Life cycle assessments of consumer electronics — are they consistent?
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Background, aim, and scope
During the last decades, the electronics industry has undergone tremendous changes due to intense research leading to advanced technology development. Multiple life cycle assessment (LCA) studies have been performed on the environmental implications of consumer electronics. The aim of this review is to assess the consistency between different LCA studies for desktop computers, laptop computers, mobile phones and televisions (TVs).
Materials and methods
A literature study was conducted covering some key LCA contributions to the consumer electronics field. The focus is primarily on global warming potential during 100 years (GWP100) efficiency in different life cycle phases and secondarily on primary energy usage/electricity usages which are normalised per year to find inconsistencies.
The life cycle impact assessment GWP100 results for consumer electronics over the years suggest that most studies are of comparable quality; however, some studies are neither coherent nor transparent. Published LCAs for mobile phone and TV sets are consistent, whereas for laptop and desktop computers, the studies occasionally give conflicting messages.
The inconsistencies appear to be rooted in subjective choices and different system boundaries and lifetime, rather than lack of standardisation. If included, the amounts of emissions of sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and nitrogen trifluoride (NF3) are crucial to the GWP100 in the various life cycle phases for a desktop using liquid crystal display (LCD) screen. Another important observation is that the MEEuP methodology report/tool underestimates the GWP100 of electronic component manufacturing processes.
Between 1997 and 2010, the ISO 14040/44 standards have ensured a rather consistent set of GWP100 results for the studied products. However, the lack of transparency for consumer electronics LCAs sometimes makes benchmarking difficult. It is nevertheless possible to compare new LCA calculations to existing studies. It is also possible to reveal which product studies are consistent with studies of submaterials and subcomponents. In most cases, the GWP100 results for consumer electronics are consistent. Based on the survey of published work, recycling and other end-of-life processes have a tiny share of the total GWP100 score for consumer electronics.
Recommendations and perspectives
LCA researchers should as a rule, if possible, make a historical survey of their technical system to establish trends, proportions and relations. Policy makers ought to ask for these surveys when using LCAs for decision support. This charter is necessary as to understand the reasonableness of the results. Additions to the ISO14040/44 LCA standardisation for mass–volume products would be worthwhile as a means of increasing the consistency.
- Alonso, JC, Rodrigo, J, Castells, F (2003) Design for environment of electrical and electronic automotive components based on life cycle assessment. Gate to EHS, March 17: pp. 1-7
- Aoe T (2003) Case study for calculation of factor x (eco-efficiency) — comparing CRT TV, PDP TV and LCD TV. Proc. 3rd int symp env conscious design inverse man, Tokyo, Japan, Dec. 11–13, pp 650–655
- Apple (2009) iMac Environmental report, March 3, 2009
- Atlantic Consulting and IPU (1998) LCA study of the product group personal computers in the EU eco-label scheme. LCA study (version 1.2). EU eco-labels for personal computers, Atlantic Consulting and IPU
- Barba-Gutierrez, Y, Adenso-Diaz, B, Hopp, M (2008) An analysis of some environmental consequences of European electrical and electronic waste regulation. Res Cons Rec 52: pp. 481-495 CrossRef
- Barba-Gutierrez, Y, Adenso-Diaz, B, Hopp, M (2009) Eco-efficiency of electric and electronic appliances: a data envelopment analysis (DEA). Environ Model Assess 14: pp. 439-444 CrossRef
- Bergelin F (2008) Life cycle assessment of a mobile phone — a model on manufacturing, using, and recycling. Master thesis, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden
- Boyd, SB, Horvath, A, Dornfeld, D (2009) Life-cycle energy demand and global warming potential of computational logic. Environ Sci Technol 43: pp. 7303-7309 CrossRef
- Choi, BC, Shin, HS, Lee, SY (2006) Life cycle assessment of a personal computer and its effective recycling rate. Int J LCA 11: pp. 122-128 CrossRef
- Confidential (2009) LCA of HSDPA phone
- Dodbiba, G, Takahashi, K, Sadaki, J (2008) The recycling of plastic wastes from discarded TV sets: comparing energy recovery with mechanical recycling in the context of life cycle assessment. J Clean Prod 16: pp. 458-470 CrossRef
- Duan, H, Eugster, M, Hischier, R (2009) Life cycle assessment study of a Chinese desktop personal computer. Sci Total Environ 407: pp. 1755-1764 CrossRef
- Ecoinvent database (2008a) Name in db: laptop computer, at plant/GLO U
- Ecoinvent database (2008b) Name in db: use, computer, laptop, office use/CH U
- Ecoinvent database (2008c) Name in db: disposal, laptop computer, to WEEE treatment/CH U
- Ecoinvent database (2008d) Name in db: desktop computer, without screen, at plant/GLO U
- Ecoinvent database (2008e) Name in db: CRT screen, 17 inches, at plant/GLO U
- Ecoinvent database (2008f) Name in db: keyboard, standard version, at plant/GLO U
- Ecoinvent database (2008g) Name in db: mouse device, optical, with cable, at plant/GLO U
- Ecoinvent database (2008h) Name in db: use, computer, desktop, with CRT monitor, office use/RER U
- Ecoinvent database (2008i) Name in db: disposal, mouse device, optical, with cable, to WEEE treatment/CH U
- Ecoinvent database (2008j) Name in db: disposal, keyboard, standard version, to WEEE treatment/CH U
- Ecoinvent database (2008k) Name in db: disposal, desktop computer, to WEEE treatment/CH U
- Ecoinvent database (2008l) Name in db: disposal, CRT screen, 17 inches, to WEEE treatment/CH U
- Ecoinvent database (2008m) Name in db: LCD flat screen, 17 inches, at plant/GLO U
- Ecoinvent database (2008n) Name in db: disposal, LCD flat screen, 17 inches, to WEEE treatment/CH U
- European Commission (2005) MEEuP methodology report
- Feng, C, Ma, XG (2009) The energy consumption and environmental impacts of a color TV set in China. J Clean Prod 17: pp. 13-25 CrossRef
- Frey, SD, Harrison, DJ, Billett, EH (2006) Ecological footprint analysis applied to mobile phones. J Ind Ecol 10: pp. 199-216 CrossRef
- Goymann, M, Wittenwiler, M, Hellweg, S (2008) Environmental decision support for the construction of a “green mountain hut. Environ Sci Technol 42: pp. 4060-4067 CrossRef
- Gurauskiene, I, Varzinskas, V (2006) Eco-design methodology for electrical and electronic equipment industry. Environ Res Eng Manag 3: pp. 43-51
- Helling, RK, Russell, DA (2009) Use of life cycle assessment to characterise the environmental impacts of polyol production options. Green Chem 11: pp. 380-389 CrossRef
- Huawei Technologies (2009) Internal calculations in SimaPro 7 of printed board assemblies.
- IVF (2007a) European Commission DG TREN Preparatory studies for eco-design requirements ofEuPs. IVF Report 07004. Laptop used in office. Table 91
- IVF (2007b) European Commission DG TREN Preparatory studies for eco-design requirements of EuPs. IVF Report 07004. Desktop with 17” CRT-display used in an office. Table 97
- IVF (2007c) European Commission DG TREN Preparatory studies for eco-design requirements of EuPs. IVF Report 07004. Desktop with 17” LCD-display used in an office. Table 93
- Kim, S, Hwang, T, Overcash, M (2001) Life cycle assessment study of a color computer monitor. Int J LCA 6: pp. 35-43 CrossRef
- Lu, L, Wernick, IK, Hsiao, TY (2006) Balancing the life cycle impacts of notebook computers: Taiwan’s experience. Resour Conserv Recycl 48: pp. 13-25 CrossRef
- Muñoz, I, Gazulla, C, Bala, A (2009) LCA and ecodesign in the toy industry: case study of a teddy bear incorporating electric and electronic components. Int J LCA 14: pp. 64-72 CrossRef
- Nokia (2005) Integrated product policy pilot project — Stage I Final report: life cycle environmental issues of mobile phones
- Park, PJ, Lee, KM, Wimmer, W (2006) Development of an environmental assessment method for consumer electronics by combining top-down and bottom-up approaches. Int J LCA 11: pp. 254-264 CrossRef
- PE International (2008) Environmental footprint of ICT equipment in manufacture, use, and end-of-life. Presentation held at ECOC Brussels, Belgium, Sept 23
- Reap, J, Roman, F, Duncan, S (2008) A survey of unresolved problems in life cycle assessment — Part 1: goal and scope and inventory analysis. Int J LCA 13: pp. 290-300 CrossRef
- Rockström, J, Steffen, W, Noone, K (2009) A safe operating space for humanity. Nature 461: pp. 472-475 CrossRef
- Scharnhorst, W (2008) Life cycle assessment in the telecommunication industry: a review. Int J LCA 13: pp. 75-86 CrossRef
- Socolof, ML, Overly, JG, Geibig, JR (2005) Environmental life-cycle impacts of CRT and LCD desktop computer displays. J Clean Prod 13: pp. 1281-1294 CrossRef
- Tekawa M, Miyamoto S, Inaba A (1997) Life cycle assessment; an approach to environmentally friendly PCs. Proc IEEE Int Symp Electron Environ, May 5–7, San Francisco, CA, pp. 125–130
- Williams, E (2004) Energy intensity of computer manufacturing: hybrid assessment combining process and economic input–output methods. Environ Sci Technol 38: pp. 6166-6174 CrossRef
- Yung WKC, Chan HK, So JHT (2009) A life-cycle assessment for eco-redesign of a consumer electronic product. J Eng Design (electronic version)
- Zhou, X, Schoenung, JM (2007) An integrated impact assessment and weighting methodology: evaluation of the environmental consequences of computer display technology substitution. J Environ Manag 83: pp. 1-24 CrossRef
- Life cycle assessments of consumer electronics — are they consistent?
The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Volume 15, Issue 8 , pp 827-836
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links
- Consumer electronics
- GWP100 results
- Life cycle assessment
- Life cycle inventory
- Industry Sectors