A Crisis of Confidence: Stakeholder Experiences of REDD+ in Indonesia
- 32 Downloads
Identifying challenges and opportunities for REDD+ will help to inform future policy and implementation of the program in Indonesia and other countries. The aim of this research is to identify and elucidate challenges and opportunities for REDD+ and other environmental governance initiatives. We present the perceptions of stakeholders and practitioners involved in REDD+ in Indonesia at multiple scales varying from global to local. Our research demonstrates stakeholders are struggling with problems of bureaucracy and a lack of confidence in REDD+, in addition to problems surrounding funding, logistics of implementation, corruption, stakeholder engagement and buy-in. Ultimately, our respondents and supporting documents reflect the particularly complex cultural and governance contexts in Indonesia. Despite challenges, REDD+ may have increased attention to these issues and acted as a catalyst for change. Effective implementation of REDD+ projects in Indonesia will require both nuanced understanding of the local and cultural context as well as long-term perspectives.
KeywordsReduced emissions from deforestation and forest degradation (REDD+) Forest management Payment for ecosystem services Environmental governance Indonesia Stakeholders Ethnography
This study was funded by the Fulbright Commission and a Dean’s Dissertation Fellowship from the University of Maryland.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
- (MoF) Ministry of Forestry Center for Forestry Planning and Statistics. (2009). Indonesia forestry outlook study. APFSOS II/WP/2009/13. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific.Google Scholar
- (WRI GFW) World Resources Institute Global Forest Watch. (2016). Indonesia | Global Forest Watch. 2016. Accessed 9 January 2016. http://www.globalforestwatch.org/country/IDN.
- (WWF) World Wide Fund for Nature. (2013). Palming Off a National Park: Tracking Illegal Oil Palm Fruit in Riau, Sumatra. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://awsassets.wwf.or.id/downloads/wwf_indonesia_palming_off_a_national_park_final.pdf.
- Abood, S. A., Lee, J. S. H., Burivalova, Z., Garcia-Ulloa, J., and Koh, L. P. (2014). Relative contributions of the logging, Fiber, oil palm, and mining industries to Forest loss in Indonesia. Conservation Letters. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/conl.12103/full.
- Barr, C. M., Resosudarmo, I. A. P., Dermawan, A., McCarthy, J., Moeliono, M., and Setiono, B., eds. (2006). Decentralization of Forest Administration in Indonesia: Implications for Forest sustainability, economic development, and community livelihoods. CIFOR. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=-bh1QmnPD_cC&oi=fnd&pg=PR5&dq=forest+concessions+sanctions+indonesia&ots=RnJsm167lp&sig=FnoVU9WCjYyrMZKqMGvlZATj7Eg.
- Beckert, B., Dittrich, C., and Adiwibowo, S. (2014). Contested land: An analysis of multi-layered conflicts in Jambi Province, Sumatra, Indonesia. Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies 7(1): 75–92.Google Scholar
- Bell, G. F. (2003). Indonesia: The new regional autonomy Laws, two years later. Southeast Asian Affairs: 117–131.Google Scholar
- Blumenthal, D., and Jannink, J.-L. (2016). A Classification of Collaborative Management Methods. https://vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/handle/10919/66233.
- Brockhaus, M., Obidzinski, K., Dermawan, A., Laumonier, Y., and Luttrell, C. (2012). An overview of Forest and land allocation policies in Indonesia: Is the current framework sufficient to meet the needs of REDD+? Forest Policy and Economics 18(May): 30–37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2011.09.004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Busch, J., Ferretti-Gallon, K., Engelmann, J., Wright, M., Austin, K. G., Stolle, F., Turubanova, S., et al (2015). Reductions in emissions from deforestation from Indonesia’s moratorium on new oil palm, timber, and logging concessions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112(5): 1328–1333. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1412514112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Carbon Market Watch. (2016). “REDD Archive - Carbon Market Watch.“ 2016. http://carbonmarketwatch.org/category/redd/.
- Carlson, K. M., Curran, L. M., Ratnasari, D., Pittman, A. M., Soares-Filho, B. S., Asner, G. P., Trigg, S. N., Gaveau, D. A., Lawrence, D., and Rodrigues, H. O. (2012). Committed carbon emissions, deforestation, and community land conversion from oil palm plantation expansion in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109(19): 7559–7564.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Charmaz, K. (2006). Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. Sage Publications Limited. Accessed 10 January 2019.http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=w2sDdv-S7PgC&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=charmaz+grounded+theory&ots=p_qn0SGJav&sig=pcji1ThvK9n979FiCal9QhdS7kE.
- Charmaz, K. (2011). Grounded theory methods in social justice research. The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research 4: 359–380.Google Scholar
- Climate Investment Funds. (2013). FIP: REDD+ Stakeholder Collaboration. Accessed 10 January 2016. https://www-cif.climateinvestmentfunds.org/sites/default/files/knowledge-documents/fip_learning_product_redd_stakeholder_collaboration_0.pdf.
- Colchester, M. (2010). Free, Prior and Informed Consent: Making FPIC Work for Forests and Peoples. Research Paper 11.Google Scholar
- Contreras-Hermosilla, A., Fay, C., Effendi, E., and Trends, F. (2005). Strengthening Forest Management in Indonesia through land tenure reform: Issues and framework for action. Forest Trends Washington, DC. Accessed 17 July 2014. http://www.worldagroforestrycentre.org/WCA2009/regions/southeast_asia/publications?do=view_pub_detail&pub_no=BK0092-05.
- Convention on Biological Diversity. (n.d.) “Indonesia - country profile.“ Convention on Biodiversity Country Profiles. Accessed 2 December 2018. https://www.cbd.int/countries/profile/default.shtml?country=id.
- Dermawan, A., Petkova, E., Sinaga, A. C., Muhajir, M., and Indriatmoko, Y. (2011). Preventing the risks of corruption in REDD+ in Indonesia. CIFOR. Accessed January 10th, 2019. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=K2czHGS_iIcC&oi=fnd&pg=PR3&dq=Preventing+the+risks+of+corruption+in+REDD%2B+in+Indonesia&ots=1Sjq_KqXFo&sig=CG1dah9GI11-bOXRT_p2A-2cFsI.
- Diana, E., and Jong, H. N. (2018). End of funding dims hopes for a Sumatran Forest targeted by palm oil growers. Mongabay Environmental News, November 9, 2018. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://news.mongabay.com/2018/11/end-of-funding-dims-hopes-for-a-sumatran-forest-targeted-by-palm-oil-growers/.
- Enrici, A., and Hubacek, K. (2018). Challenges for REDD+ in Indonesia: A case study of three project sites. Ecology and Society 23(2).Google Scholar
- Ewing-Chow, M., and Losari, J. J. (2015). Multiple authorisation: The legal complexity of Desentralisasi in Indonesia and the potential contribution of IIAs in reducing confusion. Indonesia Law Review 5(3): 241–256.Google Scholar
- Faure, M., and Wibisana, A. (2013). Regulating Disasters, Climate Change and Environmental Harm. Edward Elgar Publishing. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=xQsCAQAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR1&dq=Regulating+Disasters,+Climate+Change+and+Environmental+Harm&ots=0lIxr2YL9v&sig=Z4HACb6BaUE_Qp110icsXmu49KU.
- Forrester, G. (1999). Post-Soeharto Indonesia: Renewal or Chaos? St. Martin’s Press.Google Scholar
- Gallemore, C. T., and Moeliono, M. (2014). Discursive barriers and cross-scale Forest governance in Central Kalimantan, Indonesia. Ecology and Society 19(2).Google Scholar
- Global Canopy Programme. (2013). The REDD Desk | A Collaborative Resource for REDD Readiness. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.theredddesk.org/.
- Government of Norway, Government of the United Kingdom, and Government of Germany. (2015). Joint Statement by Germany, Norway and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland - Unlocking the Potential of Forests and Land Use. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.bmub.bund.de/fileadmin/Daten_BMU/Download_PDF/Klimaschutz/joint_statement_redd_cop21_en_bf.pdf.
- Holloway, V., and Giandomenico, E. (2009). The history of REDD policy. Carbon Planet White Paper, Adelaide, Australia.Google Scholar
- Human Rights Watch (HRW). (2013). The dark side of green growth the Human Rights impacts of weak governance in Indonesia’s forestry sector. Human Rights Watch.Google Scholar
- Indonesia Ministry of Forestry (2014). Forest area statistics 2013, Indonesia Ministry of Forestry, Jakarta. Accessed 25 January 2014. http://www.dephut.go.id/uploads/files/2fba7c7da8536e31671e3bb84f141195.pdf.
- Indrarto, Giorgio Budi, Prayekti Murharjanti, Josi Khatarina, Irvan Pulungan, Feby Ivalerina, Justitia Rahman, Muhar Nala Prana, Ida Aju Pradnja Resosudarmo, and Efrian Muharrom. (2012) The Context of REDD+ in Indonesia: Drivers, Agents and Institutions. Vol. 92. Cifor. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://theredddesk.org/sites/default/files/resources/pdf/2012/the_context_of_redd_in_indonesia.pdf.
- Indriatmoko, Y., Atmadja, S., Ekaputri, A. D., and Komalasari, M. (2014). Rimba Raya biodiversity reserve project, Central Kalimantan, Indonesia. In REDD+ on the Ground: A Case Book of Subnational Initiatives across the Globe. Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), Bogor, Indonesia. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.cifor.org/library/5280/rimba-raya-biodiversity-reserve-project-central-kalimantan-indonesia/.
- Jong, H. N. (2015). BP REDD+ officially disbanded - national - the Jakarta post. The Jakarta Post, January 29, 2015. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/01/29/bp-redd-officially-disbanded.html.
- Krishna, V. V., Pascual, U., and Qaim, M. (2014). Do emerging land markets promote forestland appropriation? Evidence from Indonesia. EFForTS Discussion Paper Series.Google Scholar
- Kuncoro, A., Adrison, V., Isfandiarni, I., et al. (2013). Varieties of governance of public goods delivery in Indonesia: The case of roads after decentralization and local democratization. Faculty of Economics, University of Indonesia. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://econ.feb.ui.ac.id/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/201301.pdf.
- Larson, A. M., Brockhaus, M., Sunderlin, W. D., Duchelle, A., Babon, A., Dokken, T., Pham, T. T., et al. (2013). Land tenure and REDD+: The good, the bad and the ugly. Global Environmental Change, April. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.02.014.
- Margono, B. A., Turubanova, S., Zhuravleva, I., Potapov, P., Tyukavina, A., Baccini, A., Goetz, S., and Hansen, M. C. (2012). Mapping and monitoring deforestation and Forest degradation in Sumatra (Indonesia) using Landsat time series data sets from 1990 to 2010. Environmental Research Letters 7(3): 034010.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Margono, B. A., Potapov, P. V., Turubanova, S., Stolle, F., and HansenM, C. (2014). Primary Forest cover loss in Indonesia over 2000–2012. Nature Climate Change.Google Scholar
- McFarland, W., Whitley, S., and Kissinger, G. (2015). Subsidies to key commodities driving Forest loss: Implications for private climate finance. Overseas Development Institute.Google Scholar
- Moeliono, M., Gallemore, C., Santoso, L., Brockhaus, M., and Di Gregorio, M. (2014). Information networks and power: Confronting the ‘Wicked problem’ of REDD+ in Indonesia. Ecology and Society 19, no. 2.Google Scholar
- Natahadibrata, N. (2013). Government recognizes customary forests. The Jakarta Post, May 18, 2013. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2013/05/18/government-recognizes-customary-forests.html.
- Parlina, I., and Nicholas, H. (2016). Norway slams slow REDD+ project Progress. The Jakarta Post, February 4, 2016. Accessed 10 January 2019.http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2016/02/04/norway-slams-slow-redd-project-progress.html.
- Parry, R. L. (2007). In the time of madness: Indonesia on the edge of Chaos. Grove Press. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=8imo5gPToE8C&oi=fnd&pg=PA1&dq=chaos+indonesia&ots=mKW483MAZE&sig=CuM4p1l6lt8kjIlJJZq4ConEt1E.
- Prasetyia, F. (2012). Corruption and decentralisation: Some evidence in Indonesia. Journal of Indonesian Applied Economics 4(1). Accessed 10 January 2019. http://jiae.ub.ac.id/index.php/jiae/article/view/121.
- Resosudarmo, I. A. P., Mardiah, S., and Utomo, N. (2011). Extractive Land Use, Spatial Planning and Their Implications for REDD+ in Indonesia: A Preliminary Analysis. 3rd IRSA International Institute, Padang, 19–21.Google Scholar
- Resosudarmo, I. A. P., Atmadja, S., Ekaputri, A. D., Intarini, D. Y., Indriatmoko, Y., and Astri, P. (2014). Does tenure security Lead to REDD+ project effectiveness? Reflections from five emerging sites in Indonesia. World Development, Land Tenure and Forest Carbon Management 55(March): 68–83 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2013.01.015.Google Scholar
- Romijn, E., Ainembabazi, J. H., Wijaya, A., Herold, M., Angelsen, A., Verchot, L., and Murdiyarso, D. (2013). Exploring different Forest definitions and their impact on developing REDD+ reference emission levels: A case study for Indonesia. Environmental Science & Policy 33: 246–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Royal Norwegian Embassy in Jakarta. (2016). Norway-Indonesia REDD+ Partnership - Frequently Asked Questions. Norway - the Official Site in Indonesia. Accessed 20 July 2016. http://www.norway.or.id/Norway_in_Indonesia/Environment/Questions%2D%2Danswers/#.V48A8I40rPc.
- Sills, Erin O., Atmadja, S. S., de Sassi, C., Duchelle, A. E., Kweka, D. L, Resosudarmo, I. A. P., and Sunderlin, W. D. (2014) REDD+ on the ground: A case book of subnational initiatives across the globe. CIFOR. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=co4UBgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=REDD%2B+on+the+ground:+A+case+book+of+subnational+initiatives+across+the+globe&ots=KiZfg-8Ynm&sig=yPSBYceSHSiorExOIPwIs1xo8sI.
- Simamora, A. P. (2011). SBY vows to protect palm oil interests. The Jakarta Post, March 26, 2011. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2011/03/26/sby-vows-protect-palm-oil-interests.html.
- Stevens, C., Winterbottom, R., Springer, J., and Reytar, K. (2014). Securing Rights, combating climate change: How strengthening community Forest Rights mitigates climate change. World Resources Institute.Google Scholar
- Sunderlin, W. D., Ekaputri, A. D., Sills, E. O., Duchelle, A. E., Kweka, D., Diprose, R., Doggart, N. et al. (2014a). The challenge of establishing REDD+ on the ground: Insights from 23 subnational initiatives in six countries. Vol. 104. CIFOR. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=5Ze2AwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR3&dq=%22redd+on+the+ground%22&ots=5kyGEple-V&sig=285Ej7DHfI_A-v1cb7iTPFX-YNI.
- Sunderlin, W. D., Sills, E. O., Duchelle, A. E., Ekaputri, A. D., Kweka, D., Toniolo, M. A., Ball, S., Doggart, N., Pratama, C. D., and Padilla, J. T. (2015). REDD+ at a critical juncture: Assessing the limits of polycentric governance for achieving climate change mitigation. International Forestry Review 17(4): 400–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Transparency International (2011). Forest governance integrity report Indonesia. Indonesia: TransperancyInternational. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://lccn.loc.gov/2012330932.
- UN REDD Programme. (2015). UN_REDD Programme 2016–2020 Strategic Framework. Accessed 10 January 2019. http://www.unredd.net/index.php?view=document&alias=14096-un-redd-pb14-2015-strategic-framework&category_slug=session-3-strategic-and-policy-issues&layout=default&option=com_docman&Itemid=134.
- UN-REDD Programme. (2013). Final Evaluation of the UN-REDD Programme In Indonesia. United Nations REDD Programme. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&ved=0ahUKEwjjorirvLrNAhVCJ5QKHZZ_DRoQFggkMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.unredd.net%2Findex.php%3Fview%3Ddownload%26alias%3D15077-final-evaluation-of-the-un-redd-programme-in-indonesia%26category_slug%3Dindonesia-187%26option%3Dcom_docman%26Itemid%3D134&usg=AFQjCNHnqpevUuEpNyMDp-pdnQo66OFDGw&sig2=VeOgXP3DJVdlf5-_X8GIMw.
- UN-REDD Programme. (2018). Regions and Countries Overview. 2018. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://www.unredd.net/regions-and-countries/regions-and-countries-overview.html.
- Vacik, H., Kurttila, M., Hujala, T., Khadka, C., Haara, A., Pykäläinen, J., Honkakoski, P., Wolfslehner, B., and Tikkanen, J. (2014). Evaluating collaborative planning methods supporting Programme-based planning in natural resource management. Journal of Environmental Management 144: 304–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Walsh, T. A., Asmui, Y.H., Hidayanto, Y., and Utomo, A. B. (2012). Supporting ecosystem restoration concessions in Indonesia’s production forests: A review of the licensing framework 2004–2012. Burung Indonesia-Climate and Land Use Alliance. Accessed 31 December 2015. http://www.climateandlandusealliance.org/uploads/PDFs/Working_Paper_ER_Licensing.pdf.
- World Bank Group. (2013). Emissions reduction program in Indonesia: A district-wide approach to REDD+. June 25, 2013. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://www.forestcarbonpartnership.org/sites/fcp/files/2013/june2013/District%20Approach%20to%20REDD%20in%20Indonesia%20-%20FCPF%20Carbon%20Fund%20Jun_20.pdf.
- WRI. (2018). World resources institute | understanding Indonesia’s OneMap initiative. February 2, 2018. Accessed 10 January 2018. https://www.wri.org/tags/understanding-indonesias-onemap-initiative.
- Yuliani, L., Indriatmoko, Y., Salim, A., Farid, I. Z., Muhajir, M., Prasetyo, L. B., and Heri, V. (2010). Biofuel Policies and Their Impact on Local People and Biodiversity: A Case Study from Danau Sentarum. Accessed 10 January 2019. https://mahider.ilri.org/handle/10568/20773.