A concept for disposal of highly acidic spent nuclear fuel solutions at PSI
- 215 Downloads
During previous radioanalytical studies at Paul Scherrer Institute ca. 30 L of acidic waste containing spent nuclear fuel was produced, and now they need to be disposed A flow sheet for conditioning of these waste was designed and the extraction chromatography technique is evaluated. Suitable sorbents, such as AMP_PAN, TBP impregnated resin and DGA resin, were selected for the task of Cs-removal, extraction of U and Pu, and extraction of minor actinides and lanthanides, respectively. A pilot device will be built for preliminary tests with simulated solutions, and the facility will be built and evaluated with the real spent fuel solutions.
KeywordsExtraction chromatography Spent nuclear fuel Ion exchange Cesium Lanthanides Actinides
Radioanalysis of spent fuel pellets is important for nuclear power plants, both, concerning the management of the fuel cycle and waste disposal. Several decades ago, a number of radioanalytical studies on ca. 700 g of spent nuclear fuel samples from Swiss nuclear power plants were performed at Hot Laboratory (hotlab), Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI), Switzerland. The samples were dissolved in approximately 30 L of 8–10 M HNO3 and the remaining solutions have been stored at hotlab for several decades and now they need to be properly disposed. In Switzerland, deep geological storage is adopted as the disposal concept for radioactive waste . Based on this, these spent fuel solutions have to be cemented for geological storage.
Concept of the “Fixbox” conditioning
A facility for conditioning of liquid radioactive waste, the so-called Fixbox 3 , was developed at PSI. This facility was installed in glove-boxes and gamma-shielded for handling the waste containing alpha- and gamma emitters, respectively. The Fixbox 3 procedure consists of chemical conditioning and pre-cementation. Acids are foreseen to be neutralized by standard solutions in the chemical conditioning step and several packages of 1 L can be produced in the pre-cementation step. Finally, these packages are solidified with cement in an approximately 200 L metal drum before being transferred to the geological storing site. In order to fulfill the requirements of the Fixbox 3 procedure, the gamma dose rate, mainly stemming from 137Cs (half-life: ~ 30 a) , must be significantly reduced.
Samples or solutions of spent nuclear fuel do not only impose huge efforts for conditioning and disposal, but contain also valuable materials for scientific studies i.e. for neutron induced fission- and capture cross sections, which are urgently needed and can hardly be obtained by other means. In the following paragraph, we explain these “spin-off” applications in more detail:
To optimize the design of advanced nuclear energy systems, and especially systems aimed to “burn” spent nuclear fuel, accurate nuclear reaction data for a large number of isotopes are required. In particular, high-accuracy, high-resolution cross-section data are needed on neutron induced reactions (capture, fission and inelastic reaction) for several actinides, long-lived fission fragments and structural materials.
The n_TOF facility at CERN —a pulsed neutron source coupled to a 200 m flight path designed to study neutron-nucleus interactions in energy ranges from a few meV to several GeV—initiated by Rubbia , gives the unique possibility to measure these urgently needed capture and fission cross sections.
Several capture and fission cross-section measurements on various long-lived U, Pu, Np, Am and Cm isotopes have already been performed during the two n_TOF measurement campaigns (2001–2004 and 2009–2012), for instance high accuracy results on the radiative capture of 232Th and fission of 233U, both of fundamental importance for the development of the Th/U fuel cycle [6, 7, 8, 9]. Fission cross-sections were determined with high accuracy also on 237Np and 240Pu [10, 11], two of the minor actinides most abundantly produced in current reactors. Recently, capture cross section of 238U, 236U, 241Am and fission cross section of 240Pu and 242Pu have been measured with the aim of reaching unprecedented accuracy [8, 12]. An overview on the n_TOF CERN fission program can be found in .
Moreover, Experimental Area II or (EAR-2)  has been operational from 2014 on with a gain in flux of more than 20 times compared to Experimental Area I (EAR-1), as thus will allow n_TOF to expand its measurement capabilities to even smaller samples of more short-lived and rare isotopes, such as 230Th, 232U, 238U,240Pu, 244Cm and even fission products.
As a consequence of this situation, we observe a strongly increasing demand for rare and exotic radioactive sample material, especially minor actinides and fission products, because a basic ingredient of a reliable cross section determination with a low uncertainty is a high quality target, containing sufficient amount of the desired isotopes and meeting the specific requirements of the measurement. The currently available spent fuel solutions can be a source of such valuable material.
Design of the flow sheet
The Cs-removal process is the first step for two reasons: (1) the reduction of gamma dose rate on these spent fuel solutions fulfills the requirement of the Fixbox 3 procedure; (2) the risk of radiation-induced decomposition on the extractants used in the following steps is lowered. U and Pu extraction is following after the Cs-removal step. The aim of this step is to remove the matrix elements from the spent fuel solutions, which lowers the concentration of interfering ions during extraction of the desired isotopes. As stated in “isotope reclamation”, those scientific valuable isotopes (e.g. minor actinides) are in high demand, therefore the extraction of minor actinides as well as the extraction of rare activation isotopes are performed before the cementation procedure. The co-extraction of minor actinides and lanthanides is conducted due to their similar chemical properties , and the step of separating minor actinides from lanthanides. For the separation of Am from Cm, currently the separation procedure is not determined. This work might be performed properly in the future.
Description of materials in each step
Because of its operational simplicity, chromatographic separation techniques were evaluated in each separation step presented in the flow sheet.
Ammonium molybdophosphate polyacrylonitrile (AMP_PAN) was used for Cs-removal. This material is an engineered product—immobilized ammonium molybdophosphate (AMP) on polyacrylonitrile (PAN) . It was developed and evaluated by Sebesta et al. . The chemical stability was tested by pre-contacting the AMP_PAN with 1 M HNO3 for a month and the radiation stability of AMP_PAN was tested after receiving 103–106 Gy of either gamma or X-ray dose [17, 18]. The results of the evaluation on pre-treated AMP_PAN showed that no changes of adsorption properties of AMP_PAN to Cs was observed in comparison with non pre-treated AMP_PAN, which proved the good chemical and radiation stability of AMP_PAN. Later, AMP_PAN was tested at Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory (INEEL) to remove radioactive Cs from acidic and radioactive liquid waste. Both batch and column methods experiments with AMP_PAN were performed at INEEL [19, 20, 21]. Their results showed that AMP_PAN has high selectivity to Cs in highly acidic and salt bearing solutions. The evaluation indicated that AMP_PAN is an efficient and promising material to remove Cs from highly acidic solutions. A manuscript concerning the optimization of the chemical separation system for Cs removal has been submitted to the Radiochimica Acta.
U and Pu extraction
The liquid–liquid extraction technique as well as the developed extractants have been widely studied for the extraction of U and Pu from spent fuel solutions [22, 23, 24, 25]. However, the complexed setup is not suitable for the small-scale extraction task. In this work, the simplified ion-exchange technique and TBP impregnated resin is evaluated for the extraction of U and Pu. It is an engineered form of U and Pu selective sorbent material marketed by the company “Triskem” in Europe. This material is produced by immobilizing tributyl-phosphate (TBP) molecules on an inert matrix and it has been studied by Dirks et al. recently . They studied the distribution coefficient (Kd) of many elements on TBP impregnated resin in a wide range of HNO3 concentrations (0.1–10 M) . Their results indicated that the Kd value of U and Pu increased with the concentration of HNO3, while the Kd value of other elements (mainly fission products) remained small. Details can be found in . This study proved that the TBP impregnated resin has high selectivity for U and Pu in concentrated HNO3 solutions. Therefore, TBP impregnated resin is a suitable material to remove the matrix elements of U and Pu from these high acidic spent fuel solutions.
Minor actinides and lanthanides extraction
The minor actinides and lanthanides extraction from spent nuclear fuel solutions have attracted much attention recently and several extractants were developed and tested . In this study, the DGA-resin was tested for the extraction of minor actinides and lanthanides extraction. This material was developed by “Eichrom Technologies Inc.” in the US and is marketed by the company “Triskem” in Europe. The DGA-resin is synthesized by immobilizing N,N,N′,N′-tetra-n-octyldiglycolamide (TODGA) molecules on an inert matrix and it has been studied extensively recently. Pourmand et al. evaluated the distribution coefficient of many elements on the DGA-resin in wide range of HNO3 concentrations (0.1–12 M) . Their results showed that the minor actinides and lanthanides have high affinity to this material in concentrated HNO3, which indicated that the DGA-resin is an effective material to extract minor actinides and lanthanides from these highly acidic spent fuel solutions. Details can be found in .
Separation of minor actinides from lanthanides
The separation of minor actinides from lanthanides is a challenging task due to their similar chemical properties and many studies have been performed by different groups [31, 32, 33, 34, 35]. In this work, the separation of minor actinides from the DGA-resin (lanthanides) is performed with hydrophilic bis-triazinyl-pyridine (BTP). Geist and Wilden et al. performed experiments of extraction of Am and Eu by the TODGA system with addition of hydrophilic BTP in aqueous phase [36, 37]. They found that the extraction of Am was effectively suppressed, but the extraction of Eu was only slightly influenced. The separation factor of Am/Eu increased with the concentration of hydrophilic BTP. Since the active component of DGA resin is TODGA, the hydrophilic BTP would be an effective material to separate minor actinides from the DGA resin.
Design of the specific flow diagram
The information of selected materials
U and Pu extraction
TBP impregnated resin
MA and Ln extraction
The loaded sorbents (AMP_PAN and TBP-resin) as well as the adsorbates (Cs, U and Pu) and the waste produced in each separation step were sent to the Fixbox 3 facility for final cementation. The separated isotopes will be kept for further scientific investigations.
Conclusions and outlook
In the present paper, a concept for conditioning of spent nuclear fuel solutions at PSI was presented. An already developed facility (Fixbox 3) will be used for the final cementation of these high-level solutions. In order to fulfill the requirement of Fixbox 3 and to meet the demand of scientific valuable isotopes, extraction of Cs, U and Pu, minor actinides and lanthanides, and rare fission products are included into a designed flow sheet for the disposal of these spent fuel solutions. For the purpose of separation or extraction of the desired elements, chromatographic separation techniques are currently evaluated. Promising materials were selected for each extraction step. AMP_PAN, TBP impregnated resin and DGA resin were selected for the extraction of Cs, U and Pu, minor actinides and lanthanides, respectively. The hydrophilic BTP was selected for the separation of minor actinides from DGA resin. A conceptual flow diagram containing these separation steps as well as the sorbents was thus developed.
In the future, the selected sorbents will be individually tested by both batch and column methods. The performed tests will allow determining the optimum condition (e.g. acidity) and parameters (e.g. dimension of column and flow rate) of the devices suitable for our tasks. The device presented in Fig. 2 will be tested using simulated solutions in lieu of real spent fuel solutions and later one with the real spent fuel solutions.
The operation of the device will establish the basis for the safe and efficient disposal of the liquid nuclear waste at PSI stemming from nuclear power plants and, additionally, can help to provide urgently needed radioactive samples for scientific experiments like neutron capture and fission cross section measurements.
This study was sponsored by Swiss nuclear project “Waste treatment and Isotope Reclamation (WIR)”. http://www.swissnuclear.ch/en/research-projects-_content—1–1020.html.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- 1.Wildi W, Appel D, Buser M, Dermange F, Eckhardt A, Hufschmied P, Keusen H, Aebersold M (2000) Disposal concepts for radioactive waste. Final Report, Federal office of EnergyGoogle Scholar
- 2.Bruchertseifer H, Sommer E, Steinemann M, Bart G (1993) “Fixbox”—A new technique for the reliable conditioning of plutonium waste solutions. Annual Report, Paul Scherrer InstituteGoogle Scholar
- 3.IAEA nuclear data section. https://www-nds.iaea.org/sgnucdat/c3.htm. Accessed 10 July 2019
- 4.The Neutron time-of-flight facility at CERN. https://ntof-exp.web.cern.ch/ntof-exp/. Accessed 10 July 2019
- 5.Rubbia C, Rubio JA, Buono S, Carminati F, Fierier N, Gálvez J, Gelès C, Kadi Y, Klapisch R, Mandrillon P, Revol JPC, Roche C (1995) Conceptual design of a solid neutron operated high power energy amplifier. Report: CERN-AT-95-44-ETGoogle Scholar
- 14.Chiaveri E (2012) Technical Report CERN-INTC-2012-029. INTC-O-015. CERN. Geneva. URL: cds.cern.ch/record/1411635Google Scholar
- 16.Triskem, AMP_PAN product sheet. https://www.triskem-international.com/catalog/products/resins-and-accessories/cs-resins/bl,product,420,0. Accessed 10 July 2019
- 17.Sebesta F, John J, Motl A, Stamberg K (1995) Evaluation of polyacrylonitrile (PAN) as a binding polymer for absorbers used to treat liquid radioactive wastes. Contractor Report. Sandia National Laboratories. SAND95-2729Google Scholar
- 18.Sebesta F, John J, Motl A (1996) Phase II report on the evaluation of polyacrylonitrile (PAN) as a binding polymer for absorbers used to treat liquid wastes. Contractor Report. Sandia National Laboratories.SAND96-1088Google Scholar
- 20.Tranter TJ, Herbst RS, Todd TA (2002) Determination of a solid phase mass transfer coefficient for modeling an adsorption bed system using ammonium molybdophospate-polyacrylonitrile (AMP_PAN) as a sorbent for the removal of 137Cs from acidic nuclear waste solutions. Adsorption 8:291–299CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 22.Wang C-Z, Lan J-H, Feng Y-X, Wei Y-Z, Zhao Y-L, Chai Z-F, Shi W-Q (2014) Extraction complexes of Pu(IV) with carbamoylmethylphosphine oxide ligands: a relativistic density functional study. Radiochim Acta 102:77–86Google Scholar
- 26.Dirks C, Vajda N, Kovács-Széles E, Bombard A, Happel S (2014) Characterization of a TBP resin and development of methods for the separation of actinides and the purification of Sn. Poster presented at the 17th Radiochemistry conferenceGoogle Scholar
- 27.Triskem, TBP resin product sheet. https://www.triskem-international.com/scripts/files/5c5864aeadddb9.15147490/PS_TBP%20Resin_EN_160927.pdf. Accessed 10 July 2019
- 30.Triskem, DGA resin product sheet. https://www.triskem-international.com/scripts/files/5c585f394367f7.40914978/PS_DGA%20Resin_EN_151210.pdf. Accessed 10 July 2019
- 36.Geist A, Müllich U, Magnusson D, Kaden P, Modolo G, Wilden A, Zevaco T (2012) Actinide (III)/Lanthanide (III) separation via selective aqueous complexation of actinides (III) using a hydrophilic 2,6-bis(1,2,4-triazin-3-yl)-pyridine in nitric acid. Solvent Extr Ion Exch 30:433–444CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.