Advertisement

Empirica

pp 1–22 | Cite as

Income and wealth of euro area households in times of ultra-loose monetary policy: stylised facts from new national and financial accounts data

  • Manuel Rupprecht
Original Paper
  • 13 Downloads

Abstract

It is often purported that the ECB’s ultra-loose monetary policy significantly affects household income and financial wealth. Considering selected euro area countries, this paper addresses two questions: first, how did households net interest income develop in recent years? Second, did portfolio structures change? Based on recently extended national accounts data, I derive stylised facts suggesting that net interest income indeed changed with monetary policy. However, patterns differ across countries. Whereas households in some countries suffered from declining incomes, in other countries they achieved incomes which, considered in real terms, were substantially higher than before. Tentative links to household balance sheets and their interest rate fixation suggest that these factors outweigh the significance of monetary policy. Regarding portfolios, however, less divergence is observed. Risk-taking did not increase in any country, despite the low yields of safe assets. General statements claiming that the ECB’s monetary policy has solely negative effects for household finances therefore seem to be inadequate.

Keywords

Monetary policy Household wealth Interest income Portfolio structure 

JEL Classification

E21 E43 G11 

References

  1. Aizemann J, Cheung Y-W, Ito H (2016) The interest rate effect of private saving: alternative perspectives. NBER working paper no. 22872Google Scholar
  2. Ampudia M, Ehrmann M (2017) Macroeconomic experiences and risk taking of euro area households. Eur Econ Rev 91(C):146–156CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Annuß C, Rupprecht M (2016) Anlageverhalten privater Haushalte in Deutschland: Die Rolle der realen Rendite“, in Schäfer, D., ed., NiedrigzinsenUrsachen, Wirkungen, Ausstiegsoptionen, DIW Quarterly. J Econ Res 85(1):95–109Google Scholar
  4. Annuß C, Rupprecht M (2017) Sparen in Zeiten niedriger Zinsen—wirtschaftspolitische Unterstützung nötig? Wirtschaftsdienst 97(2):130–134CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Aron J, Duca JV, Muellbauer J, Murata K, Murphy A (2012) Credit, housing collateral, and consumption: evidence from Japan, the UK, and the US. Rev Income Wealth 58(3):397–423CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Arrondel L, Bartiloro L, Fessler P, Lindner P, Mathä TY, Rampazzi C, Savignac F, Schmidt T, Schürz M, Vermeulen P (2014) How do households allocate their assets? stylised facts from the Eurosystem household finance and consumption suvey. ECB working paper no. 1722Google Scholar
  7. Attanasio OP, Weber P (1995) Is consumption growth consistent with intertemporal optimization? evidence from the consumer expenditure survey. J Polit Econ 103(6):1121–1157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Attanasio OP, Weber P (2010) Consumption and saving: models of intertemporal allocation and their implications for public policy. J Econ Lit 48(3):693–751CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Badarinza C, Campbell JY, Ramadorai T (2017) International comparative household finance. Ann Rev Econ 8(1):111–144CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bean C, Broda C, Takatoshi I, Kroszner R (2015) Low for long? causes and consequences of persistently low interest rates. Geneva Report on the World Economy 17, CEPR Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  11. Beer C, Gnan E, Ritzberger-Gründwald D (2016) Saving, portfolio and loan decisions of households when interest rates are very low—survey evidence for Austrian Households. Monet Policy Econ Q1(2016):14–32Google Scholar
  12. Bekaert G, Hoyem K, Hu W-Y, Ravina E (2017) Who is internationally diversified? evidence from the 401(k) plans of 296 firms. J Financ Econ 124(1):86–112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Beznoska M, Ochmann R (2013) The interest elasticity of savings: a structural approach with german micro data. Empir Econ 45:371–399CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. BIS (2014) Global financial markets under the spell of monetary policy. 84. BIS annual report 2014, Chapter 2, pp 23–39Google Scholar
  15. Carboni G, Geiger F, Rupprecht M (2013) The task force of the monetary policy committee of the ESCB, “Corporate finance and economic activity in the Euro area. ECB occasional paper no. 151Google Scholar
  16. Cohn R, Kolluri B (2003) Determinants of household savings in G7 countries: recent evidence. Appl Econ 35(10):1199–1208CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Cooper R, Zhu G (2016) Household finance over the life-cycle: what does education contribute? Rev Econ Dyn 20:63–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cooper I, Sercu P, Vanpee R (2013) The equity home bias puzzle: a survey. Found Trends Finance 7(4):289–416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Dekabank (2013) Die Realzinsfalle: Kosten für die Sparer. Volkswirtschaftliche Kurzinformation, DekabankGoogle Scholar
  20. Deuflhard F, Dimitris G, Roman I (2017) Financial literacy and savings account returns. J Eur Econ Assoc 54:18–38Google Scholar
  21. Deutsche Bundesbank (2014a) Methodological changes in the financial accounts—background, approach and selected results. Monthly report, October, 13–26Google Scholar
  22. Deutsche Bundesbank (2014b) Private debt—status quo, need for adjustment and policy implications. Monthly report, January, 53–65Google Scholar
  23. Deutsche Bundesbank (2015) German households’ saving and investment behaviour in light of the low interest-rate environment. In: Monthly report, October, pp 13–31Google Scholar
  24. Deutsche Bundesbank (2016a) The macroeconomic impact of quantitative easing in the euro area. Monthly report, June, 29–53Google Scholar
  25. Deutsche Bundesbank (2016b) Distributional effects of monetary policy. Monthly report, September, 13–36Google Scholar
  26. Deutsche Bundesbank (2017a) Monetary policy indicators at the lower bound based on term structure models. Monthly report, September, 13–34Google Scholar
  27. Deutsche Bundesbank (2017b) Recent developments in the indebtedness of the private non-financial sector in selected Euro-area countries. Monthly report, January, 41–58Google Scholar
  28. Devine J (2016) Death of the saver: how low interest rates are punishing the risk-averse. US News and World Report—Money, 10/19/2016. http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/savingandinvesting/death-of-the-saver-how-low-interest-rates-are-punishing-the-risk-averse/ar-AAj8YSP. Accessed 19 Sept 2017
  29. Dobbs R, Lund S, Koller T, Shwayder A (2013) QE and ultra-low interest rates: distributional effects and risks. McKinsey Global Institute Discussion Paper, NovemberGoogle Scholar
  30. Draghi M (2016) Addressing the causes of low interest rates. Introductory Speech held at a panel on “The Future of Financial Markets: A Changing View of Asia” at the Annual Meeting of the Asian Development Bank, 2 May 2016. https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2016/html/sp160502.en.html
  31. EIOPA (2017) Financial stability report, JuneGoogle Scholar
  32. European Central Bank (2009) Housing finance in the Euro area. Occasional paper no. 101Google Scholar
  33. French K, Poterba J (1991) Investor diversification and international equity markets. Am Econ Rev 81(2):222–226Google Scholar
  34. Geiger F, Muellbauer J, Rupprecht M (2016) The housing market, household portfolios and the german consumer. ECB working paper no. 1904Google Scholar
  35. Gräf B, Rakau O (2013) Niedrigzinsen dämpfen Sparneigung der privaten Haushalte. Ausblick Deutschland: Deutschland nach der Wahl, DB Research, 1 OctoberGoogle Scholar
  36. Holzhausen A, Sikova S (2014) The impact of the low interest rate policy on private households in the Eurozone. Allianz economic research working paper no. 176Google Scholar
  37. Hüfner F, Koske I (2010) Explaining household saving rates in G7 countries. OECD economics department working paper no. 754Google Scholar
  38. Illes A, Lombardi M (2013) Interest rate pass-through since the financial crisis. BIS Q Rev September:57–66Google Scholar
  39. Krusell P, Smith A (1998) Income and wealth heterogeneity in the macroeconomy. J Polit Econ 106(5):867–896CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Mandler M, Scharnagl M, Volz U (2016) Heterogeneity in Euro area monetary policy transmission: results from a large multi-country BVAR model. Deutsche Bundesbank discussion paper no. 03/2016Google Scholar
  41. Marek (2017) Saving patterns in the low-interest-rate setting—results of the 2016 PHF summer survey. Deutsche Bundesbank research brief no. 12Google Scholar
  42. McCarthy Y, McQuinn K (2017) Deleveraging in a highly indebted property market: who does it and are there implications for household consumption? Rev Income Wealth 63(1):95–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Necker S, Ziegelmeyer M (2016) Household risk taking after the financial crisis. Quat Rev Econ Finance 59:141–160CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. O’Farrell R, Rawdanowicz L, Inaba K-I (2016) Monetary policy and inequality. OECD economics department working paper no. 1281Google Scholar
  45. Rachel L, Smith T (2015) Secular drivers of the global real interest rate. Bank of England staff working paper no. 571Google Scholar
  46. Rodriguez Palenzuela D (2016), S. Dees and the saving and investment task force, “savings and investment behaviour in the Euro area”. ECB occasional paper no. 167Google Scholar
  47. Rösl G (2013) EZB-Niedrigzinspolitik enteignet die Sparer. Börsen-Zeitung, 7 June 2013, p 7Google Scholar
  48. Rupprecht M (2015) Who-to-whom information in the financial accounts of Germany—compilation, challenges and its usage for monetary policy. In: Proceedings of the 60th ISI world statistics congress, Rio de Janeiro, pp 631–636Google Scholar
  49. Rupprecht M (2017) Zur Einführung des ESVG 2010 in die deutsche Finanzierungsrechnung. In: Mink R, Voy K (eds) Die gesamtwirtschaftliche Finanzierungsrechnung—Revision und Anwendung in ökonomischen Analysen. Metropolis, Marburg, pp 147–167Google Scholar
  50. Sajedi R, Thwaites G (2016) Why are real interest rates so low? the role of the relative price of investment goods. IMF Econ Rev 64(4):635–659CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Summers L (2017) Secular stagnation even truer today. Wall Street J. http://larrysummers.com/2017/06/01/secular-stagnation-even-truer-today/. Accessed 25 May 2017

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Muenster School of BusinessMuensterGermany

Personalised recommendations