Novel Live Alkaline Phosphatase Substrate for Identification of Pluripotent Stem Cells
Alkaline phosphatases (AP) are a class of enzymes that hydrolyze phosphate containing molecules under alkaline conditions. In humans, there are primarily four different types of this enzyme; intestinal, placental, placental-like and non-tissue specific forms. The non-tissue specific isozyme of AP is expressed in liver, bone and kidney. A similar isozyme was identified in pluripotent stem cells when monoclonal antibodies, TRA-2-49/6E, recognizing determinants of human embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells showed specific reactivity to this isoform.1 AP is also known to be expressed at high levels in other pluripotent stem cell types such as embryonic germ cells (EG), embryonic stem cells (ESC) and induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSC).2–5 Although definitive measures of pluripotency involves in-vitro tri-lineage differentiation and in-vivo teratoma formation, the most widely tested and validated panel for initial evaluation of ESC and iPSC consists of Stage Specific Embryonic Antigen SSEA4; Tumor Rejection Antigens TRA-1-60, TRA-1-81; AP; Oct4 and Nanog.6, 7
In the case of murine ESC, AP positive colony forming in-vitro assay is used as a measure of pluripotency to demonstrate the ability of cells to single cell clone, attach and proliferate.8 A similar assay has been adapted for hESC where the sensitivity of the AP positive Colony forming assay to detect loss of pluripotent hESC has been found to be more sensitive than marker expression.9 More recently, the onset of AP positive colonies during early stages of reprogramming is used as an initial indicator of successful reprogramming of cells. Furthermore, in some instances the number of AP positive colonies is used as a mark of reprogramming efficiency.10 Nevertheless, this marker alone is not a definitive marker for the established iPSC clones. Additional marker evaluation is necessary to identify and qualify bona fide iPSCs.11 AP expression levels is a less sensitive measure to differentiate between undifferentiated and early differentiating cells since its expression level is reported to be varied depending on the lineage of differentiation.12 AP staining has been used as a fast and easy method that results in a specific chromogenic or fluorescent staining of the pluripotent stem cells. However, the current methods using AP staining require cell fixation and/or result in end products that accumulate within the cells. As a result, these AP stained colonies often lose their morphology and cannot be propagated any further. Inability to further culture selected pluripotent colonies identified using AP staining is a serious disadvantage of this methodology. An ideal solution would be an AP substrate that stains cells without altering the integrity or characteristics of stem cells thereby allowing further expansion of the stained colonies.
Here in, we report the development and application of a novel fluorogenic live cell permeant substrate for AP (Live AP Stain). When incubated with cells for 20–30 min in basal culture media, this stain shows specific and robust staining of pluripotent cells such as human EC, murine and human ESC and iPSC with minimal or no staining of feeder cells and human fibroblasts. Stained colonies retain their morphology and preserve their cell health. The green fluorescence of the stained colonies is eliminated from cells 60–90 min after removal of the stain from the media. We have further utilized this stain in iPSC work flow to identify emerging iPSC clones during reprogramming of BJ human fibroblasts using CytoTune™; a Sendai-virus based non-integrating reprogramming method.13 Clones with robust AP staining were manually picked and propagated further. Expanded clones expressed other pluripotent markers, differentiated into cell types representative of the three germ layers and maintained a normal karyotype. These results indicate that AP Live Stain reported in this study does not alter the integrity or characteristics of the stained cells and is therefore an ideal tool to label early intermediates during iPSC generation or clonal populations of ESC for further selection and expansion.
Materials and Methods
All reagents purchased from Life Technologies, unless otherwise noted.
NTERA-2 cl.D1 (ATCC) and BJ human fibroblasts (ATCC) purchased from ATCC, were cultured as per recommendations.
hESC and hiPSC Culture
Feeder-dependent human H9 ESC (WA09, WiCell Research Institute) and internally generated hiPSC were cultured in hESC media comprising of DMEM/F-12 media containing 20% KnockOutTM SR (KSR), 10 µM MEM Non-Essential Amino Acids solution, 55 µM 2-Mercaptoethanol and 4 ng/ml basic FGF on mitotically inactivated mouse embryonic fibroblast (MEF) feeder layer and maintained in a 5% CO2, 37°C, humidified incubator. For feeder-free culture, hESC and hiPSC were cultured in StemPro® hESC SFM, supplemented with 100 µM 2-Mercaptoethanol and 8 ng/ml basic FGF grown on Geltrex®, hESC-qualified reduced growth factor basement membrane matrix coated onto tissue culture treated surfaces. hESC and hiPSC were routinely passaged either using Collagenase IV or the StemPro® EZPassage™ disposable stem cell passaging tool. hiPSC clones were mechanically picked and propagated during the early stages of reprogramming.
BJ human neonatal foreskin fibroblast cells (ATCC) were seeded at appropriate plating densities onto TC treated dishes and transduced with the CytoTune™-iPSC reprogramming kit overnight as per the product manual. Seven days post-transduction, cells were harvested in single cell suspension and re-seeded at the desired densities onto MEF feeders in hESC media. Compact colonies with distinct features of pluripotent stem cells started to emerge at around 2 weeks post- transduction. Colonies at 21 days post-transduction were identified based on robust alkaline phosphatase activity using the AP Live Stain. Individual clones were scored using a 27-gauge needle, picked manually and expanded further.
Preparation of Live Alkaline Phosphatase Stock Reagent
A 10 mM stock solution of the compound was prepared by careful dissolution of the AP Live Stain in tissue-culture grade DMSO. This stock was further diluted 1:100 in DMSO to yield 0.1 mM or 500X stocks (A14353, Life Technologies). These stocks are functionally stable over several months when stored at −20 C without repeated freeze thaw.
Live Alkaline Phosphatase Staining
ESC and iPSC cultures to be stained for AP activity were washed twice with fresh, sterile, pre-warmed basal DMEM/F-12 media before proceeding. A range of dilutions between 0.25 to 1 X was tested in both negative (BJ human fibroblasts and Murine embryonic fibroblasts) and positive control cells (H9 ESC) and 1X was found to be optimal in providing a robust signal (Supplement Figure 1). For all further experiments 1X working solution was used by diluting the 500X stock solution of the LIVE AP substrate in basal DMEM/F-12 media. Once diluted, the LIVE AP dye was immediately applied on to the adherent cell culture. The cells were incubated with the substrate for 20–30 min and washed twice with the basal DMEM/F-12 media to remove excess substrate. Following the final wash, fresh basal media was added prior to the visualization of fluorescent-labeled colonies under fluorescent microscopy using a standard FIT-C filter. Images were captured within 30–60 min after staining and the most robustly fluorescing colonies were marked for selection and expansion where appropriate. Following visualization, the basal media was replaced by fresh hESC growth media and the selected colonies were either manually picked or returned to the normal culture conditions.
Cells were fixed with 2% paraformaldehyde and blocked with buffer containing 5% Normal goat serum, 1% BSA, 0.1% Triton X100 in dPBS for 30 min. Primary antibodies were added to the cells and incubated at 4°C overnight followed by addition of appropriate secondary antibodies. DAPI was used for counter nuclei staining. Images were captured using a Zeiss Axiovision microscope and images were processed using Adobe Photoshop CS. Antibodies used in this study were: Oct4 (1:500, Abcam), SSEA4 (1:500,), Tra-1-60 (1:100,); Tra-1-81 (1:500,), βIII Tubulin (Tuj1, 1:2000, Sigma), Smooth muscle actin (1:2000, Sigma), α-fetoprotein (1:1000, Sigma), AlexaFluor 488 and AlexaFluor 594 Rabbit anti-mouse IgG (1:500). Alternate AP assays Elf97 and Vector Red (Vector Labs) staining was carried out as per Manufacturer’s protocol.
H9 ESC was seeded in Geltrex-coated 96 well dishes under feeder-free culture conditions. Cells were treated with experimental conditions in replicates of 6 and were either untreated (Control) or treated with the different lots of AP Live Stain. Conditions known to impact cell integrity such as incubation with 1% paraformaldeylde (PFA) or 50% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) were included as negative controls. Each condition, seeded in 6 replicates was first stained with the AP Live Stain and visually confirmed to be stained positive. Allowing 2 h after stain removal for the stained cells to lose their fluorescence staining, PrestoBlue™ Viability reagent was added to the cells and incubated at 37 C in 5% CO2 chamber over night (~20 h). Fluorescence was measured 18–20 h after PrestoBlue™ addition. Average value of the fluorescence reading was measured at 590 nm was plotted with error bars representing standard deviation.
Karyotype was carried out by CellLine Genetics. Results were based on cytogenetics analysis performed using GTL-banding technique on twenty G-banded metaphase cells.
Undifferentiated hESCs and iPSC were harvested using collagenase to generate embryoid bodies (EBs). Cells were cultured in suspension for 4 days in differentiation medium containing DMEM-F12 with Glutamax, 20% KSR, 100 µM MEM-NEAA, and 55 μM 2-mercaptoethanol. On day 5, EBs in suspension were seeded on Geltrex coated plates for an additional 17 days of differentiation in the same medium, then the cells were used for immunocytochemistry.
Rational design and development was utilized to develop a novel nontoxic AP Live Stain. An ideal nontoxic fluorescent end product was first chosen followed by its phosphorylation to create a phosphatase substrate. Subsequent modifications were carried out to enhance the cell permeability of the phosphatase substrate to create few candidate molecules. The methods, structures and compositions of these molecules are described in a separate study (Manuscript under preparation). A modified phosphorylated green fluorescent dye referred to as “AP Live Stain” was evaluated for pluripotent stem cell detection in this study.
Several different types of stem cells demonstrated robust and specific staining with AP Live Stain under identical incubation conditions. Incubating cultured colonies of 129/SvEv mESC (Fig. 2c) or H9 hESC (Fig. 2e) on a layer of MEF feeder cells displayed robust and specific staining of mESC or H9 hESC over MEF feeder cells. Furthermore, incubating established iPSC lines cultures on feeders that are derived from BJ fibroblasts using CytoTune™ iPS-Sendai Reprogramming method show equally strong AP staining (Fig. 2f). The minor differences noted in intensities between different cells types is largely due to size of the colony with the signal more robust in the larger human ESC and iPSC relative to the smaller mouse ESC or monolayer embryonal carcinoma cells. Additionally, in all cases, the typical morphology of the ESC colonies with high nucleus to cytoplasmic ratio with distinct refractive colony edges were retained after staining with AP Live Stain and was similar to the unstained control.
Figure 4b (panel i) shows a representative image of one of these clones stained with the AP Live Stain. This positively stained clone was scored using a 27 gauge needle during which process parts of the cells around the scoring region was removed and images immediately captured to demonstrate that the iPSC clones labeled with AP Live stain colony had distinct scores with bare regions along the scored edges (Fig. 4b, panel ii). Once the AP Live Stain was removed from the media and the cells allowed to recover for 2 h in normal ESC growth media, the scored colony was again imaged to show loss of the green fluorescence (Fig. 4b, panel iii). These cells, when allowed to recover over 48 h, were able to propagate and phase contrast image of the scored colony shows that the gaps along the scored edges of the colony are now filled with proliferating cells (Fig. 4b, panel iv). As a further confirmation of maintenance of pluripotency in the proliferating areas of the scored clone, all cells within the colony continued to stain positive for the pluripotence surface markers SSEA4 (labeled Green, Fig. 4b, panel v) and TRA-1-60 (labeled Red, Fig. 4b, panel v).
These results collectively demonstrate that the AP Live Stain is an inexpensive, straightforward and undemanding alternative to existing AP dyes with the added advantage of preserving cell integrity that allows for cell manipulation and proliferation post staining.
Surface antibodies are the most widely used method to specifically identify stem cells in heterogeneous cultures. In particular, SSEA4 and TRA antibodies have emerged as a benchmark for identifying pluripotent stem cells via immunostaining methods. Additional applications of these antibodies include enrichment of the stem cell population via FACS sorting and magnetic bead based separation methods.14 Small molecule dyes offer an attractive alternative to antibodies that involve expensive, tedious and time consuming workflows. Aside from workflow issues, potential microbial contamination of antibodies may render cells less useful for some downstream applications. In addition to AP, human embryonic stem cell lines also express drug transporter ABCG2 at high levels.15 Rapid efflux of ABCG2 substrates in emerging iPSC cell colonies result in Hoechstdim phenotype that, in combination with expression of other markers, is reported to be an accurate predictor of reprogramming success (11). A recent study screened a large chemical library and identified CDy1, a rosamine analog that specifically stains pluripotent stem cells.16 The mode of staining by this dye remains largely unknown, nevertheless, it stains both live human ESC and iPSC and can be used in fluorescence-activated cell sorting.17
Although, several of the methods described above offer characterization of ESC and iPSC, a need remains for reagents and methods that could simplify the workflow without any detrimental effects on the cells. An ideal scenario would be to accomplish the characterization of stem cells without leaving any morphological, physiological or chemical ‘footprint’ on them. We envisioned a nontoxic, cell permeant, fluorogenic stain that selectively reports on the activity of AP may meet the desired requirements. In order to meet the no ‘footprint’ requirement, this stain should permeate out of the cells after reporting AP activity. The newly designed AP Live Stain reported in this study meets all of these requirements to characterize iPSC and ESC. Since the resulting reporter fluorescent compound is a small molecule that can permeate out of the cells after a short period of time, the AP Live Stain extends the widely used AP assay from terminal staining assay to an assay for real time monitoring of pluripotent stem cell cultures without compromising cell integrity or requiring duplicate cultures. Besides its use in monitoring reprogramming process to screen and choose emerging colonies, it is also applicable to other work flow such as clonal expansion of cells for creation of genetically manipulated pluripotent stem cells where gross morphological changes are less apparent than marker expression.
Although, the focus of this report has been limited to applications of AP Live Stain for pluripotent stem cell work flow, it has potential use in several different applications. Since AP is an established marker for bone precursor cells, preliminary experiments indicate that the AP Live Stain also stains differentiating osteoblasts derived from mesenchymal stem cells (unpublished results). Thus, AP Live Stain could be utilized in HTS format for screening and indentifying inducers of bone formation. This stain could also serve as a research reagent for identification and detection of differentiating bone and utilized for enrichment of osteoblasts for downstream applications, i.e. 3D bone reconstruction and cell therapy. AP is also a general stem cell marker and has been used to identify in vivo niche of stem cells such as trabecular meshwork in limbal and corneal endothelium.18 Besides applications specific to stem cell, it could be used for tracking transgenic cells in transplantation experiments as AP has been used as a marker to indentify these cells.19
In conclusion, we have rationally designed and build a nontoxic cell permeant fluorogenic AP Stain with desirable features that enables characterization of ESC and iPSC without leaving a footprint on the cells. Its application could be expanded to several other clinical or diagnostic areas where AP is used as marker.
Conflict of Interest
All authors except MSR are currently employed at Life Technologies
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.