Advertisement

Axiomathes

, Volume 29, Issue 6, pp 639–652 | Cite as

Epistemology and the History of Science: The Problem of Historical Epistemology in the Italian Debate of the Twentieth Century

  • Fabio MinazziEmail author
Original Paper
  • 44 Downloads

Abstract

The essay, based also on unpublished writings, analytically reconstructs the Italian debate concerning the problem of historical epistemology and of the different relationships that can be established between epistemological reflection and the history of science. We start from awareness, à la Lakatos, that a “history of science without philosophy of science is blind, while a philosophy of science without the history of science is empty”. However, during the twentieth century Italian different theoretical positions emerged. Giulio Preti began by underlining how the history of science should be understood as the history of scientific thought. This position was close to that expressed by Giovanni Gentile for whom the history of science had to be reduced to the history of philosophy. Against this neo-realist claim, an epistemologist like Ludovico Geymonat reacted by underlining how science has its own history as a science. The critical debate between Preti and Geymonat has finally led the first to underline how the history of science must then be articulated in different conceptual traditions, while the latter ended up sharing the need to study the history of science as a history of scientific thought.

Keywords

Epistemology History of science Historical epistemology History of scientific thought Conceptual traditions Historical topic Historical essences Critical ontology 

Notes

References

  1. Dal Pra M (1965) Sulle teorie della storiografia della filosofia e della scienza nel novecento in Aa, Vv. Introduzione allo studio della Storia, Marzorati Editore, Milan, pp 441–494Google Scholar
  2. Dal Pra M (1988) Studi sull’empirismo critico di Giulio Preti. Bibliopolis, NaplesGoogle Scholar
  3. Gentile G (1920) Teoria generale dello spirito come atto puro in Opere, Sansoni, Florence 1944, vol III, sixth revised edition published (english translation The Theory of Mind as Pure Act, Macmillan, London 1922)Google Scholar
  4. Geymonat L (1960) Filosofia e filosofia della scienza, Feltrinelli, Milan, II ed. ivi 1961, III ed. ivi 1975Google Scholar
  5. Geymonat L (1970–76) Storia del pensiero filosofico e scientifico, Garzanti, Milan 1970-76, 7 volsGoogle Scholar
  6. Minazzi F (1984) Giulio Preti: bibliografia. Franco Angeli, MilanGoogle Scholar
  7. Minazzi F (1994) L’onesto mestiere del filosofare. Franco Angeli, MilanGoogle Scholar
  8. Minazzi F (2001) La passione della ragione. Università della Svizzera italiana-Thèlema Editore, Mendrisio-MilanGoogle Scholar
  9. Minazzi F (2004a) Il cacodemone neoilluminista. Franco Angeli, MilanGoogle Scholar
  10. Minazzi F (2004b) Contestare e creare. La Città del Sole, NaplesGoogle Scholar
  11. Minazzi F (2006) L’épistémologie comme herméneutique de la raison, Préface de Jean Petitot. La Città del Sole- Librairie Philosophique J Vrin, NaplesGoogle Scholar
  12. Minazzi F (2010) Ludovico Geymonat epistemologo. Mimesis, Milan-UdineGoogle Scholar
  13. Minazzi F (2011a) Suppositio pro signitficato non ultimato. Mimesis, Milan-UdineGoogle Scholar
  14. Minazzi F (2011b) Giulio Preti: le opere e i giorni. Mimesis, Milan-UdineGoogle Scholar
  15. Preti G (1956) Continuità ed “essenze” nella storia della filosofia, « Rivista Critica di Storia della Filosofia » , XI, III, IV, pp 359–373Google Scholar
  16. Preti G (1957) Storia del pensiero scientifico, Mondadori, Milan (II edition 1975)Google Scholar
  17. Preti G (1958) Considerazioni di metodo sulla storia delle scienze, « Rivista Critica di Storia della Filosofia». XIII, IV, pp 450–457Google Scholar
  18. Preti G (1966) Introduzione to the volume of the Enciclopedia Feltrinelli Fischer, Filosofia. In: Preti G (ed) translation by Gian Antonio De Toni and Carlo Ascheri. Feltrinelli Editore, MilanGoogle Scholar
  19. Preti G (1968) Retorica e logica. Einaudi, Turin (new critical ediction, Bompiani Milan) Google Scholar
  20. Preti G (1976) Saggi filosofici, “La Nuova Italia” Editrice, Florence 1976, 2 volsGoogle Scholar
  21. Preti G (2011) Philosophical Essays. Critic Rationalism as Historical-objective Transcendetalism. Peter Lang, BruxellesGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Philosophy of Science, Dipartimento di Scienze Teoriche ed ApplicateUniversità degli Studi dell’InsubriaVareseItaly

Personalised recommendations