Advertisement

Human Studies

, Volume 41, Issue 4, pp 565–602 | Cite as

Calvinist Predestination and the Spirit of Capitalism: The Religious Argument of the Weber Thesis Reexamined

  • Milan ZafirovskiEmail author
Theoretical / Philosophical Paper
  • 118 Downloads

Abstract

The paper reconsiders the Weber Thesis of a linkage between Calvinism and capitalism. It first restates this sociological Thesis in terms of the Calvinist doctrine of predestination as its theological core and premise in virtue of being treated as the crucial religious factor of the spirit of modern capitalism. Consequently, it proposes that the Weber Thesis’ validity and consistency depends on that doctrine, succeeding or failing as a sociological theory with the latter depending on whether or not it is unique in theological terms, as well as economic-social consequences. For that purpose, it reexamines and compares the Calvinist doctrine of predestination with the pre-Calvinist versions and infers that it is basically identical to or compatible with these. It then draws the implications for the Weber Thesis in respect of the degree of its validity or consistence. It concludes that the Weber Thesis likely is fail as a sociological-economic theory with the Calvinist doctrine of predestination to the extent that the latter is its theological ground and revealed not to be unique and new theologically and probably in terms of its societal effects.

Keywords

Asceticism Calvinism Capitalism Predestination Election Weber’s Thesis 

References

  1. Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S., Robinson, J., & Yared, P. (2005). The rise of europe: Atlantic trade, institutional change, and economic growth. American Economic Review, 95, 546–579.Google Scholar
  2. Akerlof, G. (2007). The missing motivation in macroeconomics. American Economic Review, 97, 5–36.Google Scholar
  3. Alesina, A., & Giuliano, P. (2015). Culture and institutions. Journal of Economic Literature, 53(4), 898–944.Google Scholar
  4. Alexander, J. (1983). Theoretical logic in sociology. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  5. Alexander, J. (1998). Neofunctionalism and after. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.Google Scholar
  6. Ay, K.-L., & Dolphin, A. (1994). Geography and mentality some aspects of Max Weber’s protestantism thesis. Numen, 41, 163–194.Google Scholar
  7. Becker, H. (1940). Constructive typology in the social sciences. American Sociological Review, 5(1), 40–55.Google Scholar
  8. Becker, S., & Woessmann, L. (2009). Was weber wrong? A human capital theory of protestant economic history. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124, 531–596.Google Scholar
  9. Bell, D. (1977). The return of the sacred? The argument on the future of religion. The British Journal of Sociology, 28, 419–449.Google Scholar
  10. Bellamy, J., & Holleman, H. (2012). Weber and the environment: Classical foundations for a postexemptionalist sociology. American Journal of Sociology, 117, 1625–1673.Google Scholar
  11. Bénabou, R., Ticchi, D., & Vindigni, A. (2015). Religion and innovation. American Economic Review, 105(5), 346–351.Google Scholar
  12. Bendix, R. (1977). Max Weber. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  13. Benedict, P. (2002). Christ’s churches purely reformed. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  14. Benedict, P. (2014). Calvinism and the making of the modern european economic mind: A comment and call for more research. In G. van den Brink & H. M. Höpfl (Eds.), Calvinism and the making of the European mind (pp.199–209). Brill: Boston.Google Scholar
  15. Benedict, P., & Backus, I. (Eds.). (2011). Calvin and his influence, 1509–2009. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  16. Bouma, C. (1947). Calvinism in American theology today. The Journal of Religion, 27, 34–45.Google Scholar
  17. Buckham, J. (1918). Pilgrim tercentenary and theological progress. The Harvard Theological Review, 11, 285–306.Google Scholar
  18. Calvin, J. 1536. Christianæ religionis institutio. Basel (online edition).Google Scholar
  19. Calvin, J. 1560 (1888). Institution de la religion Chréttienne. Paris: Librairie de la Suisse Française (online edition).Google Scholar
  20. Camic, C. (1986). The matter of habit. American Journal of Sociology, 91, 1039–1087.Google Scholar
  21. Campbell, C. (2009). Distinguishing the power of agency from agentic power: A note on weber and the “Black Box” of personal agency. Sociological Theory, 27(4), 407–418.Google Scholar
  22. Clemens, E. (2007). Toward a historicized sociology: Theorizing events, processes, and emergence. Annual Review of Sociology, 33, 527–549.Google Scholar
  23. Cohen, J. (1980). Rational capitalism in renaissance Italy. American Journal of Sociology, 85, 1340–1355.Google Scholar
  24. Cohen, J. (2002). Protestantism and capitalism. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.Google Scholar
  25. Collins, R. (1980). Weber’s last theory of capitalism: A systematization. American Sociological Review, 45, 924–942.Google Scholar
  26. Collins, R. (1997). An Asian route to capitalism: Religious Economy and the origin of self-transforming growth in Japan. American Sociological Review, 6, 843–865.Google Scholar
  27. Dahrendorf, R. (1959). Class and class conflict in industrial society. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
  28. Davis, W. M. (1978). “Anticritical last word on the spirit of capitalism,” by Max Weber. The American Journal of Sociology, 83(5), 1105–1131.Google Scholar
  29. Davis, T. (Ed.) (2010). Introduction. John Calvin's American Legacy (pp. 3–18). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  30. De Greef, W. (2008). The writings of John Calvin. Westminster: John Knox Press.Google Scholar
  31. Dobbin, F. (2005). Comparative and Historical approaches to economic sociology comparative and historical approaches to economic sociology. In N. Smelser & R. Swedberg (Eds.), The handbook of economic sociology (pp. 26–48). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  32. Dombrowski, D. (2001). Rawls and religion. New York: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
  33. Dromi, S. (2016). Soldiers of the cross. Sociological Theory, 34(3), 196–219.Google Scholar
  34. Ekelund, R., Hébert, R., & Tollison, R. (2002). An economic analysis of the protestant reformation. The Journal of Political Economy, 110, 646–671.Google Scholar
  35. Foster, H. (1923). Liberal calvinism; The remonstrants at the synod of dort in 1618. The Harvard Theological Review, 16(1), 1–37.Google Scholar
  36. Fourcade, M. (2011). Cents and sensibility: Economic valuation and the nature of “Nature”. American Journal of Sociology, 116, 1721–1777.Google Scholar
  37. Fourcade, M., & Healy, K. (2007). Moral views of market society. Annual Review of Sociology, 33, 285–311.Google Scholar
  38. Friedman, B. (2011). Economics: A moral inquiry with religious origins. American Economic Review, 101, 166–170.Google Scholar
  39. Garrard, G. (2003). Rousseau’s counter-enlightenment. Albany: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
  40. Giddens, A. (1976). Introduction to weber, max. The Protestant Ethic and the spirit of capitalism (pp. 7–24). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  41. Giddens, A. (1984). The constitution of society. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  42. Gorski, P. (2000). The mosaic moment: An Early modernist critique of modernist theories of nationalism. American Journal of Sociology, 105, 1428–1468.Google Scholar
  43. Gorski, P. (2003). Disciplinary revolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  44. Graafland, J. (2014). Weber revisited: Critical perspectives from calvinism on capitalism in economic crisis. In G. van den Brink & H. M. Höpfl (Eds.), Calvinism and the making of the European mind (pp. 177–198). Boston: Brill.Google Scholar
  45. Greif, A. (2006). Family structure, institutions, and growth: The origins and implications of western corporations. American Economic Review, 96, 308–315.Google Scholar
  46. Gross, N. (2009). A pragmatist theory of social mechanisms. American Sociological Review, 74, 358–379.Google Scholar
  47. Grossman, H. (2006). The beginnings of capitalism and the new mass morality. Journal of Classical Sociology, 6, 201–213.Google Scholar
  48. Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., & Zingales, L. (2006). Does culture affect economic outcomes? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 20, 23–48.Google Scholar
  49. Habermas, J. (2001). The postnational constellation. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  50. Harrold, F. (1936). The nature of Carlyle’s calvinism. Studies in Philology, 33, 475–486.Google Scholar
  51. Heller, H. (1986). The conquest of poverty. Leiden: Brill.Google Scholar
  52. Hillmann, H. (2008). Mediation in multiple networks: Elite mobilization before the English civil war. American Sociological Review, 73, 426–454.Google Scholar
  53. Hobsbaum, P. (1972). Calvinism in action: The super-ego triumphant. The Hudson Review, 25, 23–50.Google Scholar
  54. Holton, R. J. (1983). Max weber, “Rational Capitalism”, and renaissance Italy: A critique of cohen. American Journal of Sociology, 89, 166–180.Google Scholar
  55. Hornung, E. (2014). Immigration and the diffusion of technology: The huguenot diaspora in prussia. American Economic Review, 104(1), 84–122.Google Scholar
  56. Hunter, M. (1914). Has calvinism a future? The Biblical World, 44, 231–238.Google Scholar
  57. Hyma, A. (1938). Calvinism and capitalism in the Netherlands, 1555–1700. The Journal of Modern History, 10, 321–343.Google Scholar
  58. Iyer, S. (2016). The new economics of religion. Journal of Economic Literature, 54(2), 395–441.Google Scholar
  59. Jonassen, C. (1947). The Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism in Norway. American Sociological Review, 12, 676–686.Google Scholar
  60. Juergensmeyer, M. (2003). Terror in the mind of god. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  61. Kalberg, Stephen. (1980). Max Weber’s types of rationality: Cornerstones for the analysis of rationalization processes in history. American Journal of Sociology, 85, 1145–1179.Google Scholar
  62. Kaplan, B. (1994). “Remnants of the Papal Yoke”: Apathy and opposition in the Dutch reformation. The Sixteenth Century Journal, 25, 653–669.Google Scholar
  63. Kaufman, J. (2008). Corporate law and the Sovereignty of States. American Sociological Review, 73, 402–425.Google Scholar
  64. Keister, L. (2008). Conservative protestants and wealth: How religion perpetuates asset poverty. American Journal of Sociology, 113, 1237–1271.Google Scholar
  65. Kloppenberg, J. (1998). The virtues of liberalism. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  66. Landes, D. (1998). The wealth and poverty of nations. New York: Norton.Google Scholar
  67. MacKinnon, M. (1988). Calvinism and the infallible assurance of grace: The Weber thesis reconsidered. British Journal of Sociology, 39, 143–177.Google Scholar
  68. MacKinnon, M. (1990). Weber, western christianity, and “Wirtschaftsethik”: A corrective to eisenstadt. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 15, 186–193.Google Scholar
  69. Mansbach, R. (2006). Calvinism as a precedent for Islamic radicalism. Brown Journal of World Affairs, 12, 103–115.Google Scholar
  70. Mathews, S. (1912). The social origin of theology. American Journal of Sociology, 18, 289–317.Google Scholar
  71. Maurer, H. (1924). The sociology of protestantism. American Journal of Sociology, 30, 257–286.Google Scholar
  72. Maurer, H. H. (1925). Studies in the Sociology of Religion II. Religion and American Sectionalism. The Pennsylvania German. The American Journal of Sociology, 30(4), 408–438.Google Scholar
  73. McCleary, R., & Barro, R. (2006). Religion and economy. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 20, 49–72.Google Scholar
  74. McKinnon, A. (2010). Elective affinities of the protestant ethic: Weber and the chemistry of capitalism. Sociological Theory, 28, 108–126.Google Scholar
  75. Means, R. (1965). Weber’s thesis of the protestant ethic: The ambiguities of received doctrine. The Journal of Religion, 45, 1–11.Google Scholar
  76. Merton, R. (1968). Social theory and social structure. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
  77. Mitchell, W. (1914). Human behavior and economics: A survey of recent literature. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 29, 1–47.Google Scholar
  78. Mullan, D. (1995). Theology in the church of scotland 1618-c. 1640: A Calvinist consensus? The Sixteenth Century Journal, 26(3), 595–617.Google Scholar
  79. Munch, R. (1981). Talcott parsons and the theory of action. American Journal of Sociology, 86, 709–739.Google Scholar
  80. Munch, R. (2001). The ethics of modernity. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
  81. Pareto, V. (2000 (1901)). The rise and fall of elites. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar
  82. Parker, C. (2014). Diseased bodies, defiled souls: Corporality and religious difference in the reformation. Renaissance Quarterly, 67(4), 1265–1297.Google Scholar
  83. Parsons, T. (1935). H. M. Robertson on Max Weber and his school. Journal of Political Economy, 43, 688–696.Google Scholar
  84. Parsons, T. (1938). The role of ideas in social action. American Sociological Review, 3, 652–664.Google Scholar
  85. Parsons, T. (1947). Introduction to Max Weber: The theory of social and economic organization (pp. 3–86). New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  86. Parsons, T. (1951). The social system. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
  87. Parsons, T. 1967 (1937). The structure of social action. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  88. Parsons, T., & Smelser, N. (1956). Economy and society. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  89. Pellicani, L. (1988). Weber and the myth of calvinism. Telos, 20, 57–85.Google Scholar
  90. Peltonen, M. (2008). The Weber thesis and economic historians. London, Max Weber Studies (pp. 79–98).Google Scholar
  91. Rachfahl, F. (2001 (1909)). Review of the protestant ethic. In D. J. Chalcraft & A. Harrington (Eds.), The protestant ethic debate (pp. 55–59). Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.Google Scholar
  92. Rawls, J., & ebrary, Inc. (2010). On my religion. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  93. Robertson, H. M. (1933). Aspects of the rise of economic individualism. Cambridge: At the University Press.Google Scholar
  94. Samuelsson, K. (1961). Religion and economic action. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
  95. Scheler, M. 1964 (1914). The thomist ethic and the spirit of capitalism. Sociological Analysis, 25, 4–19.Google Scholar
  96. Scoville, W. (1953). The Huguenots in the French economy, 1650–1750. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 67, 423–444.Google Scholar
  97. Slack, K. (2013). On the origins and intention of Benjamin Franklin’s “On the Providence of God in the Government of the World”. The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 137(4), 345–379.Google Scholar
  98. Smelser, N. (1997). Problematics of sociology. California: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  99. Smelser, N., & Swedberg, R. (2005). The sociological perspective on the economy. In N. Smelser & R. Swedberg (Eds.), The handbook of economic sociology (pp. 3–26). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  100. Snyder, B. (2013). From vigilance to busyness: A Neo-Weberian approach to clock time. Sociological Theory, 31(3), 243–266.Google Scholar
  101. Sombart, W. (1928 (1913)). Le bourgeois. Paris: Éditions Payot.Google Scholar
  102. Sorokin, P. (1970). Social and cultural dynamics. Boston: Porter Sargent.Google Scholar
  103. Squicciarini, M., & Voigtländer, N. (2015). Human capital and industrialization: Evidence from the age of enlightenment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130(4), 1825–1883.Google Scholar
  104. Stark, R. (1964). Class, radicalism, and religious involvement in Great Britain. American Sociological Review, 29(5), 698–706.Google Scholar
  105. Stark, W. (1968). Place of catholicism in Max Weber’s sociology of religion. Sociological Analysis, 29(4), 202–210.Google Scholar
  106. Stokes, R. (1975). Afrikaner calvinism and economic action: The weberian thesis in South Africa. American Journal of Sociology, 81, 62–81.Google Scholar
  107. Swedberg, R. (1998). Max Weber and the idea of economic sociology. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  108. Swedberg, R. (2003). Principles of economic sociology. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  109. Swedberg, R. (2005). The economic sociology of capitalism: An introduction and agenda. In V. Nee & R. Swedberg (Eds.), The economic sociology of capitalism (pp. 3–40). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  110. Swidler, A. (1986). Culture in action: Symbols and strategies. American Sociological Review, 51, 273–286.Google Scholar
  111. Tawney, R. (1930). Foreword to Weber, Max, The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism (pp. 1–11). New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.Google Scholar
  112. Tawney, R. 1962 (1920). Religion and the rise of capitalism. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company.Google Scholar
  113. Treasure, G. (2013). The huguenots. Princeton, NJ: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  114. Trinterud, L. (1955). Review of the history and character of calvinism by John McNeill. Theology Today, 12, 267–268.Google Scholar
  115. Troeltsch, E. (1966 (1912)). Protestantism and progress. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
  116. Tyacke, N. (1987). The rise of arminianism reconsidered. Past and Present, 115, 201–216.Google Scholar
  117. Vaisey, S. (2009). Motivation and justification: A dual-process model of culture in action. American Journal of Sociology, 114, 1615–1675.Google Scholar
  118. van den Brink, G. (2014). Calvinism and the European mind: Pitfalls and prospects in contemporary research. In G. van den Brink & H. M. Höpfl (Eds.), Calvinism and the making of the European mind (pp. 213–229). Boston: Brill.Google Scholar
  119. Walker, G. (1937). Capitalism and the reformation. Economic History Review, 8, 1–19.Google Scholar
  120. Walzer, M. (1963). Puritanism as a revolutionary ideology. History and Theory, 3, 59–90.Google Scholar
  121. Walzer, M. (1965). The revolution of the saints. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  122. Weber, M. (1930 (1905/1920)). The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.Google Scholar
  123. Weber, M. (1968 (1920)). Economy and society. New York: Bedminster Press.Google Scholar
  124. Weber, M. (1978 (1910)). Anticritical last word on the spirit of capitalism. American Journal of Sociology, 83, 1105–1131.Google Scholar
  125. Wuthnow, R. (2005). Religion and economic life. In N. Smelser & R. Swedberg (Eds.), The handbook of economic sociology (pp. 603–626). Princeton: Princeton University.Google Scholar
  126. Young, Cristobal. (2009). Model uncertainty in sociological research: An application to religion and economic growth. American Sociological Review, 74, 380–397.Google Scholar
  127. Zaret, D. (1985). The heavenly contract. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  128. Zaret, D. (1989). Religion and the rise of liberal-democratic ideology in 17th century England. American Sociological Review, 54, 163–179.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of SociologyUniversity of North TexasDentonUSA

Personalised recommendations