Abstract
The arid lands controversy beginning in the late 19th century provides a unique perspective on the role that large scale climate assessments play in the policy process. Initially the climate of the western arid lands divided scientists, policy makers, and the public between those that believed new conditions would require specialized policies and adaptations and those that argued conditions would not be severe. The consensus eventually emerged for a large-scale response, a consensus based on the seminal Report on the Arid Lands of the United States and later scientific assessments that coupled the physical and human dimensions of climatic change. This earlier debate demonstrates how climate assessments in the United States play out in policy deliberations with public opinion and climatological events to ultimately control the fate of responses.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen JL (1985) The Garden-Desert continuum: competing views of the Great Plains in the nineteenth century. Great Plains Q 5(4):207–220
American Association for the Advancement of Sciences (2014) What we know: the reality, risk, and response to climate change. American Association for the Advancement of Sciences, Washington
Anderegg WRL (2010) Moving beyond scientific agreement. Clim Change: 331–337
Aughey, S (1880) Sketches of the physical geography and geology of Nebraska. Daily Republican Book
Bowden M et al (1981) The effect of climate fluctuations on human populations: two hypotheses. In: Wigley, Farmer (ed) Climate and history: studies in past climates and their impact on man. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 479–513
Carey HC, Lea I (1822) A complete historical, chronological, and geographical American atlas. H. C. Carey and I. Lea, Philadelphia
Chen RS, Boulding E, Schneider SH (1983) Social science research and climate change: an interdisciplinary appraisal. D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht
Chittenden H (1897) Preliminary examination of reservoir sites in Wyoming and Colorado. House Document No. 141, Fifty-fifth Congress, Second Session, Serial No. 3666, Washington
Conservation Commission of Maryland (1909) Report of the Conservation Commission of Maryland for 1908–1909. State of Maryland, Annapolis
Davis WM (1915) Biographical memoir of John Wesley Powell 1834–1902. National Academy of Sciences, Washington
Dupree AH (1957) Science in the federal government. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Engineering Staff (Miami Conservancy District) (1917) Part V—storm rainfall of eastern United States. Groneweg Printing, Dayton
Engineering Staff (Miami Conservancy District) (1922) Appraisal of flood protection benefits and damages. Eng News Rec 89:831–835
Gilpin W (1857) The pastoral region of the west. Living Age 54(694):676–679
Gilpin W (1860) The central gold region. Barnes and Co, Sower
Gore T (1935) Statement of Senator Gore. Proceeding and debates. Congr Rec 79:6013
Gregg J (1844) Commerce of the prairies. Henry Langley, New York
Groat CG (2003) The National Map – a continuing critical need for the nation. Photogramm Eng Remote Sens 69(10):1087–1090
Hamilton LC, Stampone MD (2013) Blowin’ in the wind: short-term weather and belief in anthropogenic climate change. Weather Clim Soc 5(2):112–119
Hansen JE (1988) The Greenhouse Effect: Impacts on Current Global Temperature and Regional Heat Waves. Testimony to U.S. Senate, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, June 23, 1988. Washington, DC
Herring WE (1908) Applications of water power. In: Preliminary report of the Inland Waterways Commission, appendix 12. Senate Document No. 325, 60th Congress, 1st Session
Holmes KJ (2013) Pushing the climate frontier. Nature 501(7467):310–311
Holmes KJ, Wolman MW (2001) The early development of systems analysis in natural resources management from Man and Nature to the Miami Conservancy District. Environ Manag 27(2):177–193
Houk IE (1921) Part VIII—rainfall and runoff in the Miami Valley. Groneweg Printing, Dayton
House Executive Documents (1871) Preliminary report of the United States Geological Survey of Wyoming and portions of Contiguous Territories, 42nd Cong., 2 Sess. House Executive Documents No 325
Inland Waterways Commission (1908) Preliminary report of the inland waterways commission. Senate Document No. 325, 60th Congress, 1st Session. Washington
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (1990) Climate change: the IPCC scientific assessment. Houghton, Jenkins and Ephraums (eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2013) Climate change 2013: the physical science basis. Stocker et al. (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kates RW (1985) The interaction of climate and society. In: Kates, Ausubel, Berberian (ed) SCOPE 27 - Climate impact assessment. John Wiley, Chichester, pp 3–36
Lawson MP, Reiss A, Phillips R, Livingston K (1971) Nebraska droughts: a study of their past chronological and spatial extent with implications for the future. Nebraska Water Resources Research Institute. University of Nebraska, Lincoln
Leighton MO (1908) Relation of water conservation to flood prevention and navigation in Ohio River. In: Preliminary report of the Inland Waterways Commission, appendix 13. Senate Document No. 325, 60th Congress, 1st Session
Lewis GM (1966) William Gilpin and the concept of the Great Plains region. Annu Assoc Am Geogr 56(1):33–55
Libecap GD, Hansen ZK (2002) “Rain follows the plow” and dryfarming doctrine: the climate information problem and homestead failure in the upper great plains, 1890–1925. J Econ Hist 62(1):86–120
Marshall G (2014) Don’t even think about it: why our brains are wired to ignore climate change. Bloomsbury USA, New York
McGee WJ (1909) Proceedings of a conference of governors in the White House, Washington, May 13–15, 1908. 60th Congress, 2nd Session, House Document 1425, Government Printing Office, Washington
National Academy of Sciences (1878) Report on surveys of the territories. National Academy of Sciences, Washington
National Academy of Sciences and The Royal Society (2014) Climate change: evidence and causes. National Academy of Sciences, Washington
National Weather Service (2006) Drought comparisons for the tri-cities of Grand Island, Kearney and Hastings, Nebraska, http://www.crh.noaa.gov/gid/?n=droughtcomparison
New York Herald (1890) Scientists Wage Bitter Warfare. January 12, 1890
Oreskes N (2004) Beyond the ivory tower: the scientific consensus on climate change. Science 306:1686
Pew Research Center (2014) Climate change: key data points from Pew Research, January 27, 2014
Pike ZM (1810) The expeditions of Zebulon Montgomery Pike to the headwaters of the Mississippi river. C.A. Conrad, Philadelphia
Powell JW (1874) Statement of Mr. J.W. Powell, House Report 612. Washington
Powell JW (1878) Report on the arid lands of the United States. GPO, Washington
Powell JW (1890a) Institutions for the arid lands. Century Mag 40(1):111–117
Powell JW (1890b) Statement of Major J.W. Powell. Senate Report No. 1466. Washington
Public Lands Commission (1905) Partial report of the public lands commission. 58th Congress, 3rd Session, Senate Document 189. GPO, Washington
Rabbit MC (1980) A history of public lands, federal science and mapping policy, and development of mineral resources in the United States, volume 2 1879–1904. GPO, Washington
Rosenberg S, Vedlitz A, Cowman D, Zahran S (2010) Climate change: a profile of U.S. climate scientists’ perspectives. Clim Chang 101:3–4
Shannon F (1945) The farmer’s last frontier, agriculture, 1860–1897. Farrar & Rinehart, New York
Smith HN (1950) Virgin land: the American west as symbol and myth. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Stegner W (1954) Beyond the hundredth meridian. Houghtin Mifflin, Boston
Stering E (1940) The Powell irrigation survey 1888–1893. Miss Val Hist Rev 27(3):361–378
Thayed WM (1891) Marvels of the new west. Henry Bill, Norwich
Thomas ML (2007) John Wesley Powell: white water to white city. In: Berger (ed) Grand Canyon historians: ideas, arguments, and first-person accounts Grand Canyon Association. Flagstaff. pp 5–10
USGS (1890) Tenth annual report of the United States geologic survey, part II-irrigation. GPO, Washington
USGS (1891a) Eleventh annual report of the United States geologic survey, part II-irrigation. GPO, Washington
USGS (1891b) Twelfth annual report of the United States geologic survey, part II-irrigation. GPO, Washington
USGS (1892) Thirteenth annual report of the United States geologic survey, part III-irrigation. GPO, Washington
USGS (1900) Twentieth annual report of the United States geologic survey. GPO, Washington
USGS (1902) Twenty-third annual report of the United States geologic survey. GPO, Washington
van Hise CR (1910) The conservation of natural resources in the United States. Macmillan Co, New York
Vilas WM (1888) Letter from the Secretary of the Interior, Senate Executive Document, 163, Washington
Warrick RA (1980) Drought in the great plains: a case study of research on climate and society in the US. In: Ausubel B (ed) Climatic constraints and human activities. International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, Laxenburg, pp 93–123
Webb W (1931) The great plains. Ginn and Co., Boston
Wilber CD (1881) The great valleys and prairies of Nebraska and the Northwest. Daily Republican, Omaha
Woodward SM (1920) Part VII—Hydraulics of the Miami flood control project. Groneweg Printing, Dayton
Worster D (2001) A river running west – the life of John Wesley Powell. Oxford University Press, New York
Yarnel B (1998) Integrated regional assessment and climate change impacts in river basins. Clim Res 11:65–74
Acknowledgments
The author would like to acknowledge the late M. Gordon “Reds” Wolman, a mentor for this work and member of the National Academy of Sciences and National Academy of Engineering. Long an advocate for systems approaches to environmental analysis and education, Reds was a remarkable teacher who inspired generations of students and collegues. The author also would like to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Holmes, K.J. A historical perspective on climate change assessment. Climatic Change 129, 351–361 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-015-1331-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-015-1331-4