The effects of body-worn cameras on police-citizen encounters and police activity: evaluation of a pilot implementation in Philadelphia, PA
Examine changes in officer behavior, when wearing body-worn cameras, as revealed by pedestrian stops, vehicle stops, arrests, use of force, and citizen complaints during a pilot implementation in a racially diverse jurisdiction in the Northeast region of the USA.
A quasi-experimental approach was used to examine the initial implementation of body-worn cameras (BWCs) in one district. This provided the opportunity for a natural experiment comparing officers in the district that deployed cameras with officers in three similar districts where no BWCs were deployed. Propensity score matching (PSM) was used to match BWC officers with non-BWC officers.
BWC officers had about 38.3% fewer use of force incidents than non-BWC officers with similar numbers of use of force incidents in the previous year. On average, BWC officers made 46.4% fewer pedestrian stops and 39.2% fewer arrests than non-BWC officers. Vehicle stops and citizen complaints had nonsignificant declines for BWC officers.
The reductions in proactive policing by officers are consistent with a deterrence-based view that officers respond to the increased scrutiny by curtailing interactions with citizens, which in turn, limits the potential for conflict and for police supervisors to identify behavior worthy of disciplinary action. The lack of a significant reduction in citizen complaints supports the view that the effect of BWCs on negative officer behavior is contingent upon other factors in the settings in which cameras are deployed. Future research should examine the impacts of cameras on the narrowing of police discretion because of the important implications for police–community relations.
KeywordsPolice body-worn cameras Use of force Citizen complaints Arrests Pedestrian stops Vehicle stops
- Ariel, B. (2016). Police body cameras in large police departments. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 106(4), 729–768.Google Scholar
- Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., Drover, P., Sykes, J., Megicks, S., & Henderson, R. (2016a). Report: Increases in police use of force in the presence of body-worn cameras are driven by officer discretion: A protocol-based subgroup analysis of ten randomized experiments. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 12(3), 453–463.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., Drover, P., Sykes, J., Megicks, S., & Henderson, R. (2016b). Wearing body cameras increases assaults against officers and does not reduce police use of force: Results from a global multi-site experiment. European Journal of Criminology, 13(6), 744–755. https://doi.org/10.1177/1477370816643734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., Drover, P., Sykes, J., Megicks, S., & Henderson, R. (2017). “Contagious accountability” a global multisite randomized controlled trial on the effect of police body-worn cameras on citizens’ complaints against the police. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 44(2), 293–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Braga, A. A., Barao, L., McDevitt, J., & Zimmerman, G. (2018a). The impact of body-worn cameras on complaints against officers and officer use of force incident reports: Preliminary evaluation findings. Retrieved from Boston, MA: https://www.northeastern.edu/csshresearch/irj/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2018/01/Boston-Police-Body-Worn-Camera-Inititiave-Preliminary-Report.pdf.
- Braga, A. A., Coldren, J. R., Sousa, W. H., Rodriguez, D., & Alper, O. (2017). The benefits of body-worn cameras: New findings from a randomized controlled trial at the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
- Braga, A. A., Sousa, W. H., Coldren, J. R., Jr., & Rodriguez, D. (2018b). The effects of body-worn cameras on police activity and police-citizen encounters: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 108(3), 511.Google Scholar
- Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Elrbaum.Google Scholar
- Edmonton Police Service. (2015). Body Worn Video: Considering the Evidence (Final Report of the Edmonton Police Service Body Worn Video Pilot Project). Edmonton, AB, Canada: Edmonton Police Service.Google Scholar
- Ellis, T., Jenkins, C., & Smith, P. (2015). Evaluation of the introduction of personal issue body worn video cameras (Operation Hyperion) on the Isle of Wight: Final report to Hampshire Constabulary.Google Scholar
- Farrar, W., & Ariel, B. (2013). Self-awareness to being watched and socially-desirable behavior: A field experiment on the effect of body-worn cameras and police use-of-force. Washington, DC: Police Foundation.Google Scholar
- Goodall, M. (2007). Guidance for the police use of body-worn video devices. London: Home Office retrieved from library.college.police.uk/docs/homeoffice/guidance-body-worn-devices.pdf.Google Scholar
- Goodison, S., & Wilson, T. (2017). Citizen perceptions of body worn cameras: A randomized controlled trial. Retrieved from Washington, DC: perf.memberclicks.net/assets/bodyworncameraperceptions.pdf.
- Grossmith, L., Owens, C., Finn, W., Mann, D., Davies, T., & Baika, L. (2015). Police, camera, evidence: London’s cluster randomised controlled trial of body worn video. London, United Kingdom: College of Policing and the Mayor’s Office for Policing and Crime (MOPAC.Google Scholar
- Guo, S., & Fraser, M. (2015). Propensity score analysis: Statistical methods and applications (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc.Google Scholar
- Hansen, B. B., Fredrickson, M., Buckner, J., Errickson, J., Solenberger, P., Bertsekas, D. P., & Tseng, P. (2018). Optmatch: Functions for optimal matching v.9.9. Retrieved from: https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/optmatch.
- Headley, A. M., Guerette, R. T., & Shariati, A. (2017). A field experiment of the impact of body-worn cameras (BWCs) on police officer behavior and perceptions. Journal of Criminal Justice, 53, 102–109.Google Scholar
- Ho, D. E., Imai, K., King, G., & Stuart, E. (2006). MatchIt: Nonparametric preprocessing for parametric causal inference. Journal of Statistical Software, 42(8), 1–28.Google Scholar
- Hyland, S. S. (2018). Body-worn cameras in law enforcement agencies, 2016. Washington DC: U.S. Department of Justice.Google Scholar
- Jennings, W. G., Lynch, M. D., & Fridell, L. A. (2015). Evaluating the impact of police officer body-worn cameras (BWCs) on response-to-resistance and serious external complaints: Evidence from the Orlando police department (OPD) experience utilizing a randomized controlled experiment. Journal of Criminal Justice, 43(6), 480–486. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2015.10.003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Jennings, W. G., Fridell, L. A., Lynch, M., Jetelina, K. K., & Reingle Gonzalez, J. M. (2017). A quasi-experimental evaluation of the effects of police body-worn cameras (BWCs) on response-to-resistance in a large metropolitan police department. Deviant Behavior, 38(11), 1332–1339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Katz, C. M., Choate, D. E., Ready, J. R., Nuňo, L., Kurtenbach, C. M., & Kevin, S. (2014). Evaluating the impact of officer worn body cameras in the Phoenix Police Department.Google Scholar
- Koen, M. C. (2016). On-set with body-worn cameras in a police organization: Structures, practices, and technological frames. (Doctoral), George Mason University, Fairfax, VA. Retrieved from http://mars.gmu.edu/jspui/bitstream/handle/1920/10419/Koen_gmu_0883E_11230.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
- Lipsey, M. W., & Wilson, D. B. (2001). Practical meta-analysis. Thousands Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.Google Scholar
- Long, J. S., & Freese, J. (2014). Regression models for categorical dependent variables using Stata (Third ed.). College Station, TX: Stata Press.Google Scholar
- Lum, C., Koper, C., Merola, L., Sherer, A., & Reioux, A. (2015). Existing and ongoing body worn camera research: Knowledge gaps and opportunities. Report for the Laura and John Arnold Foundation. Retrieved from Fairfax, VA:Google Scholar
- Lum, C. M., & Koper, C. S. (2016). An evidence-assessment of the recommendations of the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing: Implementation and research priorities. Retrieved from George Mason University: http://cebcp.org/wp-content/evidence-based-policing/IACP-GMU-Evidence-Assessment-Task-Force-FINAL.pdf.
- Lum, C., Stoltz, M., Koper, C.S., & Scherer, J. (2019). The research on body-worn cameras: What we know, what we need to know. Criminology and Public Policy, 18(1).Google Scholar
- MacDonald, H. (2016). The Ferguson effect lives on: Violence in American cities rose again in 2016, as cops backed off proactive policing. City Journal. Retrieved from https://www.cityjournal.org/html/ferguson-effect-lives-14919.html.
- Maskaly, J., Donner, C., Jennings, W. G., Ariel, B., & Sutherland, A. (2017). The effects of body-worn cameras (BWCs) on police and citizen outcomes: A state-of-the-art review. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 40(4), 672–688.Google Scholar
- McClure, David, Nancy La Vigne, Mathew Lynch, Laura Golian, Daviel Lawrence, and Aili Malm. (2017). How Body Cameras Affect Community Members' Perceptions of Police: Results From a Randomized Controlled Trial of One Agency's Pilot. Washington, DC: Justice Policy Center, Urban Institute. Retrieved from http://urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/91331/2001307-how-body-cameras-affect-community-members-perceptions-of-police_1.pdf.
- McCluskey, J. D., Uchida, C. D., Solomon, S. E., Wooditch, A., Connor, C., & Revier, L. (2019). Assessing the effects of body-worn cameras on procedural justice in the Los Angeles Police Department. Criminology. Published on-line 1/24/2019. https://doi-org.libproxy.temple.edu/10.1111/1745-9125.12201.
- Mesa Police Department. (2013). On-officer body camera system: Program evaluation and recommendations. Mesa, Arizona: Mesa Police Department.Google Scholar
- Nowacki, J. S., & Willits, D. (2016). Adoption of body cameras by United States police agencies: An organisational analysis. Policing and Society, 1–13.Google Scholar
- Peterson, B. E., Yu, L., La Vigne, N. G., & Lawrence, D. S. (2018). The Milwaukee Police Department’s body-worn camera program: Evaluation findings and key takeaways. Retrieved from Washington DC: https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/98461/the_milwaukee_police_departments_body_worn_camera_program_2.pdf.
- Philadelphia Police Department. (2018). Body-worn cameras, Directive 4.21. Retrieved from: http://www.phillypolice.com/assets/directives/D4.21-BodyWornCameras.pdf.
- Phillips, S. W., Wheeler, A., & Kim, D. (2016). The effect of police paramilitary unit raids on crime at micro-places in Buffalo, New York. Police Science & Management, 18(3), 206–219.Google Scholar
- Ready, J. T., & Young, J. T. (2015). The impact of on-officer video cameras on police–citizen contacts: Findings from a controlled experiment in Mesa, AZ. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 1–14.Google Scholar
- Rosenbaum, P. R., & Rubin, D. B. (1985). Constructing a control group using multivariate matched sampling. The American Statistician, 39(1), 33–38.Google Scholar
- Shadish, W. R., Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T. (2002). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.Google Scholar
- Shjarback, J. A., Pyrooz, D. C., Wolfe, S. E., & Decker, S. H. (2017). De-policing and crime in the wake of Ferguson: Racialized changes in the quantity and quality of policing among Missouri police departments. Journal of Criminal Justice, 50, 42–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2017.04.003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- The President's Task Force on 21st Century Policing (“Task Force”). (2015). Final report of the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. Retrieved from Washington, DC: http://www.cops.usdoj.gov/pdf/taskforce/Implementation_Guide.pdf.
- Toronto Police Service. (2016). Body-worn cameras: A report on the findings of the pilot project to test the value and feasibility of body-worn cameras for police officers in Toronto. Retrieved from Toronto, ON: http://www.tpsb.ca/component/jdownloads/send/40-body-worn-cameras/534-toronto-police-service-bwc.
- Weisburd, D., Groff, E. R., Jones, G., Cave, B., Amendola, K., Yang, S.-M., & Emison, R. F. (2015). The Dallas patrol management experiment: Can AVL technologies be used to harness unallocated patrol time for crime prevention? Journal of Experimental Criminology, 1–25. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11292-015-9234-y.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- White, M. D. (2014). Police Officer Body-Worn Cameras: Assessing the Evidence. Retrieved from Washington, DC: https://www.ojpdiagnosticcenter.org/sites/default/files/spotlight/download/Police_Officer_Body-Worn_Cameras.pdf.
- Wood, J., Sorg, E., Groff, E., Ratcliffe, J., & Taylor, C. (2014). Cops as treatment providers: Realities and ironies of police work in a foot patrol experiment. Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy, 24(3), 362–379.Google Scholar
- Wooldridge, J. M. (2010). Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. Cambridge: MIT press.Google Scholar
- Yokum, D., Ravishankar, A., & Coppock, A. (2017). Evaluating the effects of police body-worn cameras: A randomized controlled trial. Retrieved from http://bwc.thelab.dc.gov/TheLabDC_MPD_BWC_Working_Paper_10.20.17.pdf.