# Towards conceptual coherence in the research on mathematics learner identity: a systematic review of the literature

## Abstract

This paper presents the results of a systematic review of the empirical literature, reported in research journals, on Mathematics Learner Identity (MLI). In the mathematics education research field, arguments have been made that the conceptualization of Mathematics Identity (MI) is inconsistent and this makes the literature as a whole incoherent. This study aims to summarize how the concept has been employed and to develop an integrative model for analyzing concept-definitions and concept-operationalizations of MLI. An analysis of 69 papers revealed 3 main dimensions that characterized how identity is conceptually defined in any research literature (social/subjective, enacted/representational and change/stability) and 5 main categories that describe how the literature has implemented these dimensions operationally (identity as individual attributes; identity as narratives; identity as a relationship with specific practices; identity as ways of acting; and identities as afforded and constrained by local practices). An emphasis on representational aspects of identities, particularly during higher education, and enacted and practice-related identities during primary and secondary education research was found. The discussion shows how the field would be clarified if studies made their choices of conceptualization clear in terms of these dimensions and categories, and if research as a whole becomes more aware of restrictions/limitations in identity research, particularly at different points of the educational trajectory of students.

## Keywords

Learner identity Mathematics education Mathematical identities Literature review## Notes

### Acknowledgements

The work of the first author was funded by the National Commission for Scientific and Technological Research in Chile (CONICYT) and by the Center for Mathematical Modeling through a Basal project (CMM) and Unité Mixte Internationale UMI CNRS 2807.

## References

- Ali-Khan, C., & Siry, C. (2014). Sharing seeing: Exploring photo-elicitation with children in two different cultural contexts.
*Teaching and Teacher Education, 37*, 194–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Andersen, L., & Ward, T. J. (2014). Expectancy-value models for the STEM persistence plans of ninth-grade, high-ability students: A comparison between black, hispanic, and white students.
*Science Education, 98*(2), 216–242.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Anderson, D. D., & Gold, E. (2006). Home to school: Numeracy practices and mathematical identities.
*Mathematical Thinking and Learning, 8*(3), 261–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Archer, L., Dewitt, J., Osborne, J., Dillon, J., Willis, B., & Wong, B. (2012). Balancing acts: Elementary school girls’ negotiations of femininity, achievement, and science.
*Science Education, 96*(6), 967–989.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Atweh, B., & Cooper, T. (1995). The construction of gender, social class and mathematics in the classroom.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 28*, 293–310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Axelsson, G. B. (2009). Mathematical identity in women: The concept, its components and relationship to educative ability, achievement and family support.
*International Journal of Lifelong Education, 28*(3), 383–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Bishop, J. P. (2012). She’s always been the smart one. I’ve always been the dumb one: Identities in the mathematics classroom.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 43*(1), 34–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Black, L. (2004). Differential participation in whole-class discussions and the construction of marginalised identities.
*Journal of Educational Enquiry, 5*(1), 34–54.Google Scholar - Black, L., Mendick, H., & Solomon, Y. (Eds.). (2008).
*Mathematical relationships in education: Identities and participation*. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar - Black, L., Williams, J., Hernandez-Martinez, P., Davis, P., Pampaka, M., & Wake, G. (2010). Developing a ‘leading identity’: The relationship between students’ mathematical identities and their career and higher education aspirations.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 73*(1), 55–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Black, L., Wiliams, J., Choudry, S., Pickard-Smith, K. & Ryan, B. (2017). Exploring the ‘seeds’ of disengagement: A methodological framework for researching young children’s identifications with the formal school curriculum. Manuscript submitted for publication.Google Scholar
- Boaler, J. (1999a). Creating mathematical futures through an equitable teaching approach: The case of Railside School.
*Teachers College Record, 110*(3), 608–645.Google Scholar - Boaler, J. (1999b). Participation, knowledge and beliefs: A community perspective on mathematics learning.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 40*(3), 259–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Boaler, J. (2002). Paying the price for “ sugar and spice ”: Shifting the analytical lens in equity research.
*Mathematical Thinking and Learning, 4*(2–3), 127–144.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Boe, M. V. (2012). Science choices in Norwegian upper secondary school: What matters?
*Science Education, 96*(1), 1–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Braathe, H. J., & Solomon, Y. (2015). Choosing mathematics: The narrative of the self as a site of agency.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 89*(2), 151–166.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Brubaker, R., & Cooper, F. (2000). Beyond “identity”.
*Theory and society, 29*(1), 1–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Campbell, T., Lee, H., Kwon, H., & Kyungsuk, P. (2012). Student motivation and interests as proxies for forming STEM identities.
*Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 32*(3), 532–540.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Chronaki, A. (2005). Learning about ‘learning identities’ in the school arithmetic practice: The experience of two young minority Gypsy girls in the Greek context of education.
*European Journal of Psychology of Education, 20*(1), 61–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Cobb, P., Gresalfi, M., & Hodge, L. L. (2009). An interpretive scheme for analyzing the identities that students develop in mathematics classrooms.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 40*(1), 40–68.Google Scholar - Craig, T. S. (2013). Conceptions of mathematics and student identity: Implications for engineering education.
*International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 44*(7), 1020–1029.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Darragh, L. (2013). Constructing confidence and identities of belonging in mathematics at the transition to secondary school.
*Research in Mathematics Education, 15*(3), 215–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Darragh, L. (2015). Recognising ‘good at mathematics’: Using a performative lens for identity.
*Mathematics Education Research Journal, 27*(1), 83–102.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Darragh, L. (2016). Identity research in mathematics education.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 93*(1), 19–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - de Abreu, G. (1995). Understanding how children experience the relationship between home and school mathematics.
*Mind, Culture, and Activity, 2*(2), 119–142.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Eccles, J. (2009). Who am I and what am I going to do with my life? Personal and collective identities as motivators of action.
*Educational Psychologist, 44*(2), 78–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Empson, S. B. (2003). Low-performing students and teaching fractions for understanding: An interactional analysis.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 34*(4), 305–343.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Epstein, D., Mendick, H., & Moreau, M.-P. (2010). Imagining the mathematician: Young people talking about popular representations of maths.
*Discourse-Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 31*(1), 45–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Erikson, E. (1968).
*Identity youth and crisis*. New York: Norton & Company.Google Scholar - Flores, M. A., & Day, C. (2006). Contexts which shape and reshape new teachers’ identities: A multi-perspective study.
*Teaching and Teacher Education, 22*(2), 219–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hannula, M. S. (2012). Exploring new dimensions of mathematics-related affect: Embodied and social theories.
*Research in Mathematics Education, 14*(2), 137–161.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hernandez, P. R., Schultz, P., Estrada, M., Woodcock, A., & Chance, R. C. (2013). Sustaining optimal motivation: A longitudinal analysis of interventions to broaden participation of underrepresented students in STEM.
*Journal of Educational Psychology, 105*(1), 89–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Heyd-Metzuyanim, E. (2013). The co-construction of learning difficulties in mathematics-teacher-student interactions and their role in the development of a disabled mathematical identity.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 83*(3), 341–368.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Hodge, L. (2008). Student roles and mathematical competence in two contrasting elementary classes.
*Mathematics Education Research Journal, 20*(1), 32–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Holland, D., Lachicotte, W. J., Skinner, D., & Cain, C. (1998).
*Identity and agency in cultural worlds*. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar - Holmegaard, H. T., Madsen, L. M., & Ulriksen, L. (2014). To choose or not to choose science: Constructions of desirable identities among young people considering a STEM higher education programme.
*International Journal of Science Education, 36*(2), 186–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Horn, I. S. (2008). Turnaround students in high school mathematics: Constructing identities of competence through mathematical worlds.
*Mathematics Thinking and Learning, 10*(3), 201–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Lesko, A. C., & Corpus, J. H. (2006). Discounting the difficult: How high math-identified women respond to stereotype threat.
*Sex Roles, 54*(1–2), 113–125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Lim, J. H. (2008). The road not taken: Two African-American girls’ experiences with school mathematics.
*Race, Ethnicity and Education, 11*(3), 303–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - McGee, E. O., & Martin, D. B. (2011). You would not believe what I have to go through to prove my intellectual value! Stereotype management among academically successful black mathematics and engineering students.
*American Educational Research Journal, 48*(6), 1347–1389.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Mendick, H. (2005). A beautiful myth? The gendering of being/doing ‘good at maths’.
*Gender and Education, 17*(2), 203–219.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Nasir, N. S., & Cobb, P. (2007).
*Improving access to mathematics: Diversity and equity in the classroom. Multicultural education series*. New York: Teachers College Press.Google Scholar - Nasir, N. S., & Hand, V. (2008). From the court to the classroom: Opportunities for engagement, learning, and identity in basketball and classroom mathematics.
*Journal of the Learning Science, 17*(2), 143–179.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Nivens, R. A., & Otten, S. (2017). Assessing journal quality in mathematics education.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 48*(4), 348–368.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Noland, C. M. (2006). Auto-photography as research practice: Identity and self-esteem research.
*Journal of research Practice, 2*(1), 1–19.Google Scholar - Pronin, E., Steele, C. M., & Ross, L. (2004). Identity bifurcation in response to stereotype threat: Women and mathematics.
*Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 40*(2), 152–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Radovic, D., Black, L., Salas, C. E., & Williams, J. (2017). Being a girl mathematician: Diversity of positive mathematical identities in a secondary classroom.
*Journal for Research of Mathematics Education, 48*(4), 434–464.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Sfard, A. (2006). Telling ideas by the company they keep: A response to the critique by Mary Juzwik.
*Educational Researcher, 35*(9), 22–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Sfard, A., & Prusak, A. (2005). Telling identities: In search of an analytic tool for investigating learning as a culturally shaped activity.
*Educational Researcher, 34*, 14), 14–14), 22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Smith, C. (2010). Choosing more mathematics: Happiness through work?
*Research in Mathematics Education, 12*(2), 99–115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Solomon, Y. (2007). Not belonging? What makes a functional learner identity in undergraduate mathematics?
*Studies in Higher Education, 32*(1), 79–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Solomon, Y. (2008).
*Mathematical literacy: Developing identities of inclusion*. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar - Solomon, Y. (2012). Finding a voice? Narrating the female self in mathematics.
*Educational Studies in Mathematics, 80*(40574), 171–183.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Solomon, Y., Lawson, D., & Croft, T. (2011). Dealing with ‘fragile identities’: Resistance and refiguring in women mathematics students.
*Gender and Education, 23*(5), 565–583.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Stentoft, D., & Valero, P. (2009). Identities-in-action.
*Nordic Studies in Mathematics Education, 14*(3), 55–77.Google Scholar - Stetsenko, A., & Arievitch, I. M. (2004). The self in cultural-historical activity theory. Reclaiming the unity of social and individual dimensions of human development.
*Theory & Psychology, 14*(4), 475–503.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Strauss, A., & Corbin, J. (1998).
*Basics of qualitative research*. Thousand oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar - Sutherland, L., Howard, S., & Markauskaite, L. (2010). Professional identity creation: Examining the development of beginning preservice teachers’ understanding of their work as teachers.
*Teaching and Teacher Education, 26*(3), 455–465.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Tate, E. D., & Linn, M. C. (2005). How does identity shape the experiences of women of color engineering students?
*Journal of Science Education and Technology, 14*(5–6), 483–493.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Thomas, J., & Harden, A. (2008). Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews.
*BMC Medical Research Methodology, 8*(1), 45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Turner, E., Dominguez, H., Maldonado, L., & Empson, S. (2013). English learners’ participation in mathematical discussion: Shifting positionings and dynamic identities.
*Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 44*(1), 199–234.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Varela, M., Martin, D. B., & Kane, J. M. (2012). Content learning and identity construction: A framework to strengthen African American students’ mathematics and science learning in urban elementary schools.
*Human Development, 55*(5), 319–339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Vygotsky, L. S. (1998).
*Child development, The collected works of L. S. Vygotsky*(Vol. 5). New York: Plenum.Google Scholar - Walkerdine, V. (1998).
*Counting girls out: Girls and mathematics*(2nd ed.). London and New York: Routledge Falmer.Google Scholar - Walls, F. (2009).
*Mathematical subjects: Children talk about their mathematics lives*. Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London and New York: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Wenger, E. (1998).
*Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and Identity*. Cambridge: Cambridge university press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Wetherell, M. (2010). The field of identity studies. In M. Wetherell & C. Mohanty (Eds.),
*The SAGE handbook of identities*(pp. 3–26). London, California, New Delhi and Singapore: Sage publications.CrossRefGoogle Scholar