What’s wrong with permaculture design courses? Brazilian lessons for agroecological movement-building in Canada
This paper focuses on the centrality of permaculture design courses (PDCs) as the principal sociopolitical strategy of the permaculture community in Canada to transform local food production practices. Building on the work of Antonio Gramsci and political agroecology as a framework of analysis, we argue that permaculture instruction remains deeply embedded within market and colonial relations, which orients the pedagogy of permaculture trainings in such a way as to reproduce the basic elements of the colonial capitalist economy among its practitioners. In the specific case of eastern Ontario, this embeddedness had the effect of diluting the transformative capacity of permaculture practitioners who were unable to create its own social movement organization. The paper then highlights key elements of the agroecological pedagogy used by the Brazilian Landless Rural Workers Movement (MST) and the Escola Latinoamericana de Agroecología (Latin American School of Agroecology, or ELAA) in Paraná, Brazil. The objective is to draw lessons from these inspiring experiences, in a rather unique context of struggles that can help to critically assess the pedagogical practices and principles presently informing permaculture communities in Canada and in advanced industrialized countries more generally. We then conclude by reiterating the key arguments and lessons drawn from the Brazilian pedagogical experiences, pointing out the importance of engagement and coalition-building with established rural and urban movements, as well as progressive farmer, Indigenous, and rural associations to foster a just and sustainable transformation of agri-food systems, starting at the local and regional levels. It also emphasizes the need for the most marginalized sectors to lead the way towards an agroecological transition.
KeywordsPermaculture MST Agroecology Emancipatory pedagogy Peasant movements Gramsci
Comissão Pastoral da Terra (Pastoral Land Commission)
Community Urban Food Forest
Escola Latinoamericana de Agroecología (Latin American School of Agroecology)
Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra (Landless Rural Workers Movement)
National Capital Commission
Ontario Public Interest Research Group
Permaculture Design Course
Permaculture Institute of Eastern Ontario
Permaculture Research Institute
Our gratitude goes out to all interviewees and activists, especially those from the Ottawa permaculture community, the ELAA and the Brazilian MST for sharing their knowledge and expertise informing this research. Your love for your community and dream for a sustainable world is inspiring. Thanks to Patricia Ballamingie and Jill Wigle for supervising the eastern Ontario fieldwork that went into the writing of this paper, and to reviewers for providing insightful feedback to improve this article. A special thanks to Tiaraju P. D’Andrea for research assistantship, as well as Stephen Brown, Peter Andrée, Alicia Martin, and Michael J. Wigginton for offering their feedback and editing. This paper was produced with the support of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, the Ontario Graduate Scholarship, and The Douglas Fullerton Award in Urban Studies.
Compliance with ethical standards
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
- Akram-Lodhi, H. 2013. Hungry for change: Farmers, food justice and the agrarian question. Winnipeg: Fernwood.Google Scholar
- Altieri, M. A. 1995. Agroecology: The science of sustainable agriculture. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
- Bang, J. M. 2005. Ecovillages: A practical guide to sustainable communities. New Society Publishers.Google Scholar
- Bernardes, J. 2016. Culture is the best way to build working class unity. Friends of the MST website, 21 June, access online, April 20th, 2017: http://www.mstbrazil.org/news/culture-best-way-build-working-class-unity.
- Bookchin, M. 1962. Our synthetic environment. New York: Knopf. (Published using pseudonym Lewis Herber).Google Scholar
- Branford, S., and J. Rocha. 2002. Cutting the wire: The story of the landless movement in Brazil. London: Latin America Bureau.Google Scholar
- Carson, R. 1962. Silent spring. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
- Conford, P. 2011. The organic alternative: Farming. In The development of the organic network: linking people and themes, 1945-95, 71–135. Edinburgh: Floris Books.Google Scholar
- Dawson, J. 2006. Ecovillages: New frontiers for sustainability, Schumacher Briefing. White River Junction: Chelsea Green Publishing.Google Scholar
- Fukuoka, M. 1990. The one-straw revolution: An introduction to natural farming. (Trans. L. Korn) New York: NYRB Classics.Google Scholar
- Gordon, U. 2008. Luddites, hackers and gardeners: Anarchism and the politics of technology. In Anarchy Alive! Anti-authoritarian politics from practice to theory, 109–138. London: Pluto Press.Google Scholar
- Gramsci, A., and Q. Hoare. 1971. Selections from the prison notebooks of Antonio Gramsci. New York: International Publishers.Google Scholar
- Hadich, C., and J. M. Tardín. 2009. Escola Latino Americana de Agroecología: Experiências camponesas de agroecología. Paraná.Google Scholar
- Holmgren, D. 2002. Permaculture: Principles and pathways beyond sustainability. Hepburn: Holmgren Design Services.Google Scholar
- Holmgren, D. 2011. The long view. In Permaculture pioneers: Stories from the new frontier, eds. K. Dawborn, and C. Smith, 18–29. Australia: Melliodora Publishing.Google Scholar
- Hopkins, R. 2008. The transition handbook: From oil dependency to local resilience. White River Junction: Chelsea Green Publishing.Google Scholar
- Jacob, J. 1997. New pioneers: The back-to-the-land movement and the search for a sustainable future. Pennsylvania: The Pennsylvania State University.Google Scholar
- Karriem, A. 2013. Space, ecology, and politics in the praxis of the Brazilian landless movement. In Gramsci: Space, nature, politics, ed. Michael Ekers, Gillian Hart, Stephen Kipfer and Alex Loftus, 142–160. Oxford: Wiley.Google Scholar
- Kelly-Bisson, C. 2013. Forests for the people: Resisting neoliberalism through permaculture design. Department of Geography & Environmental Studies, Carleton University.Google Scholar
- Kennedy, D. 1991. Permaculture and the sustainable city. Ekistics 58 (348/349): 210–215.Google Scholar
- Lawton, G. 2011. Thinking big. In Permaculture pioneers: Stories from the new frontier, ed. K. Dawborn, and C. Smith, 87–109.Google Scholar
- Mann, S. 2012. September 27. Episode 1223: The cost of a permaculture design course (Permabyte). The Permaculture Podcast. Retrieved from http://www.thepermaculturepodcast.com/2012/pdc-cost/.
- Massicotte, M. J. 2014. Beyond political economy: Political ecology and La Vía Campesina’s struggle for food sovereignty through the experience of the Escola Latinoamericana de Agroecologia (ELAA), Brazil. In Globalization and food sovereignty, eds. P. Andrée, J. Ayres, M. Bosia, and M.-J. Massicotte, 255–287. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McWilliams, C. 1939. Factories in the field: The story of migratory labor in the United States. Boston: Little, Brown and Company.Google Scholar
- Mollison, B. 1988. Permaculture: A designers manual. 2nd ed. Tyalgum: Tagari.Google Scholar
- Mollison, B., and D. Holmgren. 1978. Permaculture one: A perennial agriculture for human settlements. Tyalgum: Tagari.Google Scholar
- Movement Generation. 2013. Mission. http://www.movementgeneration.org/about-us/mission-and-history. Accessed 13 April 2013
- Odum, H. T. 1971. Environment, power, and society. 1st ed. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
- Ontario Public Interest Research Group (OPIRG). 2012. Working Groups. Retrieved from http://www.opirgcarleton.org/.
- Permaculture Global. 2017. Worldwide permaculture projects. https://permacultureglobal.org/. Accessed 23 Mar 2017.
- Permaculture Institute of Eastern Ontario. 2012. Home Page. http://eonpermaculture.ca. Accessed 13 Dec 2012
- Permaculture Ottawa. 2012. Permaculture Ottawa Facebook Group. Retrieved from https://www.facebook.com/groups/PermacultureInOttawa/.
- Pimbert, M. 2008. Towards food sovereignty: reclaiming autonomous food systems. London: International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED).Google Scholar
- Smith, J. S. 1950. Tree crops: A permanent agriculture. Washington, DC: Island Press.Google Scholar
- Smith, C. 2011. Introduction, ix-xx. In Permaculture pioneers: Stories from the new frontier, ed. K. Dawborn, and C. Smith, Tylagum: Melliodora Publishing.Google Scholar
- Stedile, J. P., and B. F. Mançano. 1999. Brava gente: A trajetória do MST e a luta pela terra no Brasil. São Paulo: Editora Fundação Perseu Abramo.Google Scholar
- Taylor, M. 2015. The political ecology of climate change adaptation: Livelihoods, agrarian change and the conflicts of development. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Van der Ploeg, J. D. 2009. The new peasantries: Struggles for autonomy and sustainability in an era of empire and globalization. London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
- Vergara-Camus, L. 2014. Land and freedom: The MST, the Zapatistas and peasant alternatives to neoliberalism. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar