What is Measured Matters: The Value of Third Party Hate Crime Monitoring
The appropriate recording of hate crime by state authorities (most usually by the police) has been recognized internationally as important to addressing hate crime. However, little scholarly attention has been paid to the role played by civil society in monitoring hate crime. This article will elaborate a range of purposes fulfilled by civil society organisations in collecting data on the extent and motivations of hate crime occurring in a given jurisdiction. Drawing on in-depth interviews with civil society organisations engaged in conducting third party monitoring of hate crime in one such jurisdiction, we will document the manner in which such monitoring systems (a) provide a means of reporting hate crime; (b) provide minority communities a means of reporting hate crime; (c) serve as a comparator to potentially unrepresentative official statistics where these are collected; (d) provide an evidence base for legislative change; and (e) provide a platform to affirm victims’ naming of their experiences as hate crimes. This internationally transferable taxonomy of the functions of civil society monitoring systems, is complemented by additional insights into the particular significance of such mechanisms in jurisdictions in which the construct of hate crime is not acknowledged in the justice system. On a critical note, the article will identify victim support as a natural extension of hate crime recording systems, noting that civil society organisations collecting data on hate crime in Ireland do not fulfil this remit. In summary, we argue for the value of civil society hate crime reporting systems as a source of challenge to otherwise hegemonic state constructions of jurisdictional hate crime. We advocate for international bodies to incorporate the financial support of civil society organisations into their monitoring functions on this basis.
KeywordsHate crime Civil society organisations Third party monitoring Recording hate crime
- Bowling, B. (1999). Violent racism: Victimisation, policing and social context. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Brå (2018) Reported Hate Crimes [online] available: https://www.bra.se/bra-in-english/home/crime-and-statistics/crime-statistics/reported-hate-crimes.html [accessed 20 June 2018].
- Chakraborti, N., & Hardy, S. (2015). LGB&T Hate Crime Reporting: Identifying barriers and solutions. Equality and Human Rights Commission.Google Scholar
- Christmann, K & Wong, K (2016). Hate crime reporting: Narrowing the gap between policy aspiration and victim inclination. British Journal of Community Justice, 14 (3).Google Scholar
- CEJI. (2012). Facing facts: Guidelines for monitoring of hate crimes and hate motivated incidents. Brussels: CEJI.Google Scholar
- Ellison, G., & Smith, L. (2017). Hate crime legislation and violence against sex workers: Lessons in policy and practice. In A. Haynes, J. Schweppe, & S. Taylor (Eds.), Critical perspectives on hate crime: Contributions from the island of Ireland (pp. 197–198). London: Palgrave MacMillan.Google Scholar
- Garda Inspectorate (2014) Crime Investigation [online], available: http://www.gsinsp.ie/en/GSINSP/Crime%20Investigation%20-%20Full%20Report.pdf/Files/Crime%20Investigation%20-%20Full%20Report.pdf [accessed 3 October 2017].
- Giannasi, P., & Hall, N. (2016). Policing hate crime: Transferable strategies for improving service provision to victims and communities internationally. In J. Schweppe & M. A. Walters (Eds.), The globalisation of hate: Internationalising hate crime? (pp. 190–212). Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hall, N. (2013). Hate crime (2nd ed.). London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Haynes A, Schweppe, J, Carr, J, Carmody, N. & Enright, S. (2015). Out of the shadows: Legislating for hate crime in Ireland preliminary findings, University of Limerick: HHRG.Google Scholar
- Haynes, A., & Schweppe, J. (2017). STAD: Stop transphobia and discrimination report. Dublin: TENI.Google Scholar
- Haynes, A., & Schweppe, J. (2018). Policing beyond the binary: The relationship between an Garda Síochána and the trans community in Ireland. Dublin: TENI.Google Scholar
- Herbert, R. J., & Rubin, I. (2011). Qualitative interviewing: The art of hearing data. Thousand Oaks: Sage.Google Scholar
- Home Office. (2016). Action against hate: The UK Government’s plan for tackling hate crime. London: National Archives.Google Scholar
- Iganski, P. (2008). ‘Hate’ Crime and the City. Bristol: Policy Press.Google Scholar
- Jarman, N. (2017). Acknowledgement, recognition and response: The criminal justice system and hate crime in Northern Ireland. In A. Haynes, J. Schweppe, & S. Taylor (Eds.), Critical perspectives on hate crime: Contributions from the island of Ireland (pp. 45–70). London: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Juang, R. (2006). Transgendering the politics of recognition. In S. Stryker & S. Whittle (Eds.), The transgender studies reader (pp. 706–719). New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Macpherson, W. (1999). The Stephen Lawrence inquiry, Cm 4262–1. London: The Stationery Office.Google Scholar
- National Crime Council (2015) Crime and Victimization Surveys [online] available; http://www.crimecouncil.gov.ie/statistics_cri_victim.html.
- National Crime Council (2016) Crime and Victimization Surveys [online] available; http://www.crimecouncil.gov.ie/statistics_cri_victim.html.
- Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (2009) Preventing and Responding to Hate Crimes: A resource guide for civil society organisations in the OSCE Region, http://www.osce.org/odihr/39821?download=true.
- Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (2014) Hate crime data collection and monitoring mechanisms: A practical guide, Available online: http://www.osce.org/odihr/datacollectionguide?download=true.
- Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (2003). DECISION No. 4/03. TOLERANCE AND NON-DISCRIMINATION [online] available: http://www.osce.org/mc/19382?download=true [accessed 20 November 2017].
- Perry, B. (2001). In the name of hate: Understanding hate crimes. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Perry, J. (2014). Evidencing the case for ‘hate crime’. In N. Chakraborti & J. Garland (Eds.), Responding to hate crime: The case for connecting policy and research. Bristol: The Policy Press.Google Scholar
- Perry, B. (2017), Legislating hate in Ireland: A view from here, in a. Haynes, J. Schweppe and S. Taylor (eds) Critical perspectives on hate crime: Contributions from the Island of Ireland, United Kingdom: Springer Nature, 71–92.Google Scholar
- Schweppe, J. (2012). Defining characteristics and politicizing victims: A legal perspective. Journal of Hate Studies, 10, 173–198.Google Scholar
- Swift Research (2005). West Yorkshire police hate crime reporting Centres, Unpublished Report submitted to West Yorkshire Police (report ref: 05/106).Google Scholar
- Taylor, S. (2011). Responding to racist incidents and crime: An issues paper for the equality authority. Maynooth: Equality Authority.Google Scholar
- TENI. (2014). STAD: Stop transphobia and discrimination report. Dublin: TENI.Google Scholar
- Terry, G., Hayfield, N., Clarke, V. & Braun, V. (2017). Thematic analysis. The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research in Psychology, 17–37.Google Scholar
- United for Intercultural Action (2013) Hate Crimes: Why hate crimes require special attention? The Impact of hate crimes on social cohesion, [online] available; http://www.unitedagainstracism.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/InfoLeafletHateCrimeA3.pdf [accessed 20 November 2017].
- Walker, M. (2007). Traveller/Ethnic minority communities’ attitudes to the Garda Síochána 2007 (Research Report No. 9/07). Dublin: An Garda Síochána.Google Scholar
- Whine, M. (2015a). Hate Crime in Europe. In N. Hall, A. Corb, P. Giannasi, & J. Grieve (Eds.), The Routledge international handbook on hate crime. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Whine, M. (2015b). National monitoring of hate crime in Europe: The case for a European level policy. In J. Schweppe & M. A. Walters (Eds.), The globalisation of Hate: internationalising hate crime. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Wong, K., Christmann, K., Meadows, L., Albertson, K., & Senior, P. (2013). Hate crime in Suffolk: Understanding prevalence and support needs. Sheffield: Sheffield Hallam University.Google Scholar