Does a sum of toxic units exceeding 1 imply adverse impacts on macroinvertebrate assemblages? A field study in a northern Japanese river receiving treated mine discharge
In ecological risk assessment, sum-of-toxic-unit approaches based on measured water quality factors such as trace metals are used to infer ecological impacts in the environment. However, it is uncertain whether the use of such approaches yields accurate risk predictions. To address this issue, we investigated and compared (1) water quality, including trace metals, and (2) benthic macroinvertebrate communities in a northern Japanese river receiving treated discharge from an abandoned mine and in a nearby reference river. As a sum-of-toxic-unit approach, we employed a cumulative criterion unit (CCU), namely, the sum of the ratios of the dissolved concentrations of a metal (Cu, Zn, Cd, or Pb) divided by the US Environmental Protection Agency hardness-adjusted environmental water quality criterion for that metal. Compared with the reference sites, at the metal-contaminated sites, the richness, abundance, and structure of macroinvertebrate communities were little affected, with CCUs of 1.7 to 7.4, suggesting that CCU values exceeding 1 do not always indicate marked adverse impacts on these metrics. Further study is still required to derive a more compelling conclusion on the generally applicable relationships between CCUs and ecological impacts on river invertebrates. This would lead to better ecological risk assessments based on sum-of-toxic-unit approaches.
KeywordsHeavy metals Aquatic insects Invertebrates Species richness Streams Ecological impacts
We are grateful to Susumu Norota and Kazuto Ohmori of Hokkaido Research Organization for their help in study site selection, and Shosaku Kashiwada and Daiki Kitamura of Toyo University for their help in metal analysis. The paper does not necessarily reflect the policies or views of any government agencies. Useful comments by anonymous reviewers are greatly appreciated.
Preparation of this manuscript was supported partly by the Environment Research and Technology Development Fund (5RF-1801) of the Environmental Restoration and Conservation Agency of Japan.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
- Environment Canada. (2012). Metal mining technical guidance for environmental effects monitoring. Gatineau: Environment Canada.Google Scholar
- Hokkaido Prefecture (2017). Report on work, survey, and analysis for preventing abandoned mine pollution in the fiscal year of 2016.Google Scholar
- Iwasaki, Y., Kagaya, T., & Matsuda, H. (2018a). Comparing macroinvertebrate assemblages at organic-contaminated river sites with different zinc concentrations: Metal-sensitive taxa may already be absent. Environmental Pollution, 241, 272–278. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2018.05.041.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Iwasaki, Y., Schmidt, T. S., & Clements, W. H. (2018b). Quantifying differences in responses of aquatic insects to trace metal exposure in field studies and short-term stream mesocosm experiments. Environmental Science & Technology, 52(7), 4378–4384. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.7b06628.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Jones, J. I., Murphy, J. F., Collins, A. L., Spencer, K. L., Rainbow, P. S., Arnold, A., Pretty, J. L., Moorhouse, A. M. L., Aguilera, V., Edwards, P., Parsonage, F., Potter, H., & Whitehouse, P. (2019). The impact of metal-rich sediments derived from mining on freshwater stream life. Reviews of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 247, 1–79. https://doi.org/10.1007/398_2018_21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Luoma, S. N., & Rainbow, P. S. (2008). Metal contamination in aquatic environments. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Manly, B. F. J., & Navarro Alberto, J. A. (2016). Multivariate statistical methods: A primer (4th ed.). Boca Raton: CRC press.Google Scholar
- Merrington, G., An, Y.-J., Grist, E. P. M., Jeong, S.-W., Rattikansukha, C., Roe, S., et al. (2014). Water quality guidelines for chemicals: Learning lessons to deliver meaningful environmental metrics. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 21(1), 6–16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-013-1732-8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- R Core Team (2018). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.Google Scholar
- U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (1994). Method 200.8: Determination of trace elements in waters and wastes by inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry, Revison 5.4. Cincinnati, OH.Google Scholar
- U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (2002). National Recommended Water Quality Criteria: EPA822-R-02-047. Washington.Google Scholar
- U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (2007). Aquatic life ambient freshwater quality criteria—Copper 2007 revision, EPA-822-F-07-001. WashingtonGoogle Scholar