Contribution of SPECT/CT for sentinel node localization in patients with ipsilateral breast cancer relapse
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Borrelli, P., Donswijk, M.L., Stokkel, M.P. et al. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging (2017) 44: 630. doi:10.1007/s00259-016-3545-8
- 1.1k Downloads
In recent years repeat sentinel node (SN) biopsy has been proven to be feasible in local breast cancer recurrence (LBCR). However, in these patients SNs outside the ipsilateral axilla are frequently observed. This study evaluates the contribution of SPECT/CT for SN localization and surgical adjustment in LBCR patients.
SN biopsy was performed in 122 LBCR patients (median age 60.5 years, range 24–87), enrolled from August 2006 to July 2015. Median disease-free time lapse was 109.5 months (range 9–365). Axillary lymph node dissection (ALND) had previously been performed in 55 patients, SN biopsy in 44, both techniques in 13 and fine-needle aspiration in 10. Primary breast cancer treatment included radiotherapy in 104 patients (85.3 %) and chemotherapy in 40 (32.8 %). Preoperative lymphatic mapping, using planar scintigraphy (PS) and SPECT/CT included report of SN location according to lymph node territory. In case of a territorial PS-SPECT/CT mismatch, surgery was adjusted according to SPECT/CT findings.
SPECT/CT SN visualization rate was higher than PS (53.3 % vs. 43.4 %, p n.s.) with, in total, 19 additional SN (118 vs. 99, p n.s.). PS-SPECT/CT territory mismatch, found in 60 % (39/65) of patients with SN visualization, led to surgical adjustment in 21.3 % (26/122) of patients. The SN procedure was finally performed in 104 patients resulting in a 65.7 % surgical retrieval rate with a total of 132 removed SNs (1.86/patient). SN metastases were found in 17/71 patients (23.9 %), in 16 of them (94 %) in ipsilateral basins outside the axilla or in the contralateral axilla.
Using SPECT/CT there is a trend to visualize more SNs in LBCR, providing at the same time important anatomical information to adjust intraoperative SN procedures. The addition of SPECT/CT to the standard imaging protocol may lead to better staging mainly in patients presenting drainage outside the ipsilateral axilla.
KeywordsSPECT/CT Sentinel node Lymphoscintigraphy Recurrent breast cancer Radioguided surgery
Breast cancer is the most frequent cancer in women with 1.67 million new cases in 2012, ranking second in frequency worldwide . The highest incidence is in Western Europe, reaching over 96 new cases per 100,000. Breast cancer mortality dropped over the last few decades due to earlier diagnoses by screening, increasing patients awareness and improved comprehensive care . To achieve individualized patient treatment one should take into account staging, biological cancer information, personal preferences (patient and treating physician) among other variables. Nowadays, a broad therapeutic arsenal is at our disposal: different forms of surgery, radio- and chemotherapy, endocrine therapy, and more specific targeted therapy .
Lymph node status is the most important prognostic factor in primary breast cancer . This is acknowledged in many guidelines, as in the most recent ESMO guidelines in 2015 . It is likely that nodal status is also prognostic in locally recurrent breast cancer. Therefore, knowledge of nodal status influences regional treatment strategies, particularly radiotherapy, and may also enforce the indication for adjuvant systemic (re-)treatments with curative intention . Since the introduction of the SN procedure in breast cancer planar scintigraphy (PS) has been the basis for lymphatic mapping and has proven to be an accurate tool for SN localization in primary cancer, leading to detection rates of over 97 % and 98 % in series of 4800  and 3681 patients , respectively.
Although relevant medical progress was reached in diagnosing and treating breast cancer in the last decade, locoregional recurrence is still an issue after a full set of treatment, ranging from approximately 3 % to near 30 % when associated with distant metastasis [9, 10]. Contrary to high 5-year survival rates known for primary breast cancer, relapse breast cancer has a high mortality rate. Nonetheless, life expectancy is improving due to follow-up care after treatment, and relapses are usually detected in asymptomatic stages . Ten-year survival of breast cancer patients after local recurrence was around 20 % in the 1980s and 1990s  and increased to approximately 35-45 % in more recent years . The last Dutch revision in 2015 on survival rates after locoregional relapse showed a promising 49 % survival rate at 10 years .”
Against this background, the sentinel node (SN) procedure has been introduced in breast cancer patients experiencing a local relapse. This appears to be technically feasible, although detection rates vary significantly from 62.1 % to 80.4 % [4, 5, 6, 14, 15] among several studies. Although several factors such as tumour size and patient age have been described to alter lymphatic drainage in patients at primary breast cancer presentation  in LCBR patients, previous treatment of the primary cancer has incorporated additional variables that are even more anatomically and physiologically destructive, including surgery of both the axillary region and primary tumour, systemic treatments and radiation therapy. This previous treatment frequently leads to a more complex and multidirectional lymphatic drainage with a high incidence of SNs outside the axilla suggesting the need for accurate localization imaging modalities like single photon emission computed tomography in conjunction with computed tomography (SPECT/CT) .
Early in 2015 the results from a multicentre prospective study on the additional value of SPECT/CT over PS in various malignancies, including primary breast cancer, coordinated by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) were published. On the basis of 1.182 enrolled breast cancer patients, SN visualization increased from 87.6 % for PS to 91.3 % when SPECT/CT was used additionally, and in 44 patients only visualization on SPECT/CT enabled the SN procedure . SPECT/CT led to adjustments in anatomical SN localization and surgical management in 17 % of the patients. So far no studies have addressed the SPECT/CT impact in a similar manner for breast cancer relapses.
The aim of this study was to evaluate whether the use of SPECT/CT improved both visualization, and anatomical localization of the SN, and whether this additional information may have had impact on the surgical approach and consequent retrieval of SN in patients with local breast cancer relapse (LBCR) scheduled for SN biopsy.
Material and methods
At the Netherlands Cancer Institute – Antoni van Leeuwenhoek Hospital LBCR patients were incorporated to the SN procedure from 2006 onward using both PS and SPECT/CT, together with the introduction of SPECT/CT in the protocol for lymphatic mapping in untreated breast cancer patients . All patients were restaged to exclude metastases at distance following the Dutch breast cancer guidelines, which include total body scanning with 18F-FDG PET/CT. After giving informed consent from August 2006 to October 2015, 122 consecutive patients with repeat SNB for local breast cancer relapse were studied following the protocol including SPECT/CT. Their data were analysed retrospectively.
Description of patient characteristics, primary tumor treatment, characteristics of relapse tumour, and activity and location of radiotracer injection
Number of patients
Age at relapse (years)
24 - 87
Months to relapse
9 - 365
Injected dose (MBq)
63.94 - 250.63
Relapse tumor size
3 - 70 mm
Breast conserving surgery
ALND + SNB
Sentinel node procedure
In 113 patients (92.6 %) 99mTc-Nanocolloid (Nanocoll©; GE Healthcare, Eindhoven, Netherlands) was administered by intratumoural injection, the standard procedure in our hospital; either palpation-based or image-guided (ultrasound, stereotactic, or using 125I-seed guided freehand-SPECT tumour localization). Image-guided intratumoural injection was performed in 43 patients (35 %). In nine patients (7 %) the injection was made either subcutaneously (n = 4), periareolar (n = 3), or peritumourally (n = 2). Median injection activity was 126.1 mBq (range 63.9-250.6). This dose matches the recommendation for a 2-day SN procedure using intratumoral tracer administration as validated in our institution .
Early planar scintigraphy was made at an average of 23 minutes after injection, and a late planar scintigraphy (PS) at an average of 4 h. This is in agreement with the published EANM guidelines for SN procedures in breast cancer . PS comprised 5-min static images in anterior and lateral/oblique projections, 256 × 256 matrix, and zoom factor 1.0. A 57Cobalt flood source was used to delineate the body contour. SPECT/CT was made at an average of 4.42 h after injection using a dual-head SPECT/CT gamma camera (Symbia T®, Siemens, Erlangen, Germany). SPECT parameters were: 128 × 128 matrix, zoom factor 1.0, and 180 degrees rotation with 20 views per head (30 s per view). CT (130 Kv, 40 mAs, B30s kernel, 2 mm axial reconstruction) was used for attenuation correction and anatomical localization. For image reading SPECT, CT, and fused SPECT/CT were displayed using orthogonal multiplanar reconstruction, maximum intensity projection and volume rendering.
As SNs were considered all lymph nodes with afferent lymphatic vessel draining directly the injection site, or, in cases of multiple nodes appearing with no afferent lymphatic vessels on the lymphoscintigram, the first node appearing in each basin . The number of SNs and their draining basin localization were evaluated separately on PS and SPECT/CT images to establish the incremental value of SPECT/CT over PS with respect to additional SNs or territorial mismatch following the criteria applied in a multicenter International Atomic Energy Agency trial . The anatomical territories considered for the evaluation were the following: axillar level I, II, and III, intramammary, interpectoral, clavicular, internal mammary, all of them either ipsilateral or contralateral. Partial mismatch was considered when a patient showed a sentinel node that was correctly depicted and found, but also had one or more sentinel nodes that were mismatches. Complete mismatch between PS and SPECT/CT was considered whenever sentinel nodes and/or anatomical location in a patient were totally discordant with each other.
Surgery was performed either the same day or the day following the radiotracer injection. Intra-operative SN detection was performed with a conventional gamma probe (Neoprobe®, Neoprobe Corporation, Dublin, OH, USA). In addition, patent blue dye was injected after anaesthesia induction in 76 (62.3 %) patients depending on the leading surgeon preoperative decision. In principal, all SNs visualized on PS and SPEC/CT were to be removed. Adaptation of the surgical procedure for SN biopsy was made in all cases with territorial mismatch unless this concerned only a difference in axillary levels (levels 1 to level 2, for example).
Factors associated with the SN detection were analysed using logistic regression and statistical significance was established at p < 0.05. The following variables related to prior primary tumour were included in the analysis: age, previous ALND or SNB, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, and relapse variables as time to relapse, tumour size, total activity administered, image guided injection or not. All of these variables were added in order to identify possible causes and confusion factors of altered sentinel node detection rates. Continuous variables were checked for linearity and categorized if shown to be non-linear. The analysis was performed using R version 3.2.3 (2015-12-10).
Univariable logistic regression models with testing for nonlinear effects
Time to relapse
Surgical sentinel node procedures and detection findings
Total scheduled SN procedures
Total performed SN
71 (68.3 %)
At histopathology, SN metastases were found in 17/71 patients (23.9 %): eight with macrometastasis and nine with micrometastasis. SN metastases were located outside the ipsilateral axilla in 64.7 % of the cases (11/17) and in the contralateral axilla in 29.4 % (5/17).
ALND was performed in 20 patients; with a total of 223 LN retrieved, median 11.2 nodes per patient (range 2 – 27). In 15 patients (75 %) histopathology showed no further LN involvement, in 5 (25 %) macrometastases were found. ALND did not reveal metastases in any of the patients with a negative SN.
After surgical treatment of the relapse 60 patients received hormone therapy, 43 chemotherapy and 30 radiotherapy, 38 patients received no further treatment.
The results of the present study show that additional SPECT/CT may play an essential role in patients with breast cancer recurrence scheduled for the SN procedure.
From a clinical point-of-view probably the most important contribution of SPECT/CT is the information provided to adjust the surgical approach. This concerned over one in every five breast cancer relapse patients in this study (21,3 %). The results achieved in our series seem to be in a good agreement with data from the last IAEA trial (17 % vs. 21 %); however, this small difference could be justified, firstly, due to the difference in population, and secondly, due to the complicating factors associated to local recurrent cancer mentioned in the introduction . The adjustment of the surgical approach may also lead to a better restaging in LCBR patients as in the present study SN metastases were located in ipsilateral territorial basins outside the axilla or in the contralateral axilla in 16 out of 17 (94 %) patients.
This surgical approach adjustment was particularly crucial in three patients in whom SPECT/CT correctly identified putative SN visualization due to contamination artefacts and avoided SN surgery. Similar artefact-related cases have been reported in the multicentre IAEA SN trial, where 41 (out 1182) unnecessary SN surgeries could be avoided .
The superior anatomical information provided by SPECT/CT was crucial to establish a 60 % territorial mismatch evidenced after the incorporation of SPECT/CT to the conventional protocol based on PS. The anatomical information provided by SPECT/CT enabled nuclear physicians to accurately localize SN in relation to specific lymph node basins and anatomical landmarks.
For the present study static delayed images were acquired 3–4 h after intratumoral tracer injection. This delayed point of time is based on the radiotracer biodistribution, which is completed at that moment (see the above mentioned reference). Delayed imaging (planar and SPECT/CT) is important to exclude eventual drainage outside of the ipsilateral axilla. Theoretically, in patients with local relapse tracer migration from the injection site to SN is slower than in patients without previous surgery and/or radiotherapy of the breast/axilla. This was also observed in our series, in agreement with a previous study concerning SN biopsy in patients with treated breasts .
Finally, SPECT/CT in this series led to detect more SNs with almost 10 % improvement in the detection rate when compared with conventional PS. These results are higher than those reported in an earlier study in our hospital by van der Ploeg et al.  and the more recently published multicenter IAEA SN trial, both considering only untreated primary breast cancer patients . However, this detection improvement related to SPECT/CT did not reach statistical significance and probably a larger series of patients will be needed for a definitive validation of the role of SPECT/CT.
Many factors affecting SN visualization have been largely discussed in other papers. Some examples are: body mass index (BMI), age at time of relapse, previous ALND, and radiotherapy . Also, recently, Vugts et al. analyzed multiple variables and found that only previous radiotherapy had a significant association with lower SN detection rates in LBCR patients ; this could also explain the lower detection rates in our series in comparison with the aforementioned series [14, 15, 25, 26, 27].
An interesting concept and something probably worth of further study is that there seems to be a tendency of lymphatic regeneration after ALND and/or radiotherapy. A non-linear association between time to relapse and SN detection rates supports this idea. Cordoba et al. also suggested such a concept . The results in our series also show a nonlinear association between the period of “recovery” (relapse-free period) and an improvement in detection rate (Table 2). Patients with breast cancer relapse within 10 years had a 46 % detection rate versus 62 % for patients with a relapse-free period of more than 10 years. Blum et al. also proved that neo-lymphatic vascularization was present in mice which had undergone ALND-like surgery .
In conclusion, although not reaching statistical significance the addition of SPECT/CT to the standard imaging protocol for lymphatic mapping and SN localization in breast cancer recurrence patients appears to improve detection of sentinel nodes and their anatomical localization. This all may contribute to the adjustment of the surgical sentinel node approach and a better staging mainly in patients presenting drainage outside of the ipsilateral axilla.
The authors thank Bas Pouw and Daan Hellingman for their collaboration in the editing of the images used in this manuscript.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
This study was not funded by any institution, company or pharmaceutical industry.
Conflict of interest
All the authors declare that he/she has no conflict of interest.
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the Antoni van Leeuwenhoek Hospital, The Netherlands Cancer Institute and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.