Landscape Ecology

, Volume 34, Issue 2, pp 291–305 | Cite as

Coexistence of two sympatric flagship carnivores in the human-dominated forest landscapes of Northeast Asia

  • Zhilin Li
  • Tianming WangEmail author
  • James L. D. Smith
  • Rongna Feng
  • Limin Feng
  • Pu Mou
  • Jianping Ge
Research Article



Understanding how large carnivore guilds survive in human-dominated landscapes is key to inform strategies for their conservation in the face of global carnivore declines. Amur tigers and leopards are recovering across the China-Russia border. However, knowledge is limited about competitive interactions between two large cats in Northeast Asia.


To assess the spatial, temporal and combined spatiotemporal behavioral mechanisms potentially allow co-occurrence between tigers and leopards in a human-dominated forest landscape.


Based on a large-scale camera-trapping data set in Northeast China, we used three different approaches for quantifying spatiotemporal associations: one spatial method (two-species occupancy model), one strictly temporal method (activity pattern overlap), and one spatiotemporal method based on multi-response permutation procedures at shared camera trap sites.


Spatially, leopards showed no avoidance of the areas highly used by dominant tigers, but their diurnal activity pattern was significantly different from that of tigers. Spatiotemporal overlap analysis showed fine-scale behavioral avoidance when both co-occurred at camera locations, which further facilitates sympatry. Tigers spatially overlapped with humans, but they were less active during the day when human activities were more frequent. In areas with high cattle density, low occurrence of tigers and leopards may reflect the absence of sika deer, an important prey item for both species.


This study provides the first empirical evidence that tigers do not limit leopard distributions, at least in our study area in Northeast Asia. Our results highlighted temporal segregation, not large-scaled spatial avoidance, as a key mechanism promoting coexistence of two large carnivores. Understanding these fine- spatial scale (i.e., camera locations) interactions between sympatric carnivores can help devise management strategies for predator guilds in human-dominated landscapes, currently a major global challenge.


Interspecific competition Occupancy Temporal activity patterns Cattle grazing Camera trapping 



We sincerely thank Todd W. Arnold for commenting on our single-season occupancy models and J. Andrew Royle and the anonymous referees for their thoughtful reviews of the manuscript. This work was supported by grants from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (31470566, 31210103911, and 31270567), the National Key Research and Development Program (2016YFC0500106), and the National Scientific and Technical Foundation Project of China (2012FY112000). J.L.D. Smith’s contribution to this research was supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture.

Supplementary material

10980_2018_759_MOESM1_ESM.docx (5 mb)
Supplementary material 1 (DOCX 5120 kb)


  1. Athreya V, Odden M, Linnell JDC, Krishnaswamy J, Karanth U (2013) Big cats in our backyards: persistence of large carnivores in a human dominated landscape in India. PLoS ONE 8:e57872CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Azlan JM, Sharma DSK (2006) The diversity and activity patterns of wild felids in a secondary forest in Peninsular Malaysia. Oryx 40:36–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Carroll C, Miquelle DG (2006) Spatial viability analysis of Amur tiger Panthera tigris altaica in the Russian Far East: the role of protected areas and landscape matrix in population persistence. J Appl Ecol 43:1056–1068CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Carter NH, Shrestha BK, Karki JB, Pradhan NMB, Liu JG (2012) Coexistence between wildlife and humans at fine spatial scales. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109:15360–15365CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Di Bitetti MS, De Angelo CD, Di Blanco YE, Paviolo A (2010) Niche partitioning and species coexistence in a Neotropical felid assemblage. Acta Oecol 36:403–412CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Feng LM, Shevtsova E, Vitkalova A, Matyukhina DS, Miquelle DG, Aramilev VV, Wang TM, Mu P, Xu RM, Ge JP (2017) Collaboration brings hope for the last Amur leopards. Cat News 65:20Google Scholar
  7. Harihar A, Pandav B, Goyal SP (2011) Responses of leopard Panthera pardus to the recovery of a tiger Panthera tigris population. J Appl Ecol 48:806–814CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Hayward MW, Jedrzejewski W, Jedrzewska B (2012) Prey preferences of the tiger Panthera tigris. J Zool 286:221–231CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Hayward MW, Slotow R (2009) Temporal partitioning of activity in large African carnivores: tests of multiple hypotheses. S Afr J Wildl Res 39:109–125CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Hebblewhite M, Miguelle DG, Murzin AA, Aramilev VV, Pikunov DG (2011) Predicting potential habitat and population size for reintroduction of the Far Eastern leopards in the Russian Far East. Biol Conserv 144:2403–2413CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Hebblewhite M, Miquelle DG, Robinson H, Pikunov DG, Dunishenko YM, Aramilev VV, Nikolaev IG, Salkina GP, Seryodkin IV, Gaponov VV, Litvinov MN, Kostyria AV, Fomenko PV, Murzin AA (2014) Including biotic interactions with ungulate prey and humans improves habitat conservation modeling for endangered Amur tigers in the Russian Far East. Biol Conserv 178:50–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Hebblewhite M, Zimmermann F, Li Z, Miquelle D, Zhang M, Sun H, Mörschel F, Wu Z, Sheng L, Purekhovsky A (2012) Is there a future for Amur tigers in a restored tiger conservation landscape in Northeast China? Anim Conserv 15:579–592CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Hernandez-Blanco JA, Naidenko SV, Chistopolova MD, Lukarevskiy VS, Kostyrya A, Rybin A, Sorokin PA, Litvinov MN, Kotlyar AK, Miquelle DG, Rozhnov VV (2015) Social structure and space use of Amur tigers (Panthera tigris altaica) in Southern Russian Far East based on GPS telemetry data. Integr Zool 10:365–375CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Hines JE (2017) PRESENCE 12.6—estimates patch occupancy rates and related parameters. USGS-PWRC.
  15. Karanth KU, Srivathsa A, Vasudev D, Puri M, Parameshwaran R, Kumar NS (2017) Spatio-temporal interactions facilitate large carnivore sympatry across a resource gradient. Proc R Soc B-Biol Sci 284:20161860CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Karanth KU, Sunquist ME (2000) Behavioural correlates of predation by tiger (Panthera tigris), leopard (Panthera pardus) and dhole (Cuon alpinus) in Nagarahole, India. J Zool 250:255–265CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Kerley LL, Mukhacheva AS, Matyukhina DS, Salmanova E, Salkina GP, Miquelle DG (2015) A comparison of food habits and prey preference of Amur tiger (Panthera tigris altaica) at three sites in the Russian Far East. Integr Zool 10:354–364CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Kovach WL (2011) Oriana—circular statistics for windows, ver. 4. Kovach Computing Services, PentraethGoogle Scholar
  19. Kronfeld-Schor N, Dayan T (2003) Partitioning of time as an ecological resource. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst 34:153–181CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Li BBV, Pimm SL, Li S, Zhao LJ, Luo CP (2017) Free-ranging livestock threaten the long-term survival of giant pandas. Biol Conserv 216:18–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Li ZW, Wu JG, Kou XJ, Tian Y, Wang TM, Mu P, Ge JP (2009a) Land use pattern and its dynamic changes in Amur tiger distribution region. Chin J Appl Ecol 20:713–724 (in Chinese) Google Scholar
  22. Li B, Zhang ED, Liu ZB (2009b) Livestock depredation by Amur tigers in Hunchun Nature Reserve, Jilin, China. Acta Theriol Sin 29:231–238Google Scholar
  23. Liu JG, Dietz T, Carpenter SR, Alberti M, Folke C, Moran E, Pell AN, Deadman P, Kratz T, Lubchenco J, Ostrom E, Ouyang Z, Provencher W, Redman CL, Schneider SH, Taylor WW (2007) Complexity of coupled human and natural systems. Science 317:1513–1516CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. MacKenzie DI (2006) Occupancy estimation and modeling: inferring patterns and dynamics of species occurrence. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  25. Madhusudan MD (2004) Recovery of wild large herbivores following livestock decline in a tropical Indian wildlife reserve. J Appl Ecol 41:858–869CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. McLaughlin K (2016) Tiger Land. Science 353:744–745CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Miller CS, Hebblewhite M, Petrunenko YK, Seryodkin IV, Goodrich JM, Miquelle DG (2014) Amur tiger (Panthera tigris altaica) energetic requirements: implications for conserving wild tigers. Biol Conserv 170:120–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Miquelle DG, Goodrich JM, Smirnov EN, Stephens PA, Zaumyslova OY, Chapron G, Kerley L, Murzin AA, Hornocker MG, Quigley HB (2010) The Amur tiger: a case study of living on the edge. In: Macdonald DW, Loveridge A (eds) Biology and conservation of wild felids. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 325–339Google Scholar
  29. Odden M, Wegge P (2005) Spacing and activity patterns of leopards Panthera pardus in the Royal Bardia National Park, Nepal. Wildl Biol 11:145–152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Odden M, Wegge P, Fredriksen T (2010) Do tigers displace leopards? If so, why? Ecol Res 25:875–881CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Oliveira-Santos LGR, Zucco CA, Agostinelli C (2013) Using conditional circular kernel density functions to test hypotheses on animal circadian activity. Anim Behav 85:269–280CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Petrunenko YK, Montgomery RA, Seryodkin IV, Zaumyslova OY, Miquelle DG, Macdonald DW (2016) Spatial variation in the density and vulnerability of preferred prey in the landscape shape patterns of Amur tiger habitat use. Oikos 125:66–75CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Pudyatmoko S (2017) Free-ranging livestock influence species richness, occupancy, and daily behaviour of wild mammalian species in Baluran National Park, Indonesia. Mamm Biol 86:33–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Punjabi GA, Rao M (2017) Large herbivore populations outside protected areas in the human-dominated Western Ghats, India. Mamm Biol 87:27–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Qi JZ, Shi QH, Wang GM, Li ZL, Sun Q, Hua Y, Jiang GS (2015) Spatial distribution drivers of Amur leopard density in northeast China. Biol Conserv 191:258–265CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Rayan DM, Linkie M (2016) Managing conservation flagship species in competition: tiger, leopard and dhole in Malaysia. Biol Conserv 204:360–366CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Richmond OMW, Hines JE, Beissinger SR (2010) Two-species occupancy models: a new parameterization applied to co-occurrence of secretive rails. Ecol Appl 20:2036–2046CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Ridout MS, Linkie M (2009) Estimating overlap of daily activity patterns from camera trap data. J Agric Biol Environ Stat 14:322–337CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Ripple WJ, Estes JA, Beschta RL, Wilmers CC, Ritchie EG, Hebblewhite M, Berger J, Elmhagen B, Letnic M, Nelson MP, Schmitz OJ, Smith DW, Wallach AD, Wirsing AJ (2014) Status and ecological effects of the world’s largest carnivores. Science 343:151CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Robinson QH, Bustos D, Roemer GW (2014a) The application of occupancy modeling to evaluate intraguild predation in a model carnivore system. Ecology 95:3112–3123CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Robinson TP, Wint GR, Conchedda G, Van Boeckel TP, Ercoli V, Palamara E, Cinardi G, D’Aietti L, Hay SI, Gilbert M (2014b) Mapping the global distribution of livestock. PLoS ONE 9:e96084CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Schieltz JM, Rubenstein DI (2016) Evidence based review: positive versus negative effects of livestock grazing on wildlife. What do we really know? Environ Res Lett 11:113003CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Schuette P, Wagner AP, Wagner ME, Creel S (2013) Occupancy patterns and niche partitioning within a diverse carnivore community exposed to anthropogenic pressures. Biol Conserv 158:301–312CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Seidensticker J (1976) On the ecological separation between tigers and leopards. Biotropica 8:225–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Sharma RK, Bhatnagar YV, Mishra C (2015) Does livestock benefit or harm snow leopards? Biol Conserv 190:8–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Singh HS, Gibson L (2011) A conservation success story in the otherwise dire megafauna extinction crisis: the Asiatic lion (Panthera leo persica) of Gir forest. Biol Conserv 144:1753–1757CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Soh YH, Carrasco LR, Miquelle DG, Jiang JS, Yang J, Stokes EJ, Tang JR, Kang AL, Liu PQ, Rao M (2014) Spatial correlates of livestock depredation by Amur tigers in Hunchun, China: relevance of prey density and implications for protected area management. Biol Conserv 169:117–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Sollmann R, Mohamed A, Samejima H, Wilting A (2013) Risky business or simple solution—relative abundance indices from camera-trapping. Biol Conserv 159:405–412CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Soofi M, Ghoddousi A, Zeppenfeld T, Shokri S, Soufi M, Jafari A, Ahmadpour M, Qashqaei AT, Egli L, Ghadirian T, Chahartaghi NR, Zehzad B, Kiabi BH, Khorozyan I, Balkenhol N, Waltert M (2018) Livestock grazing in protected areas and its effects on large mammals in the Hyrcanian forest, Iran. Biol Conserv 217:377–382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Steinmetz R, Seuaturien N, Chutipong W (2013) Tigers, leopards, and dholes in a half-empty forest: assessing species interactions in a guild of threatened carnivores. Biol Conserv 163:68–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Sugimoto T, Aramilev VV, Nagata J, McCullough DR (2016) Winter food habits of sympatric carnivores, Amur tigers and Far Eastern leopards, in the Russian Far East. Mamm Biol 81:214–218CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Sunarto S, Kelly MJ, Parakkasi K, Hutajulu MB (2015) Cat coexistence in central Sumatra: ecological characteristics, spatial and temporal overlap, and implications for management. J Zool 296:104–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Terborgh J, Estes JA (2010) Trophic cascades: predators, prey and the changing dynamics of nature. Island Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  54. Tian Y, Wu JG, Kou XJ, Li ZW, Wang TM, Mou P, Ge JP (2009) Spatiotemporal pattern and major causes of the Amur tiger population dynamics. Biodiv Sci 17:211–225 (in Chinese) Google Scholar
  55. Tian Y, Wu JG, Smith AT, Wang TM, Kou XJ, Ge JP (2011) Population viability of the Siberian tiger in a changing landscape: going, going and gone? Ecol Model 222:3166–3180CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Vitkalova AV, Feng LM, Rybin AN, Gerber BD, Miquelle DG, Wang TM, Yang HT, Shevtsova EI, Aramilev VV, Ge JP (2018) Transboundary cooperation improves endangered species monitoring and conservation actions: a case study of the global population of Amur leopards. Conserv Lett 11:e12574CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Wang YW, Allen ML, Wilmers CC (2015) Mesopredator spatial and temporal responses to large predators and human development in the Santa Cruz Mountains of California. Biol Conserv 190:23–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Wang TM, Feng LM, Mou P, Wu JG, Smith JLD, Xiao WH, Yang HT, Dou HL, Zhao XD, Cheng YC, Zhou B, Wu HY, Zhang L, Tian Y, Guo QX, Kou XJ, Han XM, Miquelle DG, Oliver CD, Xu RM, Ge JP (2016) Amur tigers and leopards returning to China: direct evidence and a landscape conservation plan. Landscape Ecol 31:491–503CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Wang TM, Feng LM, Yang HT, Han BY, Zhao YH, Juan L, Lu XY, Zou L, Li T, Xiao WH, Mou P, Smith JLD, Ge JP (2017) A science-based approach to guide Amur leopard recovery in China. Biol Conserv 210:47–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Wang TM, Royle JA, Smith JLD, Zou L, Lu XY, Li T, Yang HT, Li ZL, Feng RN, Bian YJ, Feng LM, Ge JP (2018) Living on the edge: opportunities for Amur tiger recovery in China. Biol Conserv 217:269–279CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Wegge P, Odden M, Pokharel CP, Storaas T (2009) Predator-prey relationships and responses of ungulates and their predators to the establishment of protected areas: a case study of tigers, leopards and their prey in Bardia National Park, Nepal. Biol Conserv 142:189–202CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Wikramanayake E, Dinerstein E, Seidensticker J, Lumpkin S, Pandav B, Shrestha M, Mishra H, Ballou J, Johnsingh AJT, Chestin I, Sunarto S, Thinley P, Thapa K, Jiang GS, Elagupillay S, Kafley H, Pradhan NMB, Jigme K, Teak S, Cutter P, Aziz MA, Than U (2011) A landscape-based conservation strategy to double the wild tiger population. Conserv Lett 4:219–227CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Wolf C, Ripple WJ (2017) Range contractions of the world’s large carnivores. R Soc Open Sci 4:170052CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Xiao WH, Feng LM, Mou P, Miquelle DG, Hebblewhite M, Goldberg JF, Robinson HS, Zhao XD, Zhou B, Wang TM, Ge JP (2016) Estimating abundance and density of Amur tigers along the Sino-Russian border. Integr Zool 11:322–332CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Ministry of Education Key Laboratory for Biodiversity Science and Engineering, Monitoring and Research Center for Amur Tiger and Amur Leopard, State Forestry and Grassland Administration & College of Life SciencesBeijing Normal UniversityBeijingChina
  2. 2.Department of Fisheries, Wildlife and Conservation BiologyUniversity of MinnesotaSt PaulUSA

Personalised recommendations