Undergraduate Research or Research-Based Courses: Which Is Most Beneficial for Science Students?
- 245 Downloads
Over the last 25 years, both research literature and practice-oriented reports have claimed the need for improving the quality of undergraduate science education through linking research and teaching. Two manners of doing this are reported: undergraduate research and research-based courses. Although there are studies reporting benefits of participating in these experiences, few synthesize their findings. In this article, we present a literature review aimed at synthesizing and comparing results of the impact of participating in these research experiences to establish which approach is most beneficial for students to develop as scientists. Twenty studies on student participation in undergraduate research and research-based courses were reviewed. Results show that both types of experiences have positive effects on students. These results have implications for both practice and research. Regarding practice, we propose ideas for designing and implementing experiences that combine both types of experiences. Concerning research, we identify some methodological limitations that should be addressed in further studies.
KeywordsUndergraduate research Research-based courses Science education Teaching-research nexus Higher education
The authors gratefully acknowledge the constructive comments made by Professor Rachel Spronken-Smith, University of Otago, which have led to an improved paper. This work was supported by the Chilean National Council for Science and Technology (CONICYT) through the research grant FONDECYT Regular 1130982. The first author is a CONICYT Ph.D. grantee (CONICYT-PCHA/Doctorado Nacional/2013-21130423).
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare they have received the following funding for supporting the work presented in this paper: research grant FONDECYT Regular 1130982 and the first author is a CONICYT Ph.D. grantee (CONICYT-PCHA/Doctorado Nacional/2013-21130423). Both grants are provided by the Chilean National Council for Science and Technology (CONICYT).
- American Association for the Advancement of Science. (2009). Vision and change in undergraduate biology education, a call to action. Paper presented at the American Association for the Advancement of Science Conference, Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://visionandchange.org/files/2011/03/VC-Brochure-V6-3.pdf
- Beckman, M., & Hensel, N. (2009). Making explicit the implicit: defining undergraduate research. Council of Undergraduate Research, 29(4), 40–44.Google Scholar
- Boyer Commission. (1999). Reinventing undergraduate education: a blueprint for America’s research universities. Princeton, NJ: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of University Teaching, University of Princeton.Google Scholar
- Council of Undergraduate Research (2016). Website of the Council of Undergraduate Research. Retrieved from http://www.cur.org
- Frantz, K. J., DeHaan, R. L., Demetrikopoulos, M. K., & Carruth, L. L. (2006). Routes to research for novice undergraduate neuroscientists. CBE–Life Sciences Education, 5(2), 175–187. *Google Scholar
- Healey, M., & Jenkins, A. (2009). Developing undergraduate research and inquiry. York: The Higher Education Academy. Retrieved from http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/assets/documents/resources/publications/developingundergraduate_final.pdf
- National Research Council. (2003). BIO2010: transforming undergraduate education for future research biologists. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.Google Scholar
- Rowland, S. L., Lawrie, G. A., Behrendorff, J. B. Y. H., & Gillam, E. M. J. (2012). Is the undergraduate research experience (URE) always best?: the power of choice in a bifurcated practical stream for a large introductory biochemistry class. Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education, 40(1), 46–62. *CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sadler, T. D., Burgin, S., McKinney, L., & Ponjuan, L. (2010). Learning science through research apprenticeships: a critical review of the literature. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 47(3), 235–256.Google Scholar
- Thiry, H., Laursen, S. L., & Hunter, A. B. (2011). What experiences help students become scientists? A comparative study of research and other sources of personal and professional gains for STEM undergraduates. Journal of Higher Education, 82(4), 357–388. *Google Scholar