Evaluation of a tool to benchmark hospital antibiotic prescribing in the United Kingdom
- 128 Downloads
Objective: To investigate whether Defined Daily Dose/Finished Consultant Episode (DDD/FCE) ratio is sensitive to changes in prescribing patterns and could be used as a prescribing indicator in hospitals. Method: The study comprised two phases. In phase 1 the weekly DDD/FCE ratios for two antibiotics were calculated and monitored in one acute NHS hospital before and after the implementation of prescribing guidelines, which impacted on the use of the antibiotics. In phase 2 data on the use of four antibiotics over one year was collected from fifty-eight medium to large acute hospitals in England, together with corresponding FCE data. DDD/FCE ratios for each antibiotic in each hospital were compared. Main Outcome measure: Whether the DDD/FCE ratio for two antibiotics changed in one hospital following the introduction of prescribing guidelines for these antibiotics. The variability in DDD/FCE ratio for two broad spectrum antibiotics compared to two narrow spectrum antibiotics across a number of acute hospitals in England. Results: In phase 1 the DDD/FCE ratios for the two antibiotics were lower post implementation of the guidelines indicating that the ratio was sensitive to changes in prescribing. In phase 2 the median DDD/FCE ratios of the two broad spectrum antibiotics from all fifty eight hospitals were much higher (0.126, and 0.265) than for the two narrow spectrum antibiotics (0.048, and 0.021), indicating higher use of the broad spectrum antibiotics. Furthermore, the variation in prescribing between the hospitals, as indicated by the inter-quartile range about the median, was greater for the two broad spectrum agents (0.201 and 0.193), than for the narrow spectrum agents (0.06, and 0.042), as was expected. Conclusion: The DDD/FCE ratio is sensitive to changes in prescribing and can reflect differences in the use of antibiotics between hospitals, after accounting for differences in activity. DDD/FCE ratio has the potential to be used to also account for differences in case mix between hospitals although further work is needed in this area.
KeywordsAnalysis Antibiotics Benchmarking Defined Daily Doses Drug usage Hospital Prescribing United Kingdom
The authors would like to thank the Chief Pharmacists of the all the NHS Hospital trusts who responded to our request for information, for taking the time to provide us with the usage data of the antibiotics in Phase 2 of the study. We would like to thank the Chief Pharmacist of The Royal Shrewsbury and Telford NHS trust, for allowing Ms Edwards the time to conduct this work.
- 1.Department of Health, Prescriptions Dispensed in the Community, Statistics for 1993–2003: England, Statistics Bulletin, London, Department of Health, 2004, ISBN 1 841882 8661.Google Scholar
- 2.Audit Commission. A spoonful of sugar: medicines management in NHS hospitals. London: Audit Commission; (2001). ISBN 1 86240 321X.Google Scholar
- 3.World Health Organisation Collaborating Centre for Drug Statistics Methodology. Complete ATC index with DDD’s. Oslo, Norwegian: Institute of Public Health; 2005.Google Scholar
- 4.Pelle B, Gilchrist M, Lawson W, Jacklin A, Dean Franklin B. Using defined Daily Doses to study the use of antibacterials in U.K. hospitals. Hosp Pharm 2006;13:133–6.Google Scholar
- 5.Department of Health. HES Factsheet Glossary of Terms. London: Department of health; 2004.Google Scholar
- 7.Curtis C, Langley CA, Marriott JF, Wilson KA. A comparison of antibiotic prescribing indicators and medicines management scoring in secondary care. I J P P 2003;11:R54.Google Scholar
- 8.Department of Health. The Governments Response to the House of Lords Select Committee on Science and Technology Report ‘Resistance to Antibiotics and other Antimicrobial Agents. London:HMSO; 1998, ISBN 0104789980.Google Scholar
- 9.Department of Health. U.K. antimicrobial resistance strategy and action plan. London: Department of Health; 2000.Google Scholar
- 10.Rosdahl VK, and Pederson KB. The Copenhagen Recommendations. European Union Conference, The Microbial Threat. 1998 1–52. Ministry of health, and Ministry of food, agriculture, and Fisheries, Copenahgen Denmark.Google Scholar
- 12.Binley’s Directory of NHS Management. Volume 11 No. 3. Beechwood House Publishing Ltd. 2003/4 ISSN 0967–7917.Google Scholar
- 13.Government Statistical Services. Hospital Episode Statistics. England: Financial year 2002–3. Department of Health. Available at http://www.dh.gov.uk/PublicationsAndStatistics/Statistics/HospitalEpisodeStatistics/HESFreeData.