Collectively ill: a preliminary case that groups can have psychiatric disorders
- 174 Downloads
In the 2000s, several psychiatrists cited the lack of relational disorders (what I call “collective disorders”—disorders of groups rather than individuals) in the DSM-IV as one of the two most glaring gaps in psychiatric nosology, and campaigned for their inclusion in the DSM-5. This campaign failed, however, presumably in part due to serious “ontological concerns” haunting such disorders. Here, I offer a path to quell such ontological concerns, adding to previous conceptual work by Jerome Wakefield and Christian Perring. Specifically, I adduce reasons to think that collective disorders are compatible with key metaphysical commitments of contemporary scientific psychiatry, and argue that if one accepts the existence of mental disorders in individuals as medical, then one has good reasons to accept the existence of collective disorders as medical. First, I outline how collective disorders are reconcilable with both the harmful dysfunction model of disorder and a denial of mind-body dualism. I then identify some potential weaknesses in the main pre-existing example of a collective disorder, offering my own examples as supplements. These examples’ medical plausibility is bolstered by: (1) work in philosophy of biology on the generalized selected effects theory of function (largely from Justin Garson), and (2) work in analytic philosophy of mind on collective mentality (largely from Bryce Huebner). Finally, after offering preliminary responses to the objection that the recognition of collective disorders may lead to an overpathologization of everyday life, I spell out ways in which this recognition may have empowering effects for some would-be patients; for example, by providing substance to the notion of a “sane response to an insane world.”
KeywordsCollective illness Relational disorder Biological function Mental illness Collective mind Group mind Sanism Neurodiversity Harmful dysfunction Extended mind
I sincerely thank Justin Garson, Bhob Rainey, Şerife Tekin, and two anonymous reviewers for their helpful feedback on earlier drafts of this manuscript.
- Armstrong, T. (2010). The power of neurodiversity: Unleashing the advantages of your differently wired brain. Cambridge, MA: Da Capo Press.Google Scholar
- Block, N. (1978). Troubles with functionalism. In C. W. Savage (Ed.), Minnesota studies in the philosophy of science (Vol. IX, pp. 261–325). Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
- Cooper, R. (2008). Psychiatry and philosophy of science. McGill: Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
- Dolnick, E. (1993). Deafness as culture. The Atlantic Monthly, 272(3), 37–53.Google Scholar
- Elliott, C. (1998). The tyranny of happiness: Ethics and cosmetic psychopharmacology. In E. Parens (Ed.), Enhancing human traits: Ethical and social implications (pp. 177–188). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
- Farber, S. (2012). The spiritual gift of madness: The failure of psychiatry and the rise of the mad pride movement. Rochester: Inner Traditions.Google Scholar
- First, M. B., Bell, C. C., Cuthbert, B., Krystal, J. H., Malison, R., Offord, D. R., et al. (2002). Personality disorders and relational disorders: A research agenda for addressing crucial gaps in DSM. In D. J. Kupfer, M. B. First, & D. A. Regier (Eds.), A research agenda for DSM-V (pp. 123–199). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.Google Scholar
- Garson, J. (2015). The biological mind. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Gilbert, M. (1989). On social facts. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Hoffman, G. A., & Zachar, P. (2017). RDoC’s metaphysical assumptions: Problems and promises. In Ş. Tekin & J. Poland (Eds.), Extraordinary science: Responding to the crisis in psychiatric research (pp. 59–86). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Horwitz, A. V., & Wakefield, J. C. (2007). The loss of sadness: How psychiatry transformed normal sorrow into depressive disorder. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Huebner, B. (2014). Macrocognition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Hutchins, E. (1995). Cognition in the wild. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Jamison, K. (1993). Touched with fire: Manic-depressive illness and the artistic temperament. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
- Jamison, K. (1995). An unquiet mind: A memoir of moods and madness. New York: Knopf Inc.Google Scholar
- Lewis, B. (2006b). A mad fight: Psychiatry and disability activism. In L. J. Davis (Ed.), The disability studies reader (pp. 115–131). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Menary, R. (Ed.). (2010). The extended mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- MindFreedom. Mad pride campaign. Resource document. http://www.mindfreedom.org/campaign/madpride. Accessed 20 Aug 2016.
- Moncrieff, J. (2016). Myth of the chemical cure. In W. Hall (Ed.), Outside mental health: Voices and visions of madness (pp. 155–162). Madness Radio.Google Scholar
- National Association of the Deaf. (2000). NAD position statement on cochlear implants. http://nad.org/issues/technology/assistive-listening/cochlear-implants. Accessed 20 Aug 2016.
- National Institute of Mental Health. Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) website. Resource document. http://www.nimh.nih.gov/research-priorities/rdoc/index.shtml. Accessed 19 Aug 2016.
- Perring, C. D. (2014). Are relationship problems disorders? In C. D. Perring & L. A. Wells (Eds.), Diagnostic dilemmas in child and adolescent psychiatry (pp. 98–108). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Pettit, P. (2003). Groups with minds of their own. In Fred Schmitt (Ed.), Socializing metaphysics (pp. 167–193). New York: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
- Theiner, G., & O’Connor, T. (2010). The emergence of group cognition. In A. Corradini & T. O’Connor (Eds.), Emergence in science and philosophy (pp. 78–117). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Vedantam, S. (2002). Doctors consider diagnosis for “ill” relationships. The Washington Post. Available from http://www.washingtonpost.com/. Accessed 8 Aug 2016.
- Walters, S. (2011). Autistic ethos at work: Writing on the spectrum in contexts of professional and technical communication. Disability Studies Quarterly, 31(3). doi: 10.18061/dsq.v31i3.1680.
- Wolframe, P. (2013). The madwoman in the academy, or, revealing the invisible straightjacket: Theorizing and teaching saneism and sane privilege. Disability Studies Quarterly, 33(1). doi: 10.18061/dsq.v33i1.3425.