 2011. Ottawa: Statistics Canada. Available online at http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/11f0027m/11f0027m2015096-eng.htm.
  9. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (1939). Changes in retail prices of electricity, 1923–1938. United States Department of Labor. Available online at https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/title/4172.
  10. Clark, G. (2017). What were the British earnings and prices then. Measuring Worth, Available online at http://www.measuringworth.com/ukearncpi/.
  11. Coursey, D., Isaac, M., & Smith, V. (1984). Natural monopoly and contested markets: some experimental results. Journal of Law & Economics, 27(1), 91–113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Dales, J. H. (1953). Fuel, power and industrial development in central Canada. American Economic Review, 43(2), 181–198.Google Scholar
  13. Dales, J. H. (1957). Hydroelectricity and industrial development: Quebec, 1898–1940. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Demsetz, H. (1968). Why regulate utilities? Journal of Law & Economics, 11(1), 55–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Department of the Interior. (1923). Central electric stations in Canada, Part II: Directory, Nov. 1, 1922. Ottawa: Department of the Interior, Government of Canada.Google Scholar
  16. Dominion Bureau of Statistics. (Editions from 1919 to 1940). Census of industry: Central electric stations in Canada. Ottawa: Department of Trade and Commerce.Google Scholar
  17. Dominion Bureau of Statistics. (1927). Index numbers of rates for electricity for residence lighting and tables of monthly bills, 1913, 1924, 1925, 1926. Ottawa: Government of Canada.Google Scholar
  18. Dominion Bureau of Statistics. (1938). Domestic rates for manufactured & natural fuel gas, 1913–1937. Ottawa: Government of Canada.Google Scholar
  19. Dominion Bureau of Statistics. (1940). Index numbers of cost of electricity for domestic service, commercial light and small power. Ottawa: Government of Canada.Google Scholar
  20. Dominion Bureau of Statistics. (1941). Family income and expenditure in Canada, 1937–1938: A study of urban wage-earner families, including data on physical attributes. Ottawa: Government of Canada. Available online at http://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2017/statcan/CS62-D-66-1941-eng.pdf.
  21. Dorion, M. (2000). L’électrification du monde rural québécois. Revue d’histoire de l’Amérique française, 54(1), 3–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Dupré, R., & Patry, M. (1998). Hydroelectricity and the state in Quebec and Ontario: Two different historical paths. In G. Zaccour (Ed.), Deregulation of electric utilities (pp. 119–147). Boston: Kluwer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dupré, R., Patry, M., & Joly, P. (1996). The politics and regulation of hydroelectricity: The case of Quebec in the thirties. Montreal: CIRANO.Google Scholar
  24. Emery, H., & Levitt, C. (2002). Cost of living, real wages and real incomes in thirteen Canadian cities, 1900–1950. Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d’Économique, 35(1), 115–137.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Emmons, W. (1991). Private and public responses to market failure in the US electric power industry, 1882–1942. Journal of Economic History, 51(2), 452–454.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Emmons, W. (1993). Franklin D. Roosevelt, electric utilities, and the power of competition. Journal of Economic History, 53(4), 880–907.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Emmons, W. (1997). Implications of ownership, regulation, and market structure for performance: evidence from the US electric utility industry before and after the new deal. Review of Economics and Statistics, 79(2), 279–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Evenden, M. (2009). Mobilizing rivers: Hydro-electricity, the state, and world war II in Canada. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 99(5), 845–855.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Faucher, A. (1992). La question de l’électricité au Québec durant les années trente. L’Actualité Économique, 68(3), 415–432.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Fleming, K. (1983). The uniform rate and rural electrification issues in Ontario politics, 1919–1923. Canadian Historical Review, 64(4), 494–518.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Fleming, K. (1992). Power at cost: Ontario hydro and rural electrification, 1911–1958. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
  32. Fleury, J.-L. (2004). Les porteurs de lumières: l’histoire de la distribution de l’électricité au Québec. Montréal: Éditions Multimondes.Google Scholar
  33. Fouquet, R. (2008). Heat, power and light: Revolutions in energy services. London: Edward Elgar Publishing.Google Scholar
  34. Gelly, A. (2003). A precipitous decline, steam as motive power in Montreal: a case study of the Lachine Canal industries. IA: The Journal of the Society for Industrial Archeology, 29(1), 65–85.Google Scholar
  35. Gelly, A. (2010). Vapeur, thermoélectricité et hydroélectricité comme force mortice le long du corridor industriel du canal de Lachine, des années 1850 à la Seconde Guerre Mondiale. PhD thesis, Department of History, Laval University. Available online at http://theses.ulaval.ca/archimede/fichiers/27029/27029.pdf.
  36. Geloso, V. (2017). Rethinking Canadian economic growth and development since 1900. London: Palgrave MacMillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Hannah, L. (1979). Electricity before nationalisation: A study of the development of the electrical supply industry in Britain to 1948. London: McMillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hillman, A. (2015). Rent-seeking as political economy. In A. Hillman & R. Congleton (Eds.), Companion to the political economy of rent-seeking (pp. 10–18). London: Edward Elgar Publishing.Google Scholar
  39. Hogue, C., Bolduc, A., & Larouche, D. (1979). Québec: un siècle d’électricité. Montréal: Libre Expression.Google Scholar
  40. Kitchens, C., & Jaworski, T. (2017). Ownership and the price of residential electricity: evidence from the United States, 1935–1940. Explorations in Economic History, 64, 53–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Krueger, A. (1974). The political economy of the rent-seeking society. American Economic Review, 64(3), 291–303.Google Scholar
  42. Liebowitz, S. (1999). Winners, losers and Microsoft. Oakland: Independent Institute.Google Scholar
  43. MacFayden, J. (2016). Hewers of wood: A history of wood energy in Canada. In R. W. Sandwell (Ed.), Powering up Canada: The history of power, fuel, and energy from 1600 (pp. 129–161). Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
  44. Marchand, S. (1988). L'impact des innovations technologiques sur la vie quotidienne des Québécoises du début du XXe siècle (1910-1940). Material Culture Review/Revue de la culture matérielle, 28(Fall), 1–14.Google Scholar
  45. McKenzie, R., & Lee, D. (2008). In defense of monopoly: How market power fosters creative production. Ann Harbor: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Ministère de l’Industrie et du Commerce. (From 1918–1944). Quebec Statistical Year Book. Québec: Ministère de l’Industrie et du Commerce.Google Scholar
  47. Montreal Light, Heat and Power (MHLP). (1934). Diminution et révision des tarifs d’électricité: annonce de la quinzième diminution. L’Ordre, September, 7, 3.Google Scholar
  48. Murray, W. S., & Flood, H. (1922). Government owned and controlled compared with privately owned and regulated electric utilities in Canada and the United States. New York: National Electric Light Association.Google Scholar
  49. Nelles, H. V. (1974 [2005]). The Politics of Development: Forests, Mines, and Hydro-Electric Power in Ontario, 1849–1941. Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
  50. Neufeld, J. (1987). Price discrimination and the adoption of the electricity demand charge. Journal of Economic History, 47(3), 693–709.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Officer, L. (2017). Exchange rates between the United States dollar and forty-one currencies. Measuring Worth, Available online at http://www.measuringworth.com/exchangeglobal/.
  52. Officer, L., and Williamson, S.H. (2017). The annual consumer price index for the United States, 1774–2015. Measuring Worth, Available online at http://www.measuringworth.com/uscpi/.
  53. Peltzman, S. (1971). Pricing in public and private enterprises: Electric utilities in the United States. Journal of Law & Economics, 14(1), 109–147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Peltzman, S. (1976). Toward a more general theory of regulation. Journal of Law & Economics, 19(2), 211–240.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Piché, P.-É. (1937). Régimes et tarifs d’électricité. Actualité Économique, 13(2), 17–30.Google Scholar
  56. Rassenti, S., Smith, V., & Wilson, V. (2001). Using experiments to inform the privatization/deregulation movement in electricity. Cato Journal, 21(3), 515–544.Google Scholar
  57. Smith, V. (1988). Electric power deregulation: background and prospects. Contemporary Economic Policy, 6(3), 14–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Statistics Canada. (2015). Table 384–5000: Data on long-run provincial and territorial economic performance, annual. Ottawa: Statistics Canada. Available online at http://www5.statcan.gc.ca/cansim/a26?lang=eng&id=3845000.
  59. Stigler, G., & Friedland, C. (1962). What can regulators regulate? The case of electricity. Journal of Law & Economics, 5, 1–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Troesken, W. (1996). Why regulate utilities? The new institutional economics and the Chicago gas industry, 1849–1924. Ann Harbor: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Troesken, W. (2006). Regime change and corruption: A history of public utility regulation. In E. Glaeser & C. Goldin (Eds.), Corruption and reform: Lessons from America’s economic history. Cambridge: National Bureau of Economic Research and University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  62. Tullock, G. (1967). The welfare costs of tariffs, monopolies, and theft. Economic Inquiry, 5(3), 224–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Wright, G. (2006). Electrical energy—retail prices, residential use, and service coverage: 1902–2000. Table Db 234–241. In S. B. Carter, S. S. Gartner, M. R. Haines, A. L. Olmstead, R. Sutch, & G. Wright (Eds.), Historical Statistics of the United States, Earliest Times to the Present: Millennial Edition. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© International Atlantic Economic Society 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Texas Tech UniversityLubbockUSA
  2. 2.HEC MontréalMontréalCanada

Personalised recommendations