Even More than Life Itself: Beyond Complexity Original Paper First Online: 24 August 2010 Received: 18 July 2010 Accepted: 05 August 2010 DOI :
10.1007/s10516-010-9119-7

Cite this article as: Mikulecky, D.C. Axiomathes (2011) 21: 455. doi:10.1007/s10516-010-9119-7
Abstract This essay is an attempt to construct an artificial dialog loosely modeled after that sought by Robert Maynard Hutchins who was a significant influence on many of us including and especially Robert Rosen. The dialog is needed to counter the deep and devastating effects of Cartesian reductionism on today’s world. The success of such a dialog is made more probable thanks to the recent book by A. Louie. This book makes a rigorous basis for a new paradigm, the one pioneered by the late Robert Rosen. If we are to make such a paradigm shift happen, it has to be in the spirit of the dialog. The relationship between science, economics, technology and politics has to be openly recognized and dealt with. The message that Rosen sent to us has to be told outside small select circles of devotees. The situation has even been described by some as resembling a cult. This is no way for universal truths like these to be seen. The essay examines why this present situation has happened and identifies the systemic nature of the problem in terms of Rosen’s concepts about systems. The dialog involves works by George Lakoff, W. Brian Arthur, N. Katherine Hayles, Robert Reich and Dorion Sagan. These scholars each have their own approach to identifying the nature of the interacting systems that involve human activity and the importance of identifying levels of abstraction in analyzing systems. Pooling their insights into different facets of a complex system is very useful in constructing a model of the self referential system that humans and their technology have shaped. The role of the human component in the whole earth system is the goal of the analysis. The impact of the Cartesian reductionist paradigm on science and the related aspects of human activity are examined to establish an explanation for the isolation of Rosen’s paradigm. The possible way to proceed is examined in the conclusion.

Keywords Complexity Category theory Biology Epistemology Ontology Robert Rosen A. Louie Earth system Organism Machine Brian Arthur Technology Causation Closed loops N. Katherine Hales Dorion Sagan Robert Reich Robert Maynard Hutchins Anticipatory system Network thermodynamics

References Abraham R, Marsden JE (1978) Foundations of mechanics. Benjamin/Cummings, Reading

Google Scholar Abraham R, Shaw CD (1982) Dynamics: the geometry of behavior; Part 1, periodic behavior. Aerial Press, Santa Cruz

Google Scholar Abraham R, Shaw CD (1983) Dynamics: the geometry of behavior; Part 2, Chaotic Behavior. Aerial Press, Santa Cruz

Google Scholar Abraham R, Shaw CD (1984) Dynamics: the geometry of behavior; Part 3, Global Behavior. Aerial Press, Santa Cruz

Google Scholar Abraham R, Shaw CD (1987) Dynamics: a visual introduction. In: Yates FE (ed) Self-organizing systems: the emergence of order. Plenum Press, NY

Google Scholar Abraham R, Shaw CD (1988) Dynamics: the geometry of behavior; Part 4, Bifurcation Behavior. Aerial Press, Santa Cruz

Google Scholar Arthur WB (2009) The nature of technology: what it is and how it evolves. Free Press, NY

Google Scholar Athans M, Dertouzos ML, Spann RN, Mason SJ (1974) Systems, networks, and computation: multivariable methods. McGraw-Hill, NY

Google Scholar Blackwell WA (1968) Mathematical modeling of physical networks. Macmillan, NY

Google Scholar Branin FH Jr (1966) The algebraic-topological basis for network analogies and the vector calculus. In: Fox J (ed) Proceedings of the symposium on generalized networks. Polytechnic Press of the Polytechnic Institute of Brooklyn, Brooklyn, NY, pp 453–491

Brayton RK (1971) Nonlinear reciprocal networks. In: Mathematical aspects of electrical network analysis, SIAM-AMS proceedings, III: 1–16, American Mathematical Society Providence, RI

Breedveldt PC (1984) Physical systems theory in terms of bond graphs, Ph.D. thesis, Enschede, The Netherlands

Caplan SR (1966) The degree of coupling and its relation to efficiency of energy conversion in multiple-flow systems. J Theor Biol 10:209–235

CrossRef Google Scholar Caplan SR (1968) Autonomic energy conversion II. An approach to the energetics of muscular contraction. Biophys J 8:1167–1193

CrossRef Google Scholar Cilliers P (2000) Complexity and postmodernism: understanding complex systems. Routledge, NY

Google Scholar Cruziat P, Thomas R (1988) SPICE-a circuit simulation program for physiologists. Agronomie 8:613–623

CrossRef Google Scholar deGroot SR, Mazur P (1962) Non-equilibrium thermodynamics. North-Holland, Amsterdam

Google Scholar Hayles NK (1999) How we became posthuman: virtual bodies in cybernetics, literature, and informatics. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago

Google Scholar Lakoff G (2004) Don’t think of an elephant: know your values and frame the debate. Chelse Green, White River Junction, Vermont

Google Scholar Lakoff G (2008) The political mind: why you can’t understand 21st-century American politics with an 18th-Century brain. Viking, New York

Google Scholar Lakoff G, Johnson BB (1999) Philosophy in the flesh: the embodied mind and its challenge to western thought. Basic Books, New York

Google Scholar Louie A (2007) A Rosen etymology, in system theory and biocomplexity. Chem Biodivers 4:2296–2314

CrossRef Google Scholar Louie Ah (2009) More than life itself: a synthetic continuation in relational biology. Ontos Verlag, Frankfurt

Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (1993) Applications of network thermodynamics to problems in biomedical engineering. New York University Press, New York

Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (1996) Complexity, communication between cells, and identifying the functional components of living systems: some observations. Acta Biotheor 44:179–208

CrossRef Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (2000) Robert Rosen: the well-posed question and its answer—why are organisms different from machines? Syst Res Behav Sci 17(5):419–432

CrossRef Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (2001) Network thermodynamics and complexity: a transition to relational systems theory. Comput Chem 25:369–391

CrossRef Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (2007a) Complexity science as an aspect of the complexity of science. In: Gershonen C, Aerts D, Edmonds B (eds) Worldviews science and us: philosophy and complexity. World Scientific, New Jersey, pp 30–52

CrossRef Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (2007b) Causality and complexity: the myth of objectivity in science. Chem Biodivers 4(10):2480–2490

CrossRef Google Scholar Mikulecky DC (2010) A new approach to the theory of management: manage the real complex system, not its model. In: Wallis SE (ed) Cybernetics and systems theory in management: tools, views, and advancements. Information science reference, Hershey

Google Scholar Onsager L (1931a) Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes I. Phys Rev 37:405–426

CrossRef Google Scholar Onsager L (1931b) Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes II. Phys Rev 38:2265–2279

CrossRef Google Scholar Oster GF, Auslander DM (1971a) Topological representations of thermodynamic systems-I. Basic concepts. J Franklin Inst 292:1–13

CrossRef Google Scholar Oster GF, Auslander DM (1971b) Topological representations of thermodynamic systems-II. Some elemental subunits for irreversible thermodynamics. J Franklin Inst 293:77–90

CrossRef Google Scholar Oster GF, Desoer CA (1971) Tellegen’s theorem and thermodynamic inequalities. J Theor Biol 32:219–241

CrossRef Google Scholar Oster GF, Perelson AS (1973) Systems, circuits, and thermodynamics. Israel J Chem 11:445–478

Google Scholar Oster GF, Perelson AS (1974) Chemical reaction dynamics. Part I: geometrical structure. Arch Rational Mech Anal 55:230–274

CrossRef Google Scholar Oster GF, Perelson A, Katchalsky A (1971) Network thermodynamics, nature 234:393–399 (See editorial: Networks in Nature, pp 380–381, same issue)

Oster GF, Perelson A, Katchalsky A (1973) Network thermodynamics: dynamic modeling of biophysical systems. Quart Rev Biophys 6:1–134

CrossRef Google Scholar Penfield P Jr, Spence R, Duinker S (1970) Tellegen’s theorem and electrical networks; research Mon. # 58. MIT Press, Cambridge

Google Scholar Perelson AS (1975) Network thermodynamics: an overview. Biophys J 15:667–685

CrossRef Google Scholar Perelson AS (1988) Toward a realistic model of the immune system. In: Perelson AS (ed) Theoretical immunology. Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, pp 377–401

Google Scholar Perelson AS, Oster GF (1974) Chemical reaction dynamics. Part II: reaction networks. Arch Rational Mech Anal 57:31–98

CrossRef Google Scholar Peusner L (1970) The principles of network thermodynamics and biophysical applications, Ph.D. thesis, Harvard. University of Cambridge, MA. [Reprinted by Entropy Limited, South Great Road, Lincoln, MA 01773, 1987]

Peusner L (1982) Global reaction-diffusion coupling and reciprocity in linear asymmetric networks. J Chem Phys 77:5500–5507

CrossRef Google Scholar Peusner L (1983a) Electrical network representation of n-dimensional chemical manifolds. In: King RB (ed) Chemical applications of topology and graph theory. Elsevier, Amsterdam

Google Scholar Peusner L (1983b) Hierarchies of irreversible energy conversion systems I. Linear steady state without storage. J Theor Biol 102:7–39

CrossRef Google Scholar Peusner L (1985a) Hierarchies of irreversible energy conversion systems II. Network derivation of linear transport equations. J Theor Biol 115:319–335

CrossRef Google Scholar Peusner L (1985b) Network thermostatics. J Chem Phys 83:1276–1291

CrossRef Google Scholar Peusner L (1985c) Premetric thermodynamics: a topological graphical model. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 2(81):1151–1161

Google Scholar Peusner L (1986a) Hierarchies of irreversible energy conversion systems III. Why are Onsager’s equations reciprocal? The Euclidean geometry of fluctuation-dissipation space. J Theor Biol 122:125–155

CrossRef Google Scholar Peusner L (1986b) Studies in network thermodynamics. Elsevier, Amsterdam

Google Scholar Peusner L, Mikulecky DC, Caplan SR, Bunow B (1985) Unifying graphical approaches to dynamic systems: network thermodynamics, Hill and King Altman diagrams in reaction-diffusion kinetics. J Chem Phys 83:5559–5566

CrossRef Google Scholar Rashevsky N (1954) Topology and life: in search of general mathematical principles in biology and sociology. Bull Math Biophys 16:317–349

CrossRef Google Scholar Reich RB (2007) Super capitalism: the transformation of business, democracy, and everyday life. Alfred A. Knopf, NY

Google Scholar Rosen R (ed) (1972) Some relational cell models: the metabolism—repair system. In: Foundations of mathematical biology. Academic Press, NY, pp 217–253

Rosen R (1985) Anticipatory systems: philosophical, mathematical & methodological foundations. Pergamon Press, New York

Google Scholar Rosen R (1986) Some comments on systems and system theory. Int J Gen Sys 13:1–3

CrossRef Google Scholar Rosen R (1991) Life itself: a comprehensive inquiry into the nature, origin, and fabrication of life. Columbia University Press, New York

Google Scholar Rosen R (2000) Essays on life itself. Columbia University Press, New York

Google Scholar Sagan D (2007) Notes from the Holocene: a brief history of the future. Chelsea Green, White River Junction, Vermont

Google Scholar Tellegen BDH (1952) A general network theorem with applications. Phillips Res Rep 7:259–269

Google Scholar © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations 1. Center for the Study of Biological Complexity Virginia Commonwealth University Richmond USA