Advertisement

Measuring Personal Economic Hardship and Its Impact on Political Trust During the Great Recession

  • Raül TormosEmail author
Article

Abstract

The great recession has severely harmed the living conditions of many citizens in South European democracies. This article explores to what extent the deterioration of personal circumstances due to the economic crisis is related to the erosion of political trust. Previous accounts have provided scarce evidence of this sort of egotropic effects. Instead, they have underlined the role of sociotropic evaluations of the economic and political performance of institutions. However, these factors could be suspicious of endogeneity and third-variable bias. This article uses a survey fielded in the Spanish region of Catalonia that contains a novel battery of items to measure how the crisis has personally affected respondents. Latent class analysis is applied to that battery and propensity score matching is employed to estimate the causal effect of being personally affected by the crisis vis-à-vis not being affected. Results indicate that personal hardship reduces trust in institutions in turbulent economic times. Furthermore, the study of the Catalan circumstances sheds light on how attribution of blame works in a multilevel structure of governance during times of crisis. Personal economic hardship happens to decrease trust on national institutions and the EU but not on regional institutions, controlling for the ethno-national composition of the population of that region.

Keywords

Political trust Economic crisis Egotropic economic considerations South of Europe Propensity score matching Latent class analysis Catalonia 

Notes

Supplementary material

11205_2019_2082_MOESM1_ESM.docx (83 kb)
Supplementary material 1 (DOCX 83 kb)

References

  1. Alós, R., & Lope, A. (2015). El desempleo y sus consecuencias: Vulnerabilidad y riesgo de exclusión social. In C. Torres (Ed.), España 2015. Situación social (pp. 651–662). Madrid: CIS.Google Scholar
  2. Álvarez, M., Nagler, J., & Willette, J. (2000). Measuring the relative impact of issues and the economy in democratic elections. Electoral Studies, 19, 237–257.Google Scholar
  3. Anderson, C., & Guillory, C. (1997). Political institutions and satisfaction with democracy: A cross-national analysis of consensus and majoritarian systems. American Political Science Review, 91, 66–88.Google Scholar
  4. Angrist, J., & Pischke, J.-S. (2009). Mostly harmless econometrics: An empiricist’s companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Aragón, J., Cruces, J., de la Fuentes, L., Martínez, A., & Otaegui, A. (2012). Trabajadores y empobrecimiento en España. Madrid: Fundación 1º de Mayo.Google Scholar
  6. Armingeon, K., & Guthmann, K. (2014). Democracy in crisis? The declining support for national democracy in European countries, 2007–2011. European Journal of Political Research, 53, 423–442.Google Scholar
  7. Ayala, L. (2016) La Desigualdad en España: Fuentes, Tendencias y Comparaciones Internacionales, FEDEA Working Papers 2016-24, Madrid: Fundación de Estudios de Economía Aplicada.Google Scholar
  8. Bianco, W. (1994). Trust. Representatives and constituents. Ann Arbor, MI: Michingan University Press.Google Scholar
  9. Braithwaite, V., & Levi, M. (Eds.). (2003). Trust and governance. New York, NY: The Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
  10. Brooks, C., & Manza, J. (2007). Why welfare states persist: The importance of public opinion in democracies. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.Google Scholar
  11. Caliendo, M., & Kopeing, S. (2005) Some practical guidance for the implementation of propensity score matching. IZA Discussion Paper 1588, Bonn: IZA Institute of Labor Economics.Google Scholar
  12. CEO (Centre d’Estudis d’Opinio). (2015). Surveys no. REO 518 (2009), 758 (2014), and 798.Google Scholar
  13. Clarke, H. D., & Kornberg, A. (1989). Public reactions to economic performance and political support in contemporary liberal democracies. In H. D. Clarke, M. C. Stewart & G. Zuk (Eds.), Economic decline and political change; Canada, Great Britain, the United States. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh. Press.Google Scholar
  14. Clarke, H., Dutt, N., & Kornberg, A. (1993). The political economy of attitudes toward polity and society in Western democracies. Journal of Politics, 55, 551–562.Google Scholar
  15. Colomer, Josep M. (2017). The venturous bid for the independence of catalonia. Nationalist Papers, 45, 950–967.Google Scholar
  16. Coromina, L., & Bartolomé, E. (2016). Trust in political institutions. Stability of measurement model in Europe. In M. Voicu, I. Mochmann, & H. Dülmer (Eds.), Values, economic crisis and democracy (pp. 50–69). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  17. Dahl, R. (1971). Polyarchy: Participation and opposition. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  18. Dalton, R. (2004). Democratic challenges, democratic choices. The erosion of political support in advanced industrial democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  19. De Castro, C., & Pedreño, A. (2015). Trabajo y ocupaciones. In C. Torres (Ed.), España 2015. Situación social (pp. 617–628). Madrid: CIS.Google Scholar
  20. Denters, B., Gabriel, O., & Torcal, M. (2007). Political confidence in representatives democracies: Socio-cultural vs. political explanations. In J. van Deth, J. Montero, & A. Westholm (Eds.), Citizenship and involvement in European democracies (pp. 66–87). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  21. Duran, J., & Isusi, Í. (2010) Working poor in Europe—Spain. In EurWORK. Accessed at: http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/ewco/studies(tn0910026s/es0910029q.htm. February 20, 2017.
  22. EAPN. (2015). El estado de la pobreza. 5º Informe. Seguimiento del indicador de riesgo de pobreza y exclusion social en España 20092014. Accessed at: http://www.eapn.es/ARCHIVO/documentos/recursos/1/1444833751_20151015_el_estado_de_la_pobreza_seguimiento_del_arope_2014_pdf.pdf. March 2, 2017.
  23. ECAS. (2014). Informe INSOCAT per al a millora de l’acció social. Indicadors socials a Catalunya en relació al context estatal i europeu. Escenari postcrisi: Treballadors pobres, desigualtats profundes. Report number 4. Accessed at: https://acciosocial.org//wp-content/uploads/2015/12/INSOCAT_num4_juliol2014_informeECAS_vreduida1.pdf.
  24. ECAS. (2015). Informe INSOCAT per al a millora de l’acció social. Indicadors socials a Catalunya en relació al context estatal i europeu. Polarització social i pobresa més severa. Report number 6. Accessed at: https://acciosocial.org//wp-content/uploads/2015/12/INSOCAT-6_Polaritzacio-i-pobresa-severa_ECAS.pdf.
  25. Echaves, A., & Echaves, C. (2017). Jóvenes aún más precarios: Crisis económica y desigualdad laboral en España. Cuadernos de Investigación en Juventud, 2, e007.  https://doi.org/10.22400/cij.2.e007.Google Scholar
  26. Ellinas, A., & Lamprianou, I. (2014). Political trust in extremis. Comparative Politics, 46, 231–250.Google Scholar
  27. Eurostat EU-SILC. Statistics on Income and Living Conditions.Google Scholar
  28. Faulkner, N., Martin, A., & Peyton, K. (2015). Priming political trust: Evidence from an experiment. Australian Journal of Political Science, 50, 164–173.Google Scholar
  29. Fernández-Albertos, J. (2015). Nuevos partidos, ¿nuevos ejes de competición política?. Piedras de Papel. Accessed at: https://www.eldiario.es/piedrasdepapel/Nuevos-partidos-nuevos-competicion-politica_6_629997015.html.
  30. Fisher, J., Heerde, J. V., & Tucker, A. (2010). Does one trust judgement fit all? Linking theory and empirics. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 12, 161–188.Google Scholar
  31. Flesher, C. (2015). Redefining the crisis/redefining democracy: Mobilizing for the right to housing in Spain’s PAH Movement. South European Society & Politics, 20, 465–485.Google Scholar
  32. Gallie, D. (1994). Are the unemployed an underclass? Some evidence from the social change and economic life initiative. Sociology, 28, 737–757.Google Scholar
  33. Goerlich, F. (2016). Distribución de la renta, crisis económica y política redistributivas. Bilbao: Fundación BBVA.Google Scholar
  34. Hacker, J. (2008). The great risk shift: The new economic insecurity and the decline of the American dream. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  35. Hacker, J., Rehm, P., & Schlesinger, M. (2013). The insecure American: Economic experiences, financial worries, and policy attitude. Perspectives on Politics, 11, 23–49.Google Scholar
  36. Hernández, E., & Kriesi, H. (2016). The electoral consequences of the financial and economic crisis in Europe. European Journal of Political Research, 55, 203–224.Google Scholar
  37. Hetherington, M. (1998). The political relevance of political trust. American Political Science Review, 92, 791–808.Google Scholar
  38. Hierro, M. J. (2013). Changes in national identification. The Case of Catalonia. Madrid: Institutio Juan March de Estudios e Investigaciones, Centro de Estudios Avanzados en Ciencias Sociales.Google Scholar
  39. Hooghe, L., & Marks, G. (2005). Calculation, community and cues: Public opinion on European integration. European Union Politics, 6, 419–443.Google Scholar
  40. Hutter, S., Kriesi, H., & Vidal, G. (2018). Old versus new politics: The political spaces in southern Europe in times of crises. Party Politics, 24, 10–22.Google Scholar
  41. Incantalupo, M. (2011) The effects of unemployment on voter turnout in U.S. National elections. Accessed at: http://scholar.princeton.edu/mincanta/pages/research. November 15, 2016.
  42. Kaase, M. (1999). Interpersonal trust, political trust and non-institutionalised political participation in Western Europe. West European Politics, 22, 1–21.Google Scholar
  43. Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (1979). Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica, 47, 263–291.Google Scholar
  44. Khandker, S., Gayatri, K., & Samad, H. (2010). Handbook of impact evaluation. Quantitative methods and practices. Washington: The World Bank.Google Scholar
  45. Kinder, D., & Kiewiet, R. (1979). Economic discontent and political behavior: The role of personal grievances and collective economic judgements in congressional voting. American Journal of Political Science, 23, 495–527.Google Scholar
  46. Kumlin, S. (2011). Dissatisfied democrats, policy feedback, and European Welfare states, 1976–2001. In M. Hooghe & S. Zmerli (Eds.), Political Trust, Why Context Matters (pp. 163–185). Colchester: ECPR Press.Google Scholar
  47. Levi, M., & Stoker, L. (2000). Political trust and trustworthiness. Annual Review of Political Science, 3, 475–507.Google Scholar
  48. Lockerbie, B. (1993). Economic dissatisfaction and political alienation in Western Europe. European Journal of Political Research, 23, 281–293.Google Scholar
  49. Luisiani, N. (2014). Rationalising the right to health: Is Spain’s austere response to the economic crisis impermissible under international human rights law? In A. Nolan (Ed.), Economic and social rights after the global financial crisis (pp. 202–233). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  50. Marien, S. (2011). Measuring political trust across time and space. In M. Hooghe & S. Zmerli (Eds.), Political trust. Why context matters (pp. 13–46). Colchester: ECPR Press.Google Scholar
  51. Marien, S., & Hooghe, M. (2011). Does political trust matter? An empirical investigation into the relation between political trust and support for law compliance. European Journal of Political Research, 50, 267–291.Google Scholar
  52. Martín, A., & Pérez, F. (2015). Cambios de las relaciones laborales. In C. Torres (Ed.), España 2015. Situación social (pp. 684–701). Madrid: CIS.Google Scholar
  53. Martínez-Celorrio, X., & Marín, A. (2016). Crisi, descens social i xarxes de confiança. Anàlisi longitudinal del PaD (2008–2012). Barcelona: Document de treball. Fundació Jaume Bofill.Google Scholar
  54. McAllister, I. (1999). The economic performance of governments. In P. Norris (Ed.), Critical citizens: Global support for democratic governance (pp. 188–203). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  55. Miguélez, F., & Molina, Ó. (2015). Políticas de empleo. In C. Torres (Ed.), España 2015. Situación social (pp. 672–683). Madrid: CIS.Google Scholar
  56. Miller, A., & Listhaug, O. (1990). Political parties and confidence in government: A comparison of Norway, Sweden and the United States. British Journal of Political Science, 29, 357–386.Google Scholar
  57. Miller, A., & Listhaug, O. (1999). Political performance and political trust. In P. Norris (Ed.), Critical citizens: Global support for democratic government (pp. 204–216). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  58. Mishler, W., & Rose, R. (2001). What are the origins of political trust? testing institutional and cultural theories in post-communist societies. Comparative Political Studies, 34, 30–62.Google Scholar
  59. Mughan, A., & Lacy, D. (2002). Economic performance, job insecurity and electoral choice. British Journal of Political Science, 32, 513–533.Google Scholar
  60. Muñoz, J., & Tormos, R. (2015). Economic expectations and support for secession in catalonia: Between causality and rationalization. European Political Science Review, 7(2), 315–341.Google Scholar
  61. Muro, D., & Vidal, G. (2016). Political mistrust in southern Europe since the great recession. Mediterranean Politics, 22, 197–217.Google Scholar
  62. Nannestad, P., & Paldam, M. (1994). The VP-function: A survey of the literature on vote and popularity functions after 25 years. Public Choice, 79, 213–245.Google Scholar
  63. Newton, K. (2001). Trust, social capital, civil society, and democracy. International Political Science Review, 22, 201–214.Google Scholar
  64. Pérez-Nievas, S., & Fraile, M. (2000) Is the nationalist vote really nationalist? Dual Voting in Catalonia, 1980–1999. Madrid, Estudio/Working Paper no. 2000/147, Juan March Institute.Google Scholar
  65. Polavieja, J. (2013). Economic crisis, political legitimacy, and social cohesion. In D. Gallie (Ed.), Economic crisis, quality of work, and social integration (pp. 256–278). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  66. Prieto, C., & Pérez, S. (2015). La precarización del empleo en el marco de la norma flexible-empresarial del empleo. In C. Torres (Ed.), España 2015. Situación social (pp. 629–639). Madrid: CIS.Google Scholar
  67. Rico, G., Guinjoan, M., & Anduiza, E. (2017). The emotional underpinnings of populism: How anger and fear affect populist attitudes. Swiss Political Science Review, 23(4), 444–461.Google Scholar
  68. Rosenbaum, P., & Rubin, D. (1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika, 70, 41–55.Google Scholar
  69. Rosenstone, S., Hansen, J., & Kinder, D. (1986). Measuring change in personal well-being. Public Opinion Quarterly, 50, 176–192.Google Scholar
  70. Roth, F., Nowak-Lehmann, F., & Otter, T. (2013). Has the financial crisis shattered citizens’ trust in national and European governmental institutions? Evidence from the EU member states, 1999–2010. CEPS Working Document 343, Brussels: CEPS.Google Scholar
  71. Rudolph, T., & Evans, J. (2005). Political trust, ideology, and public support for government spending. American Journal of Political Science, 49, 660–671.Google Scholar
  72. Schyns, P., & Koop, C. (2010). Political distrust and social capital in Europe and the USA. Social Indicators Research, 96, 145–167.Google Scholar
  73. Torcal, M. (2014). The decline of political trust in Spain and Portugal: Economic performance or political responsiveness? American Behavioral Scientist, 58, 1542–1567.Google Scholar
  74. Torcal, M. (2016). Political trust in Western and Southern Europe. In S. Zmerli & T. van der Meer (Eds.), Handbook of political trust (pp. 418–439). Chetelham: Edward Elgar Publishing.Google Scholar
  75. United Nations (2012) El Derecho a una vivienda digna. Informe Relatora Especial A/67/286. Accessed at: http://afectadosporlahipoteca.files.wordpress.com/2012/10/informe-relatora-onu-oct2012.pdf. March 20, 2017.
  76. Vidal, G. (2017). Challenging business as Usual? The rise of new parties in Spain in times of crisis. West European Politics, 41, 261–286.Google Scholar
  77. Virós, R., Canals, R., & Pallarés, F. (1991). Influència en l’opció electoral d’alguns factors sociodemogràfics i polítics. Perfils dels electorats. Estudis Electorals, 10, 125–147.Google Scholar
  78. Weatherford, M. (1987). How does government performance influence political support? Political Behavior, 9, 5–28.Google Scholar
  79. Wilson, R. (2011). The contribution of behavioral economics to political science. Annual Review of Political Science, 14, 201–223.Google Scholar
  80. Wroe, A. (2014). Political trust and job insecurity in 18 European polities. Journal of Trust Research, 4, 90–112.Google Scholar
  81. Wroe, A. (2015) Economic insecurity and political trust in the United States. American Politics Research.  https://doi.org/10.1177/1532673x15597745.

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Centre d’Estudis d’Opinió - Generalitat de CatalunyaBarcelonaSpain

Personalised recommendations