Advertisement

Journal of the History of Biology

, Volume 52, Issue 3, pp 433–461 | Cite as

Conwy Lloyd Morgan, Methodology, and the Origins of Comparative Psychology

  • Evan ArnetEmail author
Original Research
  • 129 Downloads

Abstract

The British biologist, philosopher, and psychologist Conwy Lloyd Morgan is widely regarded as one of the founders of comparative psychology. He is especially well known for his eponymous canon, which aimed to provide a rule for the interpretation of mind from behavior. Emphasizing the importance of the context in which Morgan was working—one in which casual observations of animal behavior could be found in Nature magazine every week and psychology itself was fighting for scientific legitimacy—I provide an account of Morgan’s vision for the comparative psychologist qua professional psychologist. To this end, I explore the important connection between Morgan and the evolutionary theorist, philosopher, and psychologist Herbert Spencer. It is from Spencer, I contend, that Morgan inherited a number of his key epistemological and methodological concerns about the nascent science of comparative psychology. This extends all the way to the canon, which only works as intended when paired with a Spencerian understanding of mental evolution as a progressive linear sequence. Far from being an incidental residue of a pre-Darwinian time, hierarchy was intentionally built into the very core of Morgan’s scientific comparative psychology.

Keywords

Morgan’s canon Spencer Weismann Comparative psychology 

Notes

References

  1. Allen-Hermanson, Sean. 2005. Morgan’s Canon Revisited. Philosophy of Science 72 (4): 608–631.Google Scholar
  2. Baldwin, Melinda. 2015. Making “Nature”: The History of a Scientific Journal. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  3. Barton, Ruth. 2003. “Men of Science”: Language, Identity and Professionalization in the Mid-Victorian Scientific Community. History of Science 41 (1): 73–119.Google Scholar
  4. Boakes, Robert A. 1984. From Darwin to Behaviourism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Böhnert, Martin, and Christopher Hilbert. 2018. Other Minds than Ours: A Controversial Discussion on the Limits and Possibilities of Comparative Psychology in the Light of C. Lloyd Morgan’s Work. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 40 (3): 44.Google Scholar
  6. Campbell, C. B. G., and William Hodos. 1991. The Scala Naturae Revisited: Evolutionary Scales and Anagenesis in Comparative Psychology. Journal of Comparative Psychology 105 (3): 211–221.Google Scholar
  7. Churchill, Frederick B. 1978. The Weismann-Spencer Controversy Over the Inheritance of Acquired Characters”. In Human Implications of Scientific Advance, ed. E.G. Forbes, 451–468. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
  8. Churchill, Frederick B. 2015. August Weismann: Development, Heredity, and Evolution. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  9. Clatterbuck, Hayley. 2016. Darwin, Hume, Morgan, and the Verae Causae of Psychology. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 60 (December): 1–14.Google Scholar
  10. Clifford, William Kingdon. 1878. On the Nature of Things-in-Themselves. Mind 3 (9): 57–67.  https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/os-3.9.57.Google Scholar
  11. Clifford, William Kingdon. 1886. Body and Mind. In Lectures and Essays by the Late William Kingdon Clifford, 2nd ed, ed. Leslie Stephen and Frederick Pollock, 244–273. London: Macmillan and Co.Google Scholar
  12. Clifford, William Kingdon. 2010. Lectures and Essays by the Late William Kingdon Clifford, F. R. S.. Charleston, SC: Nabu Press.Google Scholar
  13. Costall, Alan. 1993. How Lloyd Morgan’s Canon Backfired. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 29 (2): 113–122.Google Scholar
  14. Costall, Alan. 1998. Lloyd Morgan, and the Rise and Fall of ‘Animal Psychology’. Society & Animals 6 (1): 13–29.Google Scholar
  15. Darwin, Charles. 1868. The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
  16. Dixon, Edward T. 1892. The Limits of Animal Intelligence. Nature 46 (1191): 392–393.Google Scholar
  17. Editor. 1876. I.—PREFATORY WORDS. Mind os-1 (1): 1–6.  https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/os-1.1.1.
  18. Faraday, F. J. 1884a. Mental Evolution in Animals. Nature 29 (745): 335–336.Google Scholar
  19. Faraday, F. J. 1884b. Mental Evolution in Animals. Nature 29 (747): 381.Google Scholar
  20. Faraday, F. J. 1884c. Mental Evolution in Animals. Nature 29 (749): 428.Google Scholar
  21. Fitzpatrick, Simon, and Grant Goodrich. 2017. Building a Science of Animal Minds: Lloyd Morgan, Experimentation, and Morgan’s Canon. Journal of the History of Biology 50 (3): 525–569.Google Scholar
  22. Galef Bennett G., Jr. 1988. Evolution and Learning before Thorndike: A Forgotten Epoch in the History of Behavioral Research. In Evolution and Learning, ed. R.C. Bolles and M.D. Beecher, 39–58. Hillsdale, NJ, England: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc.Google Scholar
  23. Galef Bennett G., Jr. 1998. Edward Thorndike: Revolutionary Psychologist. Ambiguous Biologist. American Psychologist 53 (10): 1128–1134.Google Scholar
  24. Gieryn, Thomas F. 1999. Cultural Boundaries of Science: Credibility on the Line. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  25. Green, Christopher D. 2009. The Curious Rise and Fall of Experimental Psychology in Mind. History of the Human Sciences 22 (1): 37–57.Google Scholar
  26. Gregorio, Mario A. di and Nick W. Gill. 1990. Charles Darwin’s Marginalia. New York and London: Garland.Google Scholar
  27. Hayward, J. M. 1884. Animal Intelligence. Nature 29 (746): 357.Google Scholar
  28. Herschel, John F. W. 1831. A Preliminary Discourse on the Study of Natural Philosophy. London: Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, and Green and John Taylor.Google Scholar
  29. Hodos, William, and C. B. G. Campbell. 1969. Scala Naturae: Why There Is No Theory in Comparative Psychology. Psychological Review 76 (4): 337–350.Google Scholar
  30. Hodos, William, and C. B. G. Campbell. 1990. Evolutionary Scales and Comparative Studies of Animal Cognition. In Neurobiology of Comparative Cognition, ed. Raymond P. Kesner and David S. Olton, 1–20. Hillsdale, NJ: Taylor & Francis.Google Scholar
  31. Hofstadter, Richard. 1992. Social Darwinism in American Thought, Reprint ed. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
  32. Jamieson, Dale, and Marc Bekoff. 1992. On Aims and Methods of Cognitive Ethology. PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 2: 110–124.Google Scholar
  33. Knoll, Elizabeth. 1986. The Science of Language and the Evolution of Mind: Max Müller’s Quarrel with Darwinism. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 22 (1): 3–22.Google Scholar
  34. Ladd, George Trumbull. 1887. Elements of Physiological Psychology; A Treatise of the Activities and Nature of the Mind from the Physical and Experimental Point of View. New York: C. Scribner’s Sons.Google Scholar
  35. Lakis, A. 1879. A Golden Eagle and a Decoy—Audacity of a Hawk. Nature 20 (501): 122.Google Scholar
  36. Lamarck, Jean Baptiste Pierre Antoine de Monet de. 1914. Zoological Philosophy. London: Macmillan and Co.Google Scholar
  37. Lennep, John H. van. 1882. Nepotism? Nature 25 (638): 266.Google Scholar
  38. Lidwell-Durnin, John. 2019. William Benjamin Carpenter and the Emerging Science of Heredity. Journal of the History of Biology.  https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-019-09568-3.Google Scholar
  39. Lovejoy, Arthur O. 1976. The Great Chain of Being A Study of the History of an Idea [1936]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  40. Lubbock, Sir John. 1882. Ants, Bees, and Wasps: A Record of Observations on the Habits of the Social Hymenoptera. New York: D. Appleton.Google Scholar
  41. Mitchell, Robert W., Nicholas S. Thompson, and H. Lyn Miles. 1997. Anthropomorphism, Anecdotes, and Animals. New York City: SUNY Press.Google Scholar
  42. Mivart, St George Jackson. 1871. On the Genesis of Species. New York: D. Appleton.Google Scholar
  43. Mivart, St George Jackson. 1892. The Limits of Animal Intelligence. Nature 46 (1194): 466.Google Scholar
  44. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1882. Animal Intelligence. Nature 26 (674): 523–524.Google Scholar
  45. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1883a. Note on the (Alleged) Suicide of the Scorpion. Transactions of the South African Philosophical Society 3 (2): 19–23.Google Scholar
  46. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1883b. Suicide of Scorpions. Nature 27 (692): 313–314.Google Scholar
  47. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1884a. Instinct: Is There a Science of Comparative Psychology? Nature 29 (746): 370–374.Google Scholar
  48. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1884b. Instinct. Nature 29 (748): 405.Google Scholar
  49. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1884c. Instinct. Nature 29 (750): 451–452.Google Scholar
  50. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1885. The Springs of Conduct: An Essay on Evolution. London: Kegan Paul, Trench & Company.Google Scholar
  51. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1886. On the Study of Animal Intelligence. Mind 11 (42): 174–185.Google Scholar
  52. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1887a. Animal Biology An Elementary Text-Book With Illustrations. London, Edinburgh: Rivingtons.Google Scholar
  53. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1887b. Physiological Psychology. Nature 36 (927): 290–292.Google Scholar
  54. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1890. Animal Life and Intelligence. London: E. Arnold.Google Scholar
  55. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1891. Psychology in America. Nature 43 (1118): 506–509.Google Scholar
  56. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1892a. The Limits of Animal Intelligence. Nature 46 (1192): 417.Google Scholar
  57. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1892b. Mental Evolution. An Old Speculation in a New Light. The Monist 2 (2): 161–177.Google Scholar
  58. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1893a. Dr. Weismann on Heredity and Progress Edited by Sherwood J. B. Sugden. Monist 4 (1): 20–30.Google Scholar
  59. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1893b. Monism, Three Aspects Of. The Monist 4: 321–332.Google Scholar
  60. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1894a. An Introduction to Comparative Psychology. London: Walter Scott Publishing Co.Google Scholar
  61. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1894b. Psychology for Teachers: With a Preface by J. G. Fitch. London: E. Arnold.Google Scholar
  62. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1896. Habit and Instinct. London: E. Arnold.Google Scholar
  63. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1914. Spencer’s Philosophy of Science. The Herbert Spencer Lecture Delivered at the Museum 7 November, 1913. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  64. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1923. Emergent Evolution. New York: Holt & Co.Google Scholar
  65. Morgan, Conwy Lloyd. 1932. A History of Psychology in Autobiography, vol. 2, 237–264. Worcester, MA: Clark University Press.Google Scholar
  66. Müller, F. Max. 1862. Lectures on the Science of Language. London: Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts, & Green.Google Scholar
  67. Offer, John. 2010. Herbert Spencer and Social Theory. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  68. Perrin, Robert G. 2017. Herbert Spencer: A Primary and Secondary Bibliography. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  69. Radick, Gregory. 2000. Morgan’s Canon, Garner’s Phonograph, and the Evolutionary Origins of Language and Reason. The British Journal for the History of Science 33 (1): 3–23.Google Scholar
  70. Radick, Gregory. 2007. The Simian Tongue: The Long Debate about Animal Language. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  71. Ramsden, Edmund, and Duncan Wilson. 2014. The Suicidal Animal: Science and the Nature of Self-Destruction. Past & Present 224 (1): 201–242.Google Scholar
  72. Richards, Robert J. 1977. Lloyd Morgan’s Theory of Instinct: From Darwinism to Neo-Darwinism. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 13 (1): 12–32.Google Scholar
  73. Richards, Robert J. 1987. Darwin and the Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  74. Romanes, George J. 1879. Intellect in Brutes. Nature 20 (June): 122–125.  https://doi.org/10.1038/020122c0.Google Scholar
  75. Romanes, George J. 1882. Animal Intelligence. London: Kegan Paul, Trench & Co.Google Scholar
  76. Romanes, George J. 1884a. Mental Evolution in Animals. Nature 29 (745): 336.Google Scholar
  77. Romanes, George J. 1884b. Mr. Lloyd Morgan on Instinct. Nature 29 (747): 379–381.Google Scholar
  78. Romanes, George J. 1884c. Mental Evolution in Animals. Nature 29 (748): 404.Google Scholar
  79. Romanes, George J. 1884d. Instinct. Nature 29 (749): 428.Google Scholar
  80. Romanes, George J. 1884e. Instinct. Nature 29 (751): 477.Google Scholar
  81. Romanes, George J. 1895. Mind and Motion and Monism. New York and London: Longmans, Green, and Co.Google Scholar
  82. Romanes, George J., and Charles Darwin. 1884. Mental Evolution in Animals. New York: D. Appleton.Google Scholar
  83. Rosenzweig, Mark R., Wayne H. Holtzman, Michel Sabourin, and David Belanger. 2005. History of the International Union of Psychological Science (IUPsyS). East Sussex, UK: Psychology Press.Google Scholar
  84. Ruse, Michael. 2009. Monad to Man: The Concept of Progress in Evolutionary Biology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  85. Schwartz, Joel S. (ed.). 2010. Darwin’s Disciple: George John Romanes, A Life in Letters. Philadelphia, PA: American Philosophical Society.Google Scholar
  86. Schwitzgebel, Eric. 2014. Introspection. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Edward N. Zalta, (Summer 2014 ed.). http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2014/entries/introspection/.
  87. Secord, Anne. 1994. Corresponding Interests: Artisans and Gentlemen in Nineteenth-Century Natural History. The British Journal for the History of Science 27 (4): 383–408.Google Scholar
  88. Shanahan, Timothy. 2004. The Evolution of Darwinism: Selection, Adaptation and Progress in Evolutionary Biology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  89. Shaw, J. 1881. Singular Behaviour of a Squirrel. Nature 24 (608): 167.Google Scholar
  90. Smith, C. U. M. 1982. Evolution and the Problem of Mind: Part 1. Herbert Spencer. Journal of the History of Biology 15 (1): 55–88.Google Scholar
  91. Spalding, Douglas A. 1954. Instinct: With Original Observations on Young Animals. The British Journal of Animal Behaviour 2 (1): 2–11.Google Scholar
  92. Spencer, Herbert. 1855. The Principles of Psychology. London: Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans.Google Scholar
  93. Spencer, Herbert. 1857. Progress: Its Law and Causes. The Westminster Review 67: 445–447, 451, 454–456, 464–465.Google Scholar
  94. Spencer, Herbert. 1870. The Principles of Psychology, vol. 1. London: Williams.Google Scholar
  95. Spencer, Herbert. 1887. The Factors of Organic Evolution. New York: D. Appleton.Google Scholar
  96. Spencer, Herbert. 1894. The Inadequacy of Natural Selection. New York: D. Appleton.Google Scholar
  97. Staley, Thomas W. 2009. The Journal Mind in Its Early Years, 1876–1920: An Introduction. Journal of the History of Ideas 70 (2): 259–263.Google Scholar
  98. Thomas, Roger K. 2001. Lloyd Morgan’s Canon: A History of Misrepresentation. History and Theory in Psychology Eprint Archive. http://bit.do/eWSAG.
  99. Thorndike, Edward L. 1898. Animal Intelligence: An Experimental Study of the Associative Processes in Animals. The Psychological Review: Monograph Supplements 2 (4): i1–i109.Google Scholar
  100. Turner, Frank M. 1978. The Victorian Conflict between Science and Religion: A Professional Dimension. Isis 69 (3): 356–376.Google Scholar
  101. Valsiner, Jaan. 2011. Comparative Methodology as the Human Condition; Conwy Lloyd Morgan and the Use of Animal Models in Science. In Striving for the Whole: Creating Theoretical Syntheses, ed. Rainer Diriwachter and Jaan Valsiner, 151–161. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar
  102. Wedgwood, Julia. 1882. A Pet Baboon. Nature 25 (636): 217–218.Google Scholar
  103. Weinstein, David. 2017. Herbert Spencer. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. Edward N. Zalta.https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2018/entries/spencer/.
  104. Weismann, August. 1883. Ueber die Vererbung. Berlin: Fischer.Google Scholar
  105. Weismann, August. 1893. The Germ-Plasm: A Theory of Heredity. New York: Scribner’s.Google Scholar
  106. Wilson, David A. H. 2002. Experimental Animal Behaviour Studies: The Loss of Initiative in Britain 100 Years Ago. History of Science 40 (3): 291–320.Google Scholar
  107. Wilson, David A. H. 2011. British Animal Behaviour Studies in the Twentieth Century: Some Interdisciplinary Perspectives. In The Psychology of the Human-Animal Bond, ed. Christopher Blazina, Güler Boyra, and David Shen-Miller, 25–44. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  108. Wozniak, Robert H. 1993. Conwy Lloyd Morgan, Mental Evolution, and the Introduction to Comparative Psychology. In An Introduction to Comparative Psychology, ed. Conwy Lloyd Morgan, 7–19. London: Routledge/Thommes.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Indiana University BloomingtonBloomingtonUSA

Personalised recommendations