Advertisement

Integrating the Literature on Police Use of Deadly Force and Police Lethal Victimization: How Does Place Impact Fatal Police–Citizen Encounters?

  • Emma E. Fridel
  • Keller G. Sheppard
  • Gregory M. ZimmermanEmail author
Original Paper

Abstract

Objectives

Use of lethal force by police officers has incited riots, inspired social movements, and engendered socio-political debate. Police officers also assume a high level of risk during police–citizen encounters. Yet, existing studies tend to center on these two phenomena independently. Additionally, the under-utilization of multilevel research in these areas of inquiry has hampered attempts to empirically disentangle the individual, agency, and contextual correlates of fatal police–citizen encounters. This study integrates the predominantly distinct research bases on these phenomena to examine the contexts in which police use lethal force, relative to the contexts in which officers are killed in the line of duty.

Methods

Data were compiled on 6416 citizen fatalities and 709 officer fatalities distributed across 1735 agencies and 1506 U.S. places from 2000 to 2016. A series of three-level logistic regression models examined the civilian and officer characteristics, organizational factors, and contextual features that impacted the odds of citizen fatalities by the police relative to police lethal victimization.

Results

Findings indicated that structural disadvantage increased the odds of police lethal victimization relative to citizen fatalities by the police. Moreover, this contextual effect was, in part, a product of increased firearm usage by citizens who killed police in more disadvantaged areas.

Conclusions

A more complete understanding of fatal police–citizen encounters requires considering police use of lethal force and police lethal victimization concurrently in their broader social contexts.

Keywords

Police use of lethal force Police lethal victimization Context Concentrated disadvantage Firearm use 

Notes

References

  1. Agresti A (2013) Categorical data analysis. Wiley, HobokenGoogle Scholar
  2. Alpert GP (1989) Police use of deadly force: the Miami experience. In: Dunham RD, Alpert GP (eds) Critical issues in policing. Waveland Press, Prospect Heights, pp 480–496Google Scholar
  3. Alpert GP (2016) Toward a national database of officer-involved shootings. Criminol Public Policy 15(1):237–242CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Alpert GP, Dunham RG (1997) The force factor: measuring police use of force relative to suspect resistance. Police Executive Research Forum, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  5. Alpert GP, Dunham RG (2004) Understanding police use of force: officers, suspects, and reciprocity. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Azrael D, Cook PJ, Miller M (2004) State and local prevalence of firearms ownership measurement, structure, and trends. J Quant Criminol 20(1):43–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Baker D (2009) Police confirmation of use of force in Australia: ‘to be or not to be?’. Crime Law Soc Change 52(2):139–158CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Banks D, Ruddle P, Kennedy E, Planty MG (2016) Arrest-related deaths program redesign study, 2015–16: preliminary findings. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  9. Barrick K, Hickman MJ, Strom KJ (2014) Representative policing and violence towards the police. Polic A J Policy Pract 8(2):193–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Batton C, Wilson S (2006) Police murders: an examination of historical trends in the killing of law enforcement officers in the United States, 1947 to 1998. Homicide Stud 10(2):79–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Baumer E, Horney J, Felson R, Lauritsen JL (2003) Neighborhood disadvantage and the nature of violence. Criminology 41(1):39–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bazley TD, Lersch KM, Mieczkowski T (2007) Officer force versus suspect resistance: a gendered analysis of patrol officers in an urban police department. J Crim Justice 35(2):183–192CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Belvedere K, Worrall JL, Tibbetts SG (2005) Explaining suspect resistance in police–citizen encounters. Crim Justice Rev 30(1):30–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Berry WD, Feldman S (1985) Multiple regression in practice. Sage, Thousand OaksCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Binder A, Scharf P (1980) The violent police–citizen encounter. Ann Am Acad Political Soc Sci 452(1):111–121CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Blau PM (1977) Inequality and heterogeneity: a primitive theory of social structure, vol 7. Free Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  17. Brandl SG, Stroshine MS (2017) Oleoresin capsicum spray and TASERs: a comparison of factors predicting use and effectiveness. Crim Justice Policy Rev 28(3):279–306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Bronfenbrenner U (1994) Ecological models of human development. Int Encycl Educ 3(2):37–43Google Scholar
  19. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2017) Workplace homicides, 2011–2015. U.S. Department of Labor, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  20. Cook PJ, Ludwig J (2006) The social costs of gun ownership. J Public Econ 90(1–2):379–391CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Correll J, Park B, Judd CM, Wittenbrink B, Sadler MS, Keesee T (2007) Across the thin blue line: police officers and racial bias in the decision to shoot. J Personal Soc Psychol 92(6):1006–1023CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Drakulich K, Hagan J, Johnson D, Wozniak KH (2017) Race, justice, policing, and the 2016 American presidential election. Du Bois Rev Soc Sci Res Race 14(1):7–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dunham RG, Alpert GP, Stroshine MS, Bennett K (2005) Transforming citizens into suspects: factors that influence the formation of police suspicion. Police Q 8(3):366–393CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Engel RS (2000) The effects of supervisory styles on patrol officer behavior. Police Q 3(3):262–293CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Federal Bureau of Investigation (2018a) Summaries of law enforcement officers feloniously killed 2002 to 2017. U.S. Department of Justice, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  26. Federal Bureau of Investigation (2018b) Law enforcement officers assaulted by region and geographic division, 2017. U.S. Department of Justice, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  27. Feldman JM, Gruskin S, Coull BA, Krieger N (2017a) Killed by police: validity of media-based data and misclassification of death certificates in Massachusetts, 2004–2016. Am J Public Health 107(10):1624–1626CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Feldman JM, Gruskin S, Coull BA, Krieger N (2017b) Quantifying underreporting of law-enforcement-related deaths in United States vital statistics and news-media-based data sources: a capture-recapture analysis. PLoS Med 14(10):e1002399CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Fridell L, Faggiani D, Taylor B, Brito C, Kubu B (2009) The impact of agency context, policies, and practices on violence against police. J Crim Justice 37(6):542–552CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Fyfe JJ (2002) Too many missing cases: holes in our knowledge about police use of force. Justice Res Policy 4(1–2):87–102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Geller WA, Scott M (1992) Deadly force: what we know: a practitioner’s desk reference on police-involved shootings. Police Execution Res Forum, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  32. Gibbs JC, Ruiz J, Klapper-Lehman SA (2014) Police officers killed on duty: replicating and extending a unique look at officer deaths. Int J Police Sci Manag 16(4):277–287CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Goldkamp JS (1976) Minorities as victims of police shootings: interpretations of racial disproportinality and police use of deadly force. Justice Syst J 2(2):169–183Google Scholar
  34. Gray AC, Parker KF (2019) Race, structural predictors, and police shootings: Are there differences across official and “unofficial” accounts of lethal force? Crime Delinquency 65(1):26–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Hannon LE (2005) Extremely poor neighborhoods and homicide. Soc Sci Q 86:1418–1434CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hayden GA (1981) Police discretion in the use of deadly force: an empirical study of information usage in deadly force decision making. J Police Sci Adm 9(1):102–107Google Scholar
  37. Hemenway D, Prothrow-Stith D, Bergstein JM, Ander R, Kennedy BP (1996) Gun carrying among adolescents. Law Contemp Probl 59(1):39–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hemenway D, Azrael D, Conner A, Miller M (2018) Variation in rates of fatal police shootings across US states: the role of firearm availability. J Urban Health 96:63–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Herbert S (1998) Police subculture reconsidered. Criminology 36(2):343–370CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Hickman MJ, Piquero AR, Garner JH (2008) Toward a national estimate of police use of nonlethal force. Criminol Public Policy 7(4):563–604CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hine KA, Porter LE, Westera NJ, Alpert GP (2018) Too much or too little? Individual and situational predictors of police force relative to suspect resistance. Polic Soc 28(5):587–604CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Jacobs D, Carmichael JT (2002) Subordination and violence against state control agents: testing political explanations for lethal assaults against the police. Soc Forces 80(4):1223–1251CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Jacobs D, O’Brien RM (1998) The determinants of deadly force: a structural analysis of police violence. Am J Sociol 103(4):837–862CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Johnson O, St C, Vil KL, Goodman M, Gilbert KL, Johnson CA (2019) How neighborhoods matter in fatal interactions between police and men of color. Soc Sci Med 220:226–235CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Kachurik S, Ruiz J, Staub M (2013) Police officers killed on duty: a different view. Int J Police Sci Manag 15(2):114–124CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Kaminski RJ (2002) An opportunity model of police homicide victimization. University at Albany, State University of New York, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  47. Kaminski RJ (2004) The murder of police officers. LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC, El Paso, TXGoogle Scholar
  48. Kaminski RJ (2008) Assessing the county-level structural covariates of police homicides. Homicide Stud 12(4):350–380CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Kaminksi RJ, Stucky TD (2009) Reassessing political explanations for murders of police. Homicide Stud 13(1):3–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Kaminski RJ, Jefferis E, Gu J (2003) Community correlates of serious assaults on police. Police Q 6(2):119–149CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Kavanagh J (1997) The occurrence of resisting arrest in arrest encounters: a study of police–citizen violence. Crimin Justice Rev 22(1):16–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Kent SL (2010) Killings of police in US cities since 1980: an examination of environmental and political explanations. Homicide Stud 14(1):3–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Kleck G (2004) Measures of gun ownership levels for macro-level crime and violence research. J Res Crime Delinq 41(1):3–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Klinger DA (1997) Negotiating order in patrol work: an ecological theory of police response to deviance. Criminology 35(2):277–306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Klinger DA (2001) Police responses to officer-involved shootings. Natl Crim Justice Ref Serv 253:21–24Google Scholar
  56. Klinger DA (2012a) Into the Kill zone: a cop’s eye view of deadly force/San Fransisco. Wiley, HobokenGoogle Scholar
  57. Klinger DA (2012b) On the problems and promise of research on lethal police violence: a research note. Homicide Stud 16(1):78–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Klinger DA, Rosenfeld R, Isom D, Deckard M (2016) Race, crime, and the micro-ecology of deadly force. Criminol Public Policy 15(1):193–222CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Kubrin CE (2003) Structural covariates of homicide rates: does type of homicide matter? J Res Crime Delinq 40(2):139–170CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Kubrin CE, Herting JR (2003) Neighborhood correalates of homicide trends: an analysis using growth-curve modeling. Sociol Q 44(3):329–350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Kubrin CE, Messner SF, Deane G, McGeever K, Stucky TD (2010) Proactive policing and robbery rates across US cities. Criminology 48(1):57–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Lester D (1987) The police as victims: the role of guns in the murder of police. Psychol Rep 60(2):366CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Liska AE, Yu J (1992) Specifying and testing the threat hypothesis: police use of deadly force. Soc Threat Soc Control 53–68Google Scholar
  64. Loftin C, Wiersema B, McDowall D, Dobrin A (2003) Underreporting of justifiable homicides committed by police officers in the United States, 1976–1998. Am J Public Health 93(7):1117–1121CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Lott JR Jr (2000) Does a helping hand put others at risk? Affirmative action, police departments, and crime. Econ Inquiry 38(2):239–277CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. MacDonald JM, Kaminski RJ, Alpert GP, Tennenbaum AN (2001) The temporal relationship between police killings of civilians and criminal homicide: a refined version of the danger-perception theory. Crime Delinq 47(2):155–172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. MacDonald JM, Manz PW, Alpert GP, Dunham RG (2003) Police use of force: examining the relationship between calls for service and the balance of police force and suspect resistance. J Crim Justice 31(2):119–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Mancik AM, Parker KF, Williams KR (2018) Neighborhood context and homicide clearance: estimating the effects of collective efficacy. Homicide Stud 22(2):188–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Matsueda RL (2017) Toward an analytical criminology: the micro-macro problem, causal mechanisms, and public policy. Criminology 55:493–519CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. McCluskey JD, Reisig MD, Mastrofski SD, Terrill W (1999) Nasty as they wanna be? An investigation of suspect aggression during police encounters. In: Paper read at 51st annual meeting of the american society of criminology, November, Toronto, CanadaGoogle Scholar
  71. McElvain JP, Kposowa AJ (2008) Police officer characteristics and the likelihood of using deadly force. Crim Justice Behav 35(4):505–521CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Merry SE (1981) Urban danger: life in a neighborhood of strangers. Temple University Press, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  73. Messner SF (2012) Morality, markets, and the ASC: 2011 presidential address to the American Society of Criminology. Criminology 50:5–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Miethe TD, Meier RF (1994) Crime and its social context: toward an integrated theory of offenders, victims, and situations. SUNY Press, AlbanyGoogle Scholar
  75. Miller L (2015) Why cops kill: the psychology of police deadly force encounters. Aggress Violent Behav 22:97–111CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Molnar BE, Miller MJ, Azrael D, Buka SL (2004) Neighborhood predictors of concealed firearm carrying among children and adolescents: results from the project on human development in Chicago neighborhoods. Archiv Pediatr Adolesc Med 158(7):657–664CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Mustard DB (2001) The impact of gun laws on police deaths. J Law Econ 44:635–658CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Nieuwbeerta P, McCall PL, Elffers H, Wittebrood K (2008) Neighborhood characteristics and individual homicide risks: effects of social cohesion, confidence in the police, and socioeconomic disadvantage. Homicide Stud 12(1):90–116CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Nix J, Campbell BA, Byers EH, Alpert GP (2017) A bird’s eye view of civilians killed by police in 2015. Criminol Public Policy 16(1):309–340CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Office of the Texas Attorney General (2019) Officer involved in shooting reports. https://oagtx.force.com/oisreports/apex/OISReportsPage. Accessed 18 Aug 2019
  81. Ozkan T, Worrall JL, Zettler H (2018) Validating media-driven and crowdsourced police shooting data: a research note. J Crime Justice 41(3):334–345CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Pearce M, Zucchino D, Srikrishnan M (2004) Protesters and police face off in St. Louis suburb over shooting. Los Angeles Times, Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
  83. Peterson RD, Bailey WC (1988) Structural influences on the killing of police: a comparison with general homicides. Justice Q 5(2):207–233CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Planty M, Burch AM, Banks D, Couzens L, Blanton C, Cribb D (2015) Arrest-related deaths program: data quality profile. US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  85. Pregibon D (1981) Logistic regression diagnostics. Ann Stat 9(4):705–724CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Rabe-Hemp CE, Schuck AM (2007) Violence against police officers: are female officers at greater risk? Police Q 10(4):411–428CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Raudenbush SW, Bryk AS (2002) Hierarchical linear models: applications and data analysis methods, 2nd edn. Sage, Thousand OaksGoogle Scholar
  88. Ross CT (2015) A multi-level bayesian analysis of racial bias in police shootings at the county-level in the United States, 2011–2014. PLoS ONE 10(11):e0141854CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Sampson RJ (1984) Group size, heterogeneity, and intergroup conflict: a test of Blau’s inequality and heterogeneity. Soc Forces 62(3):618–639CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Sampson RJ (2012) Great American city: Chicago and the enduring neighborhood effect. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Sampson RJ, Cohen J (1988) Deterrent effects of the police on crime: a replication and theoretical extension. Law Soc Rev 22(1):163–190CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Sampson RJ, Raudenbush SW (1999) Systematic social observation of public spaces: a new look at disorder in urban neighborhoods. Am J Sociol 105(3):603–651CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Sampson RJ, Raudenbush SW, Earls F (1997) Neighborhoods and violent crime: a multilevel study of collective efficacy. Science 277(5328):918–924CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Schuck AM, Rosenbaum DP, Hawkins DF (2008) The influence of race/ethnicity, social class, and neighborhood context on residents’ attitudes toward the police. Police Q 11(4):496–519CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  95. Sherman LW, Blumberg M (1981) Higher education and police use of deadly force. J Crim Justice 9(4):317–331CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. Sherman LW, Cohn EG (1986) Citizens killed by big city police, 1970–84. Crime Control Reports #2, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  97. Siegel M, Ross CS, King C III (2013) The relationship between gun ownership and firearm homicide rates in the United States, 1981–2010. Am J Public Health 103(11):2098–2105CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Skogan GW, Frydl K (2004) Fairness and effectiveness in policing: the evidence. National Academies Press, WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  99. Skolnick JH (1994) Justice without trial: law enforcement in democratic society, 3rd edn. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  100. Smith DA (1986) The neighborhood context of police behavior. Crime Justice 8:313–341CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Smith BW (2003) The impact of police officer diversity on police-caused homicides. Policy Stud J 31(2):147–162CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Smith BW (2004) Structural and organizational predictors of homicide by police. Polic Int J 27(4):539–557CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  103. Smith BW, Holmes MD (2014) Police use of excessive force in minority communities: a test of the minority threat, place, and community accountability hypotheses. Soc Probl 61(1):83–104CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  104. Snedker KA (2015) Neighborhood conditions and fear of crime: a reconsideration of sex differences. Crime Delinq 61(1):45–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Snijders TAB, Bosker RJ (1999) Multilevel analysis: an introduction to basic and advanced multilevel modeling. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CAGoogle Scholar
  106. Sorensen JR, Marquart JW, Brock DE (1993) Factors related to killings of felons by police officers: a test of the community violence and conflict hypotheses. Justice Q 10(3):417–440CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Stewart EA, Baumer EP, Brunson RK, Simons RL (2009) Neighborhood racial context and perceptions of police-based racial discrimination among black youth. Criminology 47(3):847–887CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  108. Stults BJ (2010) Determinants of Chicago neighborhood homicide trajectories: 1965–1995. Homicide Stud 14(3):244–267CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  109. Swedler DI, Kercher C, Simmons MM, Pollack KM (2014) Occupational homicide of law enforcement officers in the US, 1996–2010. Injury Prev 20(1):35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  110. Tcherni M (2011) Structural determinants of homicide: the big three. J Quant Criminol 27(4):475CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  111. Terrill W (2001) Police coercion: application of the force continuum. LFB Scholarly Publishing LLC, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  112. Terrill W (2005) Police use of force: a transactional approach. Justice Q 22(1):107–138CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  113. Terrill W, Mastrofski SD (2002) Situational and officer-based determinants of police coercion. Justice Q 19(2):215–248CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  114. Terrill W, Reisig MD (2003) Neighborhood context and police use of force. J Res Crime Delinq 40(3):291–321CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  115. Thompson SK, Gartner R (2014) The spatial distribution and social context of homicide in Toronto’s neighborhoods. J Res Crime Delinq 51(1):88–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  116. U.S. Bureau of the Census (1994) Geographic areas reference manual. U.S. Department of Commerce, Economics and Statistics AdministrationGoogle Scholar
  117. Vice News (2017) Shot by cops and forgotten. https://news.vice.com/en_us/article/a3jjpa/nonfatal-police-shootings-data. Accessed 18 Aug 2019
  118. Warner BD (2007) Robberies with guns: neighborhood factors and the nature of crime. J Crim Justice 35(1):39–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  119. White MD (2000) Assessing the impact of administrative policy on use of deadly force by on- and off-duty police. Eval Rev 24(3):295–318CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  120. White MD, Dario LM, Shjarback JA (2019) Assessing dangerousness in policing: an analysis of officer deaths in the United States, 1970–2016. Criminol Public Policy 18(1):11–35CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  121. Wikström POH, Loeber R (2000) Do disadvantaged neighborhoods cause well-adjusted children to become adolescent delinquents? A study of male juvenile serious offending, individual risk and protective factors, and neighborhood context. Criminology 38(4):1109–1142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  122. Willits DW, Nowacki JS (2014) Police organisation and deadly force: an examination of variation across large and small cities. Polic Soc 24(1):63–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  123. Wilson S, Zhao J (2008) Determining the correlates of police victimization: an analysis of organizational level factors on injurious assaults. J Crim Justice 36(5):461–468CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  124. Wolf R, Mesloh C, Henych M, Thompson LF (2009) Police use of force and the cumulative force factor. Polic Int J Police Strateg Manag 32(4):739–757CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  125. Zimring FE (2016) How many killings by police? Univ Chic Legal Forum 17:691–710Google Scholar
  126. Zimring FE, Arsiniega B (2015) Trends in killing of and by police: a preliminary analysis. Ohio St J Crim L 13:247–264Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of Criminology and Criminal JusticeNortheastern UniversityBostonUSA

Personalised recommendations